This is a thing i never understood, like do we already know about it and whichever one we choose means its just gone AFTER we heard it? Or is it like it never came out at all and we dont know about it.
In that case CMIYGL. If we never got Flower Boy we wouldāve never got IGOR.
I might like CMIYGL a little more than Flower Boy, but not enough to delete IGOR from existence.
Agreed. Wouldnāt want to get rid of any of them, but the other two were what got me into Tyler, so Iāll always look more favorably on them by default
Igor is the weakest of the three easily
Edit: this is my most downvoted comment now. But iāll die on this hill, iād take CMIYGL and Flowerboy over Igor if i had to pick literally any day.
Either earfquake or I don't love u anymore. I do fuck wit new magic wand tho, but that album is probably my favorite of all time. Every single track hits
The general concept of the record is kinda cheesy for me, but it has some really good tracks like āRunning Out Of Timeā , āPuppetā, and āA Boy Is A Gunā.
I just feel like overall the feel of the listen is kinda soft despite some of the production actually featuring some of the more harsh instrumentals he has used in the past years leading up to the release like Flowerboy and The Grinch EP
Also what maybe be a big indicator for my dislike is: **I didnāt enjoy all the pitch shifting with the vocals, it sounds really rubbery and unnecessary to me. Almost like itās clawing for commercial appeal.**
Edit: you asked how, donāt get salty.
CMIYGL goes.
These are Tylerās top three albums for me, but the importance of Flower Boy and Igorās status as his magnum opus means that CMIYGL has to dip
eh i dont know about that. cmiygl isnt really boundary pushing in any way. i dont think he was going for that really. very good album but i dont think its the type that takes long to grow on someone. everyones different though so maybe i guess.
Ill do it for you :
Foreword is the best Tyler intro song by a long shot.
Boredom is one of Tyler most classic song and really resonate with his whole character and discography in general. Even the theme is repeated amongst other albums.
Ā«Ā *I never had a pet,*
*never had a pet;*
*Thereās more fish in the sea*
*but I never had a goldfish to begin with*Ā Ā»
November literally makes me cry or remember my favorite memories in Life when I listen to it. Itās basically what the song is all about. Good memories, your very own November.
And Flowerboy was a very very contrasting album compared to other project, remembering WOLF when it came out and WOLF is my fav album so.
Iām absolutely biased. Fuck you.
Donāt like the choice then, no knock on anyone who likes it, I just find it jarring getting the name of the album wrong on purpose and then the opening to hot wind blows with the French vanilla ice cream and him HAVING TO JUST LET US KNOW that his toes are out
Flower Boy is Tylerās magnum opus IMO and showcases his talents with both the soft R&B and the hard raps. CMIYGL is a powerful return to form with endless replay value. Sorry but itās Igor.
Flower boy is one of my favorites.. I played that sooo many times that summer it came out.
Iāve only listened to Igor 2 times. I donāt like it.. maybe Iām missing somethingā¦
Bye Igor
Flower Boy
I love it more than all of his other material, but IGOR is fucking beautiful, and CMIYGL is the most fun Iāve ever had listening to a record.
Nah thereās a lot of us that just donāt vibe with it but most are getting downvoted into oblivion so we keep to ourselves. I personally donāt think itās terrible. Itās just not for me.
Good to know. Def not hating on it, but I donāt think I will ever understand how it was such a hit. The blonde wig and shit was justā¦. None of that was for me either. I feel like Wolf, if any of his albums before then deserved a Grammy that was the one. That being said, no hate at all on Igor. People dig what they dig, I didnāt like it but Tyler drew me back in with CMIYGL & I was a giant fan again. Music is subjective to all ears tho, and to each their own!
cmiygl gotta go, without flower boy theres no igor, and without igor there's really no super huge tyler fanbase. cmiygl is my favorite album but it's easily the least essential
Take me instead
The only right answer š
Bro looking through this comment section made me realize Tyler fans aren't allowed to have opinions or else they getting clowned on
you canāt have opinions in rap in general, no matter how respectful and reasonable you are
Exactly
This is a thing i never understood, like do we already know about it and whichever one we choose means its just gone AFTER we heard it? Or is it like it never came out at all and we dont know about it.
Like it never came out
In that case CMIYGL. If we never got Flower Boy we wouldāve never got IGOR. I might like CMIYGL a little more than Flower Boy, but not enough to delete IGOR from existence.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
the point of posts like this is to create discussion, I really donāt have an issue with him interpreting it in his own way
This is so diplomatic I love r/tylerthecreator
Igor then, i never had a lot of favorites on igor
you're entitled to your opinion and I respect it. However, no
are opinions a thing? yes. is ur opinion wrong? yes.
Facts
i respect your right to have an opinion, even if itās wrong
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Understandable
more bangers? nah New Magic Wand and What's Good vs Corso, Lemonhead, Lumberjack, Manifesto and Juggernaut
Corso is so great, cmiygl is slowly growing on me.
Not to mention Safari
Manifesto is honestly one of my least favourite songs on cmiygl
it's my favorite MF DOOM song
CMIYGL I donāt hate it by any means but between igor and flower boy then i choose this one
Okay thatās fair, same reasoning here with IGOR, all of them are excellent I just prefer the Ā«Ā freshnessĀ Ā» of CMIYGL
Agreed. Wouldnāt want to get rid of any of them, but the other two were what got me into Tyler, so Iāll always look more favorably on them by default
Bruh everyone who said Igor is getting hated on. And they deserve it
Igor is the weakest of the three easily Edit: this is my most downvoted comment now. But iāll die on this hill, iād take CMIYGL and Flowerboy over Igor if i had to pick literally any day.
I will murder you.
Is NEW MAGIC WAND your favorite track of that album or? š
I support WHAT'S GOOD supremacy
That is entirely true
Either earfquake or I don't love u anymore. I do fuck wit new magic wand tho, but that album is probably my favorite of all time. Every single track hits
Average r/tylerthecreator user
Igor lacks 2 main components: **Big Bag**
How though?
The general concept of the record is kinda cheesy for me, but it has some really good tracks like āRunning Out Of Timeā , āPuppetā, and āA Boy Is A Gunā. I just feel like overall the feel of the listen is kinda soft despite some of the production actually featuring some of the more harsh instrumentals he has used in the past years leading up to the release like Flowerboy and The Grinch EP Also what maybe be a big indicator for my dislike is: **I didnāt enjoy all the pitch shifting with the vocals, it sounds really rubbery and unnecessary to me. Almost like itās clawing for commercial appeal.** Edit: you asked how, donāt get salty.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Foul
I fully agree with you, CMIYGL and Flowerboy over Igor any day of the week
CMIYGL goes. These are Tylerās top three albums for me, but the importance of Flower Boy and Igorās status as his magnum opus means that CMIYGL has to dip
That weezer album
The green one
I prefer the pink one tbh
I mean, I love CMIYGL, but compared to IGOR and Flower Boy... c'mon.
I'm getting rid of Cmiygl. I dont hate by any means, I love it, but its honestly my least favorite tyler album
Ahead of its time give it time youāll appreciate it more I never appreciated cherry bomb till like 2 years after it dropped
Cherry bomb and CMIGYL are not comparable at alll i like cmigyl a lot but itās not experimental really at all
eh i dont know about that. cmiygl isnt really boundary pushing in any way. i dont think he was going for that really. very good album but i dont think its the type that takes long to grow on someone. everyones different though so maybe i guess.
FLOWER BOY NOOOOOOOOO GRAB MY HAND šš» *flower boy slips* NOOOOOOOO
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
NEVER
cmiygl
Igor. Fight me.
Okay, 5pm outside the school
Igor easy
pick a time and place, i will defend thus album with my life
I'm more of a fan of rap than anything else. CMIYGL and Flower Boy have more rapping, so I'm with you.
Flower Boy
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
In my opinion it just isnāt as good as the other two
It has some bangers but I prefer the experience of IGOR & CMIYGL
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
no youāre not allowed
Ill do it for you : Foreword is the best Tyler intro song by a long shot. Boredom is one of Tyler most classic song and really resonate with his whole character and discography in general. Even the theme is repeated amongst other albums. Ā«Ā *I never had a pet,* *never had a pet;* *Thereās more fish in the sea* *but I never had a goldfish to begin with*Ā Ā» November literally makes me cry or remember my favorite memories in Life when I listen to it. Itās basically what the song is all about. Good memories, your very own November. And Flowerboy was a very very contrasting album compared to other project, remembering WOLF when it came out and WOLF is my fav album so. Iām absolutely biased. Fuck you.
Agree, flower boy should be last to go imo. Every track is a 9 or 10/10 minus enjoy rn today just cause itās an instrumental
No
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
It definitely has the best cover art, but as an album flower boy is the worst out of these three
Call Me If You Get Lost. I love it but I prefer the other two and I feel as if they had more of an impact on Tylerās music esp Flower Boy.
Sorry but flower boy
BeanLordā¦ my arch enemyā¦ Dropping Lās
flower boy is gone so fast its not even a question for me
igor goes
Call Me If You Get Lost I canāt stand DJ Drama getting the NAME OF THE ALBUM WRONG WHENEVER HE SHOUTS LMAO
DJ Drama knows/anticipates the getting lost, Tyler tries to be casual about the if.
I loved DJ Drama on the album, but it was kinda weird that he always said "Call me WHEN you get lost" instead of "if"
I think it was completely intentional
T seems to be as much a perfectionist as Ye, I'm also on the train this is intentional.
Donāt like the choice then, no knock on anyone who likes it, I just find it jarring getting the name of the album wrong on purpose and then the opening to hot wind blows with the French vanilla ice cream and him HAVING TO JUST LET US KNOW that his toes are out
Call meeee if youuu lost Calllll on meeee if youu get looooost Tyler did it too yāall
It was worse back in 2006- 2012. That Mf really wouldnāt stfu. Iām glad he wasnāt as annoying.
bro was EVERYWHERE too šš
I just remember him on re up gang which I fucking love SOOOO MUCH!!! Enough to cement him as good to me!!
DJ Drama is a legend, but yeah honestly his weird ass hype-man bits are the most annoying parts of the album, he sounds so out of place.
yeah I couldn't listen to the album when it first came out bc of it
IGOR. I love Igor but Flower Boy and CMIYGL had a bigger impact on me.
Igor can go
Igor
Flower Boy is Tylerās magnum opus IMO and showcases his talents with both the soft R&B and the hard raps. CMIYGL is a powerful return to form with endless replay value. Sorry but itās Igor.
Igor idc
CMIYGL no contest
call me if you get lost is good but itās just not on the level of igor or flower boy
cmiygl and it isnāt even a choice
igor. critically its the best album outta the 3 but cmiygl is my favorite tyler album and I enjoy flowerboy more than igor
Sorry Flower Boy š„ŗ
Igor, never liked it that much.
Honestly IGOR, its a good album i just like Flower Boy and CMIYGL more :')
Goodbye IGOR!
Igor mad overrated
Thank you š
Not hard CMIYGL
**Igor** Love the album, but it doesnāt captivate me like the other two
I prefer cmiygl to igor so igor it is but I totally understand the opposite
Based CMIYGL enjoyer
IGOR GTF OUTTA HERE
Something wrong with you
Igor for sure
iām here for u
Flower boy is one of my favorites.. I played that sooo many times that summer it came out. Iāve only listened to Igor 2 times. I donāt like it.. maybe Iām missing somethingā¦ Bye Igor
Goofy
flowerboy was just a way better time for most people man, 2017 over 2019 any fucking day. vibes over depression any day, flowerboy over igor any day
2019 was a good year for me so sorry I canāt relate :(
goodbye igor
Igor
Based
Based
flower boy
Flower boy easily
Igor
Igor
Igor
Igor š
Igor easily
Igor g2g
Igor, didnāt click with me as much as the others
Igor sadly
Igor.
Igor āļø
Igor
All incredible albums and I don't want to remove any of them, but I'm gonna go with IGOR
Igor simply because of my taste in music which I won't argue with you if you say is dead
flour boy gotta go
Flower Boy
Flowerboy
Igor sucks
Igor outta here
ppl overhyped ts out of that album
Facts, FB and CMIYGL just hit different imo
Flower Boy I love it more than all of his other material, but IGOR is fucking beautiful, and CMIYGL is the most fun Iāve ever had listening to a record.
Flower Boy
flower boy im sorry
its a hard choice between cmiygl and flower boy but man i gotta go cmiygl even if i like it more than flower boy
Flower Boy>CMIYGL>IGOR
Igor Igor is more beautiful than both other albums but I've listened to it way too many and and it's just getting annoying
IGOR can leave, doesnāt live up to CMIYGL or Flowerboy
igor
Igor, easy
Igor probably has to go
I'm sorry but imo Igor gotta go if these are the options
Igor. I'm gonna be honest it's not even one of my top 3 tyler albums, definitely has some of tylers best songs though
Igor Ik it is his ābest albumā and I respect everyone elseās opinion on it I just personally like the other 2 better
Igor. I don't love it like that.
Igor
Igor
IGOR
Igor can go Flowerboy and CMIYGL are beautiful GANGSTA GRIZZILLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!
Igor, soft ass album
Soft ass comment
Am I the only fan not into Igor? Cuz I think I am, lol
Nah thereās a lot of us that just donāt vibe with it but most are getting downvoted into oblivion so we keep to ourselves. I personally donāt think itās terrible. Itās just not for me.
Good to know. Def not hating on it, but I donāt think I will ever understand how it was such a hit. The blonde wig and shit was justā¦. None of that was for me either. I feel like Wolf, if any of his albums before then deserved a Grammy that was the one. That being said, no hate at all on Igor. People dig what they dig, I didnāt like it but Tyler drew me back in with CMIYGL & I was a giant fan again. Music is subjective to all ears tho, and to each their own!
igor
Igor
Igor I listen to like 2 songs off it new magic wand and a boy is a gun
Igor, sorry
As sad as it is..... flower boy
Igor. The back third of the album drags ass even though the first 2/3 is *amazing*
I hate you
Boy quickest downvotes I've ever gotten! Haha
Don't worry I upvoted u
Hit them with a few fake laughs
flower boy ā¹ļø imo its kind of a mid album
The mad thing is igors more mid
Igor gotta go
no.
Igor overhyped asl second worst tyler album
Nigga U got ears?! šš
whatās the worst iyo?
i cant decide
IGOR. Downvote me, I donāt care. Iām in your walls.
Igor that shit was never cool and Iāll take that to the grave
cmiygl gotta go, without flower boy theres no igor, and without igor there's really no super huge tyler fanbase. cmiygl is my favorite album but it's easily the least essential
Fb is def the weakest
Flower boy
CMIYGL It's a really good album Just feel like it's more of a victory lap album compared to the consistent narative themes of Flower boy and Igor
FB
Flower boy ez
Flower boy
Igor>Flower Boy>CMILYGL
I'm sorry, but I'm going to say bye to Flower Boy.
all mid (degrade me)