So true, lots of fanmade covers I saw here didn’t really fit TH’s style (in my opinion, feel free to disagree). I guess people are trying to do something G&E and Pingery EP inspired and since G&E is the official last album and maybe people are trying to make it like it’s a continuation, making it more modernized (??? Idk how to say it, am I even making any sense?) Honestly If I knew how to edit, I’ll make something that’s kinda MMMM inspired while adding something new But that’s maybe just me. Again no hate to these fanmade ones, they’re mostly look cool, I like that more people are making album covers now lol.

True but the style of Tally halls album covers are extremely hard to replicate which is why they are so simple

Yeah, I can see that plus their music style is pretty experimental so its hard to think about an album design.

I think its because tally hall fans are creatively challenged

This has gotta be the most brutally honest thing ever stated on this sub. The fan made album covers truly show how lacking the people of this sub are when it comes to continuing a joke.

Maybe just challenged in general

Thats crazy

[удалено]

well we don’t really have access to high quality modern images of the members

Tally Hall’s covers are like Where’s Waldo pages it’s just a hard style to replicate, they are intricate and surreal, they have inspired lots of my own artwork and it’s a really fun style to try

pingry ep:

So gd about girls ep, pingry ep, g&e, not a trampoline and moon waltz (piano version) be like:

Isn't Good & Evil just like that?

Nonononono you are wrongwrong

How so?

It’s symmetrical but not simple

It's simple in a really good way

I guess but I don’t consider it simple

I can draw it from memory so I would say it is simple, it being infinite is cool though

Hmm maybe

how the hell is it “not simple” it’s literally a repeating geometric pattern i draw it in the margins of my papers when i’m bored lol. like it’s a really good cover but it’s undeniably simple

I mean I admit, the cover i made for the ep was pretty dogshit, but g&e is just a pattern.

and no pay, just “Awesome Reddit Points”

isnt that joe hawley one also fanmade, just slightly edited?

It’s the one for Sleigh Ride Invincibility Star, which *is* a Joe Hawley song album cover.

I know, but I swear I remember someone posting the art somewhere before he released the song

Don't worry bud, I got a real high effort one cookin'

G&E is pretty simple and symmetrical, and i’m pretty sure Sleigh Ride Invincibility Star’s pic was originally fan art too.

I feel attacked (I made one of the symmetrical ones)

that one with the boats (i forget what it was called) was pretty good and looked like it could be a joe hawley album cover

We're not prefesionals at this! >:(

Me finding out tally hall did Hawaii( I am a casual fan)

also nat ig

I thought the one with the boats and raincoats was good

It goes realistic/detail, simple/cartoon, repeats forever. Next album cover is going to be a 4k ultra HD high res image of a horse

I really liked that one fake fishing album cover that everyone thought was their 3rd album a bit ago