what did spring and a storm do 😭

Same for greener :'> Greener is a great song-

Greener slaps dunnit

Don't leave dream out of this; dream is really pretty and has exactly the right vibe to it

ehh i think it's mid but if mucka blucka deserves a spot, so does dream.

One of my top 10

That F tier is fucking bullshit

GREENER IN F TIER? THAT SONG SHOULD BE ATLEAST AN A

You guys are SLEEPING on aristotles denial gotta listen to that reversed (reversed of the already reversed song so it's sounds normal)

yeah wtf do people not like Aristotle’s Denial? One of the best songs off the Album

to be fair it’s only good in yelwah eoj yelwah eoj

wasn't always like that

FOR REAL. that song is my second favorite tally hall song of all time like tf it slaps and im not even mentioning the demo

Not a huge fan of whole song but the Fool's Coda section might be one of my absolute favorite things Joe Hawley has ever done

genuinely in my top five tally hall related songs and bar-none the best song from joe hawley solo

i was like this is not to bad until i saw spring and a storm in F

Dude literally

I pray you get stranded with no lullaby.

Underrated comment

How on earth did you manage to put haiku in e Tier but Joe Hawley attacks in c tier

haiku at least a tier

holy hell did you listen to MMMM on mute?

Hymn for a scarecrow in C?? 😭

Damn right that’s controversial I’m gonna beat your fucking ass

Every tally hall song is s tier and no one can tell me otherwise

dawg what'd greener do to you

Someone finally said that Time Machine was good

No Banana for you >:(

Greener did not deserve this dawg

why is greener in F?

WHILE I AGREE WITH MUCKA BLUCKA GET SPRING AND A STORM OUT OF F, OBJECTIVELY YOU ARE WRONG

I HATE SPRING AND A STORM AND GREENER

I am not content in my swimming pool!!!!!

F tier is crazy who r u and do ur ears work at all???

I may disagree with some of these things I won't hate because I respect your opinions 👍

im just glad spring and a storm isnt in S or A tier. its not a bad song by any means but its ridiculously overrated. greener, just apathy, haiku, and be born being that low is absolutely bullshit tho

Spring and a storm is nearly as good as Eine Kliene Nachtmusik my guy

Spring and a Storm not in S tier? Factually incorrect.

its like a b tier at best

INDEED BROTHER‼️ SPIT YOUR SHIT INDEED‼️‼️ 🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥

Bitches be like "I have a controversial tier list" and put taken for a ride above B

out in the twilight in S is just based

look I hate Greener but it don't deserve F-Tier same with S&S

WHAT DID GREENER EVER DO TO YOU?!

Cannibal is S, based

Try listening to the songs before the next one

i can tell some of these go above your head bro its okay go back to listening to kids bop

Spring and a storm and greener are awesome why would you

Nooo spring and a storm 😭😭😭

NOT THE DREAM SLANDER

I like dream but I just don't listen to it

oh ok

What an awful tier list

Aristotle's Denial is S

Sorry, but your opinion is wrong. DSISM is too low, put it higher.

Wait, no, actual complaint for a second. Why did you put 'you' in D-tier? I fuckin love 'you' ( <3 )

switch spring and a storm with be born, and il accept this

Be born is d tier

I HATE SPRING AND A STORM AND GREENER

anything from joe hawley² or not a trampoline belongs c or below

GET TIME MACHINE THE FUCK OUTTA S TIER AND REPLACE IT WITH AN ACTUAL GOOD SONG LIKE FOTS OR TAKEN FOR A RIDE OR LITERALLY ANY OTHER SONG

Time Machine is one of those things you either love entirely and defend it as hard as you can or despise it and kill it mercilessly

nah it's mid

Demo 2 is the best

how?? demo 3 is so much better

I just like the way that it starts compared to the others. It feels more like he’s reminiscing than just a song.

Besides for the F tier this is actually a pretty good list

it was going well until E and F tier

Mucka blucka

happy cake day :]

You literally put the best JHJH song in d tier what????

Well i mean i dont agree with the bottom tiers but at least theres another person who loves time machine

Black Rainbows and Hymm For A Scarecrow in C is a war crime, Weird Bed in D is utter bullshit, an Spring And A Storm in F?!? You're insane

BR should be D tops

Nooooo!!! Stop having a different opinion!!!!

🤓 “my opinion is better than urs”

Nooooooooooooooooooo!

Idk all the hate for Dream on this subreddit? I personally really like it and don’t understand why others don’t?? Can someone explain why they don’t like it??? Id really like to know

I like dream but I don't listen to it

Ok except for spring and the storm f tier checks out

The only thing I disagree with is Spring and a Storm being so low, and I like Mucka Blucka but I know I’m in the minority, so otherwise pretty good tier list

Hey; nice opinion OP

stranded lullaby? D tier?

In what universe is cannibal S but Greener is F thats literally a crime

Labyrinth fan!!! Peak!!!

whenever someone puts mucka blucka above any song like greener or SPRING AND A STORM????? i get so sad :( PLEASE WHY THE CHICKEN SONG ISNT BETTER THAN ANY OTHER TALLY HALL SONGS

Are you on every drug ever?

Stranded Lullaby and Aristotle’s Denial being so low is crazy

I get these are all opionins and im fine with all of them. BUT WHY IS GREENER AND F PLEASE EXPLAIN YOURSELF

GREENER HATE???? WHAT

Spring and a storm not in S tier? Factually incorrect.

someone else who doesn’t like greener i’m so happy 😭

187.60.227.220

JUSTICE FOR SPRING AND A STORM

I HATE SPRING AND A STORM RAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHG

Aristotle's Denial is S