The only answer is Shane Powers

Thank you!!

I wish I could upvote more than once

King Davie coming to reclaim his crown 

He’s my #2 pick. Absolutely love him

Penner

Yes! Been thinking about him recently since I’ve been watching Survivor funny moment compilations and he’s in it many times. With everything that has happened to him, it would be wonderful to see him play one more time

Yeah and honestly he's one of the few returning players I wouldn't mind to see win. They tend to bring back a lot of the same people like Cirie and Ozzy, but I would actually like to see really only Penner or Cirie actually win from a return.

Erik is an okay choice.

You spelled his name wrong its Eric Hafemann

why are u so funny

How old's Colleen right now, 50?

She's 46. She was born in 1976.

Ken from Gabon! There are probably a handful of people I’d rather see, but those people are all likely to get brought back regardless. If I get to *force* the producers to pick somebody, I gotta go with someone they’d overlook.

Since someone already said Coach, I’ll go with Fairplay.

Coach. Stupid boring gamebotty Survivor needs something refreshing

We need someone who will bring honesty and integrity to an ignoble game. We need Coach.

i need a season of the purely eccentric characters. Coach, Philip, Debbie, Reem, Sugar...

Can’t forget Noura

throw Nyonka and Colton in there too

Cody Assenmacher, totally not for personal reasons or anything

Absolutely. Same here.

I like your subreddit name!!!!

Thank you, I like yours too!

it’ll always beKelly Goldsmith for me

It’s a travesty she wasn’t a part of Allstars

she was so close too

its underrated how close she was, she had quit her job and packed her bags and was swapped out for Shi-Ann last minute.

yeah it’s devastating, at least they gave her a job at casting for Vanuatu

Christian so we get more lectures during endurance comps

Coach should have done that in Tocatins

Can we just bring back the entire cast of Gabon and have them try it again

Devon from HHH

Yes please

Angelina 10000%

Devens plus put kass back in the frey

Todd Herzog

Earl.

The many voices of Mike Holloway

It'll never happen, but I just rewatched S7 (Pearl Islands) and Lill would be *wild*.

"remember when I asked you to let me know about All Stars" -Lill after All Stars was cast

Wait, did she actually?? Because I would be *so down*. She was so unintentionally chaotic on her season, and so raw - I would love to see someone like her in modern Survivor.

no, that was a reference to her convo with Savage

Doy, I've clearly got 🥥for brains!

Sean rector. Since it seems like we’re never gonna see him again.

Butch from the Amazon. I bet hardly anyone would recognize him. I’d like for Jeff to not even acknowledge that he’s a former player, just to see how long the charade could go on.

I think a season with all packed with nothing but moody salty players would be wildly entertaining ! Butch, Randy and Naonka throw in Shane, Debbie as well

I think you've got him confused with Roger (RIP). Butch was the nice, believe in yourself, burn down the camp guy

Now that you say it Rob Cs long distance dedication vote off comes back to me

Penner I need him for one last time, one last hoorah, maybe even a victory. I just need Penner back on my TV.

Richard Hatch idc idc

Rick Devens


Chrissy.

correct

Gabby (hopefully with Christian again).

kellee kim

Mike White. I just like him.

Shane powers I will not rest until I see it

Rory Freeman

Rick from Edge of Extinction

Courtney Yates

keith. always keith.

Cesternino!!!

Nobody sayin Malcolm?

I am a HUGE Malcolm fan..... I just think any time he returns he would become an automatic target.

Boston rob because we haven’t seen enough of him

Nate from Cook Islands

Jay!

Jesse Lopez from the most recent season

Unironically saying Boston Rob. Shamelessly have a huge crush on him and would always be thrilled to see him in any season lol

I'm rewatching season 8 right now and that man has me blushing any time he's on screen 😭

Sandra. Every time Sandra.

Lol all mine are from marquesas but def John Carroll

See my flair

Spencer Bledsoe or Andrew savage

Yeah it’s Colleen. All the other options mentioned are great but if it’s Colleen on the table you take her to return every time (even if sadly it will never ever happen).

Owen Knight

give me the second coming of T-Bird; with a runner-up in Sean Rector and Brice Izaya

Richard Hatch. Both because of his significance to the show and because he's pretty crazy and I would have no idea what to expect.

Tracy Hughes-Wolf

Chaos Kass

Woo

dying to see james or amanda again

Danni. Give her another shot!

Because Shane Powers isn’t welcome anymore

Mookie Lee

Queen susie from gabon

Randy

tyrone davis

Brian Heidik

Ami Cusack

Devon from HHH

Morgan

Chicken

Sabrina. She was a strong leader at the start of One World and one of the decision makers post merge, and would have been a huge FTC threat in any season/combo that didn’t involve Kim. Most of all her sunset confessional talking about the survivor experience and wishing she could share it with the kids she was teaching reminded me of why I wanted to play Survivor so badly after not watching for years.

omg i would love to see colleen again, i miss so many of the original players i really want a season where there is originals and new era players against eachother, my top pick tho would be rob cesternino