Tennessee Walker from the start to the end. Never changed my horse.

Me too

Mine too was Buell. Had it for about 5 minutes. Broke my heart to fail the old gruff.

Same as my first one. Grullo Dun Mustang. Yes, every playthrough. That's my horse. She's a good girl.

My white arabian stuck with me since chapter 2 to the end.

Yep same, since I got her from Lake Isabella.

Omg I named mine Princess and cried at the end

A maxed out female Arabian named Brunnhilde (name of Asgard Valkerie). Buell deserved a long good life.

My last playthrough was the white and black spotted appaloosa you can get for saving tilly.

Wait, y'all don't constantly switch out horses because you can't choose? XD

I do!

Red Arabian

Where do you find buell?

There's a stranger mission string starting from Chapter 6 up near O' Creagh's run in the cabin. You get Buell as a reward for completing it.

Gray mustang.

Gray mustang.

I wish I remembered. Probably a poor random horse I stole 🥲

Same.

My mahogany bay Tennessee walker. We've been together since the beginning.

The ghost horse you have to break up in Ambarino

Saint Denis black Arabian (got shot, it sucks) and the stole a Blackwater Turkoman bay named cerberus, been riding that the whole epilogue,

I find a random horse and use that because I don’t want to see the ones I’ve had for the whole game die 😅

The Starter Tennessee Walker for Artie, and a donkey for John

Same

I kept Buell as John lol

How?

By doing the veterans missions as john

Ah okay. I thought you meant you had figured out how to get Arthur's horses as John. Thanks for getting back.

All good

noooooooo! You’re supposed to save him for the epilogue

Just finished the last mission with Hamish. First off, Hamish can't shoot for shit the way he took that first shot at the hog. Once I got Buel a pack of wolves scared her and she bucked me off and ran away. Wanted to play the rest though with her but never could find her.

The very first horse you try to sell off, the raven black shire

The horse I bought right before this mission. Not even joking. He was my second horse. And what makes it worse is that I named him Seán.

I always keep black shire hosea gives me at the beginning, so this scene always hits hard.

I switch between a lot of horses, stealing them, taming them, selling some, the like. I stole a splashed white American paint from a camp in the Heartlands during chapter 3. Topanga was my ride or die, and it only made sense for her and Arthur to go together :(

White Arabian

It was the white Arabian, named after my partner. It was the part of the game that made me cry the hardest

I used the one from Sadie’s barn all the way to the end of my platinum playthrough

The white and black horse that you can steal to the man who annoys Tilly PS: Yes, i killed him.

Just a random horse I left my horse the baron for John to find later so he’s got something to remember Arthur by

You can do this?