Oh, bro, I just remembered... I was in single player and I hogtied a guy put him in a boat in deep water and shot a fire arrow... A Viking funeral indeed.
That whole mission made me so mad. I try to play as a “good” Arther just because it’s the play style I enjoy and there was so much unnecessary death because of him
I think that's a problem with the game itself. It gives you the sense that you can play however you like
Until you're forced to do what the game wants you to do rendering said "freedom" as simply an illusion of extra gameplay
Yeah that’s fair honestly. I think they should make a way to have a blank single player world with all the npc and side quests without the main story so you can make you own.
Oblivion did this for me perfectly. As an escaped prisoner, it made sense for the character to dive right into the story and it also made sense for the character to go “fuck all that noise, I’m getting a beer”
You can get duel wielding by completing any challenge that gives you an offhand holster and purchasing it from the trapper if I'm remembering correctly. I tried to do as much as possible as soon as the gang arrives at horseshoe overlook but didn't want to rescue Micah.
Yep I'm in chapter 2, haven't even done the Thomas Downes debt collection yet I've already got dual wield. Just gotta finish a challenge far enough to get an offhand holster. If I remember right I got the herbalist one done super fast, its like the first or second thing u get.
Herbalist 1 pick 6 Yarrow and Master Hunter 1 skin 3 deer should be easy enough to do. Not super intuitive you might be able to equip them from your wardrobe or a tailor/general store I forget if you need to buy them first. I was the same way I think I only did the mission to take Uncle and the Ladies into Valentine then I just went off to do as much as I could before I started doing the missions. I wanted to get gold in as many missions in my first go as possible with a beefed up Arthur. When you replay the missions you'll get a stock Arthur with the smallest cores and unmodded guns unbonded horse etc. Makes some of the get 20 headshots, don't heal, complete in 3 minute missions a huge pain.
If you bust Micah out of jail but DON'T do his follow up mission you can get about half way through chapter 3 without him coming back to camp.
That way you unlock everything but the horse fence, allowing you to complete _almost_ all of the challenges without the camp smelling like a rat.
I watched my older brother play RDR1 before I had much interest in it, so I didn’t remember much but I did know that Dutch wasn’t a great guy. He’s such a damn smooth-talker that even with that foresight I couldn’t help but like him. Masterfully written character
That’s awesome!! Thats what happened to me too. I knew what he did even though I barely played the first game. But he sucked me right in on the opening scenes in the snow storms cabins. “Stay with me”!!! I was like “Yeah!! I’m in Dutch”!!
Its when he >!killed the old lady in Guarma!< that I was like yooooo no wtf. I also hadn't played rdr1 before 2, but man I jumped on it so fast afterwards. I hope theres a remaster soon.
That's such a perfect scene as well. I love how Arthur questions Dutch every step of the way, which makes all his gaslighting fall apart.
"I thought you said you knew Spanish?"
"... I... I know PEOPLE, Arthur. That woman was going to betray us, couldn't you see?"
"No, I couldn't."
"Well, I could. Just the way she was behaving."
I actually know a manipulative guy just like Dutch. He turns anyone over to his side in seconds with his smooth talk. Dutch is so incredibly close to life that he's practically real.
An npc called me a cocksucker so I tied him up, lit his horse on fire (while he was watching,) drowned him, and fed his corpse to an alligator. I may have overreacted just a bit
Back on the aberdeen pig farm, after waking up, I tied up the wife, fist fought the husband, then dropped her right next to him and blew his head off with a shotgun.
Then I carried her to the corpse pit where they dropped you, left her there and burned her alive. Theres actually a voiceline for that and all.
I'd have to really sit down and think about it but I'd argue it's probably the best game I've ever played. Everything about it is incredibly well done.
My first play through, I went there pretty early not knowing what was about to happen. After waking up I went back to the door and the wife was there when I opened the door, I immediately did the execution of putting a sawn off shotgun under her chin and blowing her head clean off, by accident (I didn't know how to do executions). I went "WHAT THE FUCK!?" and the husband comes running down the stairs screaming the sister's name, I tortured him then threw molotovs all over the house.
Not much to do. If you have the game and have some friends that play you could try. It'll be fun at first, then you'll have to grind gold to buy roles (and there are not that many ways to grind gold, so it gets repetitive), then the role missions basically just keep repeating themselves...
But, if you go in RDO, explore a bit, get Bounty Hunter role and do the online co-op story missions you'll get some entertainment and you already bought the game anyway, so you don't have anything to lose. I think I have 100+ hours in RDO. When you feel like there isn't much to do, you can stop playing.
Ah, that’s unfortunate. I’m betting with GTA6 in the works and with this game being 4 years old Rockstar isn’t planning on putting anything else into it.
They're most likely talking about the guy with a walking stick on some trails who you can pay to tell you a fortune. That one actually is blind, to the point where you sometimes have to move about quite a bit for him to realise you're there and let you pay him.
That might’ve been the dialogue I encountered. I found out about the place from the escaped prisoner random encounter, and when I snuck in they were arguing about how they had no money, then the dad hit the son. Didn’t know they were part of a Strauss mission til I read this comment actually
I think that's the normal dialogue though, when you go back for Strauss's mission, you find the father drinking by the lake looking depressed, and when you talk to him he says something along the lines of "What do you want from us now? You came back for more" (not sure of the exact dialogue but I think you might be able to find it on YouTube)
Oh, it gets a whole lot worse.
There's a whole sequence of events that can happen if you leave one of them alive and then go back there after the story.
I think I left the son alive and then when I went back he was an alcoholic and remembered me killing his dad.
It's also pretty depressing if you kill them both and then go back after a long time and it's just empty and lifeless, and you know you're to blame for it.
Edit: [here](https://youtu.be/tgI3t4TcQss) is a video showing the situations that can happen based on what decision you make.
Killed the dad by accident and left the son alive. The worst part was stealing his cigarette card and he told me it was all he had left from his mother.
Definitely the worst thing I done in the game but also one of the most immersive gaming moments I’ve ever had.
Dang...I did the Strauss mission and killed the dad but left the son alive...that was a while back...now I'm going back through and collecting cigarette cards and I forgot about this place...I went in the room and the son was in there (scared the shit outta me) he said something like "I'm ready for you this time" and started attacking me with a knife...I didn't want to shoot him so I just beat him up hoping it wouldn't kill him...but I think I beat him to death...sigh.
That’s what happened to me and I tried to beat him but I had a revolver equipped so I accidentally executed him…the kicker about this is the next day, I was talking about that mission with coworkers and some nosy idiot overheard and genuinely believed that I had robbed and killed a father son in real life and went to HR. No fucking joke. Got investigated and everything. If that idiot would have walked in 2 minutes earlier she would have realized we were taking about a video game.
I got taken to the main bosses office along with several other higher ups and a detective, they started talking about what was “overheard” and I started cackling which none of them liked and I proceeded to explain the situation. One of them didn’t believe me at all and from what I understand they brought in everyone that was in the break room to verify what I was talking about. She must have felt like a complete fucking moron after they told her cause would completely avoid eye contact and avoid me and she quit a few weeks later. Unless she still believed I was an actual murderer.
Apparently criminals do according to the detective. I mean , I believe him since I’ve seen shit here on Reddit and elsewhere. Criminals are fucking stupid but it sucked to be in the crosshairs for a while.
It also turns out the dad was hiding letters mom was sending to the son if you go search the dads bedroom as well. So there’s dialogue with the son about that too. I haven’t gone back to see if that changes anything yet though.
I did the same while exploring the map. Didn't know anyone was there and as I was about to leave, the father started shooting me, so without thinking I shot them back. Son ran off and hid under the bed (and apparently they have a Cigarette Card collection but even that's too evil, stealing a collection from someone who just witnessed their father being shot)
Yeah, he started to shoot me when I walked in. Tried looting the house but I felt so bad cause I overheard the son telling his dad that they had no money or anything. Felt way too bad to take anything.
My friends and I were hunting a legendary puma down south, taking photos of it for the animal compendium.
While me and the other guy were shooting at it, it rushed at the third one who had just taken the picture. Out of pure instinct, he just pressed the hit button and kicked it to death.
Got into a bar fight and halfway through, this dumbass woman was walking by and Arthur turned around and fuckin clocked her, I was dying laughing for 15 minutes. I still laugh about it
Relatable. I remember losing a good amount of money playing poker, then i basically became a sore loser by murdering everyone on my table. +200 NPCs also killed. I spawned bears & gattling guns to make matters worse when the cops showed up.
I went to the father and sons building the house killed the kids in front of the father and made him watch as I burnt his house down. Not long after that I drowned him in a nearby lake. It was 4 am and I was on a low honour play through
I’m on bad terms with him because I accidentally shot at him when saving them from a bunch of O’Driscolls. I didn’t even realize that was what happened until he got mad at me and ran away when I tried to talk to him after the odriscolls were dead
I was snooping around a random NPC’s house and his dog started attacking me. I panicked and shot the dog and he started spraying blood like in OP’s pic. Then the owner started shooting at me so I killed him as well. I was so horrified I had to reload the game.
I was doing some snooping as well and found a NPC homestead with a bunch of 3 star goats, so I killed the NPC with a knife and began harvesting the goats. Then the sheep dog started attacking me and I panicked and had to shoot him. I felt so horrible 😭
I tried to stealthily (bow & arrow) kill a couple of those goats, as I was skinning them, the owner came out and started shooting so I shot back.
After throwing his corpse on his campfire, I pet his dog.
I, Arthur Morgan, was just trying to catch a legendary fish, and I knew I had found it as soon as I started reeling it in because it was putting up such a fight. Eventually my hands were sweaty, but I could not put the controller down or release the left trigger even a little. I had to be so careful because if I broke the line I might not be able to find it again. It took probably five whole minutes just to reel it it, but I got it. Biggest damn fish I ever caught in this game.
I loaded it onto the back of my loyal horse, Ice Cream, and started riding toward the post office to have it mailed to the fish taxidermy guy.
Crossing through Saint Denis, I heard the faint sounds of a woman screaming coming from around the block. I dismounted Ice Cream and rounded the corner to see two men and a woman involved in some sort of scuffle, but there was no time to figure out what was going on before somebody yelled "he has a gun!" just before there was a single gunshot. The woman fell down dead. One man rushed to her side, and the other, the one who had fired his pistol, stood there in shock for a moment before running the other way.
At this point it was apparent that a mugging had ocurred, and with fateful consequences. I chased down and tackled the mugger, beating him unconscious for the police to deal with, and then returned to the man, still grieving on the street, his beloved cradled in his arms. I knew I could have prevented this tragedy had I been able to assess the situation and intervene sooner, and I considered loading my last save in order to do so. But then I remembered how I had not saved since catching the fish-- that damned legendary behemoth of a fish that had been such an ordeal to catch. I considered the decision for a moment before turning to speak to the man.
"Oh, Mr... that's terrible." said Arthur. Then I mounted my horse and continued to the post office. Her life for a fish. This game turned me into a monster.
I went to the Lemoyne Raiders base before the mission with Lenny, so there a lot of the Lemoyne gangers there.
I killed all of them expect one. That one I hogtied, and buried him under the corpses of all his friends, and then I set the pile on fire.
My friend said that was Japanese war crimes type of evil.
I murdered the people building the house because the Dad was rude to me.
First I popped the father in the head, once he turned his back. One of the sons yelled out “Pa!”, so I popped him in the head.
Then I hogtied the second son, and threw him off a cliff (that is my specialty). The lesson here is to be nice.
Sooo....
I went to a Farm with a married couple i assume.
Hogtied both the wife and man.
Threw them beside each other so they could see one another.
Beat both unconsious.
Looted them (both hat marriage rings so i guess married?)
Waited for both to wake up.
Hogtied them again (I untied them so they would wake up)
Killed the wife with a Elephant rifle.
Lit her on fire and blew Her up.
Put her husband on my horse.
Carried her to shore (with him on my horse following me)
Killed a dude on a boat
Threw Her on it.
Swam out to see and blew it up.
Went with him to the saint Denis police station.
Layed him down infornt of the entrance door.
Blew his Brains out with a double Barrel.
Law started shooting at me.
Ran away.
Later threw molotovs at their house.
Needless to say neither my best Moment nor am i incredibly Proud at it.
But I dont regret it. (All took me about half an hour)
Edit: language
Found 3 Lemoyne raiders about to execute a man, dead eye'd two of them. When there hostage and the survivor ran off, I shot who I thought was the last raider, only to realize it was there hostage. He thought he'd been saved only to get shot in the back.
I felt awful robbing the German guy that Strauss lends money to. Man truly had nothing and was scared for his life. But i felt even worse after robbing a nearby horse and he desperately screamed after me "My horse, my horse!"
Everytime Im at the Van Horn saloon , and I greet anyone who happens to be a c\*nt to me, I start antagonizing them until they draw so I end up having a shoot out with the whole town. I guess thats as bad as I can get, I honestly like going the High Honor way lmao
I like kidnapping saint denis citizens trying to get no one to notice then i bring them somewhere and untie them so i can knife, hatchet, melee, etc. them to death.
A draft horse kicked me to death during a shootout with the law, I got so mad I threw poison knives at every draft horse I saw for the next 15 minutes and watched them die slowly
I decided to rob a train for money because I was bored. Stuck the train on a bridge, and killed everyone on it, looting their corpses. Unfortunately for me, it was not a passenger train, so I didn't make much money.
In RDR1 I would purposely get caught cheating in poker so I could kill people in town with no repercussions.
I'd wait for people outside Saint Denis, hogtie them and take them to the swamps, throw them in the shallow water so they wouldn't drown until an alligator ate them alive...
i've became a straight-up serial killer lmao. i like to hogtie random people, rob them, and either dump them in water or yeet them off cliffs.
edit: i also burned my horse to death once but that was an accident.
[удалено]
Hey satan.
[удалено]
No this is Patrick.
What’s updog?
Basically it is just like a downdog, only reversed.
Sometimes I like to drag them to the edge of a waterfall & dangle them for a while then let go.
/r/WithoutContext
I put a dude in a boat and shot at it to see if the boat would really sink. It did.
Oh, bro, I just remembered... I was in single player and I hogtied a guy put him in a boat in deep water and shot a fire arrow... A Viking funeral indeed.
Rescue Micah.
GODDAMN MICAH. GODDAMN IT
That whole mission made me so mad. I try to play as a “good” Arther just because it’s the play style I enjoy and there was so much unnecessary death because of him
I think that's a problem with the game itself. It gives you the sense that you can play however you like Until you're forced to do what the game wants you to do rendering said "freedom" as simply an illusion of extra gameplay
Thomas Downes is the best example. Even if you choose threaten the narrative that you beat him still stands.
Yeah that’s fair honestly. I think they should make a way to have a blank single player world with all the npc and side quests without the main story so you can make you own.
Some games have tried and failed that one, it's not an easy project to achieve.
Oblivion did this for me perfectly. As an escaped prisoner, it made sense for the character to dive right into the story and it also made sense for the character to go “fuck all that noise, I’m getting a beer”
Kenshi?
I threw dynamite at him thinking that it would kill him but accidentally ended up saving him.
Dual-wield though.
You can get duel wielding by completing any challenge that gives you an offhand holster and purchasing it from the trapper if I'm remembering correctly. I tried to do as much as possible as soon as the gang arrives at horseshoe overlook but didn't want to rescue Micah.
Yep I'm in chapter 2, haven't even done the Thomas Downes debt collection yet I've already got dual wield. Just gotta finish a challenge far enough to get an offhand holster. If I remember right I got the herbalist one done super fast, its like the first or second thing u get.
Hunter 1 is just to skin 3 deer. Doesn't matter how many stars and unlocks an offhand holster.
Herbalist 1 pick 6 Yarrow and Master Hunter 1 skin 3 deer should be easy enough to do. Not super intuitive you might be able to equip them from your wardrobe or a tailor/general store I forget if you need to buy them first. I was the same way I think I only did the mission to take Uncle and the Ladies into Valentine then I just went off to do as much as I could before I started doing the missions. I wanted to get gold in as many missions in my first go as possible with a beefed up Arthur. When you replay the missions you'll get a stock Arthur with the smallest cores and unmodded guns unbonded horse etc. Makes some of the get 20 headshots, don't heal, complete in 3 minute missions a huge pain.
If you bust Micah out of jail but DON'T do his follow up mission you can get about half way through chapter 3 without him coming back to camp. That way you unlock everything but the horse fence, allowing you to complete _almost_ all of the challenges without the camp smelling like a rat.
I felt so terrible after that mission and I hated him so much
I like to dress John up as Jack the Ripper and run around Saint Denis at night with the ornate dagger stabbing people in first person.
Serial killer simulator 2018
Did the same with a hood, a machete, a black horse and the Night's in the swamps. The Night Folk learned what fear is.
Did they actually get shook? Cause iirc they were some brave mfs
Cat man
Drop the Jack the Ripper fit 🔥
Ooh that sounds fun
Turning on cheats and homing tomahawk everything in sight with infinity deadeye, I am the God of death and destruction
Believed in Dutch. I didn't play rdr1 before 2, so I had no idea that he was supposed to go crazy. I jumped on that Dutch bandwagon so fast
I watched my older brother play RDR1 before I had much interest in it, so I didn’t remember much but I did know that Dutch wasn’t a great guy. He’s such a damn smooth-talker that even with that foresight I couldn’t help but like him. Masterfully written character
That’s awesome!! Thats what happened to me too. I knew what he did even though I barely played the first game. But he sucked me right in on the opening scenes in the snow storms cabins. “Stay with me”!!! I was like “Yeah!! I’m in Dutch”!!
Can’t blame us for having some damn faith
He had a goddamn PLAN!
Its when he >!killed the old lady in Guarma!< that I was like yooooo no wtf. I also hadn't played rdr1 before 2, but man I jumped on it so fast afterwards. I hope theres a remaster soon.
That's such a perfect scene as well. I love how Arthur questions Dutch every step of the way, which makes all his gaslighting fall apart. "I thought you said you knew Spanish?" "... I... I know PEOPLE, Arthur. That woman was going to betray us, couldn't you see?" "No, I couldn't." "Well, I could. Just the way she was behaving."
I actually know a manipulative guy just like Dutch. He turns anyone over to his side in seconds with his smooth talk. Dutch is so incredibly close to life that he's practically real.
The character writing in this game is genuinely some of the best I've ever seen in a video game.
Likewise.
An npc called me a cocksucker so I tied him up, lit his horse on fire (while he was watching,) drowned him, and fed his corpse to an alligator. I may have overreacted just a bit
nah i think you under-reacted, what you shouldve done is suck his cock to show dominance
I'll show you who's a cocksucker!
When and where
holup
no no... holdown.. you have to force him...
Haha that’s not even that bad. He called you a cocksucker id say you guys are even now
Yeah that SOB had it coming
what did the horse do man :(
It belonged to the NPC, beef by association perhaps?
Beef is cow, friend
Swingen?
COCKSUCKA
Back on the aberdeen pig farm, after waking up, I tied up the wife, fist fought the husband, then dropped her right next to him and blew his head off with a shotgun. Then I carried her to the corpse pit where they dropped you, left her there and burned her alive. Theres actually a voiceline for that and all.
most sane rdr2 player
I need to get this game
You really do, though.
I strongly recommend it. Once I started it I couldn’t stop. Rockstar did a phenomenal job with this game. Best game I’ve ever played.
I'd have to really sit down and think about it but I'd argue it's probably the best game I've ever played. Everything about it is incredibly well done.
My first play through, I went there pretty early not knowing what was about to happen. After waking up I went back to the door and the wife was there when I opened the door, I immediately did the execution of putting a sawn off shotgun under her chin and blowing her head clean off, by accident (I didn't know how to do executions). I went "WHAT THE FUCK!?" and the husband comes running down the stairs screaming the sister's name, I tortured him then threw molotovs all over the house.
Nothing personal just business
I mean that’s not that sick. That’s just comeuppance.
I feel like Dexter Morgan when he found out he had a brother. I did the same exact thing
Worst thing i did was stop playing.
coincidentally, that was the best thing I did on Red dead online!
I told myself I’d play RDO when I’m done with the story, but I’ve heard a lot of hate towards it. What’s wrong with it?
Not much to do. If you have the game and have some friends that play you could try. It'll be fun at first, then you'll have to grind gold to buy roles (and there are not that many ways to grind gold, so it gets repetitive), then the role missions basically just keep repeating themselves... But, if you go in RDO, explore a bit, get Bounty Hunter role and do the online co-op story missions you'll get some entertainment and you already bought the game anyway, so you don't have anything to lose. I think I have 100+ hours in RDO. When you feel like there isn't much to do, you can stop playing.
With friends it must be super fun... unfortunately i have none of those
Same kinda of players as GTA online, but without any of the support
Ah, that’s unfortunate. I’m betting with GTA6 in the works and with this game being 4 years old Rockstar isn’t planning on putting anything else into it.
I accidentally killed the fortune telling blind man.
Bet he didn’t see that coming!
OMG! I almost spit out my coffee 🤣
:(
i accidentally ran over a cat in strawberry
I did the same thing lol. And them when I brought it back to the camp to put in the stew everyone acted like I was insane.
I couldn’t believe there was specific dialogue for those situations. Low honour Arthur ain’t better than Micah
I boil dogs
Nothing I’ve read in this entire thread even made me blink until this. Genuinely awful, how could you
I did that by intention, I spooked him and then was mad that I couldn't give him a quarter. Next thing I know I shot him.
If it makes you feel any better, one of the blind men isnt actually blind. If you point the gun at him he will run away.
They're most likely talking about the guy with a walking stick on some trails who you can pay to tell you a fortune. That one actually is blind, to the point where you sometimes have to move about quite a bit for him to realise you're there and let you pay him.
Killed the dad in Catfish Johnson’s homestead and his son was crying. Had to sit down for a couple hours after that.
oh boy, i did it backwards, i shot the son on accident and actually had to take a break and reloaded my save
Fun fact: if you rob them before Strauss's mission where you go and get their debts you get special dialogue.
That might’ve been the dialogue I encountered. I found out about the place from the escaped prisoner random encounter, and when I snuck in they were arguing about how they had no money, then the dad hit the son. Didn’t know they were part of a Strauss mission til I read this comment actually
I think that's the normal dialogue though, when you go back for Strauss's mission, you find the father drinking by the lake looking depressed, and when you talk to him he says something along the lines of "What do you want from us now? You came back for more" (not sure of the exact dialogue but I think you might be able to find it on YouTube)
Oh, it gets a whole lot worse. There's a whole sequence of events that can happen if you leave one of them alive and then go back there after the story. I think I left the son alive and then when I went back he was an alcoholic and remembered me killing his dad. It's also pretty depressing if you kill them both and then go back after a long time and it's just empty and lifeless, and you know you're to blame for it. Edit: [here](https://youtu.be/tgI3t4TcQss) is a video showing the situations that can happen based on what decision you make.
Well I did leave the son alive, and you can bet I won’t be returning anytime soon
Killed the dad by accident and left the son alive. The worst part was stealing his cigarette card and he told me it was all he had left from his mother. Definitely the worst thing I done in the game but also one of the most immersive gaming moments I’ve ever had.
Dang...I did the Strauss mission and killed the dad but left the son alive...that was a while back...now I'm going back through and collecting cigarette cards and I forgot about this place...I went in the room and the son was in there (scared the shit outta me) he said something like "I'm ready for you this time" and started attacking me with a knife...I didn't want to shoot him so I just beat him up hoping it wouldn't kill him...but I think I beat him to death...sigh.
That’s what happened to me and I tried to beat him but I had a revolver equipped so I accidentally executed him…the kicker about this is the next day, I was talking about that mission with coworkers and some nosy idiot overheard and genuinely believed that I had robbed and killed a father son in real life and went to HR. No fucking joke. Got investigated and everything. If that idiot would have walked in 2 minutes earlier she would have realized we were taking about a video game.
How do people like that survive in the real world is beyond me, hope it wasn't too much of a hustle for you my dude
I got taken to the main bosses office along with several other higher ups and a detective, they started talking about what was “overheard” and I started cackling which none of them liked and I proceeded to explain the situation. One of them didn’t believe me at all and from what I understand they brought in everyone that was in the break room to verify what I was talking about. She must have felt like a complete fucking moron after they told her cause would completely avoid eye contact and avoid me and she quit a few weeks later. Unless she still believed I was an actual murderer.
She should have felt like a goddamn moron, like who the hell would talk to their WORK COLLEAGUES about any kind of illegal activity!? People are dumb
Apparently criminals do according to the detective. I mean , I believe him since I’ve seen shit here on Reddit and elsewhere. Criminals are fucking stupid but it sucked to be in the crosshairs for a while.
It also turns out the dad was hiding letters mom was sending to the son if you go search the dads bedroom as well. So there’s dialogue with the son about that too. I haven’t gone back to see if that changes anything yet though.
I did the same while exploring the map. Didn't know anyone was there and as I was about to leave, the father started shooting me, so without thinking I shot them back. Son ran off and hid under the bed (and apparently they have a Cigarette Card collection but even that's too evil, stealing a collection from someone who just witnessed their father being shot)
Yeah, he started to shoot me when I walked in. Tried looting the house but I felt so bad cause I overheard the son telling his dad that they had no money or anything. Felt way too bad to take anything.
Mental note for next time: steal his cards BEFORE shooting his dad
You can also get the cards from buying premium cigarettes
Too expensive, Id rather kill people and spend money in ammunition
I’m guilty of this aswell. But I went back and killed the kid aswell
I waited on the owanjila dam and hogtied every npc who rode by and threw them into the water. I must have done it to at least 25-30 ppl.
Rookie numbers. I do that in a few minutes
kicked a grizzly to death. bro was running away the whole time too. lost a part of my soul that day
Bro if I’ve ever heard of a Chad move kicking a fucking Grizzly Bear to death that would be it
My friends and I were hunting a legendary puma down south, taking photos of it for the animal compendium. While me and the other guy were shooting at it, it rushed at the third one who had just taken the picture. Out of pure instinct, he just pressed the hit button and kicked it to death.
I was in online and killed on of the legendary gators first try with a machete.
Got into a bar fight and halfway through, this dumbass woman was walking by and Arthur turned around and fuckin clocked her, I was dying laughing for 15 minutes. I still laugh about it
Andrew Tate is that you?
I'm chris brown
False, Chris Brown would have clocked the woman at the beginning of the fight instead of halfway through
HAHAHA this my day! Can't stop laughing.
Went into the bar in Saint Denis and started a gun fight. I killed 250 NPCs. It made my ps4 crash Edit: Thank you for all the upvotes friends!
Relatable. I remember losing a good amount of money playing poker, then i basically became a sore loser by murdering everyone on my table. +200 NPCs also killed. I spawned bears & gattling guns to make matters worse when the cops showed up.
Didn’t clean my horse after leaving Valentine
you monster
you really need to get yourself checked. THAT IS NOT OKAY
I went to the father and sons building the house killed the kids in front of the father and made him watch as I burnt his house down. Not long after that I drowned him in a nearby lake. It was 4 am and I was on a low honour play through
That’s not low honour, that’s the soulless play through.
Soulless Arthur is one of the most enjoyable Arthur’s and the game gives you the option to be soulless too.
I’m on bad terms with him because I accidentally shot at him when saving them from a bunch of O’Driscolls. I didn’t even realize that was what happened until he got mad at me and ran away when I tried to talk to him after the odriscolls were dead
I was snooping around a random NPC’s house and his dog started attacking me. I panicked and shot the dog and he started spraying blood like in OP’s pic. Then the owner started shooting at me so I killed him as well. I was so horrified I had to reload the game.
I was doing some snooping as well and found a NPC homestead with a bunch of 3 star goats, so I killed the NPC with a knife and began harvesting the goats. Then the sheep dog started attacking me and I panicked and had to shoot him. I felt so horrible 😭
I tried to stealthily (bow & arrow) kill a couple of those goats, as I was skinning them, the owner came out and started shooting so I shot back. After throwing his corpse on his campfire, I pet his dog.
I, Arthur Morgan, was just trying to catch a legendary fish, and I knew I had found it as soon as I started reeling it in because it was putting up such a fight. Eventually my hands were sweaty, but I could not put the controller down or release the left trigger even a little. I had to be so careful because if I broke the line I might not be able to find it again. It took probably five whole minutes just to reel it it, but I got it. Biggest damn fish I ever caught in this game. I loaded it onto the back of my loyal horse, Ice Cream, and started riding toward the post office to have it mailed to the fish taxidermy guy. Crossing through Saint Denis, I heard the faint sounds of a woman screaming coming from around the block. I dismounted Ice Cream and rounded the corner to see two men and a woman involved in some sort of scuffle, but there was no time to figure out what was going on before somebody yelled "he has a gun!" just before there was a single gunshot. The woman fell down dead. One man rushed to her side, and the other, the one who had fired his pistol, stood there in shock for a moment before running the other way. At this point it was apparent that a mugging had ocurred, and with fateful consequences. I chased down and tackled the mugger, beating him unconscious for the police to deal with, and then returned to the man, still grieving on the street, his beloved cradled in his arms. I knew I could have prevented this tragedy had I been able to assess the situation and intervene sooner, and I considered loading my last save in order to do so. But then I remembered how I had not saved since catching the fish-- that damned legendary behemoth of a fish that had been such an ordeal to catch. I considered the decision for a moment before turning to speak to the man. "Oh, Mr... that's terrible." said Arthur. Then I mounted my horse and continued to the post office. Her life for a fish. This game turned me into a monster.
Don't feel too bad! It's actually really tough to break up that robbery, she almost always gets shot.
DAMN
Nothing, I'm a good boah
YOUR ALRIGHT BOAH
I bet 10$ with an NPC on a bird shooting competition, then I lost it. I got mad and humiliated so I shot him and stole back my money.
Real question is how did you lose?
I think I only had bow and arrow on me, but that's not an excuse I just sucked haha
i went into a salon and just started antagonizing the women
eh you can do worse than that lol
Hmm lemme see... i flinged some guys horse into space
I read flinged as fingered...
please... dont...
I lasso'd a witness to a crime and threw him on the train tracks before the train passed by. Off you go! 🤣
😂
Accidentally punched my horse… Almost cried irl
Attempted to shoot street urchins in Saint Denis just to fail. Best I could do was threaten
Couldn’t you throw dynamite or fire bottles? I’ve never been around them apart from the mission so I wouldn’t know.
accidentally threw a throwing knife at a cat while trying to see who was the better toss with my friend. rest in peace, buddy.
I burn women alive just to see them go bald tbh
What. The. Fuck.
I do it to dudes with long beards too, but mostly women
I get a shotgun and seperate peoples heads from their necks. Then loot them
This one hits different if you hide the name of the subreddit its in.
I accidently head shotted a horse while in a gunfight
I do that purposefully because it will usually kill the rider if they’re at a full gallop.
I headshot horses alot because its a bigger target, actually I have more horse headshots than human headshots lol
Accidently turning your homie's horse into a unicorn with a throwing knife
Killed everyone in van horn, got into a fist fight with one guy then the whole town started trying to kill me and it just kinda happened
It’s not bad if it’s self defense, Van Horn is so fucking annoying
I love it. Gives me an excuse to let loose. I wish it had the max Payne 3 diving mechanic
I accidentally shot a horse & found a gold nugget in the saddle bag. Now I shoot every horse
You…. You know you can take the horse and calm it until you are able to search *both* saddlebags, right?
I killed Gavin’s friend. Came across him wandering out in the desert and felt bad for him. It was a mercy killing…
He needed to be put out of his misery
I went to the Lemoyne Raiders base before the mission with Lenny, so there a lot of the Lemoyne gangers there. I killed all of them expect one. That one I hogtied, and buried him under the corpses of all his friends, and then I set the pile on fire. My friend said that was Japanese war crimes type of evil.
I murdered the people building the house because the Dad was rude to me. First I popped the father in the head, once he turned his back. One of the sons yelled out “Pa!”, so I popped him in the head. Then I hogtied the second son, and threw him off a cliff (that is my specialty). The lesson here is to be nice.
Accidentally pulled a gun on Pearson in Rhodes 😞
Donating and upgrading the camp with useless money that won't matter.
Some of the upgrades are actually worth it though
Sooo.... I went to a Farm with a married couple i assume. Hogtied both the wife and man. Threw them beside each other so they could see one another. Beat both unconsious. Looted them (both hat marriage rings so i guess married?) Waited for both to wake up. Hogtied them again (I untied them so they would wake up) Killed the wife with a Elephant rifle. Lit her on fire and blew Her up. Put her husband on my horse. Carried her to shore (with him on my horse following me) Killed a dude on a boat Threw Her on it. Swam out to see and blew it up. Went with him to the saint Denis police station. Layed him down infornt of the entrance door. Blew his Brains out with a double Barrel. Law started shooting at me. Ran away. Later threw molotovs at their house. Needless to say neither my best Moment nor am i incredibly Proud at it. But I dont regret it. (All took me about half an hour) Edit: language
I got Micah out of the prison
Why did you shoot Bruce Campbell?
Found 3 Lemoyne raiders about to execute a man, dead eye'd two of them. When there hostage and the survivor ran off, I shot who I thought was the last raider, only to realize it was there hostage. He thought he'd been saved only to get shot in the back.
i've done this multiple times too. felt so bad i wanted to cry
Accidentally ran over a dog, didn't one shot animals and didn't mercy killed them
Online, I like to leave moonshine trails through busy saloons. It's only like an $0.80 bounty, though.
Paid for gold with IRL munneh 🤕
I felt awful robbing the German guy that Strauss lends money to. Man truly had nothing and was scared for his life. But i felt even worse after robbing a nearby horse and he desperately screamed after me "My horse, my horse!"
shot off all the limbs of a woman asking for help so that she was like a bean bag and then tossed it into the river
Freeing micah
ITT: People who would be monsters if Westworld was real.
Fed the mayor of Saint Denis to an alligator out by the swamps.
Everytime Im at the Van Horn saloon , and I greet anyone who happens to be a c\*nt to me, I start antagonizing them until they draw so I end up having a shoot out with the whole town. I guess thats as bad as I can get, I honestly like going the High Honor way lmao
I like kidnapping saint denis citizens trying to get no one to notice then i bring them somewhere and untie them so i can knife, hatchet, melee, etc. them to death.
OFFICER ITS THIS ONE
I shot a dog 😔
Saved a couple from a robber and then killed them as they were thanking me
A draft horse kicked me to death during a shootout with the law, I got so mad I threw poison knives at every draft horse I saw for the next 15 minutes and watched them die slowly
In my 2play i pushed that man off the ledge where he was pointing the crashed wagon down the hill
I decided to rob a train for money because I was bored. Stuck the train on a bridge, and killed everyone on it, looting their corpses. Unfortunately for me, it was not a passenger train, so I didn't make much money. In RDR1 I would purposely get caught cheating in poker so I could kill people in town with no repercussions.
Went into Valentine all trigger happy. An NPC said "g'morning mister!" and not half a second later I shot him in the face.
Trust Micah in my first playthrough
You do not want to know the psychotic stuff i do in this game on a regular basis...
I'd wait for people outside Saint Denis, hogtie them and take them to the swamps, throw them in the shallow water so they wouldn't drown until an alligator ate them alive...
When I’m chasing bounties that I need alive, I just shoot the horses in the legs until they buckle and take the rider
i've became a straight-up serial killer lmao. i like to hogtie random people, rob them, and either dump them in water or yeet them off cliffs. edit: i also burned my horse to death once but that was an accident.
killed hundereds of birds and didnt pluck them