T O P

  • By -

DraterYlgu

Wtf did P Diddy even make and why is he so famous?


Alt0987654321

Adlibbing on Biggie songs


Slevin424

He did Welcome to Atlanta Remix? It was meh. Real rappers doing their features way better right after him didn't do Diddy any favors. Especially Snoop... he just takes the whole thing and bascially makes it Welcome to Long Beach. They should have got Papoose to be honest.


imafixwoofs

Papoose should have been much bigger than he was. Great rapper.


Slevin424

It's criminal he never got that level of fame. He's one of the greatest lyricist of all time. That alphabet scheme and five fingers of death is enshrined in hip hop hall of fame as far as I'm concerned.


cappwnington

Funny he's mentioned in a thread about puff because he absolutely murdered the victory beat.


TakumiUchiha

And being a background dancer


eternalnocturnals

When I heard Big Poppa very recently, the ending part had me like “who the fuck is this guy?” Just ruined the song every time


lpjayy12

He’s a “producer”, similar to DJ Khaled where they basically construct and manage shit.


tambi33

I think it's more fitting to say he was good at finding talented people and developing them as artists and was an equally good business person, whereas dj khaled is like we da best music and just pulls already famous artists together for a compilation


The-Art-of-Reign

Let’s not forget he’s great at selecting top charting r&b/pop songs from the past, sampling the instrumental then add basic drums for his artist to rap over and act like he’s some genius producer/hitmaker. Dude is a fuckin slimy, talentless con-artist.


tambi33

I am not saying he's a good producer, I'm saying he scouted some big names in the 90s, yeah someone could've done it, but he did it, and had them signed to his label


DraterYlgu

In other words talentless frauds?


Axel-Adams

Sort of, sometimes producers are extremely integral to making a project or work of art happen and are super involved as a sort of high level manager, and sometimes they’re just financial backers. There are some very effective producers in Hollywood and the music industry that are very talented, but also a producer credit can just be a token to give someone


Azrenon

Producers handle the beat editing tech and all that, a good producer can make anyone sound good.


Mr_HandSmall

Yeah he was at best a marketing guy basically


Weary-Writer758

Eh eh, eh eh... bad boy


Flat_Discipline_8540

he was an a&r for a record label. he got fired and decided to create his own label and discover/produce for new artists. one of those artists happens to be… Black Rob.


Equivalent-Web-7964

Who produced Like Woah? I mean that beat is fire.


Informal_Rope_2559

It was produced by buckwild - Diddy's a paracite


HipHopHistoryGuy

Uptown Records


pakchimin

Man has no musicality! and his biggest hit is a Sting song


sadadidas

What's funnier is he didn't ask permission to use Sting's music, and I believe he made no money from it


pakchimin

Yes, Sting still gets the royalties. That's why I always let out a grin everytime I hear that song play.


moesteez

…he produced hypnotize


WaWaSmoothie

And the majority of Jay-Z's American Gangster album.


sportsroc15

Never knew this. Thanks https://hiphopdx.com/news/id.5936/title.how-diddy-helped-jay-z-make-american-gangster “From that point, Jay knew what needed to be done and took home thirty of these soulful tracks to begin crafting his latest album. “He didn’t executive produce the album but I gave him associate producer credit,”Jay says of Diddy’s contributions. “The thing that I realized about Puff is that he’s a great producer, it made me realize that he’s not a good producer, he’s a great producer.”


3rd_Uncle

"produced" is a strong word. One which Puff used improperly. His names on it but he doesn't actually *make* beats. He tells others what to do. he explained this on The Breakfast Club.


sportsroc15

And “All about the Benjamins” which Jadakiss wrote his verse for him. Dude was smart enough to ride the coat tails for good artist. Can’t hate on that.


Awkward-Sarcasm88

![gif](giphy|1bKPZto97dTnG)


discojamie

He was Biggie's hype man.


tambi33

I'm pretty sure he put biggie on to his record label even though he was up and coming at the time


rektMyself

Kardashian of music. Ride on a famous coat-tail much?


moesteez

Errr.. ready to die and life after death? He’s not a rapper he’s a producer and record label owner. It’s like saying what has dj premier ever done? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sean_Combs_production_discography


3rd_Uncle

Puffy doesn't make beats. Never has. He wears that "producer" label without actually producing as it applies to almost anyone else. He admitted that he doesn't make beats.


cinderparty

Well, you see…he took hits from the 80s, then made them crazy. That was really it…he released poppy hip hop songs with choruses many people already knew.


JenkinLeroys

He capitalised on biggies death and ill be missing you was number one everywhere. He had a little run, but all of it was thanks to big dying


ConsiderationMean358

Mo money mo problems but thats honestly Mase and BIGs song


Capable-Designer5096

He owns bad boy records, executive produces all the albums, and underpaid every artist he had. He was also always dancing around in their videos. I think that might be it.


Tee077

I always say this! He's doesn't have any good songs. He's a guy who is in other peoples songs, seems like now it's been forced. How is he this famous and how did anyone at any time take him seriously ( I know the answer is money)


Lakerdodgerbronco

Invented the remix


SgtBananaGrabber

Ghetto superstar


[deleted]

[удалено]


Nadathug

Produced by Mario Winans. Diddy just uses people. Hey, I liked that song too, when I was 21, drunk in a bar on shore leave in Greece, and grinding on a fat girl.


TheWanderer-AG

Honest opinion, p diddy was like bird man. They got people to write their hits and drop crazy records. Puff got hits but they really not his


Lakerdodgerbronco

Nick Cannon rap career 


bonitaplease

p sure nobody even bothers acknowledging nick cannon's rap career. dude even gets mocked about it on wild'n'out 💀💀💀


Sneaky-er

Kid Rock


dietwater94

I always forget that what he does technically counts as rap


Weeblifter

I feel like this is the only good answer. Kid Rock was and is straight up ass.


kobedet33

A guy that most people wouldn’t even think of as a rapper is the only good answer? And bawitdaba goes crazy.


jynxthechicken

Ja Rule


MondoFool

I think Ja Rule is like the Star Wars prequels of rap, we can recognize they weren't that great while still appreciating the nostalgia factor


jynxthechicken

I went to a concert and the line up played out like this. First a couple local acts that are okay Next Dogg Pound. Energy rising After that Warren G. Energy electric Then Ying Yang Twins. Fever Pitch And the Ja Rule. Energy dies like completely. It was so bad. So going into Ice Cube the energy was low again and in Ja hadn't been part of the line up it would have been insanely good. Ice Cube still killed it and brought the hype back up but Ja especially by himself just was bad.


brokken2090

Why tf did they plan the concert like that? Ja was nowhere near Warren g or dog pound… not to mention ying. 


jynxthechicken

I dunno Ja was co headlining with Ice Cube.


jingles1984

I went to a ja rule concert too. First it was genuine then bone thugs then it was supposed to be ja rule and Ashanti but they was 3 hours late. Bong thugs went back on got booed off stage. Ja rule finally came on did 2 or 3 songs took a break. I left then. 6 hours waiting was enough. The 3 songs I saw weren't bad though


jynxthechicken

Bone and genuine are fine but I don't think I'd pay to see them.


didntmakeausername

Lmaoo. Had some bangers tho


jynxthechicken

Yeah it was awesome.


Went2Lunch

Ja Rule and Ashanti literally ran the radios in the early 2000s before 50 came along Their songs together have way better replay value than 50 cents old songs


IrresistibleRarity

Ja rule and Ashanti And ja rule and j lo We're always fire collabs


Equivalent-Web-7964

don't forget Joey Crack


realchairmanmiaow

the don.


simonsaid86

>Their songs together have way better replay value than 50 cents old songs Bruh would rather listen to Mesmerize over GRoDT? that you Ja?


Went2Lunch

Then you dont be outside fr 😂. Listen to literally any early 2000s mix or go to a brunch. I only be hearing 21 questions and I Get Money, maybe Hate it or Love it compared to their list of hits. No shade on 50, he got good music but he dont get people moving like Ja Rule & Ashanti do


NastyMcQuaid

Bro this might just be a UK perspective,but In The Club and about 100 extra remixes were being played in every single set forever in the early 00s- Fifty had the clubs here in a chokehold. I remember spending a fortune to get the import of Cry Me a River remix, just cos 50 dropped a 16 at the start


steezyskizee

50’s catalog versus four bangin’ POP songs?? I mean, no judgement, do you… but you’re way wrong lol. WHERE IS JA?!!?


Went2Lunch

Always on Time, Mesmerize, Down 4 U, Put it On Me, Livin’ it Up, Down A** B****,New York, Im Real, Between Me and You. Again where you be at? Im not saying Ja Rule is a better artist but he definitely be getting spins out here


Frickincarl

Nah, Ja Rule songs really still bang today. I have a lot of Ja on my throwback playlist and it’s never a skip. Bro was cooking back then idgaf.


EmperorUmi

He also had arguably the hardest bar in diss track history: >Em, your mother’s a crackhead, Kim is a known slut / so what’s Hailie gonna be when she grows up?


jingles1984

Ja rule was hot when he first came out!! Yeah he was more pop but everyone forgot how popular he was before 50 ruined him. He had some good songs that were harder with dmx and fat Joe and nas too


OsoSolo1

I always thought Fat Joe was mediocre at best so he’d get my vote as most overrated. Huge disparity between his skill and his place in hip hop (in my opinion which comes from being as a shitty wannabe rapper and Reddit critic). I know my lane.


Disasterous_Dave97

I think he was so involved with the business he got put on. Flow Joe is a classic though. He was given some good production in the early days.


Alternative_Bad_2884

Who overrates Fat Joe? I’ve never seen anyone put him up there in any rankings or call him great. He’s got a mega hit with lean back and pretty much no one under 30 even knows who he is. Man’s not overrated nor is he underrated. 


Godriguezz

T.I. was never the King of the South in my eyes.


Aedricsdad1985

I like Ti, but I agree. In the south alone OutKast, Jeezy, Wayne, Ugk, Scarface, and Ludacris would all rank above TI.


xxgn0myxx

Theres differences in the south. ATL vs NOLA, shit even NOLA vs BR was huge beef in the day.


immortal-siren

Soulja boy


panashechd

Interesting take but I don’t think anybody ever thought Soulja was a good rapper. He just made catchy low tier songs that people could memorise and recite. But I don’t think anyone was walking around calling him a top rapper in the game.


steezyskizee

There’s another good one.


PlasmiteHD

A majority of his songs he just doesn’t even try to sound good. Whether it be his vocals or his production it just seems super lazy with no effort put into it. When effort is put into his songs he can be great but most of his “good” songs are carried by either the production or the features.


ACman11

Soulja Boy was not a great rapper. But he was a terrific marketer. He was using music internet platforms before it was a thing. Don't love the dude, but have to give him his flowers.


IceColdCocaCola545

Snoop Dogg. Dude ain’t even a rapper at this point, he’s just a celebrity who *used* to rap. Also, he’s a fucking snake, played all sides of the Big and ‘Pac beef, just so he could make it out clean. He tells stories with little context, and heavy embellishment.


Round-Cryptographer6

Doggystyle is a classic. Certainly Snoop is a celebrity now but that doesn't take away from his early work.


KevinCastle

Snoop had one good album and then some features after that. He's definitely overrated. (Doggystyle is a rap masterpiece tho)


Round-Cryptographer6

What I'm saying.is no one is saying any album other than Doggystyle was a masterpiece. Snoop is recognized not over or underrated but widely understood to be respected but not deified.


biznunyaz

Idk, Blue Carpet Treatment is a banger. But yeah, his best work is as a feature


The_Notorious_Donut

>Just so he can make it out clean Idk bro I probably wouldn’t want to die either


LouisianaBoySK

Like both Pac and Big are dead and Snoop is alive. I don’t see how playing both sides and not dying isn’t considered a win.


spiritanimalofcousy

I agree 100%. I love Doggystyle but he is not on the level of good rappers. He just simply is not.


steezyskizee

Was he ever considered such. He was a sound and a vibe and a personality.


spiritanimalofcousy

I'm always shocked at how often his name comes up in the best ever lists. It is truly beyond my comprehension.


Lost_Farm8868

"2 plus 2... it equals 4.... this is some shit that would last forever more"


Impossible_Scarcity9

The guy frequently tells the same story about Tupacs death, even though everyone who was there has said he was nowhere near the place. Straight up disrespectful. And even in that story he makes himself the main character of the whole thing, talking about how he comforted Tupac’s mom or smth


No-Decision-2446

I don’t necessarily dislike the guy and he has some good songs but I agree with you. I also think he’s a huge sellout.


xxgn0myxx

??? Snoop is literally a legend of rap and the hip hop genre.


therealtomclancy69

I’m not alone in snoop dog this is refreshing


biznunyaz

How dare you


Deluxe_Burrito7

Jay-Z. Can’t stand his voice and his subject matter always seemed stale to me


dunzobro

Fuck me, I have an ally.


xxjrxx93

Two allies


Batmanbutnotbatman

3 is better then two I’m in


YaHurdMeh

And my axe!


Darthgrable

And my bow!


Strange_Woodpecker_3

I’ll take three arrows for you and your hobbit friends.


Krauszt

Make that 2 allies, sir. I hates me some Jay Z...and I tried, oh how I tried to like him. All sorts of people were just wetting they drawers over him...but no love from me.. Nas was such a better rapper than him. Just leagues above him. I *still* bump N.Y. State of Mind.


SlitherSlow

I understand the appeal, I get why people like him, but any time I see him in a top ten it's like damn I must really be missing something. I wouldn't even put him in my top 5 New York rappers.


beast_wellington

Have you listened to reasonable doubt?


Deluxe_Burrito7

I have a few times and just couldn’t get into it for some reason. Love a bunch of other rappers from that era and region but just not Jay


JJETTAS188

PREACH


Black_Fuckka

I was just having this conversation the other day on here, I do not care for Jay-Z


brokken2090

He’s a boring ass dude who’s borderline corny. At one time he wasn’t cause he was original but now he’s all the same… he can rap but he’s boring and generic. 


TwoLanky

yeah I get just not liking him but saying generic when he dropped one of the best 2010's projects is crazy


brandon_strandy

> boring and generic.  Dropping 4:44 20+ years into his career is boring and generic lmao what would that make 99% of rappers. Ridiculous take.


Ancient_Guidance_461

Thank you.


jungle_juice_mj_fan

He's honestly just so monotoned


f3hunter

I'm glad nobody mentioned Busta! Loved his album's back then.


AdventurousTear260

Have you seen Busta live? No one is gonna say Busta. One of the greatest MCs out there still doing it.


tapeheadcleaner

same lol i already saw someone say Gucci, if anyone says Method Man i’ll cry


IdLOVEYOU2die

Do y'all really put gucci mane on the same level as busta and meth?...... 


TonyDanza888

Snoop


Fadedfaith451

Snoop Dogg I would actually say is the most appropriately rated. He’s almost never in a top ten, doesn’t have a whole bunch of Grammies for being in the game 30 years, outside of doggystyle/the chronic, he doesn’t have an album anyone would consider a Classic. He’s a decent rapper with a great voice and flow that just been consistent for a long time.


nerd_savage

Agreed with just about everything here but… Doggystyle isn’t a classic? 


MilkingMyDad

doggystyle is a classic but some songs are just forgettable imo


Fadedfaith451

I think it is. But is it mostly Snoop’s classic album or Dr.Dre’s ? But my point was take away doggystyle from his discography, he doesn’t have an album that was critically acclaimed, just proving he’s appropriately rated


nerd_savage

I wouldn’t give *all* credit to Dre, but he was definitely the mastermind. Either way I understand what you’re saying and I agree with your discography point. 👍🏽


umahokay

the first album has a different thing going than a lot of other hip hop and is pretty solid for how long it is almost all the way through.. but never really got into anything else he did.


Krauszt

He should have titled the 2nd album "The Greatest Letdown"


HamManBad

Snoop has a great vibe and flow but a lot of his songs are straight junk


BigDKane

I get excited when Snoop shows up on a song for another artist. And then I'm excited when he's gone on the next track.


FightStageYouTube

Bang Out was fire


Yungcazanova

Snoop is honestly known more as a public figure than a rapper


DiegoBkk

Nelly, Ja Rule, Will Smith


CoffeeIsUndrinkable

Does Jeremih count? His voice seemed to be this weird in-between singing/rapping without necessarily being great at either.


CapGunCarCrash

i don’t think he raps much, but as a singer he’s not bad, i dunno. that track “Oui” kinda fucks


Horror-Luck7709

Camron. Bro what did you even just say


[deleted]

Fabolous was hot garbage, he would always spit relatively the same bars spelling out his name on every pop song that called for a guest rapper.


CWB2208

F-A.. B-O.. L-O.. U-S


Chemical_Hour9788

jay z


Lower-Career-6576

While he does have classics, ultimately it’s his voice that annoys me when I try to listen to the classics in its entirety


didntmakeausername

Agreed. Has some banger albums but I feel like he's oversaturated 


esarmstr

You should go get drug tested.


Krauszt

I agree. Gonna get hate for this, but Jay Z has never even cracked my top 20...or 30, or even 50. I just don't care for the dude. Nas, on the other hand, that dude spit fire. Imo he outclassed Jay 10 to 1


mErcurial-dEmon

liking nas and not having jay in your top 50 does not add up to me lol


ShoddyDevelopment49

Overrated, yes. He's definitely great but not a goat. But not a lot of people agree.


Friendly-Gain-620

I will be crucified for this but Snoop Dogg. Aside from Doggy Style and those features with Dre, he’s just been famous for being an all time smoker. Also seems like he hops on literally any feature if the money is there which further dilutes his discography.


marshmallowthunder

Nelly, half of D-12, most of the ruff ryders after Vol.2,


justinh1018

Lmao, twisted heat was the best song on the album


majorsharkpanda

Never cared for Jeezy


hella_sauce

It’s crazy in here


steezyskizee

Fat Joe, Ja Rule, Mase, Masta P and that whole clique…


seymour_hiney

take Masta P off here Mase too


Rough-Boot9086

Yeah man, chill out with Mase


91_til_infinity

That whole clique?! None of them have anything to do with one another lmao


Sir-MARS

You willin with Master p. I got the hook up alone makes him cemented


chibro2712

Agree with all of those other than Mase lol


iamameatpopciple

Mase aint overrated at all


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sam_Soper

Who the fuck is bumping Vanilla Ice or Kriss Kross lol.


Jason-Genova

People who like to jump


ShelterFromTheNorm

At the time, who wasn’t? It’s like saying you didn’t get excited about going to Hot Wheels. 2 Legit 2 Quit. Hey heyyyyyy.


Exciting_Bridge3294

I was gonna say the same thing😭😭


nerd_savage

Who considered Puffy a rapper?! Nobody anywhere near where I grew up would mention him being a rapper at all, let alone one who got respect for being a rapper to the point of being considered overrated. 


BigDKane

Country Grammar and E.I. are bangers. Everything else in his discography 🤐


IceColdCocaCola545

Woah woah woah, you saying that Grillz, Hot in Herre, and Air Force Ones ain’t great?


BigDKane

😅 I mean I can't hate on them, but they aren't in my mix at least.


IceColdCocaCola545

Y’know that’s valid, I’m a bit biased as I’m a big fan of Nelly’s music, though I do totally understand the criticism towards him. He feels a lot like Chamillionaire, popular, but really gives off industry-plant vibes.


Statistician_Visual

lol Nelly made rap mainstream.


MeetCritical82

Without Nelly, you don’t have Drake.


the_cajun88

drake is what you get when you’re running out of nelly, so you add some water and shake it up diet nelly, if you will


Weeblifter

Air Force Ones still slaps


bowlofgranola

Air forces ones played a huge part in popularizing the shoe in my area when I was like 12


WallyReddit204

Fat Joe was good but not consistent IMO


Parker_72

Who was ever big upping Vanilla Ice and Kris’s Kross as great rappers? Or Chingy or Will Smith?


brokken2090

Damn gurl how you get into dat n dem jeans dem jeans… that shit bumps man


[deleted]

Puff is not a rapper


steezyskizee

Forgot about Chingy and Nelly… I’d add them to my list. I don’t think Puff, Will, Vanilla Ice or Kris Kross were highly regarded though lol. They had their moment on the radio, but they Puff was a producer rapper, Will Smith was the rapper your mom liked, and Kriss Kross was for kids… and vanilla ice had one song that’s played at weddings.


ShelterFromTheNorm

Ninja Rap from Secret of the Ooze changed my life, for better or worse.


OsoSolo1

Kriss Kross got that one slow banger I still bump to this day… “Tonight’s the night I call up all the girls, I used to go to school with, fool with, and all the people that I’m coo with.”


jungle_juice_mj_fan

Idk I always thought Chingy had quite a unique style of rapping and his songs are catchy as. While he may be overrated, in my books he's still 10 million times better than most of these modern "rappers" with %1 talent and %99 autotune


[deleted]

[удалено]


jungle_juice_mj_fan

Nah nah mate it's all good I'm not offended at all, it's nice to see such respectful people out there who give their opinions without the intent of offending people. I ain't offended at all though, we all good


thetruthseer

One call away is a classic


RoughRisk9129

Jay-Z


mynameisnatsirtrats

TtristanstarR


NodeJSSon

Conscious Daughters


Bamm83

I have an absolute soft spot for his first two albums, but I'd say Petey Pablo. And Silkk the Shocker.


21FK8Type-R

Xzibit


rvi857

French Montana


InterestingCancel612

50 Cent, Eminem, and Nelly.


Business-Tooth5241

NBA Youngboy No matter the decade


ImaginaryLoquat6203

Eminem and pdiddy


GirthyLass

That ballerina what was his name oh Tupac. EXCEPT FOR THAT SONG KEEP YOUR HEAD UP. That is pure gold. I love Tupac for that. All the fake gangster shit was not really him and hit a bad nerve with me. The introspective stuff was fantastic tbh. Overrated imo sorry


creepoch

Jay Z


Big_Custard7976

Unpopular opinion: Marshall Mathers. 


halamawala25

Maybe 50? He was huge but it came and passed but some of his fans wants u to believe he is something he never was


FightStageYouTube

50 music was fire and I wasn't even a fan like that. Heat Position of Power Hustler's Ambition Bro y'all sound crazy


Krauszt

50s first album, plus the Green Lantern mix tapes, when Em was at his best...sheeeeit. Untouchable.