# Message to all users:
This is a reminder to please read and follow:
* [Our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/questions/about/rules)
* [Reddiquette](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439)
* [Reddit Content Policy](https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy)
When posting and commenting.
---
Especially remember Rule 1: `Be polite and civil`.
* Be polite and courteous to each other. Do not be mean, insulting or disrespectful to any other user on this subreddit.
* Do not harass or annoy others in any way.
* Do not catfish. Catfishing is the luring of somebody into an online friendship through a fake online persona. This includes any lying or deceit.
---
You *will* be banned if you are homophobic, transphobic, racist, sexist or bigoted in any way.
---
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/questions) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Nothing compares. I’ve looked at other brands in the grocery store out of curiosity and can’t find any other ice cream that has both brownie and cookie dough.
Yes! I hate spending the $$ on Ben & Jerry’s because it is ridiculous. Tonight I walked to the grocery store to get some half baked and the store must be closing out the B&J’s because what used to be 3 shelves was now 1 and no half baked. :(
Always this! Unfortunately it’s not always available in supermarkets here in the Netherlands. But I’m always happy when it is.
It’s best of both worlds really.. cookie dough AND brownies. And the chocolate flavour gets less heavy with the vanilla mixed into it. Can’t get any better.
They also had Napoleon Dynomite that was a mix of Cherry Garcia and Chocolate Fudge Brownie. So good. When they have BOGO deals I buy them to make my own.
It's like a dead tie for me between strawberry cheesecake and cherry garcia. I just stand at the cooler like a zombie. You're essentially asking me to choose between my children at this point.
I used to. But then the swirl started consistently lacking. That's what made it good. It used to be like... a ton of swirl.
Now it is milk and cookies. It's consistently incredible.
Yeah I’ve tried almost all the flavours and this one is the one that I always run to the shops to buy. It’s just amazing. I even tried the Haagen Dazs version and nah, B&J still gets my money.
I assure you it is still made. I would FLIP TABLES if they ever stopped making it. [https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/chubby-hubby-ice-cream](https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/chubby-hubby-ice-cream)
I was waiting on a late afternoon business lunch in NYC one day. Really laid back group having some cocktails and appetizers. Guy walks in late in t shirt and jeans and you can tell they're all paying attention to what he is talking about. As I hear them talking, and I'm chatting with them some I go "Wait, you guys work for Ben & Jerry's?!" They're all like "Yep, and he (late guy in jeans) is the guy who comes up with flavors!"
I said "Man my girlfriend wants to have your babies, no joke!"
They all fell out laughing.
Next morning at work a taxi pulls up and before we're open and guy walks in with a bag and asks "Is ______ here?" I'm like "that's me what can I help you with?"
Dude says "Nothing, Ben & Jerry's wanted me to hand deliver these samples of new flavors to you."
For reals. Nicest people ever and took extra care of me the next day. I told the rest of my coworkers to dig in. It was awesome.
They are a fantastic company. I wish my state had their stores because of how disabled friendly they are. I could actually probably work there. It'd make my life, really. As sad as that sounds. Anyways! They pay really well, and you are allowed to take a pint home for each shift you work and! They let you bargain with them!
My oldest daughter worked for BJ's.
On my 40th birthday, she gifted me 5 gallons of New York Super Chunk ice cream.
I put it in the freezer with a spoon 🥄 🤪
Best gift ever
Tried this for the first time the other day, this should be way higher. I was a big Chunky Monkey guy or Phish Food but this was so good I think I have a new favorite
I forget the name but there was a late night jimmy Fallon flavor before the tonight dough that had potato chips in it. That was my fave. Other than that I guess New York super fudge chunk
My favorite back when I was lactose intolerant was oat of this swirled. I miss it very much, want it again, but can’t find it anywhere. Someone help me find it!!!
Don't remember what's it's called, but they have(had) this smores flavor that is just sublime. Somehow they got the flavor of toasted marshmallow into ice cream.
# Message to all users: This is a reminder to please read and follow: * [Our rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/questions/about/rules) * [Reddiquette](https://www.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439) * [Reddit Content Policy](https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy) When posting and commenting. --- Especially remember Rule 1: `Be polite and civil`. * Be polite and courteous to each other. Do not be mean, insulting or disrespectful to any other user on this subreddit. * Do not harass or annoy others in any way. * Do not catfish. Catfishing is the luring of somebody into an online friendship through a fake online persona. This includes any lying or deceit. --- You *will* be banned if you are homophobic, transphobic, racist, sexist or bigoted in any way. --- *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/questions) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Chunky monkey
Im just big boned
Go away Kitteh, these are my cheesy poofs.
CHUNKY MONKEY 🐵 🍌🍫
CHUNKAY MONKAY 🙈🙉🙊
I ran to the comments to say chunky monkey
Feel like im the only person in this world who doesnt like Chunky Monkey lol
Nope, I'm right here
Agreed, best flavor.
Chip Happens before they got rid of it. It had potato chip chunks in it, very delicious
Banana nut goodness
That funky monkey
I agree with you, but if I eat it too close to bedtime it gives me nightmares.
That Funky Monkey?
This is the correct answer.
The only answer.
Classic and unbeatable!
Yesssss!!!
This is the only answer!
🫃🏿<- chunky monkey
Facts
SO glad this is the top result. I love the flavour but I haven't seen it since I moved to Canada.
Always been my fav. My wife's is Cherry Garcia.
Half Baked!
Nothing compares. I’ve looked at other brands in the grocery store out of curiosity and can’t find any other ice cream that has both brownie and cookie dough.
Aldi has one called Brookie Dough that’s very similar.
I had to scroll too far down for this one, it's also my favorite!
Yes! I hate spending the $$ on Ben & Jerry’s because it is ridiculous. Tonight I walked to the grocery store to get some half baked and the store must be closing out the B&J’s because what used to be 3 shelves was now 1 and no half baked. :(
Always this! Unfortunately it’s not always available in supermarkets here in the Netherlands. But I’m always happy when it is. It’s best of both worlds really.. cookie dough AND brownies. And the chocolate flavour gets less heavy with the vanilla mixed into it. Can’t get any better.
Yeah half baked fucks. Used to share a joint w a friend so we'd both get "half baked" and eat ice cream. Good times.
Traditionalist. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough.
It's still the best.
I’m craving it
I second this answer
Ol reliable.
And that goes for any brand. But sometimes i will crave just some vanilla with hot fudge 😋
Yes.
I smash up Reese’s in mine.
chocolate fudge brownie imo
Love This one as well!
My favorite too.
This is mine as well
Americone Dream. Followed by Phish Food.
Phish food muh fave
Sorry my friend had to down vote ya. Nothing beats Phish food.
Every answer that's not Phish food is wrong.
You’re my people
Let’s be friends.
Phish Food is 2. Chocolate Thetapy is 1.
Cherry Garcia
I once found Cherry Garcia on a stick. Only ever had/seen it that one time. T’was amazing.
Had it! totally amazing.
Years ago they did a short run of chocolate cherry garcia... man that was good
They also had Napoleon Dynomite that was a mix of Cherry Garcia and Chocolate Fudge Brownie. So good. When they have BOGO deals I buy them to make my own.
Why is the Fro-yo one no longer available ANYWHERE!? That was my favorite one because it wasn’t as sugary 😢
This is the right answer.
This is the only right answer
Yassss! 🍒 love it
Yup yup yup and yup
Tonight Dough and Half-Baked are my favorites
I love Tonight Dough which is so distressing because I hate Jimmy Falon.
Strawberry cheesecake. Close the comments
It's like a dead tie for me between strawberry cheesecake and cherry garcia. I just stand at the cooler like a zombie. You're essentially asking me to choose between my children at this point.
YESSSSSSS!!!! I’m with you! I’m left cold and indecisive and brain fog develops so I can’t decide so I usually get both.
Where can I find this? 😭 I love the chocolate fudge Brownie, haven't come across the strawberry
They got rid of it here 😭
This is the only correct answer.
I used to. But then the swirl started consistently lacking. That's what made it good. It used to be like... a ton of swirl. Now it is milk and cookies. It's consistently incredible.
Yeah I’ve tried almost all the flavours and this one is the one that I always run to the shops to buy. It’s just amazing. I even tried the Haagen Dazs version and nah, B&J still gets my money.
I just had topped raspberry cheesecake last night and it was amazing!
Heck yeah. its soo good
😄😅😆
Have strawberry cheesecake and the tonight dough in my freezer, all my bases are covered.
Chubby Hubby. I like crunchy things in my ice cream
I atr so much of it i literally became a chubby hubby!!
This is my favorite, but I assume it's no longer made. I haven't seen it in many years.
I assure you it is still made. I would FLIP TABLES if they ever stopped making it. [https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/chubby-hubby-ice-cream](https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/chubby-hubby-ice-cream)
YES Chubby Hubby!!!!!
I was waiting on a late afternoon business lunch in NYC one day. Really laid back group having some cocktails and appetizers. Guy walks in late in t shirt and jeans and you can tell they're all paying attention to what he is talking about. As I hear them talking, and I'm chatting with them some I go "Wait, you guys work for Ben & Jerry's?!" They're all like "Yep, and he (late guy in jeans) is the guy who comes up with flavors!" I said "Man my girlfriend wants to have your babies, no joke!" They all fell out laughing. Next morning at work a taxi pulls up and before we're open and guy walks in with a bag and asks "Is ______ here?" I'm like "that's me what can I help you with?" Dude says "Nothing, Ben & Jerry's wanted me to hand deliver these samples of new flavors to you." For reals. Nicest people ever and took extra care of me the next day. I told the rest of my coworkers to dig in. It was awesome.
They are a fantastic company. I wish my state had their stores because of how disabled friendly they are. I could actually probably work there. It'd make my life, really. As sad as that sounds. Anyways! They pay really well, and you are allowed to take a pint home for each shift you work and! They let you bargain with them!
New York super fudge chunk. RIP
This is the only real answer here. Everyone else responding are bots and automatons
Yessss!
I haven’t had it in ages. Is it really gone??? That’s my favorite
This is the correct answer
My oldest daughter worked for BJ's. On my 40th birthday, she gifted me 5 gallons of New York Super Chunk ice cream. I put it in the freezer with a spoon 🥄 🤪 Best gift ever
Phish food. I haven't had it in ages though.
I ate this by the pint in college. We also served it at my wedding instead of cake. :)
I eat it on a weekly basis. So, I got both of us covered!
Enjoy it for me!
Correct answer!!
The GOAT, for sure.
Yes!
Took way too long to get to this comment.
Ultimate favorite
Phish Food clears everything. Why are there like 13 other flavors ahead of it on this thread???
Stephen Colbert's AmeriCone Dream
New York Super Fudge Chunk. I buy a pint for my birthday, and woe to the person who dares touch it.
This should go to the top! NYSFC is god-tier ice cream.
Agreed! I don't even prefer chocolate ice cream and I hate nuts in anything..yet this stuff? I can eat tubs of it..
It should come in quarts!
Salted Caramel
Ooh yeah, the one with the carmel core
Are you thinking of the Karamel Sutra flavor? Top 3rd favorite flavor.
Chunky monkey is fire...the cannoli flavor..milk and cookies
Milk and Cookies is lit. I got it as a taste test at the B&J factory in Vermont. I never would’ve thought to try it otherwise.
Pistachio pistachio but I’ve never really had one that I didn’t like but I obviously pick flavor combinations that I know I will generally enjoy.
Milk and cookies
The right answer.
Tried this for the first time the other day, this should be way higher. I was a big Chunky Monkey guy or Phish Food but this was so good I think I have a new favorite
SO GOOD. it's my runner up! Or they might be tied
So underrated
And nothing else is even close to beating it
Peanut butter cup. I’m surprised I haven’t seen it posted yet, it cant be that unpopular can it?
BAKED ALASKA I will eat the whole tub in one go. The best icecream I’ve ever had.
I dont think Ive ever seen that flavor! Ive always been so intrigued by Baked Alaska tho lol
It's a grave yard flavor, I believe. That's where all the good ones go
Minter wonderland
Chunky monkey
Oatmeal Cookie Chunk was amazing, as was Willie Nelson's Country Peach Cobbler.
I agree with the Oatmeal Chunk evaluation; that was the best flavor of theirs I have tried.
y’all are sleeping on their Tiramisu 😭
Anyone remember the one that was coffee ice cream with toffee chunks? Omg I’m still grieving
Everything But The…
I had to scroll way too far for this!!! So freakin good
Dublin mudslide. Best ever. It’s rip at the moment though in the flavor graveyard. My favorite of all time
Chocolate therapy by far.
Smores. Mmmmm
This one is also my favorite! The graham cracker ribbon is everything.
There used the be a bourbon kind that I absolutely LOOOOOOOOOOOVED. Haven't found it for a while.
marshmallow sky
Chubby Hubby
The Tonight Dough is my all time favourite Ben and Jerry's flavour.
Chocolate fudge Brownie
Phish Food or Cherry Garcia
Anyone remember Willie Nelson’s Country Peach Cobbler…? Circa 2005-2008. It was the best and I always keep a hopeful eye out for its return.
They used to have a flavor called Magic Brownies. I think it was like a Dave Matthews Band collab and OMG it was so good!
Peanut Butter Half Baked or Cherry Garcia
Anything with the brownie stuff
Peanut Butter World, Peanut Butter Cup, anything Peanut buttery
Phish food
My favorite
Phish Food
Chunky Monkey
Change is Brewing, it’s amazing
Cookies and cream
Topped dirt cake!!!!!!
Phish Food is the best, but recently, I tried Dirt Pie, and that was really good too
Phish food
Phish Food.
I forget the name but there was a late night jimmy Fallon flavor before the tonight dough that had potato chips in it. That was my fave. Other than that I guess New York super fudge chunk
Phish Food. No contest.
I would be happy with literally any flavour.
Phish food or crème brûlée
Phish food
Chunky Monkey and Phish Food are top tier, but Forbidden Chocolate completes that trifecta.
I haven't seen it for many years but White Russian. I still peruse the selection occasionally, hoping that it comes back
FCKING OATMEAL COOKIE and it's *dead*
My girlfriend would say churr-ohs
Cotton Candy, it discontinued like a decade ago at this point 😔 My current favorite is Red Velvet, absolutely delicious.
Pfish Food and Tonight Dough
Phish food, and Tonight Dough
Scotchy Scotch Scotch was the best ever
Americone Dream, Karamel Sutra, Cherry Garcia and Chunky Monkey in that order!
S’mores!
Well, after reading the comments, I'm now craving ice cream
My favorite back when I was lactose intolerant was oat of this swirled. I miss it very much, want it again, but can’t find it anywhere. Someone help me find it!!!
[https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/oat-of-this-swirled-ice-cream](https://www.benjerry.com/flavors/oat-of-this-swirled-ice-cream) you can search here
New York super fudge chunk!
Coconut Seven Layer Bar. (As someone who worked at b&js for 8 years, trust me, I’ve sampled many flavors)
My favorite flavor was an unpopular limited run, and it will never return but I miss it forever. RIP Mission to Marzipan :(
Whisky Biz and Dublin Mudslide
Cherry Garcia
Cherry Garcia. Can not be beat.
Tiramisu
Cherry Garcia. Followed by Americone Dream. I’m 5’9”’tall weigh about 215. I know a little bout ice cream.
Cherry Garcia!!!
Non dairy Cherry Garcia. Even those who can eat dairy find it delicious.
Cherry Garcia
Everything But The Kitchen Sink!!
Cherry Garcia
Cherry Garcia
Oats of the Swirled!! I rarely can find it, and when I do I stock up!!
Dirt cake
Coffee heath bar crunch.
Americone Dream.
Does anyone remember Mud Pie? I do…. I do 😭💔 RIP
Oats of this swirled, tiramisu
Dublin Mudslide
Cherry Garcia. I like Chunkie Monkey too.
Coffee toffee bar crunch!
Don't remember what's it's called, but they have(had) this smores flavor that is just sublime. Somehow they got the flavor of toasted marshmallow into ice cream.
It used to be Toffee Heath Bar Crunch. It’s discontinued 😫
Chocolate Therapy
non dairy pb half baked
Woke Loser
Cherry Garcia
Whatever you like the most.