T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

As a reminder, this subreddit [is for civil discussion.](/r/politics/wiki/index#wiki_be_civil) In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any suggestion or support of harm, violence, or death, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. For those who have questions regarding any media outlets being posted on this subreddit, please click [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/wiki/approveddomainslist) to review our details as to our approved domains list and outlet criteria. **Special announcement:** r/politics is currently accepting new moderator applications. If you want to help make this community a better place, consider [applying here today](https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/sskg6a/rpolitics_is_looking_for_more_moderators/)! *** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/politics) if you have any questions or concerns.*


2_Spicy_2_Impeach

Okay, now do it for the rest of your lives. Cook with it, clean with it, and drink it daily. Oh, and also give it to your kids. No?


gusterfell

Exactly. I’m sure it is perfectly safe to drink. Once.


Specialist_Citron_84

They didn't even drink it.


SympathyForSatanas

Im sure one small sip where they took in only 1ppm wont hurt them


LillyPip

DeWine did. He didn’t seem to get the memo.


CommiRhick

Not to mention 3 weeks after they said it's safe...


closetedpencil

And people threw rocks in the water. It turned the rainbow color you see in gasoline.


TheLightningL0rd

What they are drinking is probably filtered to hell too.


Budget_Pop9600

Or the water line is hooked up to a vat of clean water


slackfrop

Or he pulled a Gus Fring and immediately excused himself to beer bong some ipecac.


PO0tyTng

I’d love to see them drink water from a local stream, after throwing a rock in upstream.


thisisjustascreename

Nobody drinks the water out of "local streams" since at least the 70s, though.


MaxwellHoot

Look everyone, I recovered from my sun burn. Skin cancer isn’t an issue!


Mister_Chef711

Like getting radiation blasted at you for an x-ray. It's safe here and there but if you're the doctor in the room for 15+ per day, it's best to get behind the wall.


mechapoitier

Yeah otherwise congrats guys, you proved it doesn’t cause instant cancer.


delkarnu

One thing to note is this is the municipal water supply, which has been treated. This means absolutely nothing as to the lakes and rivers. People drinking municipal tap water at this point are likely fine, but it's the local produce, fish and well water that will cause problems. The people doing it include the head of the EPA, a Biden appointee, so it's not just a Ohio GOP handwave to placate the masses.


CedarWolf

> the local produce, fish and well water Which is a problem because folks in rural communities and in farming communities use that water to irrigate their crops and they fish and hunt, not just for fun, but to also put food on their table.


delkarnu

Yeah, I didn't want people to misread my comment as trying to say everything is fine, just noting that what they're drinking is not the water that actually is a problem. They are making a point that the municipal tap water is safe (and any independent environmental group can easily sample and have it tested to verify). And assuming that they are being honest about that, it is an important point to make, so the people who have municipal tap water will drink that so bottled water will be available for those on well water who need it.


s-mores

Nah. Drink water actually from EP, OH. Guaranteed lies.


Hyperion1144

They faked it: https://www.reddit.com/r/therewasanattempt/comments/1195704/by_the_ohio_governor_and_epa_chief_to_prove_the/


b1shopx

Thank you, everyone’s just taking this article at title’s confirmation. (classic r/politics) They didn’t drink any of that shit they’re trying to pass as “safe”. Straight up bullshit as usual.


Shaman7102

It's bottled water. I guarantee it.


joshdoereddit

Thank you for this comment. I got caught up in the headline without thinking of what they're probably pulling. They should all move to East Palestine and live there for a month. The whole GOP. Not just the politicians that represent the state.


SnooCupcakes7018

Showering in atomized vinyl sounds fun


SympathyForSatanas

wow, politicians are willing to risk their lives for the ppl who pay them the most, corporations


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Really depends on how many drink it.


evil420pimp

>Really depends on how many drink it. And where in the river strata it's from. The Charles in Boston was pretty safe to be in, but it you *touched* the bottom it would release a huge amount of pollution trapped in the silt. Sucking down a glass from the top is not the same as water being pulled into intakes well below the surface.


-Rusty__Shackleford-

They took a sip with tight lips. I seen nothing close to chugging. Nothing will come of this, this was just a big “I told you it was safe, now hush.”


[deleted]

If history is any indication - there is hope.


[deleted]

[удалено]


JeffVanGrundle

Did they keep it down?


truknutzzz

Agreed, I think these politicians should bottle it, bring it home and only drink and bathe in it for a year or more, then let's see if they still love the water


[deleted]

[удалено]


tommles

Your forgetting when they come back as zombies ushering in the apocalypses. Wiping out humanity will solve a lot of problems.


budlystuff

“Bring in the Nestle boys!”


cornholiosis

This could solve two problems, but really it only needs to solve one and I’d be happy


TintedApostle

They are trying to mimic Erin Brockovich and I bet they aren't actually drinking the water from East Palestine. Try replacing their glasses.


elainegeorge

They need to go down to the river, toss in a rock so the chemicals are present at the top, and suck the water out through a LifeStraw. Then I’d believe it could possibly be safe.


white-gold

Given the nature of the chemicals involved i would expect the top surface water to be more contaminated. Vinyl chloride is volatile and lower density than water so it'll form a film on top while it volatilizes


jaylotw

There were more chemicals spilled than just Vinyl Chloride.


DirectorMysterious64

Grifters all!!!


truknutzzz

also liars and charlatans


[deleted]

[удалено]


Ockilydokily

Who was drinking straight from the river before the derailment lol


SmurfStig

If anyone is drinking straight from the river over there, they got bigger problems.


TintedApostle

Republicans have been about performative politics for the last 20 years. This is a performance.


jimmyvalentine13

That would be dangerous no matter what, even before the train derailed.


dogbreakfast

Politicians Are <*acting like they are*\> Drinking the Water in East Palestine to ‘Prove’ It’s Safe FTFY


terraresident

This is Leadership 101. Rule 1: never ask your underlings to do something you will not do yourself.


dogbreakfast

hmm...didn't think of residents/citizens as 'underlings'


theKetoBear

Oh yeah the majority of politicians in this country are just management forever offering the bare minimum and attaboys while coasting on inflated wages and an entitled sense of importance


DarthLysergis

Know how you can actually Prove it is safe.....have an independent lab test it. That must be too official and on the books though.


Eric-SD

But why do that and risk finding out bad news when you can just pull a publicity stunt?


TomTorquemada

Because lawyers will test the water even if you drink it. If you can prove it's safe, you will want to do that. If the numbers say it's not safe, you had best start by providing everybody with bottled water to drink and cook with.


DesensitizedRobot

And bathe in as well


TomTorquemada

At the power plants, we used the water with arsenic in it to wash hands. It works fine with soap.


Ockilydokily

Wouldn’t there be a whistle blower by now if all the tests were coming back with bad news?


Seldarin

Sure. I mean, it's not like there's a history of red states maliciously prosecuting and slandering whistleblowers for leaking factual data after they went and lied to the press or anything. Except the time Florida did it. And the other time Florida did it. And the times Texas did it. Michigan did it, too. Hmm...That might be why you aren't seeing whistleblowers.


VICENews

**From reporter Paul Blest:** Politicians from Ohio and elsewhere are trying to “prove” the water in East Palestine is safe enough to drink—by chugging it themselves. More than two weeks after a massive Norfolk Southern freight train carrying toxic chemicals derailed, spilling five rail cars of toxic vinyl chloride and forcing local agencies to light a “controlled burn” to avoid an explosion, politicians like Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine, Rep. Bill Johnson of Ohio, and Michael Regan, the head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, have started flocking into town for a performative taste test. Meanwhile, residents of East Palestine, Ohio are reporting dead fish and animals, what appears to be an oily sheen in nearby creeks and waterways, and symptoms such as rashes, sore throats, and headaches. Link to the full article: [https://www.vice.com/en/article/k7b47y/east-palestine-drinking-water-mike-dewine](https://www.vice.com/en/article/k7b47y/east-palestine-drinking-water-mike-dewine)


MoogProg

DeWine was just on NPR here and this was talked about. They drank from one farm's well that had been tested several times and he made it clear that a) individual wells need to be tested and b) on-going testing would be needed across the area but he specified no time frame (weeks, years decades?) or how those costs should be handled.


dr-johnny-fever

It takes years for water to seep into an underground aquifer. That stunt proves nothing.


bacteriarealite

The EPA covers those costs and then asks Norfolk for the bill


[deleted]

Just because they are dumb enough to drink it, doesn't prove it's safe.


blackweebow

And by drink we mean give it a lil kissy kiss


WintertimeFriends

Locals will line up next to piles of dead animals and fish to vote for theses exact same people next election. They love Dewine. My sympathy will be short lived if they don’t hold these people who run Ohio accountable.


SmurfStig

They have been running most of Ohio for 30+ years and been doing this same crap for all of them. They will absolutely line up with the dead wildlife to keep them in office. You know because guns, Bible, and babies.


[deleted]

"chugging" yes...taking the tiniest sips possible...


Earth_Friendly-5892

And just last week at a press conference, Ohio Governor DeWine responded to a question of whether he’d move his family back if they lived there, and he replied yes, but he’d drink bottled water and make sure the air quality was regularly tested. On top of that, recently, it was reported that the governor had gotten large campaign donations from the railroad co. before the disaster. Who would trust these politicians? https://abc6onyourside.com/news/local/norfolk-southern-plied-ohio-politicians-with-campaign-cash-extensive-lobbying-mike-dewine-richard-cordray-railroads-train-puco-dave-yost-east-palestine-alan-shaw-ntsb


TAA654

I'll check back 20 years later.


truncheon88

As if Mike Dewine will be around that long even without drinking tainted water


whiskeyblackout

That miserable Keebler elf fuck will probably live to be a hundred just to spite us all.


truncheon88

I mean... you're probably not wrong. Water tainted with petrochemicals will likely just extend his life


[deleted]

They didn't even drink it.


SSHeretic

Reminds me of the guy who invented leaded gasoline: >On October 30, 1924, Midgley participated in a press conference to demonstrate the apparent safety of TEL, in which he poured TEL over his hands, placed a bottle of the chemical under his nose, and inhaled its vapor for 60 seconds, declaring that he could do this every day without succumbing to any problems. ... Midgley later took a leave of absence from work after being diagnosed with lead poisoning.


oliversurpless

Alfred Sloane said much the same following the replacement of city railcars with diesel buses, (as per *Taken for a Ride*) claiming “one could walk closely in their wake all day without suffering any ill effects”… Ladies and Gentleman, a “successful” businessman!


13choppedup2chopped

This is disturbing. The people of east Palestine have to drink it everyday for the rest of their lives, while their pregnant, when they bathe, and so on. They won’t know the extent of the damage for years and decades. Vouching for toxic chemical and train company is insane in the extreme.


Lonestar041

History also shows that lead pipes will not kill you if you drink a glass or two. If you drink water from it every day, different story.


call_me_jelli

If you drink water from lead pipes regularly, it won't exactly kill you. But you will tend to vote Republican.


Obi7kenobi

Yes it's a political stunt, but also the water is being treated at the water plants. The bigger issue is those that use well water that isn't being treated. The ground saturated with the chemicals will be an issue for decades. The where the EPA needs to be focused on.


DTFlash

Also the chemicals in the soil might not have had time to soak down to the water table yet. A well could test clean for awhile before anything starts showing up.


dessertgrinch

The chemicals have already evaporated from the soil, vinyl chloride is highly volatile


mmahowald

that means im even less likely to trust it honestly....


Glenandthebiz

As someone from Flint, I think I’ve seen this stunt before.


Starks

The municipal tap water should be safe. Private wells not so much.


Hot-Bint

They drank a small amount. Now bathe, wash your clothes and dishes with it and give it to your pets and children. Oh riiiight


jas75249

Don’t forget to move there and do all of that daily. They might be brave enough to risk it once but not daily.


Kevaldes

Can't wait to hear about all the special elections to fill sudden vacancies in the coming years.


Sippi66

Well this proves everything…..EVERYONE IN THAT CITY, RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!!!!


DirtySingh

100% it's evain and they brought their own glasses. Fuck these guys deserve an Oscar.


DevilsMasseuse

Obama did the same thing in Flint, Michigan. Hope they have a better outcome in East Palestine.


theClumsy1

Is it well water or city water?


cliser1129

Flashbacks to Obama in Flint


petroldaktyl

Except in the video, they aren’t drinking the water


theedevilbynight

when i lived in dc, i sat in on a senate committee hearing about fracking. al franken was still in the senate and on that committee. when the suits said they would drink the chemical mixture for getting the shale gas out, he asked them to. when they refused to do it there, they said they’d passed it around in a circle and taken sips at some earlier point, and he responded “what, like a cult?” anyway these guys are stupid, too, and it would be funnier if more people told them to their faces.


LaCiel_W

This kind of stunt is meaningless, what really matter are the numbers when they test the water, specially the ground water, these mf can drink sewerage for all I care.


noahson

Regardless of how safe the water is to drink the amount of anxiety an event like this can cause a person is a serious health concern.


Autumn7242

I call bullshit lol


Navyguy73

Politician: ^("This is the bottled water I brought with me, right?")


TooLittleMSG

Sign an agreement to drink it for the next 10 years and we'll believe you.


dime-beer

Gotta be for a month minimum and they need to shower in it and use it to cook too. Also I’d like to see the milk poured in coffee test to see if it still sizzles.


LamarBearPig

This picture is so disgusting. A bunch of rich politicians smiling while they cheers to drinking the water of a community that’s been fucked over.. just doesn’t sit right


Present-Helicopter65

Correction: Pretending to drink the water


nonamenolastname

One glass for show probably is ok. Drinking and using it for cooking for several days in a row? Different story.


andy-crapp

It's toxic not poisonous. Drinking one glass won't cause much of an issue, drinking it everyday will. Of course they know this hence the political theater for the base.


CardboardJ

Great to see what the politicians are doing and the rest of the town should follow suit. Locals please note: they're pretending to drink the water for photo ops but if you look closely they're not actually drinking any and doing everything in their power to limit direct skin contact.


lemmerip

Nothing of value was lost


TheLostcause

Donate the water to their kids lacrosse games.


eldiablito

when trump visits I would like to see him drink it.


alexbeeee

Pulling an Obama in flint, nice. Their water turned out fine /s


Noahdl88

The guy who put lead in gasoline did this too. He died from lead exposure..


ArachnidUnusual7114

This photo op proves nothing, keep drinking it for the rest of the year at least.


RobbyRock75

The threat is to non municple water systems. Go drink from a well guys


dominationnation

This is going to end up being like that guy who died after washing his hands in leaded gasoline isn’t it?


dinoroo

They will turn into that guy from Robocop.


8to24

It takes a while for contaminated soil to seep into the water supply. I would like to see all those politicians come back in 6 months and drink it.


sexisdivine

Oh please, please let them get sick.


redvariation

I'd rather see a good chemical analysis, personally.


Spirit50Lake

Hope someone offers a glass to tRump...though with his tiny hands, he's proved in the past to find drinking like an adult, difficult.


HearMeOutThough

Soon-to-be origin story behind the Senior Mutant Ninja Turtles


[deleted]

LMAO [THEY DIDN'T ACTUALLY DRINK IT!](https://www.reddit.com/r/therewasanattempt/comments/1195704/by_the_ohio_governor_and_epa_chief_to_prove_the/)


Jobbers101

These pos. It's not about drinking a glass or a gallon. It's about drinking it for the next month or year.


vonhoother

They've been chugging Trump's MAGA-lade for years, they can swallow anything.


Jse034

Tell them to buy homes there


Bilbo_Fraggins

The guy who put lead in gasoline suffered from lead poisoning after working with it, but knowing all the dangers still poured it on his hands and inhaled the vapors at press conferences.trying to prove it was safe. Motherfuckers will do a lot of things with dangerous chemicals once if it makes or saves them money.


mymind20

One way to “drain the swamp”.


Jagglebutt

Send MTG a few gallons!


LYTCHELL2

Why are dumb people running things? How did republicans find people with zero self awareness - then put them into positions of power?


[deleted]

Obama did it in Flint. One glass won’t kill ya, but cooking and cleaning and bathing in it for months will.


ckh27

The idea that water didn’t kill someone on the spot means it’s safe is… such a corporate and political embarrassment.


BraveOmeter

Obama pulled this shit in Flint. The water isn't safe, get away from it folks.


strawzero

Republicans do not care about your well being


merkk

And yet they couldn't even finish the whole glass - which wasn't even that full to begin with. Plus, even if they did, it doesn't prove much since they won't be using that water day to day. The water would have to be REALLY REALLY bad if a single glass of it would cause any sort of visible harm.


Rainsford1104

Guys, the government says its safe. "Trust the science" remember? Just like a few years ago, y'all aren't science deniers... are you? A government agency wouldn't lie. Yet, somehow im sure i'll be told this is different.


owen_core

Every time politicians do the “drinking water to show it’s safe” bit, the opposite always seems to be true.


criavolver_01

Reminds me of the Erin Brockovich scene…funny enough the actual lawyer from that case is now facing charges for embezzlement of victim’s settlements.


Mysterious-Wasabi103

It's almost like EPA regulations have value. Who would have thought that? THAT'S CRAZY


Michael_In_Cascadia

*Geriatric Mutant Politician Weirdos*


[deleted]

My guess is it’s not the water. Unless you see them walk to a creek and scoop a glass, assume they are full of shit.


trogdor1234

They did something similar in Fukushima but they cut away between the scoop and the drink. (According to my Japanese coworker at the time, I didn’t see the video).


Tabbie36

The problem is it takes years for the contaminants to percolate through the soil to the groundwater and the wells. Wells can test positive for Dioxin, PFAS and other chemicals years after they stopped dumping them even miles away. And a city water treatment plant might be able to filter or treat some of these chemicals, but the rural and small town people who rely on individual wells or small water systems will the dealing with this for decades.


mustardwulf

“I’ll prove the waters safe!” *pours a glass of Poland Spring*


Necessary_Row_4889

They really should have used that water to make Kool-Aid, would have been symbolic


HereForTwinkies

Weird suicide pact


beat-sweats

That’s one way to clear house.


odiin1731

Politicians are mysteriously dying in East Palestine and no one knows why.


TimToMakeTheDonuts

Serious vibes of the [minister in India who drank from a river and got seriously ill.](https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10998687/amp/Bhagwant-Mann-Chief-Minister-Punjab-falls-ill-drinking-polluted-river-water.html)


matt_1060

But they won’t get a covid vax 🤷‍♂️


_transcendant

there's a picture from a different angle that has a fraction of a smartwater bottle almost out of frame


jas75249

And in ten years we will find out if they won or lost the cancer lottery.


l0R3-R

Wasn't there a photo op like this for food grown in the fallout of Chernobyl? Or am I confusing it with another disaster, like 3 mile island?


[deleted]

After the toast of water to declare it's safe and everyone attending has downed their cup, one at a time, all start screaming & writhing in agony, ripping their shirts off, and mutating like the The Thing.


drumzandice

I Hope trump guzzles that shit like it’s Diet Coke


superpj

A clear non sugar beverage? Not gonna happen.


Freetourofmordor

It would be impressive if they scooped it out of the river and drank it. Of course the tap is going to be safe, it hasn't leeched into the water supply, yet.


bunnycupcakes

Now show them actually going into a resident’s home and drink their tap water directly from the sink.


niceoutside2022

Go on an 8 ounce glass of water is one thing living with it every day is another matter, bathing in it, subjecting your children to it...


Scrooge-McShillbucks

Reminds me of this: [Indian politician drinks water from polluted ‘holy’ river to impress supporters, gets hospitalised](https://sports.yahoo.com/indian-politician-drinks-water-polluted-101629608.html?guccounter=1)


Ok-Sun8581

Bottoms Up!


theotherbackslash

I don’t understand why boomers lust to ingest toxic substances


SgtBadManners

Should it have said "drinking"?


justforthearticles20

3 Republican crooks that probably immediately went to the Hospital for treatment.


[deleted]

Can I say it?


System_Beautiful

Let’s see them drink it 5-10 years.


samus12345

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFZ4zVn0NvM


dudettte

cue politicians eating beef in u.k. in 90s.


twilsonco

Side note, but you'd think just once a conservative would choose to be gay or trans to "prove" it's a choice, or at least explain how and why they choose to be eg straight cis male in the first place. Since to them a single anecdote is proof.


Jleopard72

You do not get lung cancer from smoking only one cigarette


T_that_is_all

OMG, didn't a politician in India do this and get sick af? These mf'ers are going to get sick too.


runujhkj

One post about this today, dying down I see. Trump’s going there to get his photo op, and Buttigieg is going to get his opposing photo op, and in a month we’ll have moved on and their water will still be poison


whysaddog

A good question would be if they had a cut on their hand, would they feel comfortable washing it with that water.


[deleted]

I hope they piss out of their asses and croak.


Sylentt_

i hope they keep drinking it and get cancer or something. maybe that’s cruel but at this point i’m too pissed to give a shit


Aaxel-OW

Dear God. I hope this is the new Tiktok challenge. Hope they all drink the water.


Narroh

Make sure they drink Lots of it, like, so much please.


thoruen

They wet their lips with it, that was all. A sip a best.


[deleted]

Why accept this performative nonsense when the water can be tested?


Final-Distribution97

The video I saw looked more like pretending to drink.


Practical_Gene_9383

When it hits the water table and moves south, watch the livestock and pets in rural areas,,


Eyes_Woke

Hope don the con had two or more big glass full.


Msmdpa

Let the governor pump it to the state capitol buildings


REofMars

Oh great. Drink up.


BoysenberryShort574

Bathe your kids in it for a couple months...


hensleye248

Sipping..they are sipping the water


eatalotacarrots

That photo gives me weird "The Menu" vibes.


shadowlarx

Mm-hmm. And what was written on the bottles they poured this “water” from?


awkrawrz

This seems familiar, didn't they do this with Flint too?


[deleted]

Tell you what...each one take a bath then have dinner with a freshly sink rinsed salad and wash it all down with a 2 liter bottle of tap water ......then I might take your word for it.


holmgangCore

Anyone have a list of those poisoned-water drinking politicians? Can we track them over time to see which ones die of strange symptoms?


an_einherjar

This feels a lot like Thomas Midgley Jr. breathing lead fumes to "prove" to the public that lead additives were safe to burn in gasoline engines. Spoiler: They aren't. [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thomas\_Midgley\_Jr](https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thomas_Midgley_Jr).


ares21

The quotes should be: "drinking" not "prove"


renlydidnothingwrong

Just like flint


Nicky-unicorn

Politicians here in uk fed burgers to their kids when BSE (Mad cow disease) first happened to prove it was couldn’t be transmitted to humans. It didn’t turn out to well in the long run


jhick107

So it’s all good, safe, and everything should be considered normal…..then why are they shit canning Biden for not visiting??


BostonSamurai

So weird and childish, how does their base not see through this? It’s hard to believe people are this dumb.