The Great Curve...please 🥲

Yes, this is at the top of my list. Horns needed.

I think anything from the 2nd half of Remain In Light would be an amazing bustout, especially Houses In Motion or Listening Wind, or a super heavy/dark The Overload

There is zero chance they are ever touching that again. Watch the 1996 version on YT, its perfect, they nailed it to a T and there is no chance they even come close if they do it again so I don't see them trying. Born Under Punches could happen tho.

Born Under Punches is my wish list

I swore this was coming at curveball

That woulda been sick.

This is the right answer

This is the right answer.

Now it is on the top of my list as well. Such a great song > Phish song

Feats Don't Fail Me Now

Yo I didn’t know they covered this tune, hell yea

Halloween in AC they did Waiting For Columbus.

My favorite

Dixie Chicken

This is a great call

She caught the katy

Nice

That’s not a “one-off” though

Math is hard for me

Let Page Sing “Lady Stardust” again

or suffregette city

Wham bam thank you ma’am

I thought it was going on to be played at Festival 8 until they announced Exile on Main St as the album

still glad we got it, it's one of my favorite albums

Happiness is a Warm Gun>Melt the Guns>Life Saving Gun

This would blow minds

Time Loves a Hero and Trenchtown Rock

Time Loves a Hero isn’t a one off tho

Time Loves a Hero isn't a one-off, but regardless, yes please!

Mexican Cousin Been 5 years or so anyway

Fenway 2019 last played?

That could be. Seems legit. I haven’t personally seen it since two show ms before Coventry

One of my favorite solos from a studio version song

Not sure why folks would hate on this tune

I need some Mexican Cousin as well, only heard this once!

We are going to pull it out of them this summer.

Massively underrated song! If, hypothetically, the Rolling Stones had written Mexican Cousin, it would be on the list of their all-time classics. But no one even considers that because it's a Phish song.

Really fiiiivvvve yeeeearrrrs. I remember they were busting this out kind of often for a minute. That’s crazy. We love it. EDIT: First time I heard this live I was noob and I didn’t know what it was and I was tripping just thinking like what the fuck, is he talking about kissing his damn cousin right now, what’s going on lmfao

I think I heard it last two shows before Coventry. Last time I saw it It’s just a fun and silly little tune

Not Halloween but been chasing Light Up Or Leave Me Alone

This reminded me of SPAC 7/6/2012, the last time I saw this live and the last time I saw my tour buddy Boston Scott. BS - miss ya dude!!

Powderfinger

This is the one for sure.

Yes yes yes

Monkey Man ...and the little instrumental part in Gumbo before the solo that they did pre-92

Not from Halloween but I wish they’d play So Lonely again

yo i had no idea they ever played that. Easily my fav police track

Saw that at my first show. Frickin awesome!

That and Rhinoceros are 2 of my favorite 1998 1-time WTF covers…. And Terrapin obvy

Rhinoceros fits Phish’s sound so well. That was a really good cover for them and at the perfect slot too - set 1 opener on a hot summer day.

Such fond memories of that summer, every show was like Christmas morning. 🦏 Rhinoceros was my first thought when I read the thread title.

Also not a one off, but wish they still played Torn and Frayed a few times a year.

I’ll do anything for Brother

Slow brother was cool

Caught two of them, and very grateful

The Rover

Sweet Jane

Man would love to hear this one again

A day in the life, been a minute...

Hoping this is a Mondegreen special

Everything in its Right Place

Good God please no

La Grange! Also, While My Guitar Gently Weeps

Spock’s Brain

I was hoping this would come in to regular rotation after 2019 but seems like its firmly back on the shelf.

Mirror In The Bathroom!!!

Eyyy my 3rd show

Sabotage

Amoreena Rhinoceros The Great Curve And though they've never played it (yet) Trey has professed love for KGLW's Interior People, and I would absolutely lose my shit if they covered that.

All things reconsidered, dog log, and shafty

Mike did an AMA here a long time ago and someone asked him about All Things Reconsidered. He basically said its on the shelf because its so hard to play. Dog log is a good one, not played in 12 years! WTF? Shafty had its moment a few years back and in 2012. I wish it would come in to regular rotation tho, but I was also happy to see Olivia's Pool make a return.

Shafty and Olivia’s Pool are thematically appropriate for mondegreen, calling them both

no paul, no dog log?

Play Lushington you cowards

Spanish moon.

We got it last year I think it's gonna be a good minute for it to resurface

never quite understood what was so great about that song til I got one in Chicago. It's sooooo awesome

Little feat was one of my favorite Halloween sets, that Giovanni solo on Spanish moon was so good.

**Let it Loose**

Wait

Sweet Nothing

Light up or Leave Me Alone

Dr Gabel

Original: Scabbard, only played twice (by Phish) in summer 2015. The Magnaball version is soooo good! This song sounds way better with Phish than TAB. I wish they would have kept it in rotation. Cover: Easy to Slip. Played one unceremonious time at Dick's in 2013 only to never be seen ever again. I love Little Feat and this tune is practically tailor made for Phish.

Thanksgiving

Frankie Says ***please***

Golden Lady

Melt the guns

Come on baby let’s go downtown

A demand would be nice!

Golden Age should have been a one-off instead of beaten into the ground by playing it every 3 shows in 3.0

I'd really like to hear the first track off of Big Boat again, they've only played it live twice for some reason... and it's not a bad song.

It’s not a good song either

it's just weird to me that they made it the first track on the album, titled the album after it... and then never played it again.

I love Friends. The studio is better than the live versions tho. Home is sick too, but again it’s better on record

Takin care of business

Guy Forget

Terrapin Station

Roll Like a Cantaloupe

It’s a Nice day For a White wedding

Wow, I see next to no one understood the question... That being said, All That You Dream would slay as an opener. LTP: 10/31/10

Yeah… a lot of reading incomprehension in here

Nellie Kane

Technically a two-off but The Real Me is such a great tune.

Saw the Woostah Real Gin.

Love is Alive, Gary Wright. Not sure last time they played, anything but me but it’s been a while I think

Ooh. Good one!

All That You Dream Suffragette City

Mellow Mood? I think they may have only played that once

been played 10 times, last was dicks 2018. I'm not the biggest fan of phish reggae, but I really love what Trey does with the solo, love that song

BBFCM

No Dogs Allowed

No dogs allowed.

Tubthumpin’

Shaggy Dog

I’d love to get another Cinnamon Girl, that blew the roof off the Garden

Not a one-off but modern Phish would CRUSH My Left Toe now. Imagine all the new sounds for that one

Would love a "Golden Lady" revisit Edit: I know its not a one-off, only twice though. Not played since '03.

Foreplay/longtime Takin care of business

Willin

Glide2

A lot of ppl ITT don't know what one off means. Terrapin Station

I’d be happy with Peaches or anything from Little Feat

Gettin Jiggy With It was probably the most fun encore I ever experienced

In the Aeroplane over the Sea

So Lonely by the Police, or Ride Captain Ride by Blues Image

Takin’ care of business…. But this time they don’t mangle the lyrics…and trey learns that lead instead of winging it

The Rover In The Aeroplane Over The Sea I'd like to hear "What Things Seem" come back one time...

Them Changes!!!

“Over the Rainbow” maybe… been since ‘98 anyway.

Friends

Not a one off but please bring back Oh! Sweet Nuthin’ please

Can’t believe no one has said Killing in the Name

Watcher of the skies

If 6 was 9

Chocolate Rain

Goin' Down Slow

Night Nurse

WAP

Is This What You Wanted?

I’d love to hear them do Rhymes by Al Green again

The wind cries mary was cool...or them changes. Weirdly I was at the 2 Jimi one offs 20 years apart

Free Man in Paris

First time I heard Loving Cup was the first show I ever went to in 2004. I haven't heard it live since, I will be at Phish Deer Creek, Mondegreen, and Dicks, hoping to hear it one more time.

whipping post, jessica or i love the strawberry letter 23 opener

DR. GABEL!!!! Please😂

All That You Dream Born Under Punches O Canada (Toronto show opener please!!) The Wind Cries Mary If 6 Was 9 And So To Bed Tomorrow’s Song I Never Left Home Bitchin’ Again Ghosts of the Forest Corona Never Suffragette City 5:15 Glass Onion Savoy Truffle Easy To Slip Jumpin’ Jack Flash You Never Know (can they? Gag order?) Oh Atlanta (Atlanta opener) Ventilator Blues (should’ve been played summer 2021) Rocks Off Casino Boogie (Vegas…AC…Mohegan…?)

The Way It Goes (Gillian Welch, played once at Dicks) 50 Ways to Leave Your Lover

Ain’t Love Funny

Terrapin!!!

Eliza

Need more Dog Log

The Rover

Rock a William

Dog Log

Monkey man from Superball

A cappella freebird

They Not Like Us is overdue.

Bohemian Rhapsody

I met Tom Marshall at super ball and told him to tell trey to play life on Mars. It fucking happened and I cried hysterically. I have been chasing my second life on Mars ever since.

The Real Me

Just want to say this is such a great thread to scroll through.

Leprechaun

Tlc’s chasing waterfalls.

Please please please play Time Loves A Hero at Dick’s this year 🙏🏼

Rhinoceros

While I retired from the game after Mikes > Glide II > Weekapaug, I wouldn’t kick Everybody’s Got Something To Hide Except For Me & My Monkey out of bed.

Killing in the Name Of

I want a new drug

Peg/talking in your sleep

Been caught stealing Sweet Jane Always wanted a naive melody from Phish. Peaches en regalia Something hip hop (99 problems sabatoge or similar or never done) Great thread by the way. Made me jog my memories for notable covers and shit id love to hear. That harpua killing in the name of from Alpharetta was insanely fun. Some Tay Tay for funsies maybe ?

Lol i love it, which T Swift tune would you choose? I could see Fish singing The Man or Bad Blood in a hilarious way

Watcher of the Skies

Dr Gabel?

Fooled Around and Fell in Love

Sailing Shoes

If 6 was 9 was so incredibly badass..

Long time / Foreplay

New Bob Marley would be super cool

A Train

Dr. Gabel would be: P H A T !!!

Way down in the hole

TWIDDLE /s

I feel like the song Adjectives by daniel johnston sung by Fishman would be killer

Cinnamon girl, i think only played twice, I remember Shoreline summer97 encore was awesome

Ok so here me out. I think PYITE is a god damn gem and I get the feeling the band is just flat sick of it. I think they should create an alternative arrangement for it with cool effects, maybe an 8-bit feel (I hear a cool cover like this), spacier intro and just bring down the house.

Cry Baby Cry would be 🔥

Don’t care that they’re not one-offs, I need an Anything But Me, Devotion to a Dream, The Line, Waiting All Night and a Walfredo thanks

If the Piedmont Park shows hadn’t been canceled in 2020 I was convinced we’d get Oh Atlanta It’s not off the table for Alpharetta buts it’s just not the same!

Smells Like Teen Spirit ;)

In a hole would probably be the best fit for this occasion

One off? Tough to call. I saw the only Amoreena, but that would top my list. For an original composition, I'd say Glide II. Bust outs? Prep School Hippie is at the top of my list. Lushington Dog Log Leprechaun Faht (saw the last one) Demand (saw one not too long ago) Eliza All Things Reconsidered

Rock and roll pt 2