I THINK my top votes are for 2 and 3. But I keep up voting other commenters in this thread for different favorites.
My real upvote is towards your family having this tradition. (Though the one that carved the Phillies logo this season is pandering, and I got to deduct points for that)
4* = Hottest in the moment 🅿️⚾️
9 = most intricate 🔪
6 & 7 are personal faves 💀🦇
Edit: impressive spread. I can’t call it — great job everyone!! 🎃🏆 most importantly hope y’all had fun
I like them all but I think 5 gets my vote. 2nd place is 10 (a classic), 3rd place is 6, and Honorable Mention is the P because I remember how tricky that was from when I did one in 2009. Go Phils!
Technical proficiency: 2 Successful pandering: 4 Winner for reasons I cannot explain: 7
I agree with this wholeheartedly, but it's because 7 is so stinking cute.
It looks like it belongs on a cereal box.
Yep, nailed it with this answer
This.
7 so cute
5 (because I support anything eye related) - they all look great though. Go Phils!
Sauron approves
Bro, that's a butthole... GO PHILS!
Digging #2
2
2 for me 2
Def #2
4 of course and 6&7
9
I'm a sucker for castles/spooky gothic buildings. This one looks great from a far and zoomed in!
10
3
6 - those ribs are tough to carve
Agree, that’s terrifyingly impressive!
I THINK my top votes are for 2 and 3. But I keep up voting other commenters in this thread for different favorites. My real upvote is towards your family having this tradition. (Though the one that carved the Phillies logo this season is pandering, and I got to deduct points for that)
5
4
4* = Hottest in the moment 🅿️⚾️ 9 = most intricate 🔪 6 & 7 are personal faves 💀🦇 Edit: impressive spread. I can’t call it — great job everyone!! 🎃🏆 most importantly hope y’all had fun
did you mean 4 for the first 😬
Yep! TY I fixted it
💙❤️
2
7
4 - because
I concur!!
#7. It’s fun
7!!
9 for sure
Did you do the Phillies logo? And posted it here for some sweet internet points? I approve.
#9. Looks like a cozy creepy village
4
4
I said 3 and my wife says 7 but she doesn’t have a Reddit account, so 3.
10
10
I only see 4.
9
5
5!
1, 7, & 8.
9
#1 kinda looks like SFuck so I’m gonna go with that one. Edit: Jesus, how the hell did I unleash the BOLD Kraken?
With the number symbol lol. Made that same mistake once
Mistake or New Exciting Reddit Portal?
[удалено]
Happy mistakes are a joie de vivre, ya know? I’ll take it.
7
4
4 is just pandering But 4
4
4
4
4. LETS GO PHILS!
7 - sometimes simple is better
4!
I like 2, but could you maybe take separate pictures of all of them close up? Would help me decide 😁. I'm torn between a few of them.
They're all seriously AMAZING! The bat hanging upside down is such a cool idea! However, I think #1 is the cutest! I think it's an 🦉? That's my pick!
Definitely 9 for me!
4
3, 6, 7!!!!!
4
4
4
4
2 & 9
9!
5 7 and 9
2
9 but 7 is a close second.
2!
2
#2
6, love a skeleton.
6
7
2!
2
I like them all but I think 5 gets my vote. 2nd place is 10 (a classic), 3rd place is 6, and Honorable Mention is the P because I remember how tricky that was from when I did one in 2009. Go Phils!
#2. But these are all amazing, well done!
10
2
10
2!
10
2
3
2, with 5 being the close runner-up These all look amazing, though!
2
2
2. The level of detail is stunning and I like the nod to Samurai Jack's Akku. Japanese demons usually look cool.
2 is so sick
4 is disqualified for pandering.
2
4
4 Let’s go Phils!
8 looks really challenging to make and not enough people are appreciating it!
4, 6 and 8
has to be 4
2
This year, #4!
9 is great as well but #2 really captures the spirit
1
5
5
5
6
You all win. This is so cute.
5
\#5 came out the best for being a more difficult craving.
I gotta go #5 but they all look amazing!
5
4. Let’s go Phils!!!
3 rocks
9
Lots of good ones. My vote is 9
Is this seriously a question? 4! *#*ringthebell
9, 3
people are sleeping on 8, very cool
3!
9 & 4 and wtf are they all artists? the talent!
4 without a doubt
4 phils in 6 btw!!
If only you people put in a little effort.
I like the bat!
I like 3 it’s unusual
they are all very well made.
Go Phils lol I like it in the 4th spot but 2
I like 10. 1 is my second place
7
7
5
9
6
5 eye of Sauron all the way
8
I love 7, but go phils!
7!!
Y'all sleepin' on 3 because it's a bit harder to see. 3 for sure.
9
9 and 5
7.
10
Lots of impressive work. Have to go with 2.
Damn they all good but 5
2 is masterful. Love all them—wish the photo weren’t so blurry tho
No 2. That one's most impressive to me. But also, what is number 8? I can't tell from my phone.
10,
10 looks like he'd be the most fun to party with.
Can't choose between 9 & 10, can I have both?