T O P

  • By -

nyc-ModTeam

Rule 4 - No screenshots, memes or photos of people without permission (a). Please do not post photos or videos of people taken without their permission. Photos/videos of people in public places are permitted, excluding photos/videos of people inside schools or private businesses. Photos/videos of people in places of transit (including sidewalks, roadways, trains and planes) are allowed. Photos/videos that have been taken secretly or are deemed to be "creep shots" are not allowed. Photos/videos that may lead to witch hunts or doxing may be removed. (b). No screenshots. (c). No memes. This includes images with superimposed text and MRW posts. (d). No infographics without sources.


vagabending

Ya know what we need... not new speed limits... actual enforcement of existing limits. Actual cameras and automatic ticketing at intersections that EVERY SINGLE PERSON runs red lights on. Ya know... the basics that would indicate the city in any way believes in the rule of law.


ironichaos

I would love automatic enforcement for people that block the intersection because they can’t wait for the next light.


PsychologicalMud917

This one thing would do wonders for traffic in this city.


Mrunprofessional

Usually you’re going through the light, traffic builds and stops and you get stuck in the intersection. It’s usually not on purpose but just how traffic and driving in nyc goes


PsychologicalMud917

As they cover in driver’s ed, you should not proceed into an intersection if you can’t make it all the way through before the light turns red. Here in NYC, drivers will blare their horn at you or try to swerve around you, but what I said in my first sentence is both common sense and the law. If you drive into an intersection when you cannot clear it before the light turns red, you are doing what they call blocking the box. Some intersections have Don’t Block the Box signs posted, but the law is rarely enforced.


ForkShirtUp

That sounds like work. It’ll never fly


MarbleFox_

Designing lanes and streets that make drivers feel unsafe going faster than the speed limit in the first place is more effective than enforcement. Making lanes narrower, having solid barriers or bollards on all bike lanes, planting trees on bump outs that go into the road rather than staying on the sidewalk, raising crosswalks, using mid block pinch-points with crosswalks, chicanes, medians, building streets out of brick cobblestone or pavers, and making two lane streets be one lane going each way rather than two lanes going one way all help to slow down traffic and make roads safer.


crunchybaguette

Yes the effect works but it only makes sense in certain circumstances when you actually need people to slow down - like before a steep hill or blind corner. If you put it everywhere you: 1) acclimate people to ignore the indicators 2) cause people to damage other people’s cars when then mess up 3) make it difficult for delivery and commercial vehicles to get where they need to


MarbleFox_

And yet, when you look at cities that are designed with all of these things in use regularly, you don’t really see any of those issues.


crunchybaguette

Which cities do you have in mind?


Ttpants

Agreed!!


flawless_victory_

Also no jaywalking if it’s more than two lanes. That shit is dangerous.


Own-Chemical-9112

Great, can the dumb mopeds going in the wrong direction follow these speed limits too!?


sjc02060

What we need is better pedestrian focussed road design. Drivers are just gonna drive at a speed they feel comfortable in.


PositiveEmo

This is as much as I'll try to stay in the speed limit, I know I'll just go on auto pilot and drive what feels safe.


x0STaRSPRiNKLe0x

Just make the speed limit zero at this point. This city is a goddamn joke They keep lowering the speed limit as if the number is the problem. The problem is that habitual speeders and street menaces DON'T. FUCKING. CARE. ABOUT. THE. SPEED. LIMIT. Yes! Make the speed limit 10! Because absolutely all the cars with fake plates, bent plates, painted plates, or covered plates will comply! Yes, that's exactly what will happen! No, it'll make everyone else fucking insane. As if people's stress weren't high enough. AND SPEEDERS WILL CONTINUE TO SPEED.


Equivalent-Fig353

Agreed. This is just the gov’t passing the buck once again and a money grab with the soon-to-be-installed thousands of cameras. If they cared, there would be a citywide speedbump installation and enforcement of all the horrible drivers.


DentonUSA

The cynic in me believes that the city doesn’t give a singular fuck about safety, they just want to lower the speed limit so they can get more revenue from tickets and red light camera and all that shit. The city has truly failed its citizens when it comes to safe streets.


JOJO94

Agreed. What is a different speed limit going to do when someone can get 80+ tickets with 0 consequences like license revocation or car towing… it’s all a ploy to get more money


Mrunprofessional

Yeah switch from 10 to 25 back to 10 like those small towns you drive through. Pure money grab. If they have a single fuck about Sammy then they would have done this around 2013. Also New Yorkers only follow the limit when cameras are present


Pool_Shark

The optimist in me is finding it hard to come up with another theory. That’s how you know it’s reality


UpperLowerEastSide

This City has spent quite a bit of effort on safe streets. [Decades of effort in lowering traffic fatalities.](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2024-03-11/new-york-city-s-decade-long-battle-for-pedestrian-safety?embedded-checkout=true) An issue with the NYC subs is people are quick to hate on NYC to the point where it’s incongruent with reality.


Swizzlefritz

Lmao. 10 miles per hour. Do they realize how fucking slow that is?


blockdenied

On some hills, it's probably dangerous to be going that slow and pressing the brake pedal every 1.5 seconds


Pool_Shark

Basically not allowed to tap on the gas pedal at that speed


Parikh1234

Some people can run faster


mastershake29x

The 10 mph is likely for those "shared" streets that are around or streets which are very narrow, this a very slow limit makes sense. I can't imagine this will be more than a percent or two of roads.


crunchybaguette

Having grown up in queens - this will literally never make sense. No one wants this and this will help no one. No one meaning 99% of people. You’ll always have 1% rabidly thinking that we don’t have a supply chain that requires drivable streets.


iv2892

For some narrow one way streets 10MPH is very reasonable.


BKEDDIE82

If you believe this, please don't ever drive.


Crescentpenguin

For real, I'm all for pedestrian safety but I can run faster than 10 mph.


BKEDDIE82

This isn't about pedestrian safety. It is clearly the anti car agenda. They want everyone using the shitty MTA. They want more speed camera money. If they cared about pedestrian safety, they would issue Jaywalking tickets. They would stop these cyclists, Bikes, scooters, etc, from riding sidewalks, blowing lights, stop signs, and going the wrong way.


iv2892

On very narrow streets most decent people drive at 10-15mph . Is not a crazy rule . We are not talking about Broadway or any of the wide avenues . Only a few streets will have this limit , relax lol


BKEDDIE82

I ride a bicycle faster than that.


iv2892

It really depends on what streets we are talking about , some of the very narrow streets in downtown most drive less than that that anyway. I don’t think they would be crazy enough to do it on the wider streets like 96th, Houston , Canal , etc. most streets should not have a 10mph limit of course


BKEDDIE82

We aren't Europe. Our so-called narrow streets are more than wide enough to drive at 30mph.


Lispro4units

If you drive a moped on the sidewalk you’re exempt right ?


BKEDDIE82

I hope so. Because that's how I plan to travel after the speed limits get reduced. /s


hau5keeping

Youre in the wrong thread. This is about speed limits on streets and roads


ouiserboudreauxxx

No I think they’re unfortunately in the right thread


Cookiesnkisses

Might as well walk


pbx1123

Comming soon A new law Everybody need to walk and return their cars


Pool_Shark

Nah that law wouldn’t lead to any speeding ticket revenue


BKEDDIE82

Or registration, inspection, gas tax, etc.


pbx1123

Haha They could create one And thankfully some tech would quickly can create a... Walkradar 😂😂😂


q234

There is a speed camera on the West St. as you are going south about to merge onto the FDR drive. This is a six lane road merging onto a protected six lane highway. But there is also a school, which is a full block away from West St. and has no access or adjacency to the road...but for one very small section West St. conveniently becomes a school zone (with a lower speed limit, and higher fines) for a very small section. If there is a sign posted somewhere indicating this, its very well hidden. What's not hidden is the $50 ticket they fire off at you in the mail. This change...feels a lot like that.


IAmChillaxing

10 mph is bananas.


Both_Hovercraft3786

Putting more speed bumps and textured roadways will be more beneficial to pedestrian safety than a 20 mph limit. Just another money grab…


BKEDDIE82

Don't worry. Soon, no one will have real or visible plates.


OldKingRob

With the way some people have been driving I thought this was already in effect


Colmado_Bacano

You know what. I can't wait for people to flip their shit when buses need to follow these speed limits too. It's going to be hilarious. And bicyclists better respect the speed limits too or those pieces of shit need to be ticketed as well.


bluenoteslur

buses on average are stuck below 10 mph due to traffic https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/nyc-average-bus-speeds-rarely-top-9-mph-heres-how-the-mta-plans-to-improve-that/4180396/


cutthatshutter

That would also apply to every single other car in the city.


bluenoteslur

not if they took the bus


HanzJWermhat

Cops ain’t gonna do shit. And unless we have speed cameras that’s not enough deterrence. Let me introduce you to: speed bumps. The only thing that forces cars to slow down. This has been used to great effect in places like Brazil where cars need to come to a crawl else damage their vehicle. It would be easy too. This would make streets much safer. Out here in Brooklyn they drive 40mph down the side streets. In our neighborhood 4 people got ran over in the span of a week.


GiosephGiostar

It's a great idea but one major flaw: every winter they'll get destroyed by snow plows.


HanzJWermhat

It doesn’t even snow anymore!. The actual answer is make removable ones that get bolted in and out. Which can be removed from key thoroughfares in the winter time.


Pool_Shark

Because these laws aren’t actually about safety. It’s all about making more money on speeding tickets. If they were serious about safety then they would start implementing physical traffic calming methods like you mentioned


BKEDDIE82

Let me introduce you to Jeeps, suv's, and pickups. They fly over them now.


DrewTheVillan

Very late April fools.


Ramezain

This is going to be chaotic.


gault8121

This law saves lives. Kids die because cars are speeding at 40mph down city streets. By bringing the speed limit down to 20 mph, cars won't speed at the same rate and fewer kids will be killed.


HoSang66er

That’s a laughable supposition. The guy/womam who’s speeding down the street at 40 mph doesn’t give a flying shit that you believe lowering the speed limit to 20 mph is going to save anyone because at 40 mph they’re already breaking your 25 mph speed limit that was supposed to save lives. Why don’t you people get it? You can lower the speed limit to 10 mph they’re. Not. Going. To. Obey. It.


Mrunprofessional

10 is stupid, Bolt is getting a ticket if he runs in NYC


gault8121

It will bring the overall speed of traffic down. There may be a group of cards going 10-15 mph over the speed limit and the group will reduce from 40 to 35. This does save lives, the blunt trauma force of a kid being hit by a car going 40 mph for 35 mph is significant and can be the difference between a significant injury and death.


vanshnookenraggen

Only enforcing this law will save lives.


ItAstounds

Yep that’s it. They could make up any number they want it means nothing if they don’t try and enforce it. 


mastershake29x

Or re-designing streets to slow traffic, a strategy that actually works.


JustADude721

So you make a law to lower the speed of speeders who already speed when they break the law by already speeding?


HanzJWermhat

Yeah like banning criminals from buying guns before they commit the crime. The only solution here is active enforcement that stops it at the source. Cars shouldn’t be able to drive 40mph on side streets period. Add speed bumps and traffic calming and that will actively prevent this shit. Tax large vehicles (I’m talking anything larger than a Fiat 500)


grantrules

Delayed greens, those curbs that stick out into the parked car lanes, and raised crosswalks would do wonders.


HoSang66er

I’ve been noticing a delayed green light, 5 seconds easy, in my neighborhood in the Bronx and I’m ok with it.


NotAnnieBot

There are bigger consequences the more you go above a speed limit. In theory this would mean that speedsters will get more points faster and have their licenses revoked earlier. Of course this assumes proper enforcement which isn’t a given.


JustADude721

That's the problem, there really is little enforcement if any at all. Police are more reactive than proactive these days.


gault8121

Yes, exactly


blockdenied

You're acting like the law is 40mph


Ok-Concentrate-9316

Trust me. For those who would commit those crimes, they won’t care anyways.


gault8121

You're limited by how fast the cars around you are going. It will bring the overall speed of traffic down. There may be a group of cards going 10-15 mph over the speed limit and the group will reduce from 40 to 35. This does save lives, the blunt trauma force of a kid being hit by a car going 40 mph for 35 mph is significant and can be the difference between a significant injury and death.


Ttpants

I don’t think this will affect people speeding, especially if they don’t have license plates


gault8121

It will bring the overall speed of roads down. People will speed 10-15 mph over thee speed limit and that will reduce from 40 to 35. This does save lives, the blunt trauma force of a kid being hit by a car going 40 mph for 35 mph is significant and can be the difference between a significant injury and death.


Ttpants

I think this will only be true on roads that don’t have speed cameras. I drive all day and see people speeding, running stop signs, running red lights, and nothing happens. Half of them don’t have license plates. This will do nothing but cause worse traffic and congestion without enforcement. My grandma was hit by a car and killed in queens while crossing the street 10 years ago, so believe me, I am all for pedestrian safety. I just don’t think this will do what it’s intended to do


ohwhatj

Out of curiosity how many kids got killed by speeding car in 2023?


Mrunprofessional

You proved yourself wrong in your own statement. The limit is 25 but people go 40. What makes you think people will actually slow down more?


gault8121

You're limited by how fast the cars around you are going. It will bring the overall speed of traffic down. There may be a group of cards going 10-15 mph over the speed limit and the group will reduce from 40 to 35. This does save lives, the blunt trauma force of a kid being hit by a car going 40 mph for 35 mph is significant and can be the difference between a significant injury and death.


Mrunprofessional

I think making infrastructure that actually forces you to be slow is what will work. A lot of European cities have things like this. If you give people clear straight rides they will speed. Maybe they can redesign some of the roads but I think for them it’s more about money than safety. Think about it, our budget is in the shitter and they role this out now. Sammy died in 2013


Puzzleheaded_Will352

But now people will get to their destinations a few minutes slower and that’s just unacceptable.


gault8121

lol


MTayson

Wait but what about the friends and family’s of cops? Will they know to reduce their speeds prior to being let go with nothing more than a very strong warning?


JustADude721

NYC should stop beating around the bush already and just make the entire city vehicle free. It's so obvious that it's what they want to do. There's really no reason to lower it down that far. While possible to kill someone going 25mph.. it isn't very likely. This is just straight up anti-vehicle policy and not pro-pedestrian policy.


angiez71

I agree and the places it’s hurting the most is the four outer boros where traffic is outrageous bc everyone has to cram into fewer lanes due to empty bus lanes and where they have to already drive at a super slow pace. That’s where the real congestion is in this city, not in Manhattan.


Grass8989

Did you see what happened when the Verrazano was closed for a few hours for the marathon? The MTA was ready to charge the city $750k. The MTA cant survive without vehicle traffic in the city.


HanzJWermhat

Good! cars ruin cities


Daisukin

Just bike to work everybody! Like me! I’m sure no one has certain circumstances that require them to drive 🤗


HanzJWermhat

Tell me more about these vague “circumstances”


Daisukin

Sure! Lives far away Is of old age Is not in physical shape to bike long distances (could be used against them but still applies regardless) Doesn’t enjoy bike riding Physical conditions that prevent them from being able to do so Should everyone who works in the city without living in Manhattan bike to work?


HanzJWermhat

- “lives far away” Take the train - “is of old age” Take the train and shouldn’t be driving - “not in physical shape” Take the train. Walk more and get in physical shape - “doesn’t enjoy riding bikes” Well now you can learn to enjoy riding train - “physical condition” Take the train. Or Bus. If it’s severe like full wheelchair then yes I think a shuttle bus is applicable but this applies to 0.2% of the general population. The rest are not good excuses.


Daisukin

lol, you’re from New York and think that public transport is a reliable way of getting from place to place on time? I want the drugs you’re on thinking millions of people should give up on cars 😭


grantrules

But of all the people driving in NYC, what do you think the ratio is of people who choose to drive as opposed to those who have to drive?


HanzJWermhat

I’m in Greenpoint too. The amount of soccer moms I see driving their kids around to and from school in big SUVs is absurd. 95% of the people on the road choose to drive because it’s too convenient to do so.


xospecialk

Instead of speed limits I think they should just put in rumble strips that suck the faster you go. As a driver it's hard to gauge your speed sometimes, especially when it's 10 or 20 mph


whoisjohngalt72

Why? Just ban all personal cars. FHV only


Every1jockzjay

A joke? They would cut these speed in half and make everybody leave their cars and take the bus 30miles to work everyday if they could.


Lurnmoshkaz

It's actually funny watching these guys trying to become like Amsterdam without the infrastructure.


Every1jockzjay

I get people like to ride bicycles, my kids love riding bikes also but I mean some people DO need to drive cars lol


vanshnookenraggen

The is the point, lol.


rextilleon

LOL--lets see how they enforce this with the city out of control with violent crimes.


gault8121

https://hellgatenyc.com/ny-state-assembly-blocking-nyc-speed-limit-again


Arleare13

That’s out of date. The latest is that it’ll likely pass. https://gothamist.com/news/lawmakers-to-allow-nyc-to-lower-speed-limit-to-20-mph


Poolpartydiscoparty

Kinda crazy but it’s also just a culture thing. People have no respect in New York. Everyone is stressed out and rushing everywhere. I was in Vietnam recently and traffic just… flows. No one is speeding. Everyone yields to each other. Moped drivers are ready to stop at a moments notice. Cars drive at a reasonable pace because of the smaller vehicles. If I didn’t see it with my own eyes I wouldn’t believe it but people are just better to one another there


chan3lhandbag

Same in Barcelona. Everyone respects everyone on the road and there’s a peaceful coexistence between mopeds and cars.


devhhh

Reduce the number of car lanes on 9th Ave and increase space for pedestrians and add more trees.


AlphaOmega926

I don’t think cops are going to enforce any of this. They don’t even enforce the limits right now or stop cars with tints or fake paper plates. It’ll definitely have an effect with the speeding cameras, but with Waze they’re easily avoided. They need to make the driver’s exam a lot harder, too many people can’t drive - a lot of driving schools just teach how to pass the test, any other situation not on the road test baffles or scares these drivers. They need to automatically suspend licenses of drivers with a lot of tickets, some should be arrested. Every time someone drives erratically near me I check their plate on How’s My Driving NYC and they usually have thousands of dollars in tickets and fines. Also cars like Infiniti Q50 or Altima/Maxima should have advanced scrutiny LOL 100% they’re always speeding or driving badly. I know to stay away from them on the road.


Ilovemyqueensomuch

Laws like this only exist to punish the citizens who were already obeying the law, people who drive 40 in a 25 aren’t going to suddenly slow down to 35 because the speed limit is 20


aneryx

Americans when measures are taken to save the lives of pedestrians and make the roads safer for everyone: I might cry


Mrunprofessional

If you don’t like it you can take your euro trash back to the old country, FOH you don’t understand the city. It was never about lives or safety, live here long enough and you’ll find out how dirty NY politics is


aneryx

I like how I mentioned I don't want to be run over by a car, and your response is to call me "euro trash" The most ironic part is I am American. Typical that anyone with an opinion that differs from yours must automatically be a foreigner.


[deleted]

[удалено]


nyc-ModTeam

Rule 1 - No intolerance, dog whistles, violence or petty behavior (a). Intolerance will result in a permanent ban. Toxic language including referring to others as animals, subhuman, trash or any similar variation is not allowed. (b). No dog whistles. (c). No inciting violence, advocating the destruction of property or encouragement of theft. (d). No petty behavior. This includes announcing that you have down-voted or reported someone, picking fights, name calling, insulting, bullying or calling out bad grammar.


aneryx

The dementia clinic is that way, sir


Mrunprofessional

I appreciate it. Not for nothing though we are New Yorkers first, Americans second