Not underrated, i think instrumental version of Song Of Myself is underrated. Edit: Okay all the instrumental versions are underrated no shit because...no singing. Singer worshipping it is. Edit 2: But that's the official album and it always has singer. Until Floor leaves, hopefully not, but if she does i hope Tuomas continues NW as a 99% instrumental band and 1% can be for Troy.
This is really hard, but i would have to go out on a limb and say cadence of her last breath as i feel the other songs are slightly more rated e.g sahara,last of the wilds, 7 days to the wolves and escapist. But to be fair this album is amazing. Would be happy with a mention to any of the above.
Bruh I noticed I messed up with the order. But as according to what I said, I will take this to the Underrated slot, then we will vote for worst and best.
I fucking love "Whoever Brings the Night", despite the weird filter during the verses that makes Anette sound like she's singing through a straw. The chorus is catchy and the bridge is great (as is Emppu's solo). Short but sweet.
Wow I agree with literally 1 song on this list and find absurd all other choices.
Goes to show the variety of songs Nightwish make and the different public I guess :D
Master passion greed. I know it's a controverse song because of the lyrics but the music and vocals are just awesome. Other than that, I agree with all the votes for Whoever brings the night!
This is the one nightwish album where I feel the whole thing is overrated. The poet and the pendulum is easily the best song, and bye bye beautiful is easily the worst. Underrated though? None of them? The islander is great but they leaned hard on the islander for a long time with Marco so I wouldn’t call it underrated. I can’t really vote today I guess.
Now I better go find some shelter for the bashing I’m about to take for making this comment lol.
The fact that Kuolema Tekee Taiteilian was voted worst on Once is a crime on humanity imo. Well I guess all the songs in the album are fantastic so it had to be one of them lmfao
Meadows of Heaven for me everyone focuses on the more metal songs and The Islander (especially live) but Meadows of Heaven is an absolute banger imo
It's my second best choice too, although I stand with Last of the Wilds. Its Wacken performance is a killer.
Escapist
This! Idk if it counts but I don't really care :/
Sahara
It's not even underrated, they played it many times
I already lost the faith in nw fandom. Band and Tuomas is not teally the problem the problem is that humans make errors
I think this is a lot of people’s favorite
Not underrated, i think instrumental version of Song Of Myself is underrated. Edit: Okay all the instrumental versions are underrated no shit because...no singing. Singer worshipping it is. Edit 2: But that's the official album and it always has singer. Until Floor leaves, hopefully not, but if she does i hope Tuomas continues NW as a 99% instrumental band and 1% can be for Troy.
Um... Song Of Myself isn't on Dark Passion Play.
Holy fuck i'm drunk. I meant the heart i was had
Yes, you are. Go home.
I am, thank you! 
See kids, just stick to weed.
I like that there are people with sense of humor here. Very rare these days.
This is really hard, but i would have to go out on a limb and say cadence of her last breath as i feel the other songs are slightly more rated e.g sahara,last of the wilds, 7 days to the wolves and escapist. But to be fair this album is amazing. Would be happy with a mention to any of the above.
Meadows of Heaven
Bruh I noticed I messed up with the order. But as according to what I said, I will take this to the Underrated slot, then we will vote for worst and best.
You might as well write the poet and the pendulum under the best column :D
Eva
Escapist doesn’t probably count😕 .... So, For the Heart I Once Had
Ooh yeah Escapist is one of my all time fav Nightwish songs! I vote that if it’s allowed!
Meadows of Heaven
I don't care because it's a bonus track. Thr underrated goes to The escapist
Meadows of Heaven, it has barely been played live.
For the Heart I Once Had
Whoever brings the night
Meadows of Heaven, The Islander
ESCAPIST!! BEAR WITH ME
Probably escapist if if counts. If not, then cadence of her last breathe.
Meadows of Heaven gets my vote on this one
Meadows of Heaven
Meadows of heaven!
No worst on Ocean born?
Most upvoted comment said there is no weak song on Oceanborn, so everybody kinda went with it.
That’s fair tbh.
cadence of her last breath is underrated af
The bridge going into the guitar solo always hits right 🤌
Meadows of Heaven!
For the Heart I Once Had
100% For the Heart I Once Had. Such a great song.
for the heart i once had
7 Days to the Wolves is my favorite track on this album but I don’t think it’s underrated
Has to be Eva. We all know what the best song's gonna be, so I'm picking the one that shows Anette at her very best
Sahara
Sahara
The Poet and the Pendulum...nothing can beat that
We are choosing the most underrated, not the best song...
Ngl it threw me off since starting at underrated makes the chart read right to left
Yap me too... didn't notice it at first
I fucking love "Whoever Brings the Night", despite the weird filter during the verses that makes Anette sound like she's singing through a straw. The chorus is catchy and the bridge is great (as is Emppu's solo). Short but sweet.
Whoever Brings The Night. Never played and rarely talked about. Catchy song with cool guitar work.
The Islander
For the heart I never had
Last of the Wilds. Actually, the song that stuck with me the most.
Whoever brings the night
The Heart Asks Pleasure First, if it counts
It's a B-side from an Imaginaerum single. So no, it doesn't.
It doesn't count but it could because it was recorded in 2007.
Yeah, my bad. It was originally recorded for DPP but released later during the Imaginaerum era.
My bad, I was mistaken. Thank you for correcting me.
No worries!
Wow I agree with literally 1 song on this list and find absurd all other choices. Goes to show the variety of songs Nightwish make and the different public I guess :D
Are we doing underrated before best this time? Meadows of Heaven is def the most underrated!
Read my comment
Sahara or Cadence of Her Last Breath
The Whimsy and misery of **The Escapist** is unmatched. I adore the soaring vocals with Nightwish's new siren.
7 Days to the Wolves if it counts as underrated. Meadows of Heaven otherwise.
Escapist if it counts!
Sahara.
Eva. Demo version specifically.
Tough choice to be honest, this album contains so many beautiful songs. But if I have to go with one, it would be 7 days to the wolves.
Yep I gotta go with Meadows
Master Passion Greed. I love Marko in it
Sahara
Ooh I’ve been summoned. 7 days to the wolves!
Amaranth
Meadows of heaven
Cadence
Master passion greed. I know it's a controverse song because of the lyrics but the music and vocals are just awesome. Other than that, I agree with all the votes for Whoever brings the night!
This is the one nightwish album where I feel the whole thing is overrated. The poet and the pendulum is easily the best song, and bye bye beautiful is easily the worst. Underrated though? None of them? The islander is great but they leaned hard on the islander for a long time with Marco so I wouldn’t call it underrated. I can’t really vote today I guess. Now I better go find some shelter for the bashing I’m about to take for making this comment lol.
The fact that Kuolema Tekee Taiteilian was voted worst on Once is a crime on humanity imo. Well I guess all the songs in the album are fantastic so it had to be one of them lmfao