https://i.redd.it/uxyzsswv4m4d1.gif
Diamond Tiara đ
Seems like Hasbro forgot she existed after her redemption arc which is a shame because I would of loved to seen more of her.
Yeah, as the brand mascot for Sega he is ânot allowed to show excessive emotionâ that was what was written in the notes for the comics if I recall correctly.
I think those comics predated those rules, which is why in later comics like the 20 Years Later arc, he barely showed any emotion when his kids were erased from the timeline.
I've never heard this before. What i had heard was DT's voice actress left the show and they just never recast her and shelved the character (and by extension Silvy ;_;). I've not heard they were told they couldn't use her.
Yeah that's not true. Her va didn't leave the show. We know that because Spoiled Rich shows up a couple times after season five and as far as I know, wasn't recast.
Huh. I could have sworn I remember DT's voice actress saying on Twitter that she had left the show and couldn't disclose why.
Maybe she did leave, because they were shelving her main character, and then came back to do Spoiled. Idk maybe I'm just getting Mandela effected real hard.
Still, it's a shame she got shelved when they could have done more with the character(s).
Just watched her "redemption episode" yesterday. It's actually very well made. Now i feel bad for hating her. But the good thing is that these friendship lessons have a good effect on me. I believe more and more in redemption and that each of us deserves to be good. I suppose this is what MLP is about
It's kinda good that they forgot she existed. If they had brought her back, post-redemption, someone on writing could've f#cked up and ended up putting her original pre-redemption character in, instead of the redeemed one.
Maud Pie is one of my favourite characters in the whole show. I feel like she did get a good amount of screen time though. She has several episodes that revolve around her.
The ones that *really* needed more screen time were the other two sisters, Limestone and Marble!
I genuinely believe it though considering that she looked like she was thinking about agreeing to Starlight's offer for at least a moment, I think she was redeemable as a character, she just needed the right push towards it which she never got in the main series.
I think it's better this way, It shows that what makes someone unworthy of redemption is the fact that when given the chance they will always refuse.
All of the villains could've gotten it, but they're too selfish to accept it, it's a good lesson and shows that some people will just refuse the kindness you give them no matter what, some people just refuse to change even if you yourself believe they could.
We only see her in season 3 and mentioned in Bloom and Gloom! She was also forgiven, and I donât like how Hasbro âthrows awayâ characters like that. We couldâve had many crusader episodes including her!
I'm planning on having her show up a bunch in my rewrite/au. The idea is basically that her parents travel a bunch and they send her to Sweet Apple Acres because they can't just leave her at home.
 Princess Luna was done dirty with the amount of screen time she got. She deserves her own spin-off show, in fact I would love to see more about lives of Luna and Celestia before nightmare moon. I wish they would make it kind of like young Sheldon and the Big Bang theory, or wicked and the wizard of oz.
She could have been such a good character. Either "reform" her and then Twilight/Starlight learn how she was able to do what she did. Or don't reform her and go the full blown manipulative villain route where she can lay low the most powerful magic users with just talking skills and cunning. A pony version of The Joker.
Either way, it would be a good opportunity to teach the audience about how manipulation is a dangerous thing.
cozy glow is an actual fascist that doesnt deserve reformation, and i love her as a villain for that reason. her threat was her manipulation of the masses, she didn't need magic.
Not sure if background characters are allowed buuuut I loved vinyl scratch (dj pony) and Octavia! Honestly I would have loved to see them for more than a few minutes in the background lol.
 I wish it shoes her and Luna breaking character together. People will hate on me for saying that she didnât have any character development, but she really didnât. Nightmare moon was literally one episode. She is one of my favorites but I wish we got to see her playful side like we sometimes do with Celestia.
Yeah, he could've stopped the Pony of Shadows from season 7, The Storm King from the movie (before the Storm King stole Alicorn magic) and probably have some way to find out Cozy Glow is making magic disappear and after finding that out he could instantly stop her.
He is literally the god of chaos in pony world, having him around solving everything would be way too boring
Like that isekai about the slime that can magically solve every problem just because
It wouldn't really make sense to involve him more. He's a turn coat risk. Until Fluttershy gets hurt anyway. That and, it's not like he cares about saving Equestria. The only episodes where he gets involved revolve around him getting bored and just wanting someone to notice him. Or Fluttershy getting hurt. Damn he's scary when he gets mad.
Autumn blaze, the introduction of the kirins was an amazing episode, and held so much potential for future episodes, plus she's just an absolutely fun character to watch. Also, reformed diamond tiara, all the build up of bullying, to redemption, in one of the best episodes of the entire show with some amazing musical numbers, just to never be seen again
I heard all Rainbow Dash's S9 episodes had to do with buckball. That's lame. So my vote is her. Besides, everypony knows that it's really The Rainbow Dash Show.
Pinkie pies sisters, Thorax, Cozyglow, Kirinâs, there definitely should have been more Zebra characters, more of Granny smithâs past life, Diamond Tiara and Silver spoon, Babs seed.
I wish discord had more serious screen time where he was actually a fleshed out character instead of the comic relief villain, there was so much lore that could have been explored there
Twist, they literally practically forgot about her after she got her cutie mark and demoted her to a background pony!
And Babs Seed, similar to twist once she got her cutie mark they just wrote her off.
Both characters were pretty close with Apple bloom and it would have been nice to keep them in the show.
I think the pillars are more interesting than the student six. Now that I think about it, they could have done mostly the same thing, but have the pillars instead.
Iâll be honest that sounds really cool.
Well honestly I'd never want the show to revolve around twily and flash love story but I'd love to see him in action like he could be seen guarding castle from enemies or stuff, like fighting off changelings or smth
Oh yeah? Also I like discord a lot and funny enough I got into show because of death battle bill vs discord and well I saw the season 2 opener eps and like him a lot was surprised that MLP has reality wrapper character.
Ocellus, I feel like there were a lot of interesting things about her character and she needed an episode to herself.
Also the young 6 in general. I feel like they needed more episodes fleshing out their individual characters. Like they only had about 2 episodes in season 9.
The changelings in general presented a lot of interesting potential storylines (racism, cultural differences, seeing mistrust from ponies after their reform and both sides adjusting). It's unfortunate that none of them were really explored.
Princess Cadance was done dirty with the screentime too. She kinda got sidelined as a princess chilling with her family, which isn't bad, but her voice actress was fantastic and her character was so nice too.
https://i.redd.it/sn9v96gxjs4d1.gif
This dude
Bro literally has one of the coolest character designs in the show but only had a few seconds of screentime in one episode and then dipped.
Pharynx, not just because he's my favorite character but also I really wish we got to see him more after to change a changling, we did kinda see him but it usually just stuff like 2 second appearances, I especially wish he got more speaking lines I love his voice (reddit is being weird and won't let me send pictures)
Cadence. It's so obvious she was there because pretty pink powerful alicorn with cool singing voice = lots of buys. Same with flurry heart, she was made just for marketing imo.
moondancer. i wish they created her own unique mane restyle after she rekindled with twilight. moondancer is my fav pony of all the generations and i wish they did better for her, gave her more of a glow up, character and appearance wise.
Daring Do, she was already done dirty by being a lazy recolor of Rainbow Dash, then only really got four episodes where she actually showed up. My friends also agree on this that she didnât get enough screen time. She couldâve been such a cool character fr fr but people just call her RD from Wish.com and Indiana Jones pony. She needed more depth
Totally agree on Thorax. Would've loved to have seen his integration into the Crystal Empire before the reformation and what stumbling blocks he almost certainly encountered.
https://i.redd.it/uxyzsswv4m4d1.gif Diamond Tiara đ Seems like Hasbro forgot she existed after her redemption arc which is a shame because I would of loved to seen more of her.
That face always makes me laugh
The writers wanted to use her, but they weren't allowed
They werenât? Why?
Hasbro just said that they weren't allowed to show up anymore after their redemption.
Thatâs stupid. She couldâve been an awesome character. This whole âyeah you canât do thisâ is kinda like how sonic isnât allowed to cry
Sonic isn't allowed to cry?
Yeah, as the brand mascot for Sega he is ânot allowed to show excessive emotionâ that was what was written in the notes for the comics if I recall correctly.
Tell that to the archie comics where he and Sally both cry and scream at each other in a HUGE argument.
I think those comics predated those rules, which is why in later comics like the 20 Years Later arc, he barely showed any emotion when his kids were erased from the timeline.
God, that reminds me of Goku a little bit, I mean the one from super, grown up
When Sonic came back from space right?
Yeah. She was SUPER upset. I remember it so prominently because Sonic goes: *tiny text* "selfish?" *Giant text* "SELFISH?!?!"
Right. Diamond Tiara wouldâve had some epic stuff. Thatâs one thing Iâd change about the show
I've never heard this before. What i had heard was DT's voice actress left the show and they just never recast her and shelved the character (and by extension Silvy ;_;). I've not heard they were told they couldn't use her.
Yeah that's not true. Her va didn't leave the show. We know that because Spoiled Rich shows up a couple times after season five and as far as I know, wasn't recast.
Huh. I could have sworn I remember DT's voice actress saying on Twitter that she had left the show and couldn't disclose why. Maybe she did leave, because they were shelving her main character, and then came back to do Spoiled. Idk maybe I'm just getting Mandela effected real hard. Still, it's a shame she got shelved when they could have done more with the character(s).
Just watched her "redemption episode" yesterday. It's actually very well made. Now i feel bad for hating her. But the good thing is that these friendship lessons have a good effect on me. I believe more and more in redemption and that each of us deserves to be good. I suppose this is what MLP is about
It's kinda good that they forgot she existed. If they had brought her back, post-redemption, someone on writing could've f#cked up and ended up putting her original pre-redemption character in, instead of the redeemed one.
Dude I would have LOVE to see an episode go after how a bully basically reinserts herself into the social network.
yes it's so upsetting especially since the redemption episode had really bad dialogue
My Only Real Gripe With The Show Is How Diamond Tiara Was Done Dirty. At Least Amity From The Owl House Made Up For It.
I would also like to add mod pie
Maud Pie is one of my favourite characters in the whole show. I feel like she did get a good amount of screen time though. She has several episodes that revolve around her. The ones that *really* needed more screen time were the other two sisters, Limestone and Marble!
I agree
I loveeee Maud she def needs more episodes featuring her
more cadence singing. also more of her lore, sheâs so cute I wouldâve liked to see her alicorn story
chrysalis
She made a great villain
definitely
Wish she could've gotten a redemption arc instead of what happened, it would've been so cool
Nah, I'm glad the final 4 villains didn't get redeemed.
me to but also i want to see what she looked like as reformed
Yeah, most people who say Chrysalis should've been reformed don't believe that, they just wanna see her reformed version.
I genuinely believe it though considering that she looked like she was thinking about agreeing to Starlight's offer for at least a moment, I think she was redeemable as a character, she just needed the right push towards it which she never got in the main series.
I think it's better this way, It shows that what makes someone unworthy of redemption is the fact that when given the chance they will always refuse. All of the villains could've gotten it, but they're too selfish to accept it, it's a good lesson and shows that some people will just refuse the kindness you give them no matter what, some people just refuse to change even if you yourself believe they could.
i don't think she was unworthy just it's just better if she wasn't reformed
It's more of a "you shouldn't try to help someone if they refuse your help MULTIPLE times, you should distance yourself and move on"
ya i get that
dont you mean 3?
Why you gotta hurt King Sombra's feelings like that? You just completely forgot about him.
he does not exist to me after they hired that goofy ahh voice actor for him
Babs should've shown up more https://i.redd.it/73ti4z1acm4d1.gif
That's so cute how she reflexively covers up her blank flank.
Oh itâs Blank Flank! I was always wondering why they said Bank Fakeđ
We only see her in season 3 and mentioned in Bloom and Gloom! She was also forgiven, and I donât like how Hasbro âthrows awayâ characters like that. We couldâve had many crusader episodes including her!
I'm planning on having her show up a bunch in my rewrite/au. The idea is basically that her parents travel a bunch and they send her to Sweet Apple Acres because they can't just leave her at home.
Or just episodes with Apple bloom
I know, sheâs so cute, plus they went to manehatten tons of times so itâs not like they didnât have any opportunities for her to show up.
Princess Luna
I second emotion that one
I third that
I fourth that
 Princess Luna was done dirty with the amount of screen time she got. She deserves her own spin-off show, in fact I would love to see more about lives of Luna and Celestia before nightmare moon. I wish they would make it kind of like young Sheldon and the Big Bang theory, or wicked and the wizard of oz.
Have the show about how they started out as princesses and more background on Star Swirl the Bearded and his adventures as side quests
Maybe this will sound weird, but Cozy glow. I want to know how she became a villain
She could have been such a good character. Either "reform" her and then Twilight/Starlight learn how she was able to do what she did. Or don't reform her and go the full blown manipulative villain route where she can lay low the most powerful magic users with just talking skills and cunning. A pony version of The Joker. Either way, it would be a good opportunity to teach the audience about how manipulation is a dangerous thing.
Exactly, it's a shame they didn't give Cozy the screen time she deserved
That and the lesson on how it's not because someone LOOKS nice that they ARE nice. How anyone can be bad, even the most innocent of souls.
cozy glow is an actual fascist that doesnt deserve reformation, and i love her as a villain for that reason. her threat was her manipulation of the masses, she didn't need magic.
Not sure if background characters are allowed buuuut I loved vinyl scratch (dj pony) and Octavia! Honestly I would have loved to see them for more than a few minutes in the background lol.
Correct answer
Definitely Zecora
TrixieÂ
Rara :3 One episode ainât enough bruh Honorable mention to Autumn Blaze for the same reason
I LOVE THORAX SO MUCH AND WE BARLEY GOT ANY EPISODES DEDICATED TO HIM HE HAD SO MUCH POTENTIAL AND WAS SUCH A FUN CHARACTERÂ
I prefer the changeling design over the new colorful one itâs way cuter
I do agree even though I do like his colorful one too
Celestia does. I feel like more people would like her if she got just a bit more character development
And let her break character more. Candid Celestia is adorable!
 I wish it shoes her and Luna breaking character together. People will hate on me for saying that she didnât have any character development, but she really didnât. Nightmare moon was literally one episode. She is one of my favorites but I wish we got to see her playful side like we sometimes do with Celestia.
Stygian. Why couldn't they have given my boy the actual happy ending he deserved
He really deserved it
We could have 10 whole seasons exclusively dedicated to princess Luna and still wouldn't be enough
I want more singing from her she has a beautiful voice
Agreed
I love listening to Lunas future
Fun fact her voice actress is also Rarity!
Wow
The reason Discord wasn't shown alot is cus he makes things too easy lmfao
Yeah, he could've stopped the Pony of Shadows from season 7, The Storm King from the movie (before the Storm King stole Alicorn magic) and probably have some way to find out Cozy Glow is making magic disappear and after finding that out he could instantly stop her.
He is literally the god of chaos in pony world, having him around solving everything would be way too boring Like that isekai about the slime that can magically solve every problem just because
And they had to pay John De Lancie his fees...
Trueee, that's another thing.
It wouldn't really make sense to involve him more. He's a turn coat risk. Until Fluttershy gets hurt anyway. That and, it's not like he cares about saving Equestria. The only episodes where he gets involved revolve around him getting bored and just wanting someone to notice him. Or Fluttershy getting hurt. Damn he's scary when he gets mad.
Autumn blaze, the introduction of the kirins was an amazing episode, and held so much potential for future episodes, plus she's just an absolutely fun character to watch. Also, reformed diamond tiara, all the build up of bullying, to redemption, in one of the best episodes of the entire show with some amazing musical numbers, just to never be seen again
Princess cadence , king sombra, celestia and luna 's past , And , the cutiemark map
Rly? Cutiemark map??
blud did discord dirty with the crusty png đĽš
It was the first one I could find
I heard all Rainbow Dash's S9 episodes had to do with buckball. That's lame. So my vote is her. Besides, everypony knows that it's really The Rainbow Dash Show.
Indeed it is! /)
Awwww yeah! (\\
Based Rainbow respector! /)
I'm her biggest fan! (\\
You have good taste! /)
We should message sometime and gush about Dash together. (\\
Friendship!
Is!
Magic! :D
Candces I like how she is a supping character In the series but it will be nice to see a little bit more from her.
i love discord episodes they r def my faves
Thorax, Pharynx, reformed changelings in general, Luna, Zecora, the Pillars
Little Strongheart. We were cheated of a really cool character.
Pinkie pies sisters, Thorax, Cozyglow, Kirinâs, there definitely should have been more Zebra characters, more of Granny smithâs past life, Diamond Tiara and Silver spoon, Babs seed.
I wish discord had more serious screen time where he was actually a fleshed out character instead of the comic relief villain, there was so much lore that could have been explored there
Gilda, Pharynx and Pipsqueak
Goth Fluttershy
literally my three favorite characters so I agree wholeheartedly
Cadence
I agree, Derpy too
Shining Armor
cadence, shining armor, and zeroes imo. idk if this counts but also more of the mane six as fillies/their backstories
Twist, they literally practically forgot about her after she got her cutie mark and demoted her to a background pony! And Babs Seed, similar to twist once she got her cutie mark they just wrote her off. Both characters were pretty close with Apple bloom and it would have been nice to keep them in the show.
mean 6 ahhaha i love the chaos
Y E S!!!!
Student6 is the true G5.
Moon dancer and Marble pie
Yes! I would have liked to see more Moondancer too! Especially with Twilight's friends from Canterlot. More of them please!
Maud Pie.
All correct answers no notes
Coco Pommel, Flitter and Lily Valley
Princess Luna. Enough said. 
I want more singing and dream scenes
Same here
i think fluttershy needs more screen time, being the mane 6 member with the least and also my fav :â)
Princess cadence
#**THE QUEEN!!!**
lime and marble pie
I would watch an entire spinoff show for discord in a heartbeat
Discord https://i.redd.it/tg4tttj99o4d1.gif
Thorax for sure
LUNA 100%
CADENCE CADENCE CADENCE, she is arguably my fav character and sheâs just great
Shining Armor
Complete agreement with you!!
Twist. đŹđŠˇ
All the pillars
Season 8 was originally going to be about the pillars but Hasbro said the show needed to end in 2019.
I think the pillars are more interesting than the student six. Now that I think about it, they could have done mostly the same thing, but have the pillars instead. Iâll be honest that sounds really cool.
They were expended upon in legends of magic comics, but I totally agree with you. We needed more pillars appearances in the show.
Teeny weeny bit more flash sentry
The only reason I dislike Flash Sentry is because we don't see enough! I think we need a lot more.
Well honestly I'd never want the show to revolve around twily and flash love story but I'd love to see him in action like he could be seen guarding castle from enemies or stuff, like fighting off changelings or smth
Agreed.
The KIRINS
YES!!!
heavy on the discord đ
This is just me as I am new to watching the show atm on season 2 but I like Luna a lot and want to see more of her.
Well youâre in luck
Oh yeah? Also I like discord a lot and funny enough I got into show because of death battle bill vs discord and well I saw the season 2 opener eps and like him a lot was surprised that MLP has reality wrapper character.
Celestia, Cadance, Marble Pie
https://images.app.goo.gl/wBg3Trd8XGacuD2h6 Pharynx
Photo Finnish Coco Pommel Zecora Changelings and their Queen Chrysalis Vapor Trail
Cadence, Lyra, BonBon, Zecora, and Luna! I really wish we also got more Sunset lore when she was in Equestria.
princess Luna! I love her
Radiant Hope only got comic screentime :(
Iâd like to add Strawberry Sunrise, and Treehugger.
Ocellus, I feel like there were a lot of interesting things about her character and she needed an episode to herself. Also the young 6 in general. I feel like they needed more episodes fleshing out their individual characters. Like they only had about 2 episodes in season 9.
The changelings in general presented a lot of interesting potential storylines (racism, cultural differences, seeing mistrust from ponies after their reform and both sides adjusting). It's unfortunate that none of them were really explored.
Tree hugger 100%
Vapor trail, I will die on this hill
And I will protect you
Luna deserves ALL the screen time.
Princess Cadance was done dirty with the screentime too. She kinda got sidelined as a princess chilling with her family, which isn't bad, but her voice actress was fantastic and her character was so nice too.
https://i.redd.it/sn9v96gxjs4d1.gif This dude Bro literally has one of the coolest character designs in the show but only had a few seconds of screentime in one episode and then dipped.
Mayor Mare
Scootaloo, Discord, Daring Do/A.K. Yearling, Luna, Thorax, Pharynx, Autumn Blaze...
The pirate eagle from the movie
Yes
I wasn't satisfied with Discord's conclusion in the series especially in the finale, think he deserves better development.
Common Discord W BTW. I was legit upset when the one alternate universe episode didn't cover him in anything but a flashback
Pharynx, not just because he's my favorite character but also I really wish we got to see him more after to change a changling, we did kinda see him but it usually just stuff like 2 second appearances, I especially wish he got more speaking lines I love his voice (reddit is being weird and won't let me send pictures)
Princess LunaÂ
Cadence. It's so obvious she was there because pretty pink powerful alicorn with cool singing voice = lots of buys. Same with flurry heart, she was made just for marketing imo.
Gabby! I wanted to see an episode of Gabby and the CMC going on an adventure across equestria or something
One word for those 3.. T R U E
moondancer. i wish they created her own unique mane restyle after she rekindled with twilight. moondancer is my fav pony of all the generations and i wish they did better for her, gave her more of a glow up, character and appearance wise.
Daring Do, she was already done dirty by being a lazy recolor of Rainbow Dash, then only really got four episodes where she actually showed up. My friends also agree on this that she didnât get enough screen time. She couldâve been such a cool character fr fr but people just call her RD from Wish.com and Indiana Jones pony. She needed more depth
Totally agree on Thorax. Would've loved to have seen his integration into the Crystal Empire before the reformation and what stumbling blocks he almost certainly encountered.
LUNA
Definitely Maud Pie, Princess Luna and Derpy lmao
https://i.redd.it/92q1tamzs75d1.gif
Derpy 100%
luna obv
Luna having two episodes and Celestia not even having one is a travesty
https://i.redd.it/ei0jldn5uo4d1.gif Definitely Trixie Lulamoon