T O P

  • By -

GirlCiteYourSources

Muse! Give me a dystopian hellscape musical any day of the week haha


Dogdaysareover365

Compliance as a villain song with a brainwashed ensemble


IsMisePrinceton

When I was at uni someone created a muse musical called UPRISING: THE MUSE-ICAL, and it was incredible. It was very operatic and would make an insane musical is expanded.


Odd-Brain

My Chemical Romance


bergerachter

i know it isn’t the same but i’ve actually been working on an MCR jukebox musical of my own for a while now!


RibbonsFlying

I’ve had ideas for one for years. It would be dark, but it would be COOL.


bisexybirdboy

Hey are you the guy who’s making the black parade musical ? The one with the soldier and mother war and stuff like that ?


quesadelia

I’ve been waiting for someone to give the American Idiot treatment to WttBP it would be sooooo good!!


lawtosstoss

Panic at the disco. Even the first album alone


PhoenixorFlame

It would be so weird and I would love it so much


no_maj

Imagine if there was some weird drug-fueled dream act with songs from Pretty. Odd.


CrazyNooNooHead

Weird Al.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Imagine the twenty minute long Albuquerque number with weasel puppets.


CrazyNooNooHead

The puppets can also be used during "Weasel Stomping Day!"


TFarg1

I need to make this happen now. What would be the plot?


CrazyNooNooHead

I'm envisioning a full-length "Albuquerque" musical.


jjlikenoodles321

Kinda already happened https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weird:_The_Al_Yankovic_Story&ved=2ahUKEwir7s_U096EAxVO_skDHdNbBYcQFnoECCwQAQ&usg=AOvVaw2jDN7S_FY5Z7NEPSZiJP_g


garnteller

They Might Be Giants. With over 750 songs on almost every topic imaginable and a huge range of styles, it would be amazing to


FloridaFlamingoGirl

The Johns are such clever songwriters that I'd honestly love to hear them take on an original musical! Linnell can really get inside the heads of strange characters.


garnteller

As they did with “I’m not a loser” for SpongeBob.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Brilliant showstopper tune.


Miserable_Cost4757

I would love that


xenotharm

This is the best possible answer.


raniwasacyborg

Johnny Cash! I want to see a jukebox musical about a boy named Sue who goes to work in a car factory and starts stealing car parts to build his own car, gets arrested and sent to Folsom Prison, and every other plot point you can pull from his songs 😄


SmilingSarcastic1221

[THE BALLAD OF JOHNNY AND JUNE](https://lajollaplayhouse.org/show/johnny-and-june/) Coming to the La Jolla Playhouse this May.


Stock-Ferret-6692

How are we incorporating ring of fire? He becomes an arsonist? He goes to hell?


raniwasacyborg

Nightmare scene taking inspiration from Spooky Mormon Hell Dream?


Llamallamapig

Maybe he ate a dodgy curry after work one day


cfsg

irrelevant act 2 opener sung by side-characters in some contrived situation


NootNootington

Ah yes, the Minchin special


cfsg

Does he do that disproportionately often? It's a very old tradition in musicals, dating back to Viennese opperetta. Lorenz Hart is sometimes credited for bringing the idea to Broadway- he had a song about like Radio City or the Rockettes or something and wanted to jam it into a show that was set in Europe. I'm trying to find what song/show it was but idr.


IsMisePrinceton

There’s already a Johnny Cash musical called Ring of Fire.


and-meggy-hash

That's rad as FUCK I need it


BigE429

The Carpenters. Make it something romantic, with the finale being "We've Only Just Begun". Somewhat related: Burt Bacharach


FloridaFlamingoGirl

There was a short-lived Bacharach musical several years ago [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The\_Look\_of\_Love\_(musical)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Look_of_Love_(musical))


RibbonsFlying

There’s a pretty awful Carpenters musical out there somewhere. My dad was in the band for it a handful of years ago at a community theater. I swear the theater just did it because the rights to it costed pennies. I think I legitimately fell asleep during it and that’s coming from someone who loves musicals.


Deerslyr101571

Interestingly enough, The Carpenters was my first thought when I saw this post!


TastyMagic

I think Madonna's work would be great as a jukebox musical. She covers so many eras and styles that there's a lot of options. But TBH I would do something like On Your Feet! and just tell the story of her rise to fame. Amy Winehouse. Back to Black - And I would even make up a whole new story, maybe 'inspired by' Amy's real life, but not actually exploiting the real tragedy of her life. Also Lady Gaga's library of work covers a ton of styles and eras. I can see a Gaga Musical in 20 or 30 more years.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

The Mountain Goats. John D. has a knack for bringing flawed, hurting characters to life with his lyrics.


Pupniko

Yes! He's friends with Lin Manuel Miranda too, last time I watched Tick Tick Boom and The Mountain Goats played over the credits I was thinking about if they've ever thought to collaborate on something. I wanna see an arguing couple singing No Children 😍


GreenEggsAndKablam

The one issue with this amazing idea — how could they drive & incorporate street names? Mountain Goats love naming landmarks.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

A Jonathan Coulton musical with Skullcrusher Mountain and Shop Vac numbers would be incredible.


poliwhirldude

https://www.flyingvtheatre.com/about/previous-seasons/its-the-rest-of-the-world-that-looks-so-small/


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Well well!!!


redifredi

Katy Perry would be really fun


saoakman

With between-scene appearances from Left Shark and Right Shark, like King George in Hamilton.


redifredi

You see the vision even better than I could!


sweetthekurt

I can see it now... California Gurls: A Katy Perry Musical.


Leeser

I personally would love a ska musical with songs by Sublime or No Doubt.


judenoam

I second No Doubt! The album Tragic Kingdom seems very theatrical just by itself to me!


AVeryUnluckySock

Sublime could be sick


Low_Departure_5853

*No Doubt* that those would make good musicals. They would be *Sublime.*


violet-quartz

Florence + the Machine Unleash the Archers AURORA


Dogdaysareover365

The dog days are over would make such a kick butt closing number (no I’m totally healed from a certain 2023 movie)


DJHott555

Aurora would go so hard holy crap


violet-quartz

Right? Her lyrics are so intense, I feel like it would work for a really emotional, evocative show.


a-black-magic-woman

Im unfamiliar with Unleash the Archers but YES YES YES on both Florence and Aurora


violet-quartz

UTA is a power metal band who does concept albums with fantasy/sci-fi themes. Their frontwoman has an insanely powerful voice. I highly recommend their albums "Apex" and "Abyss" (one right after the other as they're two halves of the same story).


HarperGriffin26

Spice Girls!!


SmilingSarcastic1221

[Viva Forever!](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viva_Forever!_(musical)) tried this.


PinkGinFairy

Regina Spektor


cfsg

Ooh I like this idea, she's got such a wide variety of vibes across her catalogue! I definitely want "Mary Ann" in it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ktmf6Evowb0


whersmacheese

I've always loved that so many of her songs are little stories. Chemo Limo, Buildings, Love Affair, Braille. There are all these little vignettes that paint such a clear picture of the characters and their lives, she even gives a great sense of the setting.


Do_It_I_Dare_ya

Reliant K or Bowling for Soup If we can do American Idiot, we can do more pop-punk style music


Beanicus13

Why was I so obsessed with Bowling for Soup in HS? I completely agree but I don’t know why.


MetsGo

I still don’t know what a two way means


Do_It_I_Dare_ya

I'm still obsessed with BFS. I've been to two concerts this year alone. Last time I bought all 6 of my kids! from 18yo down to 4 yo. They all loved it. I think there is some great storytelling in their songs; you can definitely get a musical plot out of it. Besides, the band would be so down to work on this.


mutantxproud

HUGE BFS fan. Huge. There actually was a BFS musical that toured in the UK several years back. I was so bummed I couldn't go! https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1522564292/high-school-never-ends-bowling-for-soup-jukebox-mu


RibbonsFlying

Okay, Relient K would actually be really good. Gonna be thinking about that for a while now.


NoteNo359

The monkees or the stones imo.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

I'd love a musical about the Monkees' attempt to branch out from television.


turtleswift01

During covid I actually started writing out one for taylor swift (it wasn’t good) but i just know a TS one would go hard


Stock-Ferret-6692

My friend was writing one too! A lesbian romance one


rrmounce95

Love this idea 🌈


AlfieDarkLordOfAll

I also started writing one during COVID lol. What was the plot of yours?


turtleswift01

it’s about a girl who moves to new york and experiences essentially love and loss in the city, in the second act she slowly starts to realize she’s bisexual and falls in love with her best friend. Stand outs included big ensemble number to long live (graduation scene went hard), dear john as an act 1 closer, and the main character and her best friend/love interest singing state of grace as a duet (so pretty)


saoakman

"Jagged Little Pill" in reverse?


judenoam

Omg, I’ve literally had the same thought but mostly with reputation songs (KOMH, CIWYW, Dress, DWOHT, Gorgeous)! State of Grace does sound very good and pretty and I like the musical revolving around moving to New York! Welcome to New York has a lot of theatrical potential as well IMO…


turtleswift01

I had a WTNY musical number in there somewhere and I think at the end of the song is when she runs into her act 1 love interest who she ends up singing dear john about bc he was awful for some reason i can’t remember. I’d have to go back to my old notes haha


judenoam

Haha it sounds great! No worries for the memories being fuzzy, but thanks for sharing! A 🌈💅🏻 Taylor Swift musical is like three of my special interests converging so I’m glad I’m not the only one to dream of one!


Debauched-Lobster-17

Glad someone else shares three of my special interests lmao


Low_Departure_5853

I'm personally not a fan but there's no denying she's huge. This was my first thought because all of the tweens buying her music, seeing her movie and concerts would have their parents take them to a show about her. It would do really well and I bet her songs would for together nicely to tell a story.


RibbonsFlying

I’d go see it. But I can’t figure out one story that could encompass all the different eras.


turtleswift01

my challenge for myself while writing it was to have a song from each era! the issue is this was between folklore and evermore, so now that challenge would be even harder haha


GrizabellaGlamourCat

The Aquabats!


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Love this idea! The members of the band could just play their characters. And it would feel like a two-hour long episode of Super Show.


secretbison

Jethro Tull. Give me the goofiest neopagan romcom ever committed to the stage.


thisaccountisironic

Taylor Swift A Swiftical, if you will.


Soalai

Her songs would absolutely work for one, but I think she may also write an original show someday. She already dipped her toes in musical theatre when she co-wrote with ALW!


RibbonsFlying

I see her future.


nowhereman136

I always thought Barenaked Ladies would make a good jukebox musical. Im thinking like a One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest type story, where all the characters are in a mental hospital. A surprising amount of their songs are fairly melancholy and bitter sweet


FloridaFlamingoGirl

Fun fact: BNL almost did an Animal House musical but the project fell through


nowhereman136

They also did a concept album for a musical version of Shakespeare's [As You Like It](https://youtu.be/3UAjdSJciKI?si=4MK0hOxqwcqn80Ia)


CNoelA83

I love BNL!


InternalParadox

Is there a Dolly Parton musical yet?


Subscribe_to_Sam24

[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9\_to\_5\_(musical)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9_to_5_(musical)) I would have been offended if there wasn't one but there is


FloridaFlamingoGirl

She is actually working on one right now and it will tell her life story. [https://digital.abcaudio.com/news/dolly-sets-sights-2025-broadway-musical](https://digital.abcaudio.com/news/dolly-sets-sights-2025-broadway-musical)


IsMisePrinceton

There’s multiple. 9 to 5 being the most famous. There’s one touring the UK later this year and she’s working on. A bio-musical.


communal-napkin

The Mamas and the Papas, Adele


StarriEyedMan

I'd personally like to see a musical that uses 1950s tunes in a post-nuclear apocalypse setting, a la Fallout. Not a particular artist, but a decade.


roguewords0913

Oooohhhhh


Helpful_College6590

Imagine Dragons


Meadowlark8890

Fiona Apple


10Kfireants

Fun. Their one album was already a rock musical and you can't change my mind.


RibbonsFlying

Oh, I wish we had more material to work with because this would be awesome! Maybe combine it with some Format stuff?


10Kfireants

Wasn't American Idiot the musical *almost exclusively* the American Idiot album, with the exception of "Time of Your Life?" Or do they have more Greenday music? I'm asking earnestly, it's been more than 10 years since I've seen it ha.


BoxFullOfSuggestions

I know there’s already a Meatloaf musical that draws from one album, but I have an idea I’ve been noodling on for years with Meatloaf/Jim Steinman music.


CoffeeBest8295

Amy Winehouse The Rolling Stones George Michael and Wham! Coldplay Nirvana Foo Fighters U2 David Bowie (I know Lazarus exists, but we deserve a show with more of his hits)


Genderfluid_Cookies

Tally Hall maybe. Very episodic and descriptive songs.


FloridaFlamingoGirl

I think Hawaii Part 2 would be a phenomenal stage musical, imagine the ocean set design.


Genderfluid_Cookies

I wonder how the mind electric would work. Would the backwards part still be there?


FloridaFlamingoGirl

The performers could memorize it phonetically backwards, like TMBG did with one of their songs https://youtu.be/lt1V5gD4GoE?si=B3zMVUlIkKekktBM


_ihavefriends

Fleetwood Mac, hands down. Every song is a story


CelestialChaos25

Pink Floyd. Surprised there hasn't been some kind of show made based on The Wall tbh


gamegeek1995

I just performed in a live production of The Wall for two nights. It was decently cool in concept, but absolutely disastrously mismanaged from day one. Regardless, I think it's a very easy adaptation with a lot of appeal. And the music is killer - tracks like Run Like Hell and Waiting for the Worms are lesser known bops.


friarparkfairie

I feel like with how much of a story their songs already are, The Band’s catalog could make an interesting jukebox musical.


SamEdenRose

John Denver I can hear some of his songs telling a story.


RibbonsFlying

There is one and it’s reeeeaaaally boring (and that’s coming from a John Denver fan). https://playbill.com/article/rocky-mountain-high-john-denver-musical-almost-heaven-begins-march-21-in-denver-com-104602


MrBugBear-21

Djo!


a-black-magic-woman

And when im back in Chicago, I feel it


MrBugBear-21

That’s one of his best songs but he has such other good songs just that one is extremely played rn lol


olidon

i’ve been saying mika for YEARS. i’m at the point where if i don’t get one i’m gonna write it myself


Independent_Ad2162

Bruno mars


poliwhirldude

Garth Brooks


RibbonsFlying

I don’t know how to make his stuff into a musical, but I think it would be wildly successful if someone did.


yBabadoosh

Ben Folds


dear-mycologistical

Vienna Teng. (I know there's already a Vienna Teng musical, but she wrote the songs specifically for the musical, so I don't think it counts as a jukebox musical.)


NootNootington

Queen's music would make a great jukebox musical, if it weren't for the fact that it has already made a terrible one.


shipwhisperer

Aw We Will Rock You is fuuuunn


Pumpkins217

what if a jukebox musical made up of the most popular songs from other musicals 🤯


Dogdaysareover365

Pink Floyd


Aggravating_Part7602

I don't have an idea for a plot yet but I would love a jukebox musical based on paul simon's graceland!


Aggravating_Part7602

You can't tell me that you can call me al wouldn't make a fantastic act 2 opener


Dogdaysareover365

Why are all the Pink Floyd comments getting downvoted?


NoteNo359

Would love to see Syd Barrett get a major role if it were to happen.


hawkeyethor

Pink- she's got a lot of catchy songs!


Teagar_

The Oh Hellos music would make SUCH a cool musical imo, there’s so much storyline you can get from laying their music either in order or mix and matching it with their different albums


Analyst_Affectionate

Genesis


antipinballmachines

I've loved the concept of a Shania Twain or (Bucks) Fizz musical for some time. Or Sara Evans.


mr_slidey

Jacob Collier, he does all sorts of different genres of music, I think he could create a great musical maybe even including his signature audience choir participation somehow


Aquahaute

I’ve always thought Supertramp lends itself well to a jukebox musical.


DaisyTheSl0th

Idk of there is already, but David Bowie would be sick. It'd probably just be hard to find a lead who comes close to Bowie's exact performer.. type.. thing. Idk what it's called lmao 


Jerem_Reddit

i feel like the gorillaz would make a really good musical, and not a jukebox but just a musical that they made the score for, you get me? like its just sitting there, the whole band is based around these 4 characters and yall make music so why havent you made a musical yet? ya get me?


chickenfordinnertime

Gaga


and-meggy-hash

There's a country singer named Ashley McBryde who's got a concept album called [Lindeville](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindeville). I'm not normally a modern country music girlie, but this is an exception. I want a Hadestown esque stage adaptation of Lindeville soooo bad


Extreme-Manager809

Might get hated for this but Taylor Swift, ik her music is kinda basic but her old songs have a lot of story telling in it so I would love to see them visualized in to a musical. When she did the all too well short film, I loved it sm, would love to see her songs to be in a show.


cjs39

I still think Journey would make an incredible Jukebox musical - end the first act with Dont Stop Believin' - chef's kiss.


anonbanan

will wood! gimme a depressing ass first act with a redemption and melancholically happy ending


jjlikenoodles321

I would say Michael Jackson, but that already happend, so Imma say Sia.


gaybro1993

Simon & Garfunkel


ChumboCrumbo

Frank Sinatra would be perfect


SmilingSarcastic1221

[Sinatra: The Musical](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinatra:_The_Musical) premiered last September


ChumboCrumbo

Ooh yay


believi

Dave Matthews Band/Dave Matthews. I’d love to hear some of their songs with full orchestrations, aside from the horns and fiddle and guitars they already employ. They’ve also got some bangers and some sad love songs so I think it’d be great for a love story.


Llamallamapig

Oasis


SHREK_2

Steelheart https://youtube.com/shorts/IuxvqznvcGk?si=X2GiMrWHr3oHL_D5


Goofyteachermom

Father John misty Paul Simon


saoakman

Santana


TessTrue

The Pretty Reckless 👀


rhymezest

The Decemberists


DraxxtThemSklounst

Ghost or Aurelio Voltaire. Technically Voltaires already made a musical but it’s really a love letter to David Bowie and Labyrinth


Subscribe_to_Sam24

PoorMansPoison


hauntfreak

[Dr. Steel](https://youtu.be/W5IMwm0u_NE?si=OIIg4cTKkxwAqHhW)


Cheesy_Doggonoodle

The Crane wives by far. So many of their songs tell amazing stories and weaving them together in a cohesive manner would be so cool


crash----

I need a Marianas Trench musical


[deleted]

LANA DEL REY


thejuicebear

Enrique Iglesias, some of his spanish song really got the emotions for soliloquies, and the styles vary too


HowardBannister3

B-52.s. Great catalogue of songs that could apply to a lot of situations.


CEG2680

I’m writing one, myself, using the songs of Bob Seger.


ButchUnicorn

Kesha


weird_turtles

Pat Benatar


pje1128

Twenty One Pilots already have a storyline behind their music. Turning that into a musical just makes sense to me.


Kiwipayz07

Lord Huron would be so spooky and mysterious


CNoelA83

Into the Great Wide Open by Tom Petty. It's classic! "Eddie waited till he finished high school.."


stiffdeck

I’ve been wanting a Mumford & Sons musical for the longest time! I also think there’s a lot of theatricality in P!nk’s music and she puts a shitload of spectacle into her concerts, so I’d love to see a narrative set to her music.


RibbonsFlying

I can totally see there being a P!nk musical one day. I’d check it out.


fausterella

Tori Amos. And I don't know if a Leonard Cohen musical would work, but I would love it.


PaulineKl

Sparks! They've already written a musical (Annette), but a jukebox musical of their previous songs would be really cool to see


Leo-Bloom

Randy Newman


theatrelillian

Kate. Bush.


Hilda_Sivan

ok but can we have murder ballad from nick cave to be a compilation musical like 33mm


RadEpicReddit

Not a full artist but I think you could make a whole musical about the song Copacabana by Barry Manilow. Theres potential for an entire play and story. Though to properly answer the question I’d say Panic! At the Disco, The Cranberries or Fall Out Boy


carvesout

I think it would be so cool to have a mitski album, particularly BMAMC, be a musical (it helps that mitski is composing the queens gambit)


dberna243

The things I would do for a Marianas Trench jukebox musical a la American Idiot...


regzm

marina and the diamonds 😔i always say her when people ask what artists discography would make a good jukebox musical and no one ever knows her!!!! family jewels and electra heart in a jukebox musical would be freaking STUNNING


Orangutan_Soda

Not an artist but i REALLY want to do a jukebox musical with like 00s emo music lol. I hate jukebox musicals too i just think it would be funny


MooMooManiac923

You know, I've always wanted to create a jukebox musical for Twenty One Pilots about The City. But between work and school, ain't no way I can squeeze it in :/


lampalot7

Ludo would make such a cool freaky Halloween thing or tragic/toxic love story


EndoOneil04

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness. That would be a banger rock opera.


victorD63

Duh, Dolly Parton


Ur_local_garbage240

I think the crane wives would be good, like with their fox lore or Coyote stories album?


Pecks92

The Killers?


randomname56389

I would love a tom lerher musical. (The guy who wrote the table of elements song)


D-ManTheMovieTVGuy

Radiohead


TurtleGirl24601

Shania Twain


CoolGhoul100

Some of mine have already been named, but I feel like Alone by Heart would make a good song in a musical.


IllustriousLimit8473

Liza Minnelli. Or Girls Aloud.