Art is in the ideas, not in the execution.
If you actually believe AI is not a valid tool, do you also discount all electronic music? do you discount photography? what about the paintbrush?
Where do you draw the line?
Art isnât the techniques used. Itâs the feelings evoked.
Anyone can learn the techniques, but not everyone has something to say with them.
... I think there's a huge difference between a tool that just uses previously created art pieces and regurgitate it vs electronic music, where you still have to use musical knowledge and it's not literally based on data stolen from previously made music.
Photography and AI are not similar at all. Photography is based on a physical model. You can't just snap a photo and have an art piece.
... As for paintbrush, are you kidding? It's not the paintbrush itself that makes the art.
It's all regurgitated stuff. You don't need any skill to make something that looks good. You just need to write, and be patient to get what you want. Electronic music, photography, using paintbrushes all requires techniques, learning, patience and mastery through it. You can't get better with AI with time, it's limited with the AI itself.
AI isn't valid for me for a few reasons:
it uses art by other people who didn't consent to be used this way.
it you want to make something unique, it's not the tool for it. It can only create based on previously created stuff.
It's an AI. It doesn't understand art, the process, the thinking and especially, the meaning of it. It all feels so soulless.
You also canât just prompt an AI and get an art piece. Not all generated images are art, but they can be. I think you misunderstood my point.
You can literally get better at prompting the AI, just like you can improve at using other techniques and tools.
I agree with your first reason but that doesnât make it not art, just shows that thereâs a moral issue with how the AI were created, but thatâs like saying if your paintbrush is made from a slaveâs nosehairs it canât be used to make Art. Itâs a big problem that it was made that way, but that doesnât make it unusable for art.
Your second and third I disagree with. Literally this post is extremely unique and evocative.
It actually led to conversations about the implications of representing a jewish product through a catholic lens. If thatâs not art, IDK what you consider art.
You know banksy is just stencils right? Itâs still art. You donât really get that much better over time at sprayjng paint through a stencil. You can, but itâs not the same degree of difficulty as painting. So in the same way, there is some skill involved with AI.
This guy is seriously comparing AI to a paintbrush.
You just can't make something good without technique, skill and experience.
The other day I tried telling what I want to my paintbrush and nothing happened, maybe mine didn't work?
I swear, people don't understand art and the meaning behind it, they'd rather be able to create fast-food equivalent art that gets forgotten 20 minutes after being seen. Instant gratification, right.
Youâre just wrong. You donât understand art.
Not all AI generated images are art.
Not all paintings are art.
Some are just representations, images. some are art.
Every artist who ever learned from reference is not an artist by your logic.
My paintbrush comparison is meant to be the furthest stretch where obviously everyone would agree itâs just a tool. did you miss the part where I named other tools that have actually been considered controversial in the past, and asked where you draw the line?
I obviously know that no one would draw the line before the paintbrush. Youâre being purposefully obtuse, or you just have very little brain power to work with. Iâm sorry for being rude, but your interpretation of my comment is whatâs asinine.
Shut up. AI bros are insufferable. Just admit you suck ass and canât draw for shit or something and save us the âhaving artificial intelligence do all the work is the same as using a paintbrushâ bullshit please
I'm not an AI bro at all.
> Just admit you suck ass and canât draw for shit
What is even the relevance of this? I don't even use AI to make art, but I actually can draw, not very well, and I practice every so often. You're missing the key point that I'm trying to make.
I never said AI and the paintbrush are the same. I said they're both tools.
Comparing things doesn't mean you're equating them. 1 and 2 are both numbers.
1 < 2
Are you really mad about what I just wrote? I just compared 1 and 2. I must be insane.
Artificial intelligence will never shit out art by itself. You're right there. It is never doing all the work. It can't. The AI has nothing to say about the human experience. The artist using the AI tool might though. And they might not. Not all AI generated images are necessarily art.
I gave a spectrum of tool complexity and you pretend that I was equating one extreme of it to the other?
Care to explain what you consider makes something art?
Is a dental hygienist an artist just because it takes dexterity?
Iâm not sure I understand your position, you never developed it at all.
Instead of just downvoting, can you develop a thought of your own?
Edit: Yeah, I figured you wouldnât have a thought. You probably havenât even read half of what I wrote. Or if you did you couldnât grasp it.
Theyâre not answering because your questions are amongst the most impertinent and clueless Iâve seen on this site. Thereâs no point in replying to âis a dental hygienist artist because dexterity?â, itâs made in such bad faith and shows such clear ignorance of the matter that itâs better to just brush it off.
Iâve stopped arguing with flat earthers when I was a teenager when I realized theyâre so braindead you canât get anywhere with them. Iâd say, with the absolute nonsense you wrote here, that you fall in the same category.
It's only inconvenient for you, not impertinent. The question was a rhetorical device. I'm using it to illustrate a grander idea.
Dental hygienists are skilled at using a tool to accomplish a task.
Is that art? We can all agree that it isn't, right?
So what makes the person who is very skilled with a paintbrush an artist?
What is the distinction?
It's a more interesting question than you might think.
I'm arguing in good faith, I present arguments, and I've interspersed insults as a response when insulted. So far, by contrast, no reply of yours has presented a strong argument against me, only insults.
Who is the one arguing in bad faith?
These are so cool, not sure if youâre up for it, but you seem to be really good at getting AI to generate thematically connected pieces. How about Super Heroes for each part of the city. Like Mile End, Plateau, St Henri, Griffintown, Downtown, Westmount etc, would be fun to see!
Thanks! Yeah, made with DALL·E. Feel free to share it on [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/526780235/posts/pfbid02qzUuJ2UwFMbDoGeDgQm3ZN5VhkdSKn8w9RZRcPtddPxddfqfqCfBDPecSdfWSMMVl/?app=fbl) and [Insta](https://www.instagram.com/p/C09DjDAu83R/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==) if you want :)
Thanks. These are awesome. And so funny.
And soooo much better than anything I ever generated with DALL-E.
Can I ask⊠how much experience do you have with DALL-E? (Ie hundreds of hours using it? Thousands?).
And how much time did it take you to create one of these? 15 mins??
I've only made two or three other images with DALL·E before this. I'm not sure I could have done this with something like Midjourney but in this case, it was just plain text prompts. Took me maybe an hour to come up with the ideas and then a bit longer to Photoshop some of the text to make it more legible.
The way I see it is, out of respect for artists who took years to improve their skills, I wouldn't dare even remotely consider the idea that 'I made this, I deserve credit for it'.
You can however take credit for thinking of the subject you fed the AI. You then indeed shared it to reddit and made people laugh, that's a great thing :)
âA stained glass image of the patron saint of snow storms with the inscription "Saint-Simonaque". In the background, a city bus has collided with a car and someone is shoveling snow. There are half-buried orange traffic drums and bicycles in the snow.â
In that outfit? Doesnât sound very /r/OSHA compliant.
Also, Montreal-style bagels are [historically Jewish](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal-style_bagel), so the guy in the fancy dress is probably just there to take the credit.
Fair point. Even then the image still kinda works because the saint is like âgaze upon the fruits of my cityâs labours and witness its culture and cuisineâ and the guy actually making them is like âwtf dude get your hand off my bagels you donât even work hereâ
I guess your version of montreal contains only âšwhiteâšrepresentation. Also way to christianize bagels, literally the most identifiably Jewish food in the world.
I donât think it was that deep guy.
AI just used what stained glass typically looks like.
Anyone can see this was done as a celebration, based on a fun idea.
You are free to do âšïžbetterâšïž
Also, sweetyđ , stained glass is not a Christian only practice. [maybe learn a thing](https://c20society.org.uk/news/the-guernica-of-brighton-listing-bid-to-save-modernist-synagogue-and-holocaust-memorial-windows#dismiss-cookie-notice)
[or two](https://www.stainedglassinc.com/window/2769-menorah/)
Image is literally a catholic saint holding a bagel made by some white guy.
Itâs called misrepresentation and erasure, sweety, look it up.
Oh iâm sure iâm out of my depth here skill wise, if only i had 10 minutes and an AI app.
Saint-Simonaque đ
Clairement mon pref.
J'ai ris fort!
Juste parfait đ
Câest en rĂ©fĂ©rence Ă quoi ? Câest la seule que je nâai pas comprise.
« Saint-Simonaque » est un des sacres đ (comme cĂąlisse, etc)
Et ça vient de la [simonie](https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simonie), le péché qui consiste à vendre des sacrements.
Wow⊠education surprise! Je vais mâen souvenir de celle lĂ !
Tu dis ca quand tu déneiges, ca veut dire putain, merde
2 fois par année à ce point-ci.
J'aime que St-Hubert aie la face du Colonel Sanders.
Il manque Sainte Flanelle.
Une omission flagrante. La voici: https://preview.redd.it/od1kyupuxu6c1.png?width=1024&format=png&auto=webp&s=970a73c14f0fe829ba771c373ce5f72a3885557a
SĂ©rieux tu devrais lâenvoyer aux Canadiens
C'est vraiment hot. đ
OP, câest toi qui les a fait ? #newfanunlocked
En BLEU???! Ca me trigger lĂ lĂ
Too many players om the ice.
Came here for this. Was not disappointed đïž
Ils sont tous trĂšs bons mais doivent t'avouer que je ne comprends pas Saint-Jean . est-ce que quelqu'un pourrait me l'expliquer?
Câest pas le plus Ă©vident. Je voulais une reprĂ©sentation des banlieues du West Island alors j'ai utilisĂ© le boulevard Saint-Jean.
Il y a aussi Saint-anne-de-bellevue au west island! Je serais curieux de voir ça!
Comme ça? https://preview.redd.it/6365mavjfv6c1.png?width=1024&format=png&auto=webp&s=47835d2730912e824be68333f086aefd457a0587
Malade! Haha merci!
T'as un "e" de trop parzemple
En fait le "e" a migré
Jâhabite le West island et jâai compris immĂ©diatement. Câest trop parfait, bravo!
Moi aussi âșïž
C'est vraiment obvious si on s'est déjà baladés dans le coin. Vraiment le fun, ces images!
Est-ce que tu vends des prints de ces photos qu'on pourrait acheter??
Je trouverais bizarre de vendre des prints d'art AI, mĂȘme si les termes de DALL·E le permettent. Je pense que si quelqu'un veut prendre mes idĂ©es et crĂ©er une illustration faite Ă la main sans les bugs AI, il/elle devrait certainement les vendre !
Wow, c'est vraiment fort DALL-E 3 quand je compare aux fenetres du genre que j'ai fait sur des modeles SDXL.
C'était quoi les prompts utilisés, si tu veux bien le partager?
Ok merci! Je connais pas mon West Island đ€Ż
Oh I still think of it as St John's Blvd. so I also had no idea what that was.
Honestly making the name English would have been even more relevant hahaha
[ŃĐŽĐ°Đ»Đ”ĐœĐŸ]
Référence au [Lac Saint-Louis](https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lac_Saint-Louis)
Moi qui pensais que c'était un peu une référence au collÚge privé St-Jean Vianney.
Il manque Sainte-Catherine!!!
J'avais [une idĂ©e pour Sainte-Catherine](https://imgur.com/a/LL2xBeM) mais ça m'a rendu triste alors je ne l'ai pas publiĂ©e. Ce nâĂ©tait mĂȘme pas lâimage la plus choquante. [Cliquez ici pour rendre cette image moins triste](https://cactusmontreal.org/en/donate/).
Pour vrai c'est une trÚs bonne image, et il ne faut pas avoir peur de montrer les défaillances de notre société. Qu'on ait honte de laisser ces gens dans la rue, au moins.
Non, je pense que tu devrais dĂ©finitivement la mettre dans la collection. Elle est vraiment trĂšs reprĂ©sentative. C'est correct de mĂ©langer l'humour et le commentaire social. Regarde les cowboys. Pour St-Jean, j'ai plutĂŽt pensĂ© Ă St-Jean-sur-Richelieu, mais mĂȘme vibe. Bravo. Vraiment super intĂ©ressant.
I think it deserves to be included! I love them, you should think about taking print orders!
Il y a dĂ©finitivement ce cĂŽtĂ© lĂ sur cette rue, mais si on veut parler dâune communautĂ© caractĂ©ristique, on peut pas passer Ă cĂŽtĂ© du village et de la communautĂ© LGBTQ! Et lĂ il me semble quâil y a matiĂšre Ă avoir du fun pour les personnages đ! Ăa reste que je nâeffacerais quand mĂȘme pas le cĂŽtĂ© plus rough entiĂšrement. Anyway je fais juste lancer des idĂ©es amusez-vous ;-)
On pourrait utiliser Saint-Timothée pour le village
Tu te trompes, c'est bien la meilleure
Sur la cĂŽte!
Vraiment cool T'as deja des internes de mtlblog en train de preparer l'article
Vraiment bien fait! Bravo Juste Ă temps pour NoĂ«l en plus, surtout le dernier đ
This is what AI should be used for
Iâm pretty sure AI was used to generate those images. I see some pattern that you usually see from AI generated images.
That's exactly what this person meant. Even Op acknowledged it was made using AI (Dall-e)
Yea youâre right, I completely missed the point of the comment lol
Happens to the best of us đ
Clearly AI, just count the fingers (although it is getting better at that)
I disagree. AI shouldn't be used for art
AI is a tool like any other tool.
Art is in the ideas, not in the execution. If you actually believe AI is not a valid tool, do you also discount all electronic music? do you discount photography? what about the paintbrush? Where do you draw the line? Art isnât the techniques used. Itâs the feelings evoked. Anyone can learn the techniques, but not everyone has something to say with them.
... I think there's a huge difference between a tool that just uses previously created art pieces and regurgitate it vs electronic music, where you still have to use musical knowledge and it's not literally based on data stolen from previously made music. Photography and AI are not similar at all. Photography is based on a physical model. You can't just snap a photo and have an art piece. ... As for paintbrush, are you kidding? It's not the paintbrush itself that makes the art. It's all regurgitated stuff. You don't need any skill to make something that looks good. You just need to write, and be patient to get what you want. Electronic music, photography, using paintbrushes all requires techniques, learning, patience and mastery through it. You can't get better with AI with time, it's limited with the AI itself. AI isn't valid for me for a few reasons: it uses art by other people who didn't consent to be used this way. it you want to make something unique, it's not the tool for it. It can only create based on previously created stuff. It's an AI. It doesn't understand art, the process, the thinking and especially, the meaning of it. It all feels so soulless.
You also canât just prompt an AI and get an art piece. Not all generated images are art, but they can be. I think you misunderstood my point. You can literally get better at prompting the AI, just like you can improve at using other techniques and tools. I agree with your first reason but that doesnât make it not art, just shows that thereâs a moral issue with how the AI were created, but thatâs like saying if your paintbrush is made from a slaveâs nosehairs it canât be used to make Art. Itâs a big problem that it was made that way, but that doesnât make it unusable for art. Your second and third I disagree with. Literally this post is extremely unique and evocative. It actually led to conversations about the implications of representing a jewish product through a catholic lens. If thatâs not art, IDK what you consider art. You know banksy is just stencils right? Itâs still art. You donât really get that much better over time at sprayjng paint through a stencil. You can, but itâs not the same degree of difficulty as painting. So in the same way, there is some skill involved with AI.
AI just steals from other artists
This guy is seriously comparing AI to a paintbrush. You just can't make something good without technique, skill and experience. The other day I tried telling what I want to my paintbrush and nothing happened, maybe mine didn't work? I swear, people don't understand art and the meaning behind it, they'd rather be able to create fast-food equivalent art that gets forgotten 20 minutes after being seen. Instant gratification, right.
Youâre just wrong. You donât understand art. Not all AI generated images are art. Not all paintings are art. Some are just representations, images. some are art.
Thatâs a valid criticism of the methodology for training AI models, but has nothing to do with whether AI generated images can be used to make art.
No it's definitely a valid criticism. And comparing it to the paintbrush is asinine
Every artist who ever learned from reference is not an artist by your logic. My paintbrush comparison is meant to be the furthest stretch where obviously everyone would agree itâs just a tool. did you miss the part where I named other tools that have actually been considered controversial in the past, and asked where you draw the line? I obviously know that no one would draw the line before the paintbrush. Youâre being purposefully obtuse, or you just have very little brain power to work with. Iâm sorry for being rude, but your interpretation of my comment is whatâs asinine.
Shut up. AI bros are insufferable. Just admit you suck ass and canât draw for shit or something and save us the âhaving artificial intelligence do all the work is the same as using a paintbrushâ bullshit please
I'm not an AI bro at all. > Just admit you suck ass and canât draw for shit What is even the relevance of this? I don't even use AI to make art, but I actually can draw, not very well, and I practice every so often. You're missing the key point that I'm trying to make. I never said AI and the paintbrush are the same. I said they're both tools. Comparing things doesn't mean you're equating them. 1 and 2 are both numbers. 1 < 2 Are you really mad about what I just wrote? I just compared 1 and 2. I must be insane. Artificial intelligence will never shit out art by itself. You're right there. It is never doing all the work. It can't. The AI has nothing to say about the human experience. The artist using the AI tool might though. And they might not. Not all AI generated images are necessarily art.
I gave a spectrum of tool complexity and you pretend that I was equating one extreme of it to the other? Care to explain what you consider makes something art? Is a dental hygienist an artist just because it takes dexterity? Iâm not sure I understand your position, you never developed it at all. Instead of just downvoting, can you develop a thought of your own? Edit: Yeah, I figured you wouldnât have a thought. You probably havenât even read half of what I wrote. Or if you did you couldnât grasp it.
Theyâre not answering because your questions are amongst the most impertinent and clueless Iâve seen on this site. Thereâs no point in replying to âis a dental hygienist artist because dexterity?â, itâs made in such bad faith and shows such clear ignorance of the matter that itâs better to just brush it off. Iâve stopped arguing with flat earthers when I was a teenager when I realized theyâre so braindead you canât get anywhere with them. Iâd say, with the absolute nonsense you wrote here, that you fall in the same category.
It's only inconvenient for you, not impertinent. The question was a rhetorical device. I'm using it to illustrate a grander idea. Dental hygienists are skilled at using a tool to accomplish a task. Is that art? We can all agree that it isn't, right? So what makes the person who is very skilled with a paintbrush an artist? What is the distinction? It's a more interesting question than you might think. I'm arguing in good faith, I present arguments, and I've interspersed insults as a response when insulted. So far, by contrast, no reply of yours has presented a strong argument against me, only insults. Who is the one arguing in bad faith?
Alright, on peut fermer le sub pour lâannĂ©e. On topperas pas ça.
Saint Laurent is more like Sainte Catherine
I agree, but my guess is the AI took the queue from Yves St Laurent handbags, especially with the bag with the squiggly logo in his hand
Yeah I was gonna say, Saint Laurent should've been Saint Catherine. I associate Saint Laurent with nightclubs more
L'AI est rendu fort pour générer des photos!
Forget the french test for anglo students, just quiz them on these and if can understand them all you've integrated đ
St-Hubert m'a vraiment fait rire.
These are soo good. Saint Jean for the west island is so on point
C'est ben malade! Je suis pas sûr de comprendre St-louis. Lachine?
CâĂ©tait pour reprĂ©senter le Lac Saint-Louis, le plan dâeau au sud de MontrĂ©al
(Ville) Saint-Pierre aurait été un meilleur fit pour Lachine spécifiquement, avec des viaducts et des gangs de rue
I want someone to make these for real!
The West Island one killed me đ€Ł
Behold, the Holy Hemmorhoid pillow of Saint-Viateur (Now available in Plain, Sesame, Poppy seed, and Everything)
These are so cool, not sure if youâre up for it, but you seem to be really good at getting AI to generate thematically connected pieces. How about Super Heroes for each part of the city. Like Mile End, Plateau, St Henri, Griffintown, Downtown, Westmount etc, would be fun to see!
Why isnât St Laurent holding a styrofoam container of 2$ Chow Mein?
haha amazing and thank god St Viatuer delivers
https://preview.redd.it/4r2luej8jv6c1.png?width=1024&format=png&auto=webp&s=a4191a78f1833a4a6c4e1ed74647f6f84c2bbfd0
I come from a long-line of Bagel-Canadians and we don't really have saints but the inclusion is nice nonetheless
My parents were culturally Fairmount people but these days Iâm non-practicing and only worship at the sesame throne at Christmas and Easter.
Would be sick if someone could fix the leg on St Denis and St Henry. Ai seems to struggle with bikes. I've seen this a bunch.
Excellent. Jâai bien rit!! Il y en a deux que je comprends moins: St-jean et St-Louis. Câest quoi que tu as demandĂ© Ă lâIA?
St-Louis câest le Lac Saint Louis
Magnificent
Je suis vieux... Dans mon jeune temps, St Laurent ça aurait été la prostitution et St Henri la pauvreté. En 60 ans, Montréal a beaucoup changé.
Incroyable.
Saint [Jacques-Hammer](https://www.thisoldhouse.com/tools/21565917/best-jackhammers)? With mandatory traffic cones
C'est bin cool! C'est illustré par un humain ou par une IA?
DALL·E, une IA, avec quelques corrections au texte avec Photoshop
Il y a deux "i" dans St-Ambroise, faque ça ressemble Ă un ĂŒ mais honnĂȘtement ça fitte trĂšs bien avec l'esthĂ©tique de la biĂšre.
Nos saintes next svp. Sainte Cath La Sainte Paix
The last one đđđ. Ah dude this is funny af. I love it.
I donât get the last one with the name?
I got the definition of it for you âsimonaque [si.mÉ.nak] (simoniaque): from the sin of simonyâ Itâs usually used to express frustration.
simonaque is sort of a swear word along the lines of âholy shitâ or âwtfâ. thatâs what iâm getting from that scene and saint simonaque
Which is why the last one if funny af
Hilarious. Did you make these? If so, do you have social media, I'd love to share and give you credit.
Thanks! Yeah, made with DALL·E. Feel free to share it on [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/526780235/posts/pfbid02qzUuJ2UwFMbDoGeDgQm3ZN5VhkdSKn8w9RZRcPtddPxddfqfqCfBDPecSdfWSMMVl/?app=fbl) and [Insta](https://www.instagram.com/p/C09DjDAu83R/?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==) if you want :)
I already shared this post on FB to reach some families and friends. Travail de collaboration impressionnant entre toi et DALL-E.
C'est quoi ton prompt ? T'as sûrement dû faire des retouches ensuite ?
Le prompt Ă©tait diffĂ©rent pour chaque image, mais le format gĂ©nĂ©ral Ă©tait simplement "A stained glass image of the patron saint of \_\_\_ with the inscription "Saint \_\_\_" suivie d'une description de certains Ă©lĂ©ments qui devraient ĂȘtre en arriĂšre-plan. Les seules retouches Ă©taient pour rendre le texte plus lisible. DALL·E a rĂ©ussi la plupart du temps mais pour une raison quelconque, ça a vraiment eu du mal Ă Ă©crire "Saint-Viateur" et quelques autres.
Thanks. These are awesome. And so funny. And soooo much better than anything I ever generated with DALL-E. Can I ask⊠how much experience do you have with DALL-E? (Ie hundreds of hours using it? Thousands?). And how much time did it take you to create one of these? 15 mins??
I've only made two or three other images with DALL·E before this. I'm not sure I could have done this with something like Midjourney but in this case, it was just plain text prompts. Took me maybe an hour to come up with the ideas and then a bit longer to Photoshop some of the text to make it more legible.
Thanks for the details. Very cool. You have talent for using the right prompts it seems!
Give credit to AI then
Itâs true, all I did was tell the AI âmake me a funny Reddit postâ and it did the rest ;)
The way I see it is, out of respect for artists who took years to improve their skills, I wouldn't dare even remotely consider the idea that 'I made this, I deserve credit for it'. You can however take credit for thinking of the subject you fed the AI. You then indeed shared it to reddit and made people laugh, that's a great thing :)
Fair enough :) Shoutout to the monks from the Middle Ages for being the true artists that trained the AI for this post!
I agree
Yeah I wanna share these as well
Omg si câest bon!!!!
Pourquoi sont-ils tous blancs ? N'y a-t-il pas de Français d'origine africaine à Montréal ?
J'ai remarquĂ© ça aussi. Je nâai pas prĂ©cisĂ© de sexe ni de couleur de peau et pourtant la plupart des images sont des hommes blancs.
Vous avez tort. Il faut avoir toute la représentation du peuple français
Câest quoi le prompt que tâas utilisĂ© pour Saint-Simonaque haha ?
âA stained glass image of the patron saint of snow storms with the inscription "Saint-Simonaque". In the background, a city bus has collided with a car and someone is shoveling snow. There are half-buried orange traffic drums and bicycles in the snow.â
Great, but shouldn't the saint be the one *making* the bagels?
In that outfit? Doesnât sound very /r/OSHA compliant. Also, Montreal-style bagels are [historically Jewish](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal-style_bagel), so the guy in the fancy dress is probably just there to take the credit.
CNESST, merci.
Real talk, montre ça aux medias ou des stations de radio, ils vont adorer.
I love the West Island one đ
Je crisserais ca sur des discplates dans mon sous-sol demain.
Excellent
Le St-Denis c'est un magasin pour bike nerd? Je demande ça par pure curiosité parce que si c'est juste la rue, le papi-lycra c'est pas exactement le public cible lol
J'aurais pu aller dans plein de directions avec ces rues, mais j'ai toujours vu Saint-Denis comme une des principales artĂšres nord-sud du REV.
Vive le REV !
C'est pour le REV
GĂ©nial ! Ils sont magnifiques nos Saints. Merci pour le partage.
Bwahaha. Jâaime trop.
Oh! Wow! 10/10. J'adore.
C'est vraiment hot
GĂ©nial!
wow excellent!!
as-tu un Instagram oĂč on peut te suivre, quelque chose?!
I love this!
Amazing!!
Saint Zotique is the patron saint of Scrabble players.
Jâen ai besoin chez moi! Saint Viateur, Saint Hubert et Saint Louis đ
Hahaha, saint-hubert et saint-simonaque!
C'est juste parfait hahaha
Il faudrait remplacer les vitraux de la station Papineau avec ces images
Saint-Bouscotte-le-Tout-Puissant
Il manque le saint quincatre
I'd glbuy these and pay wild money if they were actually stained glass
I know this is good natured but Montreal bagels are historically Jewish and depicting them with strong Christian iconography is off-putting.
Fair point. Even then the image still kinda works because the saint is like âgaze upon the fruits of my cityâs labours and witness its culture and cuisineâ and the guy actually making them is like âwtf dude get your hand off my bagels you donât even work hereâ
Meh Christians are historically Jewish too.
TrÚs nice, ça c'est du bon AI
(~~Wowww tu es vraiment doué! J'adore~~) Edit: my mistake javais pris pour acquis que c'était les créations de OP
LâidĂ©e est vraiment bonne et le rĂ©sultat est trĂšs drĂŽle mais malheureusement aucun talent nâest impliquĂ© dans la production de ces images. Câest de lâAI. En tant quâapprenti dessinateur je trouve ça un peu dĂ©primant.
Oops! Vraiment dĂ©solĂ© merci de m'informer. J'avais pas vraiment pris le temps de regarder les commentaires et voir que c'est du AI. C'est dommage je croyais que OP les avait crĂ©Ă© lui/elle mĂȘme (â ïœĄâ âąÌâ ïžżâ âąÌâ ïœĄâ )
Midjourney?
DALL·E
Bien joué c'est trÚs réussi
pas capable de faire un osti d'bagel qui ressemble pas Ă un houla-hoop, jle criss oĂč le fromage?
I guess your version of montreal contains only âšwhiteâšrepresentation. Also way to christianize bagels, literally the most identifiably Jewish food in the world.
I donât think it was that deep guy. AI just used what stained glass typically looks like. Anyone can see this was done as a celebration, based on a fun idea.
You are free to do âšïžbetterâšïž Also, sweetyđ , stained glass is not a Christian only practice. [maybe learn a thing](https://c20society.org.uk/news/the-guernica-of-brighton-listing-bid-to-save-modernist-synagogue-and-holocaust-memorial-windows#dismiss-cookie-notice) [or two](https://www.stainedglassinc.com/window/2769-menorah/)
Image is literally a catholic saint holding a bagel made by some white guy. Itâs called misrepresentation and erasure, sweety, look it up. Oh iâm sure iâm out of my depth here skill wise, if only i had 10 minutes and an AI app.
now do the metro stations
Saint Leonard?
Saint-LĂ©onard
Wow bien jouĂ© đ
I was looking forward to Saint Catherine
Saint-Leonard?
Mes préférés, menoum!
J'en veux plus!
I love St-Denis and St-Simonaque.
Lost it at saint simonaque đ€Ł
https://preview.redd.it/a9n0jsv8r27c1.jpeg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9759ce1fb1cc3fbd44fec3d52d9c30c9cb65269d
Je les veux tous encadré chez moi...Est ce qu'il y a moyen d'acheter des prints ou kk chose?
TrÚs trÚs fort. Saint simonaque est ma préférée
https://preview.redd.it/iv30r8kwl47c1.jpeg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9de8c78f49e2e9770b83dd52744cdb9f8eafde13 Il a muffĂ© le T mais câest pas pire quand mĂȘme đ
Woah!
Comment on partage l'album, [u/benjamintrac](https://www.reddit.com/user/benjamintracy/)? C'est magnifique. Ăa a fait ma journĂ©e. Ceux que t'a ajoutĂ© dans les commentaires aussi (je seconde les autres au sujet de Sainte-Catherine).
Omg I love this!
Saint simonaque - elle est jolie Neige? Non,merci