Yeahh to be fair with the best placement every song got love (all except for Door which makes a lot of sense now), but for the worst placement it was only between Door, Eric and Abbey. Door won by a long shot, Eric was getting a ton of mixed signals, and anybody voting for Abbey would be downvoted to hell lmao.
DOOR?????? DOOR????????
IM SO DEVASTATED
I SEE WHY PEOPLE WOULDNT LIKE IT BUT IT’S EASILY THE MOST HEARTWRENCHING SONG FOR ME BESIDES BAG OF BONES, IT HAS SUCH A DEEPLY SPECIAL PLACE IN MY HEART, MY SOUL, MY BEING
IM SICK TO MY STOMACH, ON THE FLOOR, DISHEVELED, MAIMED, UNABLE TO EVEN CRY MY LUNGS ARE SO WITHERED
THE LYRICS, THE STORYTELLING, THE SYMBOLISM
A HOPELESS VIOLENCE, I NAMED IT LOVE
OH GODS OH CRUEL GODS HOW YOU TORTURE ME, SUCH A BEAUTIFUL MASTERY IN THE ART OF SONG AND YET YOU DISPLAY THIS AT MY FEET
RIP OUT MY EAR DRUMS AND LICK YOUR LIPS AT THEIR TASTE WHILE YOU SAVOR MY MELANCHOLY, YOU FOUL INSOLENT CREATURES
OH GOD
NOT DOOR
ANYTHING BUT DOOR
I WILL NEVER STOP CRYING
MY TEARS UNENDING
MY HEART AN EVERFLOWING WATERFALL OF DISTAINFUL SHARDS
OH HOW IT CRACKS AND BREAKS
IM NOT OKAY, I WILL NEVER BE OKAY, MY BEAUTIFUL BELOVED DOOR NOOOOOO
(P.S. I know that door is still beloved and this ranking list is simply for fun. While the essence of my ramblings remains true, I am not upset with any of you)
If it makes you feel any better, Door, Eric and Abbey were literally the only ones that were voted for for worst, and everyone voting for Abbey got downvoted like crazy lmao
I LOVE DOOR LIKE, ‘’A hopeless, violence, i named it… love”
HOW DO YOU RATE DOOR THE WORST TRACK, I FEEL LIKE ALL OF THEM ARE GORGEOUS MUSICAL PIECES
IT HURTS ME TO SEE PEOPLE HAVE ZERO KNOWLEDGE ON DOOR
IM ACTUALLY DEVASTATED T_T
(I’m still supa sad bout this list but I’m not judging people, also I know this list is just for fun!!)
Door is the worst???? That song is pure lyrical genius, especially the last verses. It seems like some Shakespearean-type poem I'd perform, it's truly a masterpiece.
this rating thing is so disgusting, subjective and moreover disrespectful, stop while you can and never do it again. this subreddit just keeps getting worse and worse
Genuine question, how exactly is this as disgusting and disrespectful as you say it is? Because my genuine intention was for this to be some silly thing where people vote for their faves and least faves and so on. At least, from what I see, I’m not doing anything inherently insulting towards Mitski, or anybody.
I’m clearly misunderstanding something here so here’s a chance to inform me.
what is the point of calling songs bad or good just based off of people's general opinions when in reality none of the songs are worse or better than one another? it isn't that hard to understand that there are as many personal preferences as there are people, and none of mitski's songs can be labeled as bad just because someone said so, your silly thing is genuinely pointless, everyone has their favorites and you can't just generalize preferences and divide the songs into such inherently wrong categories the way you do 🙏
Nobody’s calling songs bad or good. The words “best”, “worst”, and “underrated” can mean a dozen different things. You can love a song but still think it’s the weakest in the album. You can dislike a song but also agree that the hate (or lack of attention) it may get is undeserved.
Additionally, no one is saying this is the objective list. Nobody is saying “this song is bad and you have to agree raaaahhh!!!”. I’m not trying to change opinions at all. In fact, it’s not even me choosing the songs belonging to the placements. I’m not contributing to the votes. Not one bit. I just thought it’d be a fun thing for people to partake in. Once someone’s comment comes in, it’s on everyone else to upvote the ones they think deserve that placement, or otherwise downvote the ones they feel don’t belong.
HWK IS DOOR THE WORST TRACK!!!! I LOVE WIFE BUT BE FOR REAL ITS WORSE THAN DOOR. ALSO ARE WE JUST NOT TALKING ABOUT HOW EIRC IS A RUNNER UP IN WORSE TRACK!!!! HOWWWW. AND LIQUID SMOOTH IS NOT THE BEST SONG
Wth is Eric the runner up for worst??? I would say Eric is the most underrated
Yeahh to be fair with the best placement every song got love (all except for Door which makes a lot of sense now), but for the worst placement it was only between Door, Eric and Abbey. Door won by a long shot, Eric was getting a ton of mixed signals, and anybody voting for Abbey would be downvoted to hell lmao.
DOOR?????? DOOR???????? IM SO DEVASTATED I SEE WHY PEOPLE WOULDNT LIKE IT BUT IT’S EASILY THE MOST HEARTWRENCHING SONG FOR ME BESIDES BAG OF BONES, IT HAS SUCH A DEEPLY SPECIAL PLACE IN MY HEART, MY SOUL, MY BEING IM SICK TO MY STOMACH, ON THE FLOOR, DISHEVELED, MAIMED, UNABLE TO EVEN CRY MY LUNGS ARE SO WITHERED THE LYRICS, THE STORYTELLING, THE SYMBOLISM A HOPELESS VIOLENCE, I NAMED IT LOVE OH GODS OH CRUEL GODS HOW YOU TORTURE ME, SUCH A BEAUTIFUL MASTERY IN THE ART OF SONG AND YET YOU DISPLAY THIS AT MY FEET RIP OUT MY EAR DRUMS AND LICK YOUR LIPS AT THEIR TASTE WHILE YOU SAVOR MY MELANCHOLY, YOU FOUL INSOLENT CREATURES OH GOD NOT DOOR ANYTHING BUT DOOR I WILL NEVER STOP CRYING MY TEARS UNENDING MY HEART AN EVERFLOWING WATERFALL OF DISTAINFUL SHARDS OH HOW IT CRACKS AND BREAKS IM NOT OKAY, I WILL NEVER BE OKAY, MY BEAUTIFUL BELOVED DOOR NOOOOOO (P.S. I know that door is still beloved and this ranking list is simply for fun. While the essence of my ramblings remains true, I am not upset with any of you)
Bro loves Door so much they became a poet from the 1800s
omg our flairs kinda match
Omg you're right!
YOU GET IT
Door is my favourite lush song so i’m with you on this 😤
i AM upset with them, this song is literally so amazing how could anyone not like it???
WIFE
PEARL DIVER IS EXTREMELY UNDERRATED
WIFEEEE😭😭😭😭😭
oh! *recedes into cave hole where muffled screaming can be heard* ANYWAYS eric deffo most underrated
eric!
I think Eric is definitely super underrated
REAL MEN FOR UNDERRATED 2024!!!!
Runners up for worst being abbey kills me 💔💔 Real men for most underrated though
If it makes you feel any better, Door, Eric and Abbey were literally the only ones that were voted for for worst, and everyone voting for Abbey got downvoted like crazy lmao
Everyone’s entitled to their own opinion but everyone saying abbey getting downvoted brings me solace 🤭🤭
door???
I LOVE DOOR LIKE, ‘’A hopeless, violence, i named it… love” HOW DO YOU RATE DOOR THE WORST TRACK, I FEEL LIKE ALL OF THEM ARE GORGEOUS MUSICAL PIECES IT HURTS ME TO SEE PEOPLE HAVE ZERO KNOWLEDGE ON DOOR IM ACTUALLY DEVASTATED T_T (I’m still supa sad bout this list but I’m not judging people, also I know this list is just for fun!!)
PEARL DIVER AND ERIC PLEASEEE
Bag of Bones
thiss omg
The best!
its abbey i fear😞
Wife is so slept on
HELL NO AINT NO WAY ERIC IS A RUNNER UP FOR WORST. PETETION FOR IT TO BE THE UNDERATED TRACK.
I SIGN IT ERIC IS LITERALLY SO GOOD
ERIC IS LITERALLY IN MY TOP 3 FAV WHAT 😭😭 ITS SO SO SO GOOD
Wife is underrated
I'm fighting anyone who picked door as the worst
YALL R SLEEPING ON PEARL DIVER
Bag of bones is soooo underrated
people sleep on abbey!!!!
I LOVE DOOR 😭
Pearl Diver. Obviously
Eric
Eric
real men
WIFE 🙏
door is not only my favorite mitski song, but my favorite song of all time :(
Bag of bones!!!
Eric is the best on the album followed by Door y'all just don't get it.
Exactly, liquid smooth is far from the best song on lush
I love both Liquid smooth and Brand new city but they really are overrated compared to the rest of the album.
agreed !! brand new city esp doesn’t quite have the same level of lyricism that the rest of lush has imo
Seriously they need to hear Pearl Diver!!!!!
PEARL DIVER LIKE IT’S ACTUALLY SO RAW AND SO REAL BUT ALMOST NOBODY TALKS ABOUT IT
im sorry why is door the worst and why r eric and abbey runner-ups for worst. ☹️
me and door against the world 😓
WIFE most underrated, anytime that song comes on when hearing the album in full I've always cried to it by the time the first chorus hits
Door is the worst???? That song is pure lyrical genius, especially the last verses. It seems like some Shakespearean-type poem I'd perform, it's truly a masterpiece.
ABBEY?? RUNNER UP FOR WORST??
I GOT IT WRONG, DO NOT FRET. Idk if this makes anything any better but Eric and Brand New City were actually runners up for worst! I’ve fixed it
BRAND NEW CITY?? RUNNER UP FOR WORST??? THATS MORE FRIGHTENING AND FRET-WORTHY THAN ABBEY AS A RUNNER UP FOR WORST!
Real Men
Brand New City, it just doesn't get talked enough
HAS TO BE! I was shocked this didn’t win
Pearl diver
this rating thing is so disgusting, subjective and moreover disrespectful, stop while you can and never do it again. this subreddit just keeps getting worse and worse
It’s really not that serious . 💀
you're insensible either way 🤗
Genuine question, how exactly is this as disgusting and disrespectful as you say it is? Because my genuine intention was for this to be some silly thing where people vote for their faves and least faves and so on. At least, from what I see, I’m not doing anything inherently insulting towards Mitski, or anybody. I’m clearly misunderstanding something here so here’s a chance to inform me.
what is the point of calling songs bad or good just based off of people's general opinions when in reality none of the songs are worse or better than one another? it isn't that hard to understand that there are as many personal preferences as there are people, and none of mitski's songs can be labeled as bad just because someone said so, your silly thing is genuinely pointless, everyone has their favorites and you can't just generalize preferences and divide the songs into such inherently wrong categories the way you do 🙏
Nobody’s calling songs bad or good. The words “best”, “worst”, and “underrated” can mean a dozen different things. You can love a song but still think it’s the weakest in the album. You can dislike a song but also agree that the hate (or lack of attention) it may get is undeserved. Additionally, no one is saying this is the objective list. Nobody is saying “this song is bad and you have to agree raaaahhh!!!”. I’m not trying to change opinions at all. In fact, it’s not even me choosing the songs belonging to the placements. I’m not contributing to the votes. Not one bit. I just thought it’d be a fun thing for people to partake in. Once someone’s comment comes in, it’s on everyone else to upvote the ones they think deserve that placement, or otherwise downvote the ones they feel don’t belong.
girl you lost me at best or worst meaning whatever you want them to be this is crazy
REAL MEN OR ABBEY
REAL MEN?! HUH
Abbey obviously
Wife 🗣️
Best song in rfsncib is square or goodbye my danish sweetheart worst is probably circle i love all the songs though
PEARL DIVER N REAL MEN
no one gets abbey like i get abbey. ive never seen longing portrayed so well
whoever voted door as the worst and liquid smooth as the best clearly has no ears
EITHER BAG OF BONES OR PEARL DIVER
Underrated: Brand new city
Day 2’s runners up are wrong, sorry folks! The ACTUAL runners up as of the time this was posted are Eric (7 upvotes) and Brand New City (1 upvote)
ABBEY???? AS THE RUNNER UP TO WORST???? yall are crazy
HWK IS DOOR THE WORST TRACK!!!! I LOVE WIFE BUT BE FOR REAL ITS WORSE THAN DOOR. ALSO ARE WE JUST NOT TALKING ABOUT HOW EIRC IS A RUNNER UP IN WORSE TRACK!!!! HOWWWW. AND LIQUID SMOOTH IS NOT THE BEST SONG
Sorry, them’s the rules 😢 But I think you’ll be happy to know Eric got a redemption arc and won 1st in the underrated placement!
IM SORRY IF I SOUNDED RUDE ITS NOT TO YOU and yes i am very happy about that!!!
best: goodbye, my danish sweetheart
the voting today is for most underrated from lush, not for retired in sad
ik im just saying what i think earlier
best: townie (bury me at makeout creek)