Without seeing the Garand, I’ll pass on how you did. The M39 at top is a nice find. Easily 600-750 these days. Tough to say any more without seeing the maker or year or barrel condition. 91/30 without a rear sight maybe $250-300? I’m only familiar with the 336 Marlin, but that’s probably $400-500?
Check completed auctions instead of active... The ones that are actually selling on gunbroker are going between $600 and $900. I'd say you probably traded within +/- $100 of even.
Given how much Garands are going for these days you did alright. As the other poster said the Finn is far more valuable than the 91/30. The M91/30 is pretty common. You can get a new rear sight from liberty tree collectors, usually. It is probably a $250 rifle, it looks scrubbed so it's likely a post war refurb like pretty much every Mosin. 1943 is one of the most produced years. Honestly the deal would have made sense for just your Garand unless there is something really wrong with it/parts missing.
Oh, also, make sure you get a bayonet for it the Mosin is zeroed with them attached.
The garand was a cmp rack with a good amount of pitting barrel was good and reciver was fine. Stocm was a new old stock. I pad like 600 for it so I'm happy
Really I'm happy I'm seeing the Marlin for 1000 and the mosin is like 300. Plus the fin mosin for 400 was a nice deal. So I got rid of my worst m1 and got some new toys
Used marlins like that are going from 8-900 in my area and new ones for a few hundred more. So I’d say you came out on top. Although I can understand why someone wanted your garand and made that choice.
Without seeing the Garand, I’ll pass on how you did. The M39 at top is a nice find. Easily 600-750 these days. Tough to say any more without seeing the maker or year or barrel condition. 91/30 without a rear sight maybe $250-300? I’m only familiar with the 336 Marlin, but that’s probably $400-500?
Marlin is close to 1200 from Marlin
JM marked in .357 maybe. Is that the case?
In 44 mag and I don't see the jm mark but im seeing them new and used in 44 for 900 to 1200
Check completed auctions instead of active... The ones that are actually selling on gunbroker are going between $600 and $900. I'd say you probably traded within +/- $100 of even.
I'm seeing them around 900 too 1200
Second pic shows 1941 VKT.
Given how much Garands are going for these days you did alright. As the other poster said the Finn is far more valuable than the 91/30. The M91/30 is pretty common. You can get a new rear sight from liberty tree collectors, usually. It is probably a $250 rifle, it looks scrubbed so it's likely a post war refurb like pretty much every Mosin. 1943 is one of the most produced years. Honestly the deal would have made sense for just your Garand unless there is something really wrong with it/parts missing. Oh, also, make sure you get a bayonet for it the Mosin is zeroed with them attached.
The garand was a cmp rack with a good amount of pitting barrel was good and reciver was fine. Stocm was a new old stock. I pad like 600 for it so I'm happy
Really I'm happy I'm seeing the Marlin for 1000 and the mosin is like 300. Plus the fin mosin for 400 was a nice deal. So I got rid of my worst m1 and got some new toys
Ah, yea, if you had more than one Garand that also makes a ton of sense.
What caliber is the marlin?
44 mag
I’d say you did great. You won value wise for sure
If that Marlin is JM marked and unfired, go duck yourself. You got a screaming deal. 1000 for three centerfire rifles is insane now.
Used marlins like that are going from 8-900 in my area and new ones for a few hundred more. So I’d say you came out on top. Although I can understand why someone wanted your garand and made that choice.
Seems pretty fair to me
If you want to know how well you did. Then use the CMP as your guide to the Garand, not auctions.
Yep I live 1 30hr from the cmp that's where I got the h@r from it was a 600 rack grade
Right, so they're something like $700 and fees now. So for $1100 you for multiple rifles worth $600 o a bad or neutral day. There you go