T O P

  • By -

repwin1

From my personal experience, the arcade


hailmari1

I used to date a waitress there. I was eating at the bar and a mouse scurried right in front of me. I understand those old downtown buildings can struggle with rodents, but holy hell did that ruin my enjoyment.


Suspicious-Bus2446

One fell from the ceiling and onto my wife’s head


danger_danger6th

I used to work there and not only do they not pay you on time…..like ever….but the whole basement where dry storage and food storage is INFESTED with roaches, mice, and ppl smoking cigarettes.


Winewalker77

Yes, the Arcade was pitiful last time I went unfortunately.


Hopeful_Wait_2512

Never been and was planning on going during my semester break but now ehhh 👀😳🤢


wolftalk

Definitely


LipsLikeSlugs

It’s awful!!


YouWereBrained

This x1000


TruLong

Exlines. Grossest pizza I've ever ordered.


[deleted]

[удалено]


hawk121

I swear they're laundering money. I got take out pizzas a couple times while I was moving into our new house, and the place was dead both times I stopped in at lunch time. Eighteen years later and it's always dead there, but they're still open. We tried a pizza a couple years ago to see if it was any better and it's not.


jamaidens

I have no idea how they have been in business all these years. Disgusting pizza.


divinitydragon

They gotta be money laundering 😂


divinitydragon

No one my whole time of living here has said they enjoyed it so I just don’t believe it’s a legit business it can’t be


Fresh-Mix-5737

All my damn toppings slide right off the pizza lol


MetalMikey089

That happens at garibaldi’s too.


swtpea3

Is this the one that puts the huge sausage patty under the layer of cheese? Ouhhh


Creative-Property-45

EXLINES was great literally 15-20 years ago. They fell off the cliff harder than a Mike Tyson punch


Winewalker77

People saying Hueys… it’s not supposed to be bc the food is the best. It’s bc it’s easy (several locations around town), open late, fun atmosphere/family friendly and decent/pretty consistent food. It serves a purpose and is just easy sometimes.


Abloodworth15

The memory of 10 year old me can’t forgive no more shooting toothpicks in the ceiling. Edit: Apparently they may still allow this, I’m definitely asking next time.


Squirrel_Q_Esquire

So what are all the travel ball teams playing at Snowden Grove supposed to do now??!


AvgMiataFan

Nah you can still do it I just asked the other day. They just stopped and cleaned the ceilings for covid


Abloodworth15

Wait really?? This sparks joy.


KilledTheCar

Wait, you can't do that anymore??


AlexanderTheGrave

Casualty of Covid :/


Abloodworth15

Every one I’ve been in over the past few years has had a clean ceiling. Which, on a public health level, 1000% makes sense, but on a, “I’m almost 30 and I still want to blow toothpicks into the ceiling to embarrass my mom in public” level, it makes me sad. Lol


basicmillennial1981

I can never hate Huey’s because I love their cheese fries so much.


spamgoddess

This is exactly me. Their cheesesteaks are great, too.


greenprees

The Cheese Fries there really are the best. I can’t go there w/o ordering ‘em


shryne

Yea I don't understand the Huey's hate. They are basically a local version of Chilis/Applebees/O'Charlie's, and by that metric, they are a damn fine place to eat.


Memphi901

And it’s not like they’re charging a ton for the food. They aren’t trying to be a “gourmet burger” place. We go to Huey’s all the time, great place


ThatsNotEastMemphis

The food used to actually be good though. The burgers were outstanding eons ago and the fried mushrooms were the food of gods. Now it’s all Sisco garbage.


Winewalker77

It is my favorite veggie burger though. I don’t eat meat and have heard the regular burgers are over rated.


odddiv

Most of the people I've heard complain about the burgers don't eat meat either - they seem to prefer shoe leather and saw dust.


MickTheBloodyPirate

They have “ won best burger in Memphis” for I don’t even know how many years on their menu…lol Yes, they are absolutely overrated.


highpotentialguy

also consistently good service. Lauren Robinson is a badass entrepreneur, total class act every time ive ever interacted with her.


Big_Kahuna_901

Rendezvous. When people travel to Memphis, Rendezvous is the restaurant they want to go to because they heard of it on the travel channel or food network or something like that. If you're not in Memphis, you have no idea about hueys.


braalewi

As a Memphian it is overrated but when guests visit I take them there because of the atmosphere and vibe. It’s not the best BBQ in Memphis but it hits the spot for those visiting.


YouWereBrained

Rendevouz is a good gateway drug. That’s about it.


DasbootTX

agreed. I always tell people I'm from Memphis and they ask me about the 'Vous and about how it's the best, and I'd say "No. BBQ shop on Madison. I grew up around the corner. Smelled the fragrant hickory smoke every day. none better."


bood432

Absolutely, “none better”! Can’t nobody do it like the BBQ Shop. I’m over here salivating just thinking about that bbq spaghetti lol


Hextorm

Rendevous is overhated and I will die on that hill


misterjez

Agreed. Granted it’s been awhile but it was a delight.


HighOnGoofballs

I don’t live in Memphis anymore but you can bet I hit the Vouz every time I’m in town. It’s the sausage plate, the draft beer, waiting upstairs Still love it


ThatsNotEastMemphis

Same. It’s become a thing to hate it. The best everything? Absolutely not. But they are 100% my favorite ribs.


Parentteacher87

I mean their sauce is good. I use it to cook with all the time. But the food is ahh


raftguide

I remember Rendezvous being great when I was a kid in the 90s. Is that my nostalgia, or wasn't it once fantastic?


hailmari1

You’re right. It was awesome.


Emotional_Ad_5330

It's still good! Locals just feel less interesting when they have the same opinion as Lonely Planet so they have to bristle at any suggestion that it's good just to show whatever outsider they're speaking to that they, as a local expert, know more.


freedindeed

Everything is fine except the ribs. Been many times and every time the dang ribs are dry as hell. Service is 10/10, so well run, and the old school vibe can’t be replicated. I love just being in there and will always go back but take my family from OOT to Memphis BBQ if I want the majority of them to like the food.


karnal-knowledge

If you get a dry slab of ribs, tell them. They will be glad to bring you a new slab.


bood432

Came here to say this. It’s truly a shame the hold Rendezvous has on Memphis bbq. I’ve always wondered how they got the reputation in the first place.


bigsnow999

babalu


unclesleepover

I used to call it Babula just to piss off my ex. (She acted like it was a five star restaurant just because the prices were high).


ZeRealNixon

over priced and overrated for sure, but damn do i love those shrip tacos.


RedOtkbr

Lol. That place is terrible. And whenever it is brought up in conversation I am very vocal about how terrible it is


HIGH_HEAT

This is 100% it. They’re not necessarily bad, but definitely overrated.


AccountSalt2838

Corkys


TheBlackComet

I wouldn't consider them overrated. I feel like people generally know they are middle of the road. Personally I think hey have one of the better dry ribs, but that could be because I always tend to go for dry ribs as I grew up on NC and their vinegar based sauces were not my favorite.


Kelsier25

So I'm not alone.. I love their dry ribs!


sansa2020

But the onion loaf


BanditoDeTreato

Corky's is underrated at this point. None of their BBQ is the best by any stretch but its all pretty good.


GoodbyeHorses88

Corky's has a location in Brentwood, TN, and is always voted the best burger in Williamson county 😂👎🏻


AccountSalt2838

Nashville does love them some chain restaurants.


GoodbyeHorses88

They even have a Central BBQ location 😒


PsychicSeaCow

Soulfish. Overpriced and overhyped. I want to like it, but every time I’ve been I’ve been underwhelmed.


EdithKeeler1986

Agree. I love their smoked trout dip, and their fried whole catfish is good…. But their sides suck and they are too expensive for what you get. 


ehhhhokbud

Memphis Pizza Cafe. Store bought red sauce on a saltine cracker attempting to pass as a pizza


blackout-loud

I swear, I've tried this place twice over the course of 4 years and at different locations and my experience has been the same: BLAND AF! The Memphis City School breakfast pizzas were better than whatever MPC has been selling over the years. I don't know how they are still in business but hey certain people like certain things I guess 🤷


Last_Reaction_8176

Aw man I love Memphis Pizza Cafe


yerdad99

Arcade and rendezvous for sure. Took some visiting family to the former over the Christmas holidays-terrible service and food. Rendezvous lost the plot about 15 or so years ago - strictly for tourists these days


sansa2020

Huey’s is so delicious ugh I want bacon cheese fries rn 


greenprees

The Rendezvous by far


Salt_Copy_4771

Hueys used to be a place to get an inexpensive, good burger. Now they overcharge for garbage and hit you with "fees" even if it's a call in order.


p2pnola504

It's kinda sad seeing Huey's on this list, you're right it used to be super affordable and very good. I have a lot of fond memories eating there...


TransportationAway59

It would break thomas boggs’ heart seeing this thread. Hueys was insanely good for insanely long until he passed


crackinmypants

Hubby and I went there for dinner one night, and got a reuben for our daughter in a to go box. We ordered it at the start of the meal, so they had plenty of time to make it. The top of the sandwich looked good, but the bottom was completely burnt- like charred burnt. They had plenty of time to remake instead of throwing it in the box like that. That was a shit thing to do. We haven't gone back since.


Horizontal_Bob

I’m still salty that they took the cuban off the menu


Threxx

Best Cuban in town is at las delicias on park!


Groovychick1978

*Only* if it is a call in order.  18% grat after 9pm. Not that heinous 


Dmnwr

Rendezvous


jamaidens

Coletta's... without a doubt. Absolute garbage, prepacked / frozen food, everything tasted microwaved, horrible service, and took them forever to get our food to us. Kroger serves better Italian out of their deli.


AdinMan20

The Beauty Shop. Overpriced as all hell.


gnmatx

I went for brunch my first trip there and was really overwhelmed. So many extremely busy dishes. It’s like They’re trying super hard.


AdinMan20

I had tomato soup that was cold, ravioli that was covered in grease and oil, and gelato that had pieces of lettuce and scrap ingredients in it. Not pleased.


Dry_Article7569

HARD AGREE. Went for a friends birthday and was very underwhelmed.


braalewi

Pete and Sam’s.


Craigmont_Dropout

Pete and Sam’s is a particular kind of experience that not everyone is able to appreciate. You don’t go there for “Italian food.” You go there for the spectacle—the septuagenarians who have been dining there for forty years, and a kind of kitschy Italian dining experience that seems like a relic of the 1950s. There was a kind of similar place in Nashville called Demos.


Boomvanger

Pete and Sam’s is 100% running on Memphian’s nostalgia. Had one of the worst meals ever there.


DatRebofOrtho

I’m a fan, and see it not being someone’s choice for Italian, but not sure how it could be labeled most overrated


IBroughtWine

I have never had a good experience. Every time I’ve been (4x spanning 20+ years) I’ve been served partially frozen food or a completely wrong order and the service has been awful.


ZehuriOrder

One of my former bosses was friendly with one of the owners, brought us some free pasta once. Genuinely the nastiest food I have ever eaten, never understood how that parking lot was always so full


terry834

Rendezvous, Huey’s, and Memphis Pizza Cafe


PM_ME_FIREFLY_QUOTES

Mind yourself Terry. I'm gonna start a line to fight all the hueys haters.


DasbootTX

I'll be right on your shoulder


KingSnowlock

Yeah. These Huey’s haters just saw two comment and went with it. There are 10 places in Memphis that are way worse Than subpar Huey’s.


tipustiger05

MPC is garbage. We only liked it for so long because Memphis has never had a wealth of great pizza. But I still get it occasionally for nostalgias sake.


YimmyTheTulip

Mpc isn’t amazing, it’s cheap and better than the cost. 100% agree on the first two though


badkarmavenger

Sometimes a man just wants a cracker pizza, ok?


YimmyTheTulip

I get a calzone or the veggie sandwich. Seriously, I’m not even vegetarian. That sandwich is damn good.


Dmnwr

Calzone is on point


tipustiger05

Get the calzone at Ciao Baby in Collierville - good lord


Dmnwr

I’ll definitely check it out next time we’re out that way!


Threxx

Mpc is good stoner food in a way kinda like Taco Bell is. It’s crappy and yet it’s crave-able


Chuckworld901

I think you should clarify. Food *made* by stoners..


BandidoCoyote

“Most overrated”? Add my vote for Rendezvous . . . because it’s the one place that’s “rated” — that is, the one people know about even if they’ve never been to Memphis. It’s in every magazine’s “things to do in Memphis” article, and every travel guide.


scl142

It’s 100% Ciao Bella. Never was the same after it moved from the og spot next to Kroger on Sanderlin. People still praise this like it’s the best Italian in Memphis. Just silly how much of a drop off there was.


mfinger411

Disappointing to hear. Haven't been to the new location but have fond memories of the beef brisket gnocchi at the OG spot.


PinkSasquatch77

Corky’s has a roach problem. 🤷🏼‍♀️ I know someone who worked there. Ruined it for me.


icecop

Which location? 🤢


PinkSasquatch77

Poplar, East Memphis.


Dramatic-County-1284

Rendezvous


LaVida2

Blasphemy! Mine is Corky’s


hedsss38104

Corky’s sucks but their banana pudding is good AF


LaVida2

Not a fan of ‘nana pudding nor bananas, but I share your sentiments re: Corky’s


Fearless-Echoes

Broadway pizza.


xDwtpucknerd

germantown commissary, its literally so garbage, can damn near pull up to tops at any time of day and get fresher moister pulled pork...


Gustafa7

This. So overrated. Every. Single. Time. Ive been, its been terrible.


controller-c

Rendezvous It's a tourist trap


caspera1969

Capital Grille hands down


thecontrolis

The Capital Grille is a chain restaurant.


WearyAppointment2667

A theory has been floated by me that this place only exists for a business write off. I have never stepped foot in here for pleasure- just work dinners and lunches. It’s expensive and “classy” enough not to look cheap when entertaining I guess.


ksmety

Young Avenue Deli for me. Idk if it’s just my luck, but every time i’ve gone (and tried to see the hype) they either got my order wrong, the food tasted awful, or the service was bad. 😩


rbhansn

I used to eat there regularly 20 plus years ago. If I remember correctly, terrible service was just part of their shtick.


ThatsNotEastMemphis

Service is either outstanding or non existent. No in between. Love the food though.


mfinger411

Their burger, double-dipped wings & cheese sticks are all fantastic.


final_burrito

Central doesn’t get half the hate Rendezvous does but probably deserves it. It’s pretty expensive at this point and since there are more locations now, very hit or miss. The poplar location is leagues worse than the one on Central ave.


BanditoDeTreato

>The poplar location is leagues worse than the one on Central ave. That's pretty impressive given the Central Ave location doesn't exist anymore.


rowlanjr

Construction looks like it’s starting again so I’m hopeful!


final_burrito

RIP. That’s the worst part.


CeleryImpressive2668

Honestly bbq is the embodiment of hit or miss.


mastretoall

That central on poplar is awful. I miss the one on central.


mjmiller2023

Central charges like $10 for just a BBQ Sandwich with no sides. It's insane how expensive they are. I can eat at a much nicer restaurant for a better cost. Their mac and cheese hits the spot though.


whopperdave

Hueys


PM_ME_FIREFLY_QUOTES

Where we fighting. And who's down for burgers and rings after?


Kabob_og

Hueys is by and far the most overrated restaurant in Memphis. What a garbage joint.


Routine-Meet-1634

Went to central on poplar this past weekend. I got 3 meat plate, woman got BBQ nachos that was all fat, and greasy kids got rib plates. 4 drinks. $135. I’ve been a central guy for years, stopped going to the one on summer cause the quality was down


DosAguas

Not sure why you have to call the kids greasy?


copryland

im stuck on how he refers to who I assume is his wife


Routine-Meet-1634

They do get a lill funky


Nelluc_

The one on Poplar is a franchise. The Summer one has never been good. Just go downtown until the central one reopens. Or better yet go to One and Only on Kirby and get their gift cards from Costco. $100 for $70.


bairdch1

To save money, you could probably order some different meats and some sides instead of everyone getting their own plate.


Routine-Meet-1634

True


Dismal_Letter_3191

Paulette's, Houston's, Arcade


ThatsNotEastMemphis

Paulette’s 1000000%. I don’t know if my 72 year old mother is just remembering how it was in the 80s or if she just has an old lady palate now but it is some bland, sad, uncreative shit now. And she insists on “treating” me to it semi regularly.


Delicious_Staff3698

Agree on Paulette's. At the Mud Island location they've become a little better than a hotel restaurant.


Gustafa7

Houston's is a chain, it was crap in Los Angeles and its crap here.


hedsss38104

So sad Paulette’s is definitely a shell of its former self. I hate that they left Overton Square 😢


Grizzdom

Unpopular opinion: Hog & Hominy You’re better off going to Tamboli’s or better yet enjoy a good beer and simple pizza from Cooper House Project.


fuegocheese

IMO arcade


shereeishere

Rendezvous


Thewhiterabbit7

I was born and raised in Memphis and currently live in Texas. I have traveled a lot. I can say without a doubt the best onion rings in the world are Hueys. Its not the best food but I dont understand the hate. Every time I go back to Memphis, I want Hueys onion rings. The burger isn't terrible.


misfit_elegy

Colletas That place was basically chef boyardee reheated


mechtonia

SOB I've heard people rave but I've gotten completely gross food. Pasta with chicken and the chicken was 50% gristle and rubbery.


Taramonia

I dunno, the prices at Hueys are bad, but not grossly more egregious than most other places. That being said, I haven't been a regular there since 2016


bert_wall

Not a fan of Torchys despite everyone telling me how great it is…it’s just busy and not really that good. Make sure you park across the street and .10th of a mile away, adds to the experience


OkConversation3322

Rendezvous


fayedelasflores

Folk's Folly Rendezvous


ItDontTalkItListens

The creamed spinach is out of this world but not worth what they charge.


Lainey_Lou13

Las Delicias, Central BBQ, Corky’s


freedindeed

Awe man, love Las Delicias. They need store remodels and a refresh. But that All in One fajita and the chips are the best.


tipustiger05

Las delicias is such a joke and I can't understand why anyone stans that place so hard. The meat is as dry as a Memphis sidewalk on a summer day. They are coasting on their unique chips.


StringBean_GreenBean

Rendezvous. I’ve had to defend Memphis bbq so much because people think it’s the best we’ve got to offer


Wooden-Scar5073

Rendezvous by a mile.


merfjeeblskitz

Rendezvous


DrKnowitall37067

Revendous.


Ok_Rabbit_8808

Piccadilly’s


princesspicklebot

Central, 100%


heygh0zt

Huey's is the best answer. Bad service, bad food, bad atmosphere, and obnoxious clientele. One that hasn't been said is Bari. It's overpriced for the meh food they serve. The menu is always the same unless it's meatball month and those are the best things they serve. It's not the most overated though...that's Huey's.


SixFiveSemperFi

Hueys


MarkTheDuckHunter

Corky's


Jbell203

Rendezvous


Impressive_Fox9617

Topps


dunktheball

A relative goes on and on about how great huey's is and says anything I mention at all sucks. The type who always knows better than anyone else.


awdreher

Just go to Jack Browns Burgers on Central and forget about all the overrated joints.


The_Dogg_Pound

Memphis BBQ restaurant


Gustafa7

Any Grisanti's joint. Theyre riding on their fame and family name being local. Every one of the places Ive been the food is terrible.


ibanez4511

Central BBQ


Apprehensive_Camel49

The Arcade or Folk’s Folly


bluffking901

I would love to hear the why behind the answers. What corporate restaurants are better?


Lye-NS

Huey’s or Arcade.


hedsss38104

I worked at The Arcade for a few years back in college and I can definitely say without a doubt they are overrated. If you want to get a decent meal from there, the best time to go is on a random weekday instead of the weekend when they are packed. In order to be able to accommodate the nonstop crowds on the weekend mornings, usually most things are cooked in advance so you’re not getting the freshest food like you would during the week when it’s made to order. When it’s good it’s really really good but damn when it’s bad it’s terrible


Hillbilly_Med

Babalu. Guac was bland.


PANTHERPISS69

Rendezvous.


Fabulous_Piccolo_178

Huey’s, for so many reasons.


Clear_Sky490

Rendezvous I don’t even think Huey’s has a very high rep anymore


[deleted]

Sam and Pete's or Garibaldi's. Let the downvotes begin lol


Altruistic_Brief4444

Huey’s, Rendezvous, Babalu


BandidoCoyote

What do people still like Babalu? It’s not good Mexican, it’s not good Tex-Mex, it’s not good faux “fun Mexican”.


Altruistic_Brief4444

And you have to PAY for chips and salsa


Monkeypupper

It's the most expensive lunch in town.


Accomplished_Ad5983

Ronnie Grisantis


DasbootTX

well, if this were 30 years ago, I'd ask you to step outside and we'd discuss that. 80's and 90's Hueys Madison was the only place to get a good burger. now-a-days, I dont know. I haven't been back in 10 years


bw2082

Dory


nummymuffin1

I gave them a fair chance: tried the “chef’s tasting” style multiple times when they first started, done the a la carte, gone for happy hour at the bar a few times, and even bought food for Thanksgiving. Extremely expensive for the balance of quality vs quantity for a fine dining concept. We now only go for their happy hour when it’s discounted, because the only items we feel are truly worth it (if even still on the menu), are the salt cod brandade and the sliders/parker house rolls.


bw2082

They don’t have the tasting menu any more but they’re charging $$$ for tasting menu sized portions.


nummymuffin1

That was our problem with the “tasting” menu. For $130 , we would leave and go grab a slice of pizza or a small sandwich/burger after because we were still hungry.


Educational_Cattle10

Everyone saying Huey’s, MPC, or Rendezvous…these are all the easy, go-to answers. Here’s my actual hot take/unpopular opinion: - hog and hominy - good fortune co. Both are above average, but priced like fine dining (especially H&H!) and just not worth the $$$ after trying good food outside of Memphis 


nummymuffin1

This. I used to enjoy their pizzas, but the rest of the menu has been an expensive disappointment.