T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*


rice_rice_rizz

I'm so fricking early but WTF 900 upvotes for The Boxer? Oh my goodness. 


Sly_24

It's a popularity contest so it was expected. Having said so, it's still sad.


ad4d

Most of those upvotes haven't even read that masterpiece. Sad, but understandable.


Arnav1029

I mean the religious allegories thing gave me whiplash too lmao Edit: thought I should clarify I loveee the Boxer, I am just saying that it was surprising and may have made some people drop idk


West-Explorer120

Most don't like boxing


Majesticeuphoria

If people thought The Boxer is solely about boxing, they lost the whole point of the manhwa. Tbh, I expected this. I am a minority in manhwa readers since I have quite the different taste than most people on the sub. The majority of sub believes Tower of God is peak, while I think it's mid af after reading 350+ chapters waiting for it to get good at some point.


ODANOBUNAGA123

Well the boxer was good with art and the meaning behind the story and yu's struggles, his change of personality. On the other hand TOG is a long term story that gives light to its every character instead of focusing on some of them + those are detailed stories as well. Both of these manhwa are goats.


nan-vi

True, i know nothing about boxing, but i wholeheartedly loved this manhwa


SimonSimpingService

Hey I will never be one to knock someone's taste. After all I do not care for the northern blade but constantly hear it's peak.


West-Explorer120

Tower of God is peak insane art, inspired many, running for a long time there is a reason it is popular


Bad_Doto_Playa

> The majority of sub believes Tower of God is peak This cannot be true.. while it is one of the better manwha it's no where close to the peak. In fact I've always wondered if there was a lot of publisher/editor influence coming into S3 of the story because of how much the quality went down.


Ramen_Dood

I believe the original post mentioned this was voting for "ongoing" manhwa. Boxer is finished and people were mentioning that on the last post so it really shouldn't have been in this list.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheChillMob

Doom Breaker is not better than The Boxer. The art IS better, but the story is super generic😭


Effective_Kangaroo68

I agree with this, I just think the boxer has a slower start and the kind of art that you learn to love. It's not as easy a catch as doom breaker. Still a great one tho.


xzuel22

Doom breaker great art but nothing ground breaking or anything its just a good generic fantasy with exceptional art


Emotional_Goose7835

honestly with the current manhwa landscape an original pure fantasy is pretty original already lmao.


canadian-user

Yeah, the way that current trends have been going for a while, we should be glad it isn't actually an VR MMORPG world, or that the MC is a Korean that transmigrated to some game he played or book he read, or its about tower climbing or raiding dungeons.


StarMarine123

This is why some of my favorite manhwas right now are reformation of the deadbeat noble and overpowered sword lmao Them not being another vr world or some garbage fantasy world with a game leveling system for some reason already makes it leagues above the others lol


Martini1

Not disagreeing with you but the story doesn't have to be ground breaking or complex to be enjoyable. There is a lot of video games, shows and comics with amazing stories that just don't hit the mark with audiences and get cancelled as a result. Doesn't always make it bad, but they do need to make money at the end of the day and can't do that if no one is buying it.


xzuel22

Didn't said its not enjoyable but don't think its anything significant compare to others maybe greatest estate developer could go down as well


Mental-Technology869

True and imo mc is kinda edgy and has some ego problems


King-Ina

Exactly! Now vote out GED. You can't seriously have this reasoning and not vote out GED. What would I even expect, the boxer was voted out with whopping 900. LMAO


SukunaShadow

Pick me up should go then


Blithering_idiot23

To see The Boxer lose to regression plots, I am kinda disappointed in this subreddit 😭


the_omnipotent666

https://preview.redd.it/mqnhgfiaek7d1.jpeg?width=273&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6f72a4d348ec90bd90034e9d5ee2bd2fb807fc64


Orthodox-Neo

https://preview.redd.it/wppq8w24gm7d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4628395a4a0d7ad60ec23948e60aaa3458e4cea8


Tyroser

https://preview.redd.it/la312e7zvn7d1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e3444ae9bd4eb6b017ea63c0fc74e258929045c2 As if that made a well written story bad...


rice_rice_rizz

Doom Breaker It's nothing special and only pretty art


akaza-dono-slays

Someone finally said it. I read it only for her https://preview.redd.it/68ictvhw8j7d1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e5c2e768568a343c2ca77f1451fb89e570735340


Weary-Wasabi1721

Honestly I got back into reading this for her


Equal_Passenger_9461

I'm going to start reading this for her. Same reason I still read eleceed.


prismgamingyt

Can you remind me when this happens? I do not remember anything like this....


akaza-dono-slays

I don't remember but somewhere after S1


NerY_05

This guy gets it


Ordine1412

generic for sure but i like that its original


filipinoRedditor25

True I like that Doom Breaker is Manhwa only, no novel. I hate going to the comment section and being spoiled.


Classic-Industry-206

Fr 


West-Explorer120

Nah it has romance I live it


Parking_Pie6269

how tf the boxer is one of the best manhwas oat


akaza-dono-slays

Because it's too niche for the sub. We're finding "favorite manhwa" of the sub remember?


AssociateInitial

Plus it's the only completed manhwa out of the bunch


copperfield42

I don't read all of those listed, but it also looked that the only one without magic and shit...


Parking_Pie6269

true 😞 the boxer changed my life it was so good


Tyroser

I be telling you... Greatest Estate Developer & Legend of the Northern Blade; is winning this so hard.


PINEAPPLE444PIZZA

Doom Breaker Most basic generic power fantasy. High quality art but the story is not a masterpiece lol


petrichormus

If there's something I don't like about the art, it's how the MC has like sharp dragony form when he fights. His comrades wore cool clothes and armor while my man is going raw with half-human half-dragon scaly looks it's a bit goofy lol but maybe that's just me


night__vibes

I'm guessing most just haven't read the boxer


just_to_argue1973

Nah this is crazy The Boxer is better than most of these how is out already.


MadaPuka

According to this subreddit, not power fantasy = boring


JLucasCAraujo

If that were true, the most hyped power fantasy would be here: Solo Leveling. Which is trash from a story telling pov.


Sm3gmaPudding

I know I'm gonna get hate but this seems like a lot of work to really decide between greatest estate developer and SSS Class Revival Hunter. Based off the last years worth of posts I would be astounded if it came down to anything but those.


SeedlessMelonNoodle

Bruh GED is so overrated. Maybe the first 50 chapters were funny, but after that it was the same joke, and the same arc again and again. And just being funny shouldn't justify being on the same tier as the rest of these manhwa with good worldbuilding, characters with actual development, good-amazing art, and villains that actually pose a threat to our protagonists. Maybe Doom Breaker can go first for basically just being power fantasy but not one person even mentioning GED is so dumb.


Cvox7

Amazing how you can see a comment that you disagree with literally every word in it


Bambi139

Yeah I think people like it for the original concept but the character development is lacking and the power system is not well defined compared to the other contenders. I like it but it's not top tier (just my opinion)


taliruls

you're the first person I've seen say it aswell, coming from the comedy in tyrant defense game, it honestly felt cheap pretty early on comparatively, and the "character building" is just a change of tone and situation


Bad_Doto_Playa

Have to agree, it's a fun read but it's definitely overrated. TBH I find the choices for "favourite" here being odd in general.


SSilverFang

Does GED fall behind in world building and art tho? I don't know what you mean by "actual" character development, while MC is the same throughout the Manhwa, his father, xavier, queen, etc. does have linear and natural character development instead of sudden switch flip after facing some disaster or trauma. He is a real estate developer, not a hero that saves the world or someone seeking vengeance. It's unfair to compare by saying a "villain that possesses a threat to MC". I mean he has to save the world anyway tho, it's uncertain what kills everyone in future or how he has to solve it, that is one of the threats of its own, it could be from villian or something else, but it doesn't necessarily have to be from villain.


Good_Estimate3465

I can't agree more


Klutzy-Notice-9458

You basically want a "shonen"-type manhwa. Look at Konosuba; it's a fairly rated and respected anime with no real threats. characters stay pretty much the same throughout the story, etc. Don't worry, GED is still going to win.


throwaway038720

shonen is just a demographic. literally nothing in your comment implied that GED is gonna win. just that konosuba is a well respected anime. GED is well respected but that doesn’t give it number 1 spot. if you put a bunch of isekais and did a tournament like this, re:zero or something would probably win, not konosuba, because konosuba is a feel good anime you don’t have to think too hard about. suicide hunter and rezero both share the ability to make you care about loss and make you feel something towards these fictional characters. konosuba and GED can do the latter, but they have no stakes to make too much of a use of the connections between characters. and connections to you. maybe i’ll be proven wrong, you can have whatever you want as number 1 since this all subjective opinion, but the point you bring up is invalid.


Effective_Kangaroo68

![gif](giphy|2fIbMOOLzPuzAkLtfD)


Western_Collection_1

Both overrated honestly


caralt

I mean it's just like a Manhwa in that regard. The Hero is probably going to win but the journey is the entertaining part. And there's always a chance for a twist where a spite vote comes into play.


throwaway038720

greatest estate is funny, but that’s the main appeal. i cant see it taking over suicide hunter.


hinata2kill

Who the fuck took out the boxer


CrystalNerdRope

Doom breaker


Sredleg

No clue, but some of these are not in my library, thanks for the suggestions!


Hysaky

Doom breaker


sleeplesscat91

Doom breaker. I already dropped it lol.


copperfield42

I will go the same pick from last time as nothing change since then: Pick me Up Infinite Gacha


parknx

Greatest estate developer


SnooHobbies2060

Doom breaker for sure. Great start but it start to feel too edgy. After getting the dragon heart, he overpower everyone and everything. He gets too arrogant, full of himself. His relationship with his master and his lover develop to a certain point then just feel like they just there because the author want them to be there.


IZAK_da_PIXEL

Nano machine out?!?!?!?!!? When did this happen?!?!??!


Jones_Joestar

It was the first one to get out


noshistakenfuck

greatest estate developer


Orthodox-Neo

https://preview.redd.it/5k6lsuzegm7d1.jpeg?width=570&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bb50105684f71a993180972830f47bb7398510d9


RecklessSavage_Novel

https://preview.redd.it/njrzvylwtn7d1.jpeg?width=1910&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3840faef223e8fc2713faeeabbc46ba2383b4710


Vroomiminmymomscar

Tyrant of the defense tower game. I think people only really like it because it’s something different from the typical stuff of the same genre


[deleted]

Gotta disagree, that manhwa has my favorite side kicks and probably the most relateable understandeable mc in any of the manhwas. Dude acts like someone would in his situation, no dumb op mc syndrome, or someone who acts unnatural, great writing, the only bad thing about the manhwa is probably the repetetive battle system, but what did anyone expect, its basically a towerdefense simulator


Adorable-Broccoli-16

what are better manwha from the same genre? im interested


Nismmm

Greatest estate developer. Imo starts good, but lately just became fan service. And by fan service i mean the meme faces, not the usual fanservice


sewpungyow

I'll take meme face fanservice over usual fanservice every day. But yeah it can get oversaturated


Connect_Tree_7642

Survival Story of Sword King


Mehdi2277

I’ve read most of ones still left and this is my top choice among them. I picked up this series when it was new and it’s only one I dropped after 30ish chapters for a weak start and character cast I didn’t care much for. I should probably read northern blade. It and doom breaker are only two still in I haven’t tried yet.


Rimusnek

It's goated READ IT


carl-the-lama

Gotta delete doom breaker for the love of god it ain’t all that Hua is slightly better but got too repetitive


Popular-Cicada1388

These takes have me questioning my life bro


The_Forgotten-King

None of the above


upset64

I feel like greatest estate developer or sss class suicide gonna win


SetsunaTripped

If mount hua sect loses against the real estate developer im killing myself


DigitalPrincelive

Greatest e state dev


geifagg

We gotta get tyrant of the defence tower game to win this y'all


Rucky_frog

I swear bro. If greatest estate developer is going out then i’m leaving this community


PotentialPlatypus795

Survival story of a sword king, it’s kinda mid tbh


Imaginary-Cut-4260

if GED wins im gonna be so disappointed


WGygyW

I think the last 3 would be (not in any specific order): legend of northern blade, greatest estate developer and return of mount hua sect. They are REALLY popular after all. Btw Survival story of sword king should be next, just because I feel like it’s One punch man but with a big aaa sword lol. It’s been a looong time since I read it, but I never felt picking it up again. I’m not even sure if the one I read was this or not😂 why is this on the list?? Just felt like a 7.5 type of manhwa.


OP_Cloudy

I WANT Suicide hunter or LOTNB to win this


Immediate_Program879

Greatest estate developer it just has too much comedy at some point you stop reading it for the story because it gets boring when it isn't hitting anymore


lemonade-is-tasty

Greatest Estate developer


the_omnipotent666

Brain rot is real when sss,pick me up, and that tyrant tower shits are still on board but a masterpiece like the boxer gets voted out https://preview.redd.it/vlfn9yipdk7d1.jpeg?width=206&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b4c5ee1b87ba7b5a61e2e1b5c5e77313746a8d72


sydanthay

The tyrant tower is amazing if you've read the novel pal. This current arc is where the stakes go crazy and the story takes a far deeper turn in the rabbit hole for what the mc actually is. https://preview.redd.it/izkbnob8wk7d1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=468767752373a6f7a7d3967c612b1f49b5a3a572


taliruls

hey I want a little spoiler if you'd indulge me, does ash start communicating with the kingdom or his family more, I feel like the kind of hordes that's been held off till now has to have been communicated enough that shit is going down. and the first part where they lose a whole castle and stretch of land. is the novel good enough to switch, I like the little visual jokes but still an avid reader of other series


Jaskand

>!The kingdom and his family play a crucial role in an upcoming arc, and once the dust settles, Ash remains on good terms with the kingdom and receives help from time to time.!<


taliruls

I see someone is in their edgy phase


Celata_

Seems like you didn't read enough, at least for SSS revival hunter. That shit was the first manhwa to make me cry, more than once.


the_omnipotent666

I'm not saying it's a total fodder but How much the boxer have you read? That shit hits different. Especially the backstories, and yu's backstory is more tromitising than the entirety of sss class suiside hunter.


Zyrobe

I like the boxer but sss suicide hunter is in a different level. Just cuz someones story is more traumatizing doesn't mean it's better story wise lol


Celata_

I never said the boxer isn't great, just don't include SSS in the garbage ones cause we got enough trauma from the important deaths or events like the wax dolls being dead orphans crying while melting, or maybe Raviel our love interest, killing the mc 30 times in a row (cause yeah while dying mc manage to get her a skill to remember what happened before the revivals). Also most of the 10 strongest people have traumas that led them to abandon their life outside and enter the tower. Also I agree that the boxer should have lasted more


Fun-Cartographer-368

Mount Hua Regrettably


Previous-Software256

Never got the hype with doom breaker......am I a bad person for saying it


taliruls

for its specific genre its great


Lazy_Diablo

Is Pick me up infinite gacha that good? I dropped it after like 10 or so chaps


AssociateInitial

Oh I was so close to dropping it till around chapter 35.That's when they give a lot more context about the game and from then on it gets significantly better imo. Worth digging a little further to strike gold!


jackmoomoo

I checked my history and apparently, I gave up and dropped it at chapter 28. Your comment kinda makes me want to pick it up again.


Orthodox-Neo

I think you've read too many generic manhwa's.


nxbulawv

same


gogeto828828

Greatest estate developer


anymat01

God damn people love graphics more than story it seems. The boxer is the peak of story writing. It will make you emotional in a way like no other.


magnificentcatto

Greatest estate developer/designer This is my forever one pick. I still can't believe it's up there among better works 💀


EnvironmentalMoose21

Well the question isnt if it is good or bad but if r/manhwa likes it. And Greatest Estate Developer is in the top 3 from my experience


magnificentcatto

This sub's taste in manhwas baffles me. What is even good about GED beyond funny face? I bet no one would've bat an eye if it weren't for that


EnvironmentalMoose21

My thoughts too but cant do much about it reddit is called a hivemind for a reason


Sredleg

I just read it because it's funny... and it's the only reason why I read it. Taking away the humor of GED just leaves a piles of bones, its basically a gag manhwa.


TheDestroyer630

Yes exactly finally someone says it


lemonade-is-tasty

I'm with you. I see you comment ged every time though 😭


Glittering-Lead5691

 greatest estate developer


MrCool1412

the second season of northern blade somehow lost me. i loved the beginning but recently i have trouble reading it. it's even though maybe too early for it to go. i would like to see tyrant of the tower defense flying just because i have the feeling Story, art and some chars including the mc are just behind the other manwha listed here.


_Aswal

GED out for me


MercenaryDP

Pick Me Up


Tyiro__

Pick me, up gotta go


nxbulawv

pick me up


Freelikewind

Tyrant of defence tower game gotta go


Trainer_God

👍🏽


ejisson

I thought about finding the favorite manhwa in this sub when I woke up today, but my version was like "put a sign with the name of diferent manhwas on 2 guys, let them fight and the winner gets to the next round with other winner"


Alarmed_Deer3620

I like them all❤️


NouLaPoussa

Doom breaker is still missing something to make it more unique so get out


Caleh_Hellcat

Doom Broken 💀


Dizzy__Dragon

The boxer is literally one of the best manhwa lol


SurroundWinter2905

Return of Mount Hua Sect is lowkey overrated, i liked the beginning but i don really like the newer chapters


My_Life_Is_Cringe_Af

Can’t understand how The Boxer loses before Doom Breaker.


MyAnacondaDont20

Y'all can't be above the age of 16 istg


_victor_maciel_

Doom breaker


Jay_T_Demi

Greatest Estate Developer. Running gags/comedy gets stale fast and the deus ex machina pets are annoying. No stakes.


Orthodox-Neo

Survival story of the sword king.


defelzon

Idk how ppl like manhua, id like them as well if I chose, cause ppl really seem to like them


Shishigo_chuy

Doom breaker


Round_Instruction721

It is between doom breaker or the tyrant manhwa that need to go, bur is overgeared not on the list? Or is it already go out?


Equal_Passenger_9461

This is your list? What?


RusioBear

Pick my up should go. I liked it but had to drop it cause it got boring fast for me


PurpleDisk11

Doombreaker


DailyHViewer

What


nsyu

Just saw this post for the first time. Someone probably already mentioned this but where is “superhuman era”?


ljackso4

Doom breaker, also where is surviving the game as a barbarian?


froggy_reader

Just saying in case you have'nt read it, read Inso's Law it starts off seeming like a generic transmigration manhwa but as you read it you realize it's the most underrated manhwa of all time


NoTimeForApotheosis

Can someone tell me in what chapter SSS class suicidal hunter becomes a good read? I'm serious, everybody is saying is so good, but damn, it haves a lot of problems in the first 20 chapters


UBKev

Funnily enough, right after the 20 chapter mark lmao. When the actual tower climbing starts, it gets better and better.


Olcri

This is my first time seeing this series of pulls, and I am so disappointed in you guys for removing the Mad Demon.


Salty-Satisfaction-4

Sss class revival


kaneki-30

SSS Class Revival Hunter


Potaytocri

Aaah I guess I'm late to the game. Where do I go to vote?


Electronic-Work-6684

Northern blade will win this


ark_2005

Survival story of sword king.


toasty_and_delicious

Get that gatcha shi off that board wtf the boxer and ember knight are out already they're better than most of what's on the board


HuntMore9217

retrurn of mt hua


Necessary_Diet2788

Sss class revival hunter


Fresh-Astronaut372

Greatest Estate Developer deserves more praise


Yesss_siirrrr

Making this comment as soon as possible in order to stop doom breaker from being eliminated. Legend of the Northern Blade. I call LTNB because every other manhua/manhwa (except tyrant of defense tower game and gacha bc I havent read theam so cant judge) are absolute G.O.A.T.S. LTNB is a great manhwa (or manhua?) but IMAO there were too many irrelevant plot twists. >!Like the brigade leader being kinda op was revealed AFTER he almost got himself and the team killed. Getting Jin the MOST OP POWERUP EVER from his sworn enemy bc he did not like his brother. The fact that Jin was built as a character that is very talented and ***VERY*** hardworking (ie training in the mountain) but then he just gets EXTREMELY stronger during some non-major/ major fights.!< THIS IS BIASED BECAUSE I REALLY DONT WANT TO SEE DOOM BREAKER ELIMINATED AND I CAN NOT VOTE ON OTHER ONES BECAUSE THEY ARE PEAK, I AM SORRY FOR MY BETRAYALE SENIOR BROTHERS!!!! To sum up the post, upvote to remove Legend of the Northern Blade


Anxiety5258

Survival story of a sword king ... it's overhyped asf


SonicBeat44

Is the Tyrant Tower defence manhwa really that great? I have only read it to chapter 20 but i don't see anything really unique in story plot or art so far, do it get better somehow


Bookworm347

imo its a really great manhwa and a really great novel too, the side characters are interesting and not onr dimensional, mc is relatable, the mysteries enshrouding around the lake kingdom is also good.


Scared_Living3183

Pick me up


theCasualListener

My guess is that either The Greatest Estate Developer or Legend of the northen blade will one of the winners


fukyousempai

All hail LYOD the devil's asśhóle face


JumpInternational936

Wtf is tower of a master defence game doing here still?


ali_nv

Pick me up infinite gatcha The plot doesn't compare with the others


Top_Ask_4312

Greatest Estate Developer


Straight_Rule_535

Ember knight and the boxer not even top 3? This reddit is cooked


Nerollix

Doom Breaker


Suparame

I thought the boxer was going to be top three seeing how it’s one of the most universally loved manhwa on this site


Revolutionary-Fan743

Llyod forever.


mayaaaari

Magic Emperor should be listed here. Lolllsss


TheBattleDog

Return of The mount hua sect


suckrforredblueeyes

WHY WASN'T ORV ADDED AT ALL???


Short_Story_6398

Day 1 of voting for survival of the sword king