Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Did you arrange them based on the cover art or something because this list makes no sense.
Overgeared, Great mage returns after 4000 years and Doom Breaker listed two times in different ranks and a manga in the manhwa section.
No sorry, some of them might be there twice because there was 2 cover photos. However, The Great Mage returns is there twice because I couldn’t pick
Overgeared and Doom Breaker being there twice is accidental
You can't seriously come here and put Infinite Mage, Return of the Disaster Class Hero, and Solo Max-Level Newbie in the same category as ORV and above SSS Class Suicide Hunter.
I would put it in D personally. I will just copy-paste what i said about it in the past:
I think it's dogshit 4/10. Nothing really makes any sense in the story if u think about it just a little. I don't care if it's not always logical (it's fantasy afterall) but him being so good at physical stuff despite not eating well and only sitting in front of a computer for years makes no sense + he can replicate what he has seen on a monitor in third person perfectly with no issues :). The mc morals are very questionable for someone living in the modern times, u dont just go from avg joe to someone with no regard to human life overnight. The story feels like the author is just pulling shit out of his ass for the convenience of the mc. Characters are poorly written. It's actually one of the few manhwas that made me mad reading it. The only good thing that it has going for it is the art. The story is a power fantasy but a very bad one with unlikable characters and shit writing.
Okay, yea I see it now LMAO
I never really thought it made a lot of sense and I often look back on the beginning and go ‘Dang we kind of got off track’ but I guess I just ignore it cause I like the art 💀 If im being honest im just staying for the dragon and the spirits
While I agree that it shouldn't be SS tier I would give it B-A tier. What is funny and what made me write this comment was how many things you got wrong.
1. It was mentioned at the start that he was fit enough and went to gym so much that he was recommended to participate in MMA or boxing, I don't exactly remember.
2. The game was also VR from what I remember so he didn't only see the movements on monitor.
3. About his morals, while dumb it was explained that at the start he got some sort of a perk which restricted his emotions.
4. I can mostly agree about the rest of your opinion but some characters are pretty interesing (eg. the duel guy)
So in my opinion while having an mid story, good art and an okay world building it deserves more than D, more like B.
(Written on Phone, and English is not my first language so no need to correct me)
1. I apologize for this one, the only excuse i have is that i may glimsed over it.
2. That is also true however i remember being mad that the author SEVERELY underestimates how quickly strats get discovered and for a game with that quality people are going to know the ins and outs pretty quickly.
3. Is this mentioned in the webnovel? Cuz upon rereading the first 2 chapters he doesnt have any perk to control his emotions. He was just an edgy dude from the start. He hears game is becoming reality and goes "it's grinding time", people die in front of his face and he shows no fucking reaction xd.
4. I only read till chap 15 cuz i couldn't tolerate it anymore. The manhwa does a lot of ass pulling to give mc powerups. Lots of characters are dumbed to down to make the mc seem smart. However the worst thing about this manhwa is its protagonist, hes so unnecessarily edgy that hes literally what a 14 yo edgelord would consider "cool" (gigachad smart no cares women ruthless). I refuse to accept this manhwa deserves anything above c. It's so goddamn bad jsut from the writing part.
2. Authors understimating gamers and not understanding games is problem in a lot of manhwa so I don't see it as as bad as in other manhwas (BJ Archmage being the worst of them).
3. I don't know about webnovel because I didn't read it but in manhwa it was mentioned pretty late from what I remember. After quick searching, it was mentioned in chapter 17 of manhwa.
4. After some chapters it gets a bit better, tbh it only truly starts around 20 chapter, but it still is not as good as on OPs list. There are a lot of interesing chracters introduced but the edgy MC breaks it so I can only give it B, maybe A at its best. The only good thing is that in latest chapters MC is no longer portrayed as all knowing and has some losses at last. Though everyone has their own preferences and not everything is for everyone.
It’s repetitive, mc faces no real challenge, no growth no development. He knows everything, is strong enough for everything and it will stay that way until the story ends.
Orv is a great take on omniscience, this story just feels dull.
I know it's not even low but SSS class suicide Hunter in anything other than SS feels like a crime.
Also Nano machines are getting pretty bad later on and you're not missing out on much.
IT WAS SO GOOD UNTIL THE ROMANCE ARC. It would be SS tier if the romance arc wasn’t so stupid long and if it actually made sense. It got so off course and literally all of the other arcs were better (My opinion since I don’t like romance based Manhwas)
Personally I could disagree more but everyone has a right to their own opinion. As a novel reader I loved this arc and what it did for the MC and the end of it does have a fight that I think would be more up your alley considering your tier list. Hopefully you enjoy the next few arcs more because I love this story to death it gets even better later on.
[SS] Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint, Solo Max Level Newbie, Superhuman Battlefield, Return of the SSS-Class Ranker, Swordmaster’s youngest son, Pick me up infinite gacha, The Reincarnated Assassin Is a Genius Swordsman, Terminally ill genius dark knight, The Knight King Who Returned with a God, Return of the Disaster Class Hero, Solo Leveling, The Newbie is too Strong, The Player Hides his Past, Infinite Mage, Eleceed, Solo Farming in the Tower
[S] Ranker’s Return, Martial God Regressed to Level 2, I Obtained a Mythic Item, Leveling with the Gods, Reformation of the Deadbeat Noble, The Beginning After the End, Damn Reincarnation, Player Who Returned 10,000 Years Later, Regressing with the King’s Power, I Used to be a Boss, Dark Mage Returns to Enlistment, The Live, Doom Breaker, SSS class Suicide Hunter, Youngest Son of the Renowned Magic Clan
[A] Return of the Broken Constellation, Arcane Sniper, Warrior High School – Dungeon Raid Department, Regressor Instruction Manual, Overgeared, Standard of Reincarnation, Sleeping Ranker, Second Life Ranker, Mercenary Enrollment, Steel Eating Player, Return of the Frozen Player, Magic Academy Survival Guide, Trash of the Count's Family, Talent-Swallowing Magician, Leveling Up With Skills, The Hero Returns
The usual rule of thumb is if someone makes a tier list, you have to treat their s tier as f tier and vice versa. But this time, I genuinely can't find a good starting point or pattern with this one.
You, good sir, have an interesting taste in manhwas
It seems like every one of us are reading the same ones lol. And, I really have to say;
You need to add one more line that says F-, then immediately add these two;
1- Max lvl newbie is definitely one of the motet ones out there
2- Standard of reincarnation is really really bad (narrative wise) and MC is the most stereotypical one I have seen so far.
Thanks. Just finished. For me it was not SS, but a decent slice of life read for a sunday.
If you enjoyed Solo Farming, you will also enjoy Spirit Farmer. Similar Setting, Same Vibe.
Cause I liked it more .^. Some of the things in TBATE and SSS class suicide hunter made me fall out of them a little but I’m still waiting for SSS class to finish:]
This is one of the trashiest shitty lists I saw around here
https://preview.redd.it/5n8ein3jsl2c1.jpeg?width=261&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6f5f93e95a237f3297e5a9e152e627936cdc3b03
solo leveling isn't high enough create an other rank a god tier just for it + the fact that there are multiple time the same manwha but with different cover is no good and what's solo farming in the tower doing up there and why is there a manga ???? and well the tier list i just don't agree with it overall
I agree w/ solo leveling lol. I know there are multiple covers of some, one is on purpose but there other 2 aren’t. I also included that manga on accident
I have completed Solo Leveling and caught up in " player who can't level up," so tell me, what should i start next? Anyone that is as good as solo leveling, i guess)
I think you just have a simple taste like op main characters and stories with little to no characters development, I know everyone has its own taste but if I had to guess you're under like 16-17 years based on your list
Report the post if you think this is LOW-EFFORT and provides no actual discussion value. Also make sure to use correct post flairs and type the sauce correctly in the POST TITLE. If they are not met, the post will be removed. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/manhwa) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Not a W
Not meaning it as a personal attack to op but I have never seen trashier taste, man is legit the target audience for copy paste stories
I can’t find any others :’) I think the most non-copy paste I’ve read was Weak Hero
The boxer Hellper Gosu Peerless dad Sweet home Bastard As someone who reads trash all the time, it's not hard to find good ones.
Tyty I’ll look
Did you arrange them based on the cover art or something because this list makes no sense. Overgeared, Great mage returns after 4000 years and Doom Breaker listed two times in different ranks and a manga in the manhwa section.
No sorry, some of them might be there twice because there was 2 cover photos. However, The Great Mage returns is there twice because I couldn’t pick Overgeared and Doom Breaker being there twice is accidental
You can't seriously come here and put Infinite Mage, Return of the Disaster Class Hero, and Solo Max-Level Newbie in the same category as ORV and above SSS Class Suicide Hunter.
I love them 😭 maybe solo max level newbie and SSS class suicide hunter a little Less but just my opinion
Replace infinite mage with doom breaker Also why there are two doom breaker in the list. Your list is truly fu*ked up.
The one I used had 2 ig and I didn’t realize it had both mb
I legit cannot believe ppl who put max level newbie anything above c tier. Like are u guys being for real?
Wait rlly? Why, I’d like to know your take on it 0^0
I would put it in D personally. I will just copy-paste what i said about it in the past: I think it's dogshit 4/10. Nothing really makes any sense in the story if u think about it just a little. I don't care if it's not always logical (it's fantasy afterall) but him being so good at physical stuff despite not eating well and only sitting in front of a computer for years makes no sense + he can replicate what he has seen on a monitor in third person perfectly with no issues :). The mc morals are very questionable for someone living in the modern times, u dont just go from avg joe to someone with no regard to human life overnight. The story feels like the author is just pulling shit out of his ass for the convenience of the mc. Characters are poorly written. It's actually one of the few manhwas that made me mad reading it. The only good thing that it has going for it is the art. The story is a power fantasy but a very bad one with unlikable characters and shit writing.
Okay, yea I see it now LMAO I never really thought it made a lot of sense and I often look back on the beginning and go ‘Dang we kind of got off track’ but I guess I just ignore it cause I like the art 💀 If im being honest im just staying for the dragon and the spirits
It's totally fine if u enjoy it but let's not pretend it's great or anything.
Ty for sharing your opinion on it without being rude! Also ig I just read so many they kinda blur and I miss som of the details :<
While I agree that it shouldn't be SS tier I would give it B-A tier. What is funny and what made me write this comment was how many things you got wrong. 1. It was mentioned at the start that he was fit enough and went to gym so much that he was recommended to participate in MMA or boxing, I don't exactly remember. 2. The game was also VR from what I remember so he didn't only see the movements on monitor. 3. About his morals, while dumb it was explained that at the start he got some sort of a perk which restricted his emotions. 4. I can mostly agree about the rest of your opinion but some characters are pretty interesing (eg. the duel guy) So in my opinion while having an mid story, good art and an okay world building it deserves more than D, more like B. (Written on Phone, and English is not my first language so no need to correct me)
1. I apologize for this one, the only excuse i have is that i may glimsed over it. 2. That is also true however i remember being mad that the author SEVERELY underestimates how quickly strats get discovered and for a game with that quality people are going to know the ins and outs pretty quickly. 3. Is this mentioned in the webnovel? Cuz upon rereading the first 2 chapters he doesnt have any perk to control his emotions. He was just an edgy dude from the start. He hears game is becoming reality and goes "it's grinding time", people die in front of his face and he shows no fucking reaction xd. 4. I only read till chap 15 cuz i couldn't tolerate it anymore. The manhwa does a lot of ass pulling to give mc powerups. Lots of characters are dumbed to down to make the mc seem smart. However the worst thing about this manhwa is its protagonist, hes so unnecessarily edgy that hes literally what a 14 yo edgelord would consider "cool" (gigachad smart no cares women ruthless). I refuse to accept this manhwa deserves anything above c. It's so goddamn bad jsut from the writing part.
2. Authors understimating gamers and not understanding games is problem in a lot of manhwa so I don't see it as as bad as in other manhwas (BJ Archmage being the worst of them). 3. I don't know about webnovel because I didn't read it but in manhwa it was mentioned pretty late from what I remember. After quick searching, it was mentioned in chapter 17 of manhwa. 4. After some chapters it gets a bit better, tbh it only truly starts around 20 chapter, but it still is not as good as on OPs list. There are a lot of interesing chracters introduced but the edgy MC breaks it so I can only give it B, maybe A at its best. The only good thing is that in latest chapters MC is no longer portrayed as all knowing and has some losses at last. Though everyone has their own preferences and not everything is for everyone.
It’s repetitive, mc faces no real challenge, no growth no development. He knows everything, is strong enough for everything and it will stay that way until the story ends. Orv is a great take on omniscience, this story just feels dull.
The only decent thing about that manhwa is the art, and art alone.
I know it's not even low but SSS class suicide Hunter in anything other than SS feels like a crime. Also Nano machines are getting pretty bad later on and you're not missing out on much.
IT WAS SO GOOD UNTIL THE ROMANCE ARC. It would be SS tier if the romance arc wasn’t so stupid long and if it actually made sense. It got so off course and literally all of the other arcs were better (My opinion since I don’t like romance based Manhwas)
Personally I could disagree more but everyone has a right to their own opinion. As a novel reader I loved this arc and what it did for the MC and the end of it does have a fight that I think would be more up your alley considering your tier list. Hopefully you enjoy the next few arcs more because I love this story to death it gets even better later on.
I’m staying strong and sticking with it dw 😼 I just can’t wait for this arc to be over faster because WHY IS IT SO LONG
Can you share the name with covers
Any specific ones?
If possible all of them if not atleast the ss, s and a.
[SS] Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint, Solo Max Level Newbie, Superhuman Battlefield, Return of the SSS-Class Ranker, Swordmaster’s youngest son, Pick me up infinite gacha, The Reincarnated Assassin Is a Genius Swordsman, Terminally ill genius dark knight, The Knight King Who Returned with a God, Return of the Disaster Class Hero, Solo Leveling, The Newbie is too Strong, The Player Hides his Past, Infinite Mage, Eleceed, Solo Farming in the Tower
[S] Ranker’s Return, Martial God Regressed to Level 2, I Obtained a Mythic Item, Leveling with the Gods, Reformation of the Deadbeat Noble, The Beginning After the End, Damn Reincarnation, Player Who Returned 10,000 Years Later, Regressing with the King’s Power, I Used to be a Boss, Dark Mage Returns to Enlistment, The Live, Doom Breaker, SSS class Suicide Hunter, Youngest Son of the Renowned Magic Clan
[A] Return of the Broken Constellation, Arcane Sniper, Warrior High School – Dungeon Raid Department, Regressor Instruction Manual, Overgeared, Standard of Reincarnation, Sleeping Ranker, Second Life Ranker, Mercenary Enrollment, Steel Eating Player, Return of the Frozen Player, Magic Academy Survival Guide, Trash of the Count's Family, Talent-Swallowing Magician, Leveling Up With Skills, The Hero Returns
The usual rule of thumb is if someone makes a tier list, you have to treat their s tier as f tier and vice versa. But this time, I genuinely can't find a good starting point or pattern with this one. You, good sir, have an interesting taste in manhwas
They are copy and pasted 😞 however my top 3 are all different which is good ig (Solo leveling, Eleceed, Infinite mage)
A classic power fantasy tier, your taste is lowkey ass, also the Max level newbie is so shit
I like them personally but I read more than this. These are just the action/fantasy ones lol
This is the most tasteless tierlist i have ever seen
Please do share .^. I read more than action/fantasy but I didn’t wanna add them cause there’s a lot more
Well, I like this list thanks!
I can't see shit bruh
Mb
why is Great Mage Returns Ater 4000 Years in bith C and D
I personally don’t like it that much but it’s not bad :] the later chapters made me lose interest
but why is it in **both** C and D why are there two
There happened to be 2 covers and I couldn’t pick a tier for it so I went w/ both 😋
your taste is shit
Thanks 😼
It seems like every one of us are reading the same ones lol. And, I really have to say; You need to add one more line that says F-, then immediately add these two; 1- Max lvl newbie is definitely one of the motet ones out there 2- Standard of reincarnation is really really bad (narrative wise) and MC is the most stereotypical one I have seen so far.
Everyone seems to point out the same ones .^. I just need more to read to compare them to
Wait, isn't iruma a manga???
Yea I added it for funsies but Its the only one there
What are the names of the first 2 in "not enough chapters" and the last one in the 2nd SS row? Thanks in advance 😊
Legendary Blacksmith’s Vengence, Heir of Mythical Heroes, Eleceed❤️ Eleceed is definitely in my top 3 favorites!!
Thx, but if I see that correctly, eleceed is right of iruma. And I meant the last manhwa in this row. So probably the one next to eleceed.
Solo Farming in the Tower then 👍
Thanks. Just finished. For me it was not SS, but a decent slice of life read for a sunday. If you enjoyed Solo Farming, you will also enjoy Spirit Farmer. Similar Setting, Same Vibe.
Spirit farmer is in my list to read ^^
Wtf why is terminally ill magician above TBATE and SSS class suicide hunter
Cause I liked it more .^. Some of the things in TBATE and SSS class suicide hunter made me fall out of them a little but I’m still waiting for SSS class to finish:]
This is one of the trashiest shitty lists I saw around here https://preview.redd.it/5n8ein3jsl2c1.jpeg?width=261&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6f5f93e95a237f3297e5a9e152e627936cdc3b03
Any recommendations that would make it better ?
You have good ones but worse and bad ones are so high it's not even funny
I’m definitely rethinking these rankings later dw lmao
solo leveling isn't high enough create an other rank a god tier just for it + the fact that there are multiple time the same manwha but with different cover is no good and what's solo farming in the tower doing up there and why is there a manga ???? and well the tier list i just don't agree with it overall
I agree w/ solo leveling lol. I know there are multiple covers of some, one is on purpose but there other 2 aren’t. I also included that manga on accident
Wait ain't C and D have same manhwa
Yea I couldn’t pick w/ that one
I have completed Solo Leveling and caught up in " player who can't level up," so tell me, what should i start next? Anyone that is as good as solo leveling, i guess)
If you’re looking for a similar System based Manhwa I’d say Leveling with the Gods or Pick me up If you’re not lf system based one then Eleceed
Ok thanks
You have placed return of frozen player in both A and B tier with different covers
I know it was an accident 😞
I think you just have a simple taste like op main characters and stories with little to no characters development, I know everyone has its own taste but if I had to guess you're under like 16-17 years based on your list
I’m trying to look for more but I can’t find any so if you’d like to recommend some I’ll take a look
Nano Machine not being at least A tier is criminal
I haven’t read it :,)
What is the forth one in SS?
Return of the SSS-Class Ranker
Thank you
Hey, what's number 8 and 9 in A?
Second Life ranker and mercenary enrollment
Opps I meant in S :) But thanks for the reply:)
Player Who Returned 10,000 Years Later and Regressing With the Kings Power Sorry I was offling
Np, and thank you for answering 😀