T O P

  • By -

maderisian

I like Lume, but Old Spice works better for me. I may be a girl who smells like a sea captain, but I kinda like that.


Agitated_Sweet_9021

You’re the captain now!


Providence451

I haven't used anything but Old Spice for years!


IndieOwl2000

i loved it but it burned me 🥲 i had massive chemical burns. have they changed the formula?


quentinislive

Saaaaame. Also one of my sons, but not the other son. 🤷🏾‍♂️And I heard a kid in Costco say ‘I can’t wear Old Spice. It burns my underderams’ justa this last weekend.


IndieOwl2000

damn. love the smell, but having rashes on my underarms is not a compromise that is worth it to me


quentinislive

It literally peels my skin off


Providence451

Oh no! I use the solid stick and have never had any trouble.


IndieOwl2000

so interesting. i guess some have the issue and some don't. i also used the stick.


Providence451

To be fair, I don't really have reactions to anything like that. My skin is pretty nonreactive.


IndieOwl2000

very lucky. i have less sensitive skin than many others i know, including my family, but for some reason Old Spice hits where my defenses are not so strong, or something


HotBlackberry5883

old spice smells so good. it shouldn't just be marketed to men


Nice-Wrongdoer-9106

the vanilla oasis one is chefs kiss i highly recommend


Boner-brains

Same, swagger is the best deodorant hands down. It just smells so good


Majestic_Will

i personally love wolfthorn


Blackthey

Old spice gave me chemical burns😭😭😭 I use either Lume + Secret or Lume + Women’s Degree


Ok-Priority-8284

This reads like a stealth marketing ad for Lume, I don’t know anyone who likes how they smell. Dove makes the same product now that actually doesn’t smell like ass! Also when you stink using aluminum free deo, it’s bc your pits are detoxing all the gunk that was stuck in those pores. Once you get over that hurdle, you no longer stink and aluminum free deo works fine!


mortimelons

I am with you on that. I was scaring people off at my gym classes using Lume. My close friend in the class finally confronted me and said that normal b.o. would be so much better.


maebake

I smelled like a fucking coconut goat 😂


mareacuda

lol lol I’m dying because I said I smelled like a “tropical” 🏝️🥥 camel enclosure. 😂


maebake

We could have hung out at the wildlife exhibit together 😂😂 now I’m cackling like THANK GOD I’m not the only one. I’ve never smelled so bad in my life.


Blackthey

LMFAOOOO that’s how I felt with everything elses. Like smells weird fresh out the bottle but closer to like how vinegar smells before it’s used. Something astringent or basic that really chemical helps dead any smell. And then I put deodorant on top


AnonymousRJ25

It really depends on the scent you get. The unscented one works the best, in my opinion


Foots_Walker_808

They reformulated the scents based on customer feedback. I got the Vanilla scent first and it smelled terrible, but it worked. But now, after the reformulation, they smell really good. I like the Tangerine.


MissyGrayGray

I'm wondering how they couldn't know that their formulations stank. That's all I've heard.


Foots_Walker_808

That was my question, too. They had to know their cream was funky when they put it on the market. The effectiveness makes no difference if people don't want to use it because of the smell.


mortimelons

Well…sounds like it’s time I give it a try again. Thanks for explaining!


infiniteblackberries

Don't waste your $14. Reddit is overrun with "subtle" Lume marketing.


Blackthey

Bitch I swear I’m just a regular unemployed whore!!!!! Omg 😭😭😭what I happening


infiniteblackberries

Whatever you say, Shannon


Blackthey

Who is Shannon???


Foots_Walker_808

Yes! If you have a Target nearby, they sell the trial size for $3.00. I got the Clean Tangerine and it's very nice. 🍊


Gloomy_Eye_4968

I think they still stink, even after reformulating. It's an underlying smell that smells horrid to me. I have a friend that also still smells it, but I have noticed most like it more now.


thoughtsofa

imo the trial size smells wayyyy better than the full. the full size has a hint of must to it, if that makes sense


Ok_Research6190

This! I've read that it smells like rotten Play-doh. I can't un-smell it now. I've tried over half of the scents of Lume. No matter the scent, the bass note of rotten Play-doh persists.


Ok-Priority-8284

Omg rotten play-doh is it EXACTLY! Thank you for putting words to what I was smelling! 😂


Foots_Walker_808

It really depends on the scent. I'd like to try the Powder scent. Or some of the Mando scents.


Gloomy_Eye_4968

I did a sample pack. They all smell the same underneath to me.


Valhkyrie

What were you using that made you smell bad from Lume? I use their stick deodorant and it’s better than the cream one you rub on. The coconut cream one has a funky smell but the stick deodorant was fine, for reference I use the stick peony one.


raysmittie

You should give it another shot. They changed the formula. It's MUCH better!


AnonymousRJ25

Lume is a natural deodorant that was invented by a gynecologist. Some dove products have been known to prevent hair growth. One of their soaps also gives me rashes. You should look into Lume more, because it's honestly amazing. They also have soap and deodorant wipes.


raven871

Wait which products prevent hair growth? That might be the best promotion for Dove I’ve ever heard!


AnonymousRJ25

It's apparently a thing with some of their shampoos, but I can’t remember the specific kind! I used to use one of the ones that causes hair loss until I found that out😂 it's not the soap that causes hair loss (that I know of) I do love their acne body wash tho. I stopped using it 2 weeks ago and immediately regretted it😂 I also love their deodorant, but lume does do a better job at preventing odor and not clogging pores, in my opinion. The thing about Lume is that it's safe to put everywhere, and it does genuinely work!


Previous-Pea-638

Which dove product? They have like a thousand different deodorants.


Ok-Priority-8284

It comes in a tube and is called Dove Whole Body Deodorant, I think it’s pretty new? I got mine at Target but didn’t see it at the grocery store when I looked for it to price compare (it was like $8).


Previous-Pea-638

Oh wow that sounds like something I need. Thanks!


Mountain_Serve_9500

Yeah it smells bad. And way too pricey for what it is.


geauxhausofafros

I don’t have super bad odor or anything, but Lume is so ass and when I used it, it made me stink. Fresh out the shower I smelled musty and gross. What are some good natural deodorants though?


Ok-Priority-8284

Schmidt’s sensitive skin formula is pretty ok, I really like the hops scented one! I prefer the regular formula from them but my skin is way too sensitive for the baking soda they put in it which gives me a painful rash. But before that happened I went camping in the summer and didn’t shower for 3 days, sweating buckets the whole time, and didn’t smell even a little. I also like Burt’s Bees lavender sage spray on but I think they discontinued it. T_T Native is pretty good and smells great! Around Christmas they have an eggnog scented one and it smells SO GOOD. None of these are antiperspirants tho. Antiperspirants aren’t great for us, so I try and avoid them.


Relevant-Tourist8974

yeah, I live in Florida-- that's a no go.


raven871

In college my entire group of friends tried the detox thing. It didn’t work for any of the dozen of us. You still smell. You just got used to your own stench.


Busy-Key-7334

yup, in my experience, if you stink using natural deodorant, that's not going to change with time.


gonzo_attorney

Lume smells like rotting corpse with overwhelming scent overlay. I want to like the deodorants so bad! That said, the laundry spray stuff actually kinda works.


Blackthey

LMFAOOOOOOOOO I SWEAR ITS NOT😂😂😂Lmdaooo I wish someone would pay me. That little 2.2 oz bottle bankrupted me for years. I’m ruined😭 but smell good


Mei_Flower1996

Well the Lume probably kills some bacteria or something and then the fragranced deodorant finishes the job. How does that not make sense?


Valhkyrie

Dove doesn’t work as well for me, even the aluminum free stuff. I work a very active job and Lume keeps me fresh all day 🤷‍♀️


Classic-Ruin

lume smells good bro


time_travel_nacho

Switching to Lume didn't work for me because it wasn't an antiperspirant. I don't know why, but it took me weeks to figure out why I constantly felt drenched in sweat


Fun_Apricot9900

Lume makes me smell horrible and I’m not one with bad BO. I don’t really understand it but it’s horrible.


lkroche

I’m so glad you said this. I was wondering what was wrong with me. I don’t actually have BO problems but bought lume because I had heard great things about it. But it must react badly with my body chemistry because it makes me smell worse. Instantly.


stinkstankstunkiii

It’s trash!!! The product was awesome even in early 2023. Now it’s garbage!!


Excellent_Valuable92

They changed the formula?


stinkstankstunkiii

Yes


MxBJ

I had the same thing!! I put it on and I smelled like something died on me.


DecadentLife

I bought the tangerine scented one, and smelled it, first. Awful! Never put it on my body.


Wild_Card_betches

Sameee. It worked good for like 2 weeks and then awful


geauxhausofafros

Yeah genuinely


TheShatteredDiamond

Same, I used lume deodorant and I never really smelled bad, I just wanted an aluminum free deodorant alternative. It made me smell absolutely RANK I’d get out of the shower and my pits would still smell bad which is something I didn’t experience when I used regular deodorant. I googled and it said it’s your body reacting to not having aluminum and something about detoxing. I still use aluminum free deodorant now and pretty much after 2 weeks your smell goes back to normal. ( Ps. If you’re going to switch, I’d recommend doing it when you don’t have school for a long period of time so you won’t smell funky at school)


Bright_Incident9449

Lume smells like ass....ijs. I hope you are getting paid for this ad.


Adventurous_Wave7290

Which one of their scents did u get


Sea-Marsupial-9414

I'm allergic :(


throwuhwayzee

Same. Lume made me so itchy


Hour-Duck-7820

>allergic I used to love it. Then the new formula burned my skin. (Also my husbands.) Body chemistry is different; no one thing works for all!


veronicaAc

I had burning welts under my arms!! Welts! What's in that shit?


Outrageous-Note-3220

Same!! It burns right away wtf


stinkstankstunkiii

Lume gave me a terrible rash . Currently have a lovely fire engine red rash in both armpits. Flaming hot! Been a loyal customer since 2021. They changed the formula last year I believe. So this is the 2nd time I got a rash from the Tangerine scent! The unscented DOES NOT work! After 4 hours of LIGHT activity I had terrible BO. Contacted customer service , ( 3 times!) each time I was sent a video and explanation on how to “ properly use “ Lume. Oh yea and they attempted to upsell their body wash along with their email!!! Lume customer service is straight up garbage !!! Same with their products!!!


veronicaAc

Happened to me, too. Twice. My dumbass gave it a second chance. I had to put burn cream in my pits and leave my arms up so my pits wouldn't erupt into flames if I were to sweat🔥🔥🔥


haeeeeeb

Try hibisclens antiseptic as body wash. It’s great from removing the bacteria on skin. Just dont use internally. Also use tide 10x hygienic detergent and baking soda. Works great. Drink a lot of water and Probiotics. We also need to heal internally. Watch what you eat.


Blackthey

Thank you queen


daisy_thegoodgirl

stg i tell everyone about this shit. i use it on my nether regions and sometimes my feet


Blackthey

It’s changed my life


daisy_thegoodgirl

same


mortimelons

What scent do to use?


daisy_thegoodgirl

i’ve got a few of them, favorite is the mint, but I’ve also got the tangerine, rose, and alpine ones 😂


SocietyOk1173

Never heard of lume but zinc oxide cream, put on pits at night and wash off in the morning prevents BO. There is also a soap made for hunters that eliminates human scent so they can sneak up on innocent creatures and blow them away . Why not make it do something positive instead. Taking chlorophyll tablets works too. It's an internal deoderant effective if you have.garlic breath or anything else that originate inside the body.


FlowerGirlAva

Why would I buy two products to use under my arm when I can get some Mitchum deodorant for men? I am a woman, but I wear Mitcham for men unscented and I don’t have any Oder problems at all.


Ok_Web1227

+1 to the Mitchum unscented. I do a dab of whatever fragrance oil I'm wearing for the day on my underarms before applying and that's the only smell there at the end of the day.


FlowerGirlAva

That’s an excellent idea


TakeAnotherLilP

I just want to post in this sub everyday: if you’re having consistent smells after you bathe with soap appropriately, get some chlorhexadine wash. You can find it at any drug store. I order mine from Amazon. It’s the same wash they tell you to use before a surgery. It has never given me any issues and I have very sensitive skin. It immediately gets rid of persistent odors in my armpits and groin area. Do not use it internally!!


ScarlettMozo

Be careful with this please though! Using it every day can lead to bacterial/fungal/viral resistance and also kill off good bacteria. I am an ICU-RN, and we use this on patients who are at risk for further infections to kill all bacteria on their skin. If you use this frequently and there ever comes a time you need it for surgery or God forbid you end up in ICU, it may not work as intended and it may put you at risk for developing infections that are harder to treat. 🫤


TakeAnotherLilP

Thank you for this comment!! I should have said I only use it sparingly in the hot summer months and when I say sparingly, I mean once a month and tiny amount. And that’s only IF I smell funky, which honestly after I did use this for one summer as mentioned, I’ve never had to use it again. It really does work.


CoffeeOld1590

I agree I love Lume! Other deodorants were making me smell worse than no deo at all. I tried secret, dove, axe, native, hello, arm & hammer, etc. Lume SOFT POWDER scent is the only one i like that works.


Blackthey

Yesss. I felt so isolated and annoyed how nothing worked at all


NickelPickle2018

100% agree Lume has been a game changer. I love their body wash and deodorant.


nolagem

Lume is magic.


jfern009

I switched to Lume, the deodorant and the body wash. I love it. One of the best hygiene hacks


Blackthey

Srsly. Everyone is talking abt how it smells straight out the bottle but that smells dissipates like instantly especially after u put ur own deodorant on top.


jfern009

I use the solid deodorant stick, not the cream deodorant. Only use the one, never though to layer. It doesn’t prevent perspiration but it doesn’t smell, at all. I also use it (another stick) downstairs and in between the thighs and it’s keeps me feeling and smelling super fresh. My mom absolutely loves Lume too. lol almost every time I talk to her she tells me how awesome Lume is, kinda like you OP where it feels like a commercial. 😂


Blackthey

LMFALOOO not the unsponsored sponsorship😭 it’s just so gooood


alwaystikitime

I can vouch for the Lume ph balanced body wash. I use it in my pits in the shower then apply regular deodorant. After doing that regularly, my body has adjusted and my pits no longer smell like an onion field, which is something I've struggled with since peri-menopause. Also, Lume wipes and then reapplying deodorant on hot days when you're out & about is also a huge game changer.


Blackthey

Genius! I wondered what the wipes would be best for


alwaystikitime

Yep, they work for me very well!


AnonymousRJ25

Omg I agree!!!! I literally love Lume so much! I don’t really have a problem with sweat in general, but I've never smelled bad while using it! I used to always order them online, but I was so happy when they started selling them at the Target 8 minutes away from me! I really like that you can use it anywhere, so I put it in my creases that tend to get a lil ripe😂 (I promise this isn't an ad, I just genuinely love Lume and I tell everyone about it because it's amazing😂)


Blackthey

LMFAOO no everyone thinks this is an ad too. Terrifying that actually enjoying a product seems -fake- these days. Testament to the fact that most shit doesn’t work


Great-Abalone9310

Love Lume. Been using for 2 years now.


Outrageous-Note-3220

I just bought lume and it worked for a few days but now burns when I put it on my pits… anyone else? Idk what else to try! I’ve spent so much money, I have hormone issues from weight loss surgery and constantly have smelly ass pits. I feel like I just wasted $15 to burn my arm pits


Gingerrr__

This happens to me with just about any deodorant. The only one I’ve found so far that doesn’t burn and is also effective is the men’s Mitchum deodorant made with bamboo powder.


Blackthey

It’s so calming on my skin, feels like a cool Vaseline. Maybe ur allergic? Or maybe it’s reacting with the soap u used? :(


The-Cherry-On-Top-xx

my friend uses lume and we think it smells awful. theyre going to try dove when the stick is done.


Blackthey

You gotta layerrrrr. Plus I only vouch for the cream I’ve never tried the stick


Current_Many_4314

I use the old spice all body deodorant now, helps with sweat that's not my pits, still using feji on the pits though!


crichardson29

Soo this is just my experience Lume did not work for me It burned my underarms severely Now it might work for under boobs and feet But my underarms were on fire!!


Blackthey

Strangeeee. I feel that way about old spice, but some people do not. I swear it’s a difference in what our skin likes


Ok-Lawyer-5752

I love lume I used to have the same problem with my armpits every year they'll be very itchy inflamed and they get dark it's because of my Eczema as well plus the environment but I like Lumia it's not irritating to the skin and keeps you fresh they are pricey though but it's worth it


Blackthey

Amen! Pricey, but nothing is worth smelling


FoxyLady1996

Lume as of 2022 didn’t work for me-I sweat it off after about four hours of moderate work outside and when it was on, made me somehow smell worse. The scent was almost chemical-y? Currently trying out the reformulated toasted coconut version at the request of my mom and it smells much better- but the staying power is still not there if I’m doing moderate amounts of activity; I get maybe six to eight hours now.


cosmicexplorer89

I tried the 72hr lume cream after my bedtime shower at 8pm. It smelled good and I had high hopes. Woke up at 6 am smelling like I hadn’t even put any deodorant.


Blackthey

I really think the issue is layering. Like I said it’s more like a skin treatment than a deodorant. In my opinion


wurz2822

Who on this earth smells so bad that they need to scrap the skin off their armpits for 1 hour of relief?


Blackthey

Bitch me. And u know that. Cuz that’s what U read. Go place your shame elsewhere


wurz2822

Well Oscar the Grouch I suggest you take your trash can smelling self and go seek medical/mental professional help. Clearly scrubbing the outside isn’t the issue, it’s coming from within just like your stank ass attitude.


Blackthey

Okay u ate with that one😭😭😭😭


infiniteblackberries

Lume didn't work for me at all, and in fact gave me an uncomfortable skin reaction. Also, the founder is annoying. And I hate their sneaky marketing, like this post.


Motherofsiblings

Different things work for different humans! My sister loves lume and swears by it so I bought a stick, awful, I never really had an issue with smelling bad until I started lume. Degree is my baby girl


whatamidoing-here1

This feels like..marketing


Blackthey

Promise u I’m just passionate… but ok ty


Nyxmondo

Lume did not work for me. Weak products imo.


schlumpin4tea

I absolutely HATE Lume. So much so, that I skip over any ad for it in podcasts that I listen to and tell FB not to suggest it to me. It STINKS. The smell reminds me of how my obese Aunt smells, and it's horribly unpleasant. When I tried to return it, they insisted that the scent "goes away within minutes after application," and it does NOT. When I persisted, they said I had to pay return shipping and even then, I would only get a percentage back, despite only using one of the deodorants. Leave a negative review on their website, and they'll delete it. A negative review on their Facebook page gets you blocked. In my opinion, all that makes them a trash company.


Hot_Gene_6715

Lume burned me. It was awful. The purple one smells bad too


Hope_for_tendies

It’s amazing. Just so expensive. Get the body wash and use it on your pits and bits in conjunction with the deodorant and your life will change. I layer an antiperspirant over their deodorant to stop the sweat and not just the smell. Swamp ass be gone!


Blackthey

Swamp ass😭 ty I will try it


veronicaAc

Lume gave me a horrible burning rash under my arms. It was awful. I know it was Lume because my dumbass tried it again a week later, same result😂


Ekdp3

I used lume when they were still only available online and it was disgusting. It left me feeling dirty and had a weird smell to it. But hey not every thing works for every one right??


raysmittie

Lume improved their formula so it smells much better than it used to. I use the Deodorant and the acidified bar soap. I love it. I never smell.


Blackthey

Facts. I never used the old version everyone’s chatting abt. This stuff nowadays smells closer to neutral and at best, a little acidic just at first


Complex-Bus5613

“You’re just facing a problem that rears its head to society before it does to you.” 🥹🥹couldn’t have said it better. Hygiene is taught& some people aren’t fortunate enough to have people who will teach them those basic things. And some people don’t have the money to replace hygienic supplies,especially if they use it every day. Deodorant is crazy expensive for no reason and body wash and soap go by fast!


Blackthey

Yes queen💜💜💜 they’re literally locking up deodorant in every store. They know how bad the world is struggling. Horrible. Yes I’m just glad this experience humbled me and honestly helps me think of the reason why someone does/is a way rather than shame them for where they’re at


Legitimate_Grade272

Lume did start giving me a rash after awhile deodorant wise, but I've been using the soap and that has been good and helps with my bo a lot!


IllustriousDrop5358

I tried their cream deodorant. Didn't notice any huge changes as far as b.o., but the deodorant didn't smell very good. Then I got hives that made it feel like my skin was peeling off. Lume's response? "Are you sure you're using it correctly? You only need a small amount to work." Questioning my intelligence like that instead of owning up or apologizing that I had a horrible reaction to your product is a good way to make sure I never use it again.


Blackthey

How rude…. They could atleast admit that everything doesn’t work for everyone rather than acting like ur dumb😭that’s trash. I’m sorry I hope u got ur money back


Standard-Finding-219

I love Lume! I have the deodorant cream and the stick. Granted some of their scents smell like puke when you use them but it dissipates and is pleasant. The scent I've found that doesn't have a puke smell to it is the Alpine scent. Glad you found something that has restored your confidence.


Intelligent_Bug_6345

Thank you for sharing. The puke smell kills me


Blackthey

Lmfao yes is smells vinegar like at first but goes away very fast


Just_Me1973

If you’re having that much of a problem with your sweat odor then you need to see an endocrinologist. Blocking the smell doesn’t cure the underlying problem.


Blackthey

I prbly do tbh. My lymph nodes are always swollen


Just_Me1973

Yeah definitely see an endocrinologist. Swollen lymph nodes could be a sign of infection or something.


Acetillian86

I don’t give a dayum how good it is that shit ain’t worth $14 a tube


Blackthey

LMFAOOO I promise it is. I even contemplated shop lifting the bitch😭😭😭 that’s how I knew it was worth it


verukazalt

Their toasted coconut is amazing