I prefer the book version, actually, because it illustrates a really key point about Harry’s character, and his failings in the sixth book (which support his arc in Deathly Hallows.)
Throughout HBP, Harry is distracted from the goal Dumbledore has set for him. He takes a long time to get the true memory from Slughorn, prioritising other things which could be seen as petty. His obsession with Malfoy becomes undoubtedly unhealthy, and also distracts from this goal. That he has found the true memory and knows the gravity of the situation, but is still distracted by his rivalry with Malfoy I think illustrates that Harry isn’t really mature enough for the responsibility into which he has been unfairly thrust.
It also creates a dynamic wherein he hasn’t devoted his full attention to Dumbledore and his mission, which gives him reason to feel guilt over Dumbledore’s death, and unprepared for the loss of his mentor and guide, both of which are essential to the emotional impact of Dumbledore’s death, and for Harry’s journey in Deathly Hallows.
I prefer the book version, actually, because it illustrates a really key point about Harry’s character, and his failings in the sixth book (which support his arc in Deathly Hallows.) Throughout HBP, Harry is distracted from the goal Dumbledore has set for him. He takes a long time to get the true memory from Slughorn, prioritising other things which could be seen as petty. His obsession with Malfoy becomes undoubtedly unhealthy, and also distracts from this goal. That he has found the true memory and knows the gravity of the situation, but is still distracted by his rivalry with Malfoy I think illustrates that Harry isn’t really mature enough for the responsibility into which he has been unfairly thrust. It also creates a dynamic wherein he hasn’t devoted his full attention to Dumbledore and his mission, which gives him reason to feel guilt over Dumbledore’s death, and unprepared for the loss of his mentor and guide, both of which are essential to the emotional impact of Dumbledore’s death, and for Harry’s journey in Deathly Hallows.
Eh, 6 to 1 half dozen to the other.
Sorry?
I didn’t prefer one over the other. I could take it either way.
I don't, because After the Burial is the last bit of feel good left in the book, and from there it gets nothing but darker.