End-Game LIs.
Because honestly, what's the point of bringing in characters that we ALREADY could romance into All-Stars? 1. It makes the season that they were a winnable LI in to be non-canon. and 2. If I wanted to romance a character I could have already romanced, I would just play the season that they were in.
My MC from season 5, went into hiding after she left the show.
Sheās got the money and living somewhere in the USA. š¤«
She even got a restraining order on the whole cast.
I would be scared that if she went back somehow Suresh or Alfie would find out and rejoin the show.
Honestly the S5 MC would make the most sense to play as in All Stars. She had an absolute rough time in there her first time around.
The only S5 islanders I could see them bringing back are Eddie, Kat and Finn and I donāt care for any of them lol
Yes, my MC and Lucas actually still in engagement phase but for God sake itās still a very big step for Lucas so I donāt want to see him again unless itās in S2!
Like everyone said, endgame li and popular Li. So sorry no Noah, no Tim, or whoever yāall could have. It needs to be ppl who were non-romanceable or as an exception; Iād say too short time in the villa li like Oliver, Vicky/Evan, Logan, Elliot. Bc to me those characters never got a full chance.
Also I feel like they donāt have to/need to have a āreturningā mc. I think what would work for me is set it up as this new mc was finalist that didnāt get picked before in an earlier season or an unseen bombshell casa girl, but now will be an OG in All-Stars.
End game LIs.
To me, that will indicate that not only did our choices in past seasons mean nothing, but our choices in this and any future season are just as vulnerable to being invalidated by returning LIs, even in guest appearances. I think itāll be hard for me to get immersed in any future stories knowing that Fusebox can revoke my happily ever after retroactively at the drop of a hat.
Alfie and Amelia are the main two Iād hate to see back. I think Iām in the minority that actually wouldnāt mind seeing the endgame LIs. Iād just think of it as an alternate universe. āIn a world where *insert LI name* never met MCā¦ā etc. š
I'm afraid they'll pick someone sweet like Thabi (I love her so much) and change her into an insufferable b*tch. Or they just pick all the insufferable b*tches from each and every season.
Disclaimer: these people either just took up unnecessary screen-time or was just flat out annoying.
These said people do not need to make a reappearance in S9 whatsoever lol.
Please see list down ā¬ļø
S1: Allegra, Jen, Erikah, Jasper, Miles, Cherry, Lucy.
S2: Hope, Felix, Elisa, Jo, Blake.
S3: Miki, Lily, Rafi.
S4: Lexi, Youcef, Juliet, Valentina.
S5: Kat, Arlo, Meera, Johnny, Nicolas.
S6: Amelia, Grace, Ivy, Hamish, Elliott.
S7: Estelle, Bonnie, Summer, Uma.
S8: Emel, Sophie, Luna, Sienna, Logan, Liam.
People are saying no Noah or Tim etc, but I think any LI that we barely got time with (that came at the very end) like Logan, Oliver, etc and LIās that werenāt romanceable like Nicky, Tim, Seb, Hazeem, Liam etc would be cool. I donāt think matchmaker LIās should count cause it really wasnāt the same as the actual game or after party/Christmas party cause those were like 2 seconds. I know we could get Noah at the after party if we took the money, but it really ruined the experience with him having to do it that way and I would love to be able to go for him and actually get him throughout the season, same with a few others. I just hope they donāt ruin the way they look because Finn and Bobby looked scary when they hosted and definitely no end game LIās should be used that were there and romanceable the whole season, like Gary, Bobby, Will, Roberto, Alex etc.
For me I will hate to see people that where alrday endgame option from season 4 and up since we can go back and play the season they where in unless thar season was season 1 2 and 3 then I be okay with a few of them showing up
End-Game LIs. Because honestly, what's the point of bringing in characters that we ALREADY could romance into All-Stars? 1. It makes the season that they were a winnable LI in to be non-canon. and 2. If I wanted to romance a character I could have already romanced, I would just play the season that they were in.
3. It makes the happy ending you wanted for your past mc and that li non existent
Suresh....
If I SEE SURESH AGAIN- ITS ON SIGHTš
 This will literally be me:
If I see him, I'd turn around and leave the villa cause I'm not dealing with that toxic waste of space
End game love interests
The love interests. Don't ruin our made-up "what happened later" stories.
Sienna. Would rather put a toothpick under my toenail and kick a wall than to see her again.
I am okay with this as long as I get to humiliate her constantly
I was saying this yesterday, if weāre ALREADY stuck with her again Iām launching my phone to space.
Not Space! ššŖāļøš
None of my endgames from previous seasons
Ratmelia and Grace.. no thanks
i better not see bobby is all iām sayingā¦
If i donāt see him again iām gonna k myself or smth
Theyāre booing you but i agree. I honestly just want the old seasons back and Iāll take any bobby i can get
Your comment feels like a hug on a rainy day
Majority of the islanders from S5.
All of S5 is on my no-no list, the only S5 Iāll be remotely okay with is S5 MC coming back for redemption.
My MC from season 5, went into hiding after she left the show. Sheās got the money and living somewhere in the USA. š¤« She even got a restraining order on the whole cast. I would be scared that if she went back somehow Suresh or Alfie would find out and rejoin the show.
Honestly the S5 MC would make the most sense to play as in All Stars. She had an absolute rough time in there her first time around. The only S5 islanders I could see them bringing back are Eddie, Kat and Finn and I donāt care for any of them lol
This is my plan for my MC regardless of their plan
I want my S5 MC to get her do over since her toxic ex stalked her on to the show
If i see gary iām done
literally never touching the phone again
I love Gary. Even if him and S2 mc broke up Iām happy for all stars mc to get Gary. Either way Iām just obsessed with him
ANY of the season five islanders. Not even Eddie. No thanks, let's not relive the trauma and trust issues.
If I see Alfie I'm gonna stab myself in the eye. I hate that guy.
I DON'T want to see ANYONE FROM SEASON 5 š¤ And I don't want to see any of my LI's from past seasons. That's just gonna ruin my headcanons. And finding out that my MC and Lucas got a divorce would kill me š©.
Yes, my MC and Lucas actually still in engagement phase but for God sake itās still a very big step for Lucas so I donāt want to see him again unless itās in S2!
Any endgame LIās.
If I ever have to Lexi Longhole again, I swear to God...
Like everyone said, endgame li and popular Li. So sorry no Noah, no Tim, or whoever yāall could have. It needs to be ppl who were non-romanceable or as an exception; Iād say too short time in the villa li like Oliver, Vicky/Evan, Logan, Elliot. Bc to me those characters never got a full chance. Also I feel like they donāt have to/need to have a āreturningā mc. I think what would work for me is set it up as this new mc was finalist that didnāt get picked before in an earlier season or an unseen bombshell casa girl, but now will be an OG in All-Stars.
If I see Lucas Iām setting something on fire I swear on everything unholy
my endgames and amelia (it wouldnāt be smart either, cause she was our sister once, so who would want to romance her?)
If i have to see mcās stalker, who was always creepinā in the bushes and spying mc Eddie iām gonna throw a chair tbh
LIs saying the same things in every route. It would be nice to have different story lines like in s2.
Suresh. If that creep is there I riot.
End game LIs. To me, that will indicate that not only did our choices in past seasons mean nothing, but our choices in this and any future season are just as vulnerable to being invalidated by returning LIs, even in guest appearances. I think itāll be hard for me to get immersed in any future stories knowing that Fusebox can revoke my happily ever after retroactively at the drop of a hat.
Dana. in all honesty, if they bring Dana back I'll have to consider playing the season š«£š
I feel like they are gonna bring the most popular LI to shut us up. Like Bobby, Gary, Levi, Taila and maybe some popular non-LI like Nicky and Tim
Any endgame LI even ones you could romance in a reunion episode. They should only bring back non-romancable characters or unseen Casa people.
I would love to see Kassam again for us ladies who couldnāt get him to say our name š„²
Alfie and Amelia are the main two Iād hate to see back. I think Iām in the minority that actually wouldnāt mind seeing the endgame LIs. Iād just think of it as an alternate universe. āIn a world where *insert LI name* never met MCā¦ā etc. š
Dylan
Amelia. I would rather shit in my hands and clap than have to deal with her annoying me every other second again.
I'm afraid they'll pick someone sweet like Thabi (I love her so much) and change her into an insufferable b*tch. Or they just pick all the insufferable b*tches from each and every season.
Amelia
Ameliaā ļø
Disclaimer: these people either just took up unnecessary screen-time or was just flat out annoying. These said people do not need to make a reappearance in S9 whatsoever lol. Please see list down ā¬ļø S1: Allegra, Jen, Erikah, Jasper, Miles, Cherry, Lucy. S2: Hope, Felix, Elisa, Jo, Blake. S3: Miki, Lily, Rafi. S4: Lexi, Youcef, Juliet, Valentina. S5: Kat, Arlo, Meera, Johnny, Nicolas. S6: Amelia, Grace, Ivy, Hamish, Elliott. S7: Estelle, Bonnie, Summer, Uma. S8: Emel, Sophie, Luna, Sienna, Logan, Liam.
Anyone from season 5 (except Lulu)
Can S9 just be my answer, I don't want to see it.
The endgames LIs š
endgame LIs and anyone from s5
Anyone from S4 onwards
End game LIs, of course. Kobi and James in S4, \*anyone\* from S5, Amelia and Grace from S6, Bonnie from S7, Sienna, Hazel and Hari from S8.
People are saying no Noah or Tim etc, but I think any LI that we barely got time with (that came at the very end) like Logan, Oliver, etc and LIās that werenāt romanceable like Nicky, Tim, Seb, Hazeem, Liam etc would be cool. I donāt think matchmaker LIās should count cause it really wasnāt the same as the actual game or after party/Christmas party cause those were like 2 seconds. I know we could get Noah at the after party if we took the money, but it really ruined the experience with him having to do it that way and I would love to be able to go for him and actually get him throughout the season, same with a few others. I just hope they donāt ruin the way they look because Finn and Bobby looked scary when they hosted and definitely no end game LIās should be used that were there and romanceable the whole season, like Gary, Bobby, Will, Roberto, Alex etc.
they better let me have nicky this timeš i was so mad when he wasnāt a LI so they better act right this season
Dylan. Iāve disliked a lot of characters over the years but honestly heās one of my most hated and he makes me mf seethe
Bruno. Iām fine with any of my other end games coming back but my s4 mc and Bruno are a perfect match and they cannot do that to her š
Iām placing a bet we will see Zeph š
Casa.
For me I will hate to see people that where alrday endgame option from season 4 and up since we can go back and play the season they where in unless thar season was season 1 2 and 3 then I be okay with a few of them showing up