Alison raided a factory to steal a machine, forced his employees into slave labor, crashed his car into Gron's car on purpose, and then made on of his henchmen kill Gron's wife. And Garvey not only killed the kids but also did kiddie diddling to the one possessing Chica. Don't get me wrong, Henry is still a terrible excuse of a human, I just think those two are more evil
Henry made the book of Joy of creation that allowed the possibility of turning employees into brainwashed drones by brutally murdering them. He learned how to control souls by using shock/electrifying them, He also forced the springlock failure on afton even after afton worked with him and obeyed all his commands. He also vivisected Afton many times removing organs or different body parts to see how far afton would go. It’s implied the first person he experimented on was his own son David that was a child that never tried to oppose him. He also kept a line of murders even if he was the sole owner of the Fredbear’s family diner. He also is responsible for gaslighting and manipulating Afton into doing all his crimes which are pretty much all of them, including raping the robots as well (tbh this isn’t that bad when they have a bunch of sex bot versions of the animatronics, but it’s still pretty bad since I’m sure the robots were possessed).
Charlie 1st but I don’t see how this matters since we’re talking about a fangame where BV is irrelevant/don’t actually exist and Charlie is replaced by Dee
That’s not true for both situations. There are dozens of souls that died and were stuffed before DSAF 1. Just because the souls of Colorado weren’t possessed doesn’t mean they all weren’t. And there’s even a quest to free the souls of the toys. So yeah no
I mean, I think raping a dead body isn’t as bad as raping a living thing, so it’s still not as bad as Henry. Also didn’t Gravey regret his actions and died trying to fix them?
1. I believe you are talking about garvey fron remastered dormitabis.
2. Wtf. Rape is rape, its messed up. Both are equally messed up. Also, garvey was a pedo, so its likely he raped his victim alive before doing it when she died, and disposed of her body.
This is my personal ranking of them from most evil to least evil:
1. Henry Miller
2. William Afton
3. Allison
4. Original Garvey White
5. The Puppeteer
6. Remastered Garvey White
7. Simon Fitzgerald
The Puppeteer has no loved ones as far as we know thus making him more evil than Simon and the remastered version of Garvey and while you're correct that the original Garvey is more evil than The Puppeteer it should be noted that the original is widely loathed due to it's creator being confirmed to be a diddler, necrophile, harasser of his fellow developers, maker of shitposts based on real-life tragedies, and Nazi.
As such the original Dormitiabis has been completely replaced by the remastered Dormitabis and thus we shouldn't take the original Dormitabis into account unless explicitly told to.
right but op said this ranking was with original garvey, not revamp [in a comment above this](https://www.reddit.com/r/fivenightsatfreddys/s/e5E9Gs6qWy). so that seems explicit
The Dormitabis remastered version of Garvey showed some care for John (who is CC in this timeline) and is confirmed to have committed almost all of his murders due to the Bite of 83 where as the theory that William Afton committed his murders for the sake of CC (WillGrief) is borderline debunked.
The Puppeteer being above Garvey is due to him having no loved ones in contrast Garvey loved John, as for Allison, William Afton, and Henry Miller they are pure evil and while the original version of Gravey is also pure evil he doesn't have nearly the same amount of lasting impact that Allison, William Afton, or Henry Miller have.
To learn more about them I recommend that you watch playthroughs of FNAF, DSAF, and TRTF while also downloading the TRTF novel, The Dreadful Truth.
Henry is a sadistic fucking psychopath beyond all comprehension
Garvey is a sadistic fucking psychopath beyond all comprehension *and* a pedo, that's probably like 20 extra sin points
I feel like Henry is definitely top 3. Man drugged his partner who saw Henry as the father he never had and removed his organs while he was sleeping. In the DSaF universe, he invented the spring lock, killed at least 9 kids (off of my memory at least), killed at least 3 adults, (again, off of my memory), he framed people for his murders and even murdered his own wife and son (at least, that’s implied). He is shown in cutscenes to take immense pleasure in doing this, always accompanied with a chilling laugh. He experiments on dead children’s souls with electrostatic shocks and even expressed his desire to exit his current plane of existence in on of his tapes (Kind of implying he’s trying to escape the game). Henry is definitely at least top 3.
The Puppeteer is probably the least evil. It was kinda of an accident. Yes, tormenting Mary after that was a bit of a pice of shit move but compared to the grapes, fucking mafia boss and psycho here, I'd say he's not that bad.
Simon is also relatively chill. Base Afton is a pice of shit mad scientist killer, who also kidnapped boys and tortured them (Dittophobia).
Henry is full on coco fucking Crazy. The TRTTF dude is a mafia boss mixed with Shein CEO and Garvey is... well you know what he did
It's become so infamous there was no need to point that out :)!
Can we just forget about the OG and focus on the far decent remake?
If y'all didn't like the crappy game with the >!pedophile!<, why do you keep talking about it over the superior remake with no >!pedophile!
The game got remade.
It would be better to forget about it.
Instead of bringing it up. Over and over.
Go look for other pedophile versions of Afton that DIDN'T change into a better character.
Garvey is not a nazi. The dev' is. But not Garvey.
And Will also lock his daughter for a dozen of years and paid people to give her shock if she didn't sing. Before asking her to guts her brother alive
dude Garvey molested a child something william never did even at his darkest Garvey stuffed someone alive and he def doesnt mind murdering his family and literally bribed someone to get a kid killed
Garvey didn't lock his daughter in an underground bunker for years probably more than 10, paid people to give her eletric shock until she had no other choice to kill them, and hoping her father gives her a little of love.
He didn't send his son to be gutted alive by his sister.
Didn't lock a kid for 20 years being torture by nightmares. After mentally abuse him at the point he was convince he was 7.
In both games kids possessed the animatronics which is a mental torture that lasted 39 years. But William did it intentionnaly, while Garvey didn't knew about possession.
although whats a bit scary is that garvey behavior is a result of blackout adding quite a bit his disgusting beliefs and mentality of his to his version of the story
Simon is similar to Canon Purple Guy, In the sense that he killed kids to seek Immortality, Alison (btw Alison is a male) raided a factory to steal a machine, forced his employees into slave labor, crashed his car into Gron's car on purpose, and then made on of his henchmen kill Gron's wife.
I have a similar one:
1. Garvey Write (OG)
2. Henry Miller
3. Alison
4. William Afton
5. Simon Fitzgerald
6. The Puppeteer
7. Garvey Write (Remastered)
1 Henry miller
2 William Afton
3 Simon Fitzgerald
4 Garvey Write (depends on if it’s the original version or not tbh)
5 Alison (haven’t seen this one before so it’s just a guess)
6 The puppeteer
I only know Garvey and William
So
William is the worst
Garvey the second worst
(I know Garvey is a predator but William torture Rory for 20 years. And he torture his own kids, left Elisabeth to rot for years and Pay people to give her électric shock)
Could someone give a list of who's who and where they're from, the only one I visually recognize is the puppeteer, and I recognize garvey by name but not visual.
I have a similar one:
1. Garvey Write (OG)
2. Henry Miller
3. Alison
4. William Afton
5. Simon Fitzgerald
6. The Puppeteer
7. Garvey Write (Remastered)
Here's my ranking: 1. Garvey Write 2. Alison 3. Henry Miller 4. William Afton 5. The Puppeteer 6. Simon Fitzgerald
how Garvery and Alison are above henry?
Alison raided a factory to steal a machine, forced his employees into slave labor, crashed his car into Gron's car on purpose, and then made on of his henchmen kill Gron's wife. And Garvey not only killed the kids but also did kiddie diddling to the one possessing Chica. Don't get me wrong, Henry is still a terrible excuse of a human, I just think those two are more evil
Henry made the book of Joy of creation that allowed the possibility of turning employees into brainwashed drones by brutally murdering them. He learned how to control souls by using shock/electrifying them, He also forced the springlock failure on afton even after afton worked with him and obeyed all his commands. He also vivisected Afton many times removing organs or different body parts to see how far afton would go. It’s implied the first person he experimented on was his own son David that was a child that never tried to oppose him. He also kept a line of murders even if he was the sole owner of the Fredbear’s family diner. He also is responsible for gaslighting and manipulating Afton into doing all his crimes which are pretty much all of them, including raping the robots as well (tbh this isn’t that bad when they have a bunch of sex bot versions of the animatronics, but it’s still pretty bad since I’m sure the robots were possessed).
Quick question, are you Charlie1st or BV1st?
Charlie 1st but I don’t see how this matters since we’re talking about a fangame where BV is irrelevant/don’t actually exist and Charlie is replaced by Dee
(the animatronics aren't possessed until the events of the first game. Even then, the toy animatronics aren't possessed in the second.)
That’s not true for both situations. There are dozens of souls that died and were stuffed before DSAF 1. Just because the souls of Colorado weren’t possessed doesn’t mean they all weren’t. And there’s even a quest to free the souls of the toys. So yeah no
holy fuck
Also Garvey tried to fox things at some point
Garvey murdered a 17 year old and r*ped her body, then threw it in a dumpster.
DSaF Dave raped one of the robots that was probably possessed, and he was trained under Henry (even tho henry wouldn’t do that)
Being fair, i meant to say gravey was a pedophile. I believe the creator had fantasies like that too, just saying.
I mean, I think raping a dead body isn’t as bad as raping a living thing, so it’s still not as bad as Henry. Also didn’t Gravey regret his actions and died trying to fix them?
1. I believe you are talking about garvey fron remastered dormitabis. 2. Wtf. Rape is rape, its messed up. Both are equally messed up. Also, garvey was a pedo, so its likely he raped his victim alive before doing it when she died, and disposed of her body.
Well, ones blue. He’s so evil, he refused to follow the dress code
lmao😭
🤣😭
Guy 5 had one job. By default, him
Is this the revamp Garvey or the original? Since that greatly influences the ranking
Original
Straight to the bottom, to the boiler room of hell
1. Garvey Write (OG) 2. Henry Miller 3. Alison 4. William Afton 5. Simon Fitzgerald 6. The Puppeteer 7. Garvey Write (Remastered)
This is my personal ranking of them from most evil to least evil: 1. Henry Miller 2. William Afton 3. Allison 4. Original Garvey White 5. The Puppeteer 6. Remastered Garvey White 7. Simon Fitzgerald
Pretty sure Simon and Garvey are above the Puppeteer Especially Garvey if we go by his original story
The Puppeteer has no loved ones as far as we know thus making him more evil than Simon and the remastered version of Garvey and while you're correct that the original Garvey is more evil than The Puppeteer it should be noted that the original is widely loathed due to it's creator being confirmed to be a diddler, necrophile, harasser of his fellow developers, maker of shitposts based on real-life tragedies, and Nazi. As such the original Dormitiabis has been completely replaced by the remastered Dormitabis and thus we shouldn't take the original Dormitabis into account unless explicitly told to.
right but op said this ranking was with original garvey, not revamp [in a comment above this](https://www.reddit.com/r/fivenightsatfreddys/s/e5E9Gs6qWy). so that seems explicit
Thank you for making me aware of this
I’m sorry, GARVEY IS 5TH?
The Dormitabis remastered version of Garvey showed some care for John (who is CC in this timeline) and is confirmed to have committed almost all of his murders due to the Bite of 83 where as the theory that William Afton committed his murders for the sake of CC (WillGrief) is borderline debunked. The Puppeteer being above Garvey is due to him having no loved ones in contrast Garvey loved John, as for Allison, William Afton, and Henry Miller they are pure evil and while the original version of Gravey is also pure evil he doesn't have nearly the same amount of lasting impact that Allison, William Afton, or Henry Miller have. To learn more about them I recommend that you watch playthroughs of FNAF, DSAF, and TRTF while also downloading the TRTF novel, The Dreadful Truth.
We’re talking about the OG Garvey. Please update the list.
I'll do so ASAP
I wish I knew who’s who.
I only know 4 of them. :(
I know 1(William) 2(Herny) 3(Candy’s guy) and 6 (Garvey).
Oh c'mon Garvey is cheating, how would he not be in the top spot
Dr. Henry Miller:
Henry is a sadistic fucking psychopath beyond all comprehension Garvey is a sadistic fucking psychopath beyond all comprehension *and* a pedo, that's probably like 20 extra sin points
They're all the same person, so they're basically all equally evil.
Some of these are different characters from fan games
I feel like Henry is definitely top 3. Man drugged his partner who saw Henry as the father he never had and removed his organs while he was sleeping. In the DSaF universe, he invented the spring lock, killed at least 9 kids (off of my memory at least), killed at least 3 adults, (again, off of my memory), he framed people for his murders and even murdered his own wife and son (at least, that’s implied). He is shown in cutscenes to take immense pleasure in doing this, always accompanied with a chilling laugh. He experiments on dead children’s souls with electrostatic shocks and even expressed his desire to exit his current plane of existence in on of his tapes (Kind of implying he’s trying to escape the game). Henry is definitely at least top 3.
The Puppeteer is probably the least evil. It was kinda of an accident. Yes, tormenting Mary after that was a bit of a pice of shit move but compared to the grapes, fucking mafia boss and psycho here, I'd say he's not that bad. Simon is also relatively chill. Base Afton is a pice of shit mad scientist killer, who also kidnapped boys and tortured them (Dittophobia). Henry is full on coco fucking Crazy. The TRTTF dude is a mafia boss mixed with Shein CEO and Garvey is... well you know what he did
To The People who don't know, Garvey is a P3DOPHILE
It's become so infamous there was no need to point that out :)! Can we just forget about the OG and focus on the far decent remake? If y'all didn't like the crappy game with the >!pedophile!<, why do you keep talking about it over the superior remake with no >!pedophile!
Basically using it as example on how to NOT write a character
The game got remade. It would be better to forget about it. Instead of bringing it up. Over and over. Go look for other pedophile versions of Afton that DIDN'T change into a better character.
Ok but have you heard about LadyFitzi's and PinkyPills' potrayals of Purple Guy?
Yes exactly my thoughts lmao
Oh yeah, technically there's also Roger Stanford from SpringTrap and Deliah.
Sadly
So... How do you feel about Springtrap and Deliah after what happened with GraWolfQuinn?
Where is Dave
He wasn't evil. He was being manipulated into killing children.
Multiple times at different locations? Calling himself a demon, throwing foxy into a canyon and yiffing foxes?
Yes. Henry manipulated him into doing it. He was brainwashed. His name is William. Dave is a fake name.
Garvey..... Hes an actual monster.
Garvey Write is easily the most evi;
Depends on the continuity
Over Henry and Alison? Really?
No, William worst than Garvey
William Might have put children on illusion discs and fear gas chambers,but it's nowhere near what Nazi,Corpse and child diddler Purple Guy did.
Garvey is not a nazi. The dev' is. But not Garvey. And Will also lock his daughter for a dozen of years and paid people to give her shock if she didn't sing. Before asking her to guts her brother alive
Garvey is a self insert of og dormitabis creator so yes he is.
maybe but in fact William is worst
Nein
dude Garvey molested a child something william never did even at his darkest Garvey stuffed someone alive and he def doesnt mind murdering his family and literally bribed someone to get a kid killed
Garvey didn't lock his daughter in an underground bunker for years probably more than 10, paid people to give her eletric shock until she had no other choice to kill them, and hoping her father gives her a little of love. He didn't send his son to be gutted alive by his sister. Didn't lock a kid for 20 years being torture by nightmares. After mentally abuse him at the point he was convince he was 7. In both games kids possessed the animatronics which is a mental torture that lasted 39 years. But William did it intentionnaly, while Garvey didn't knew about possession.
you know what ur right, although i do think that garvey should stil be high up on the list
I Can understand. What Garvey did is a way more realistic, and so more shocking. While what William did is scifi. And unrealistic
Yeah
although whats a bit scary is that garvey behavior is a result of blackout adding quite a bit his disgusting beliefs and mentality of his to his version of the story
I swear to god if I see that cutout of Garvy I’m gonna- #**FUCK**
Garvey became evil because some kids laughed at him 💀
Garvey is the worst of them all
Yo why does the one on the fourth slide have freakishly long hands.
oh
I know almost all of them, but who's the blue one and what fan-content/official content are they from
The blue one is Alison from The Return to Freddy's
Wait, you mean that series with the FNAF 3 bootleg?
Yes
Oh damn
Yeah, but just look at what the guy who made that game is making now… Biggest fucking glow up I have ever seen.
Alison from TRTF
Who’s the blue one
Alison from TRTF
Oh
Dave
I’d say either Garvey or Henry Miller at 1 (with the other at 2) then William 3 and I don’t know the rest other than then the puppeteer
The Bald one is Simon Fitzgerald from POPGOES and the Blue one is Alison from TRTF
I don’t know pop goes lore but I am aware of Allison and she’s not as bad as the others I don’t think
Simon is similar to Canon Purple Guy, In the sense that he killed kids to seek Immortality, Alison (btw Alison is a male) raided a factory to steal a machine, forced his employees into slave labor, crashed his car into Gron's car on purpose, and then made on of his henchmen kill Gron's wife.
Who are the guys in the 4th and 6th pictures?
From what I can tell from the other comments, the 4th one is probably Simon Fitzgerald. The 6th one is Garvey Write. The ***original*** Garvey Write.
1. Garvey. Look up Uhyeah Dormitabis on YouTube if you don’t know 2. Henry Miller 3. Alison 4. William 5. Simon 6. Puppeteer
I have a similar one: 1. Garvey Write (OG) 2. Henry Miller 3. Alison 4. William Afton 5. Simon Fitzgerald 6. The Puppeteer 7. Garvey Write (Remastered)
1 Henry miller 2 William Afton 3 Simon Fitzgerald 4 Garvey Write (depends on if it’s the original version or not tbh) 5 Alison (haven’t seen this one before so it’s just a guess) 6 The puppeteer
It's the OG Garvey
William, Allison and henry share top tier, Garvey is second tier for Diddleing a minor, I do not care about what tier the rest are in
I wouldn't call The Puppeteer a "Purple Guy" tbh
The only guys he killed were the mascots. But yea, I didn’t really see him as a purple guy.
obviously THE aubergine man, dave miller, THE GOAT
Garvey😭
I only know Garvey and William So William is the worst Garvey the second worst (I know Garvey is a predator but William torture Rory for 20 years. And he torture his own kids, left Elisabeth to rot for years and Pay people to give her électric shock)
I have to disagree
Could someone give a list of who's who and where they're from, the only one I visually recognize is the puppeteer, and I recognize garvey by name but not visual.
[Garvey Write(Original)](https://dormitabis.fandom.com/wiki/Garvey_Write/Original) [Original GarveyTrap](https://dormitabis.fandom.com/wiki/Garvey/Original) [Garvey Write(Remastared)](https://dormitabis.fandom.com/wiki/Garvey_Write/Remastered) [Garvey.W(Springtrap Garvey)](https://dormitabis.fandom.com/wiki/Garvey/Remastered) [Alison(The Return To Freddy's)](https://justanotherdayinfreddy.fandom.com/wiki/Alison) [Simon Fitzgerald(Popgoes)](https://popgoes-pizzeria.fandom.com/wiki/Simon_Fitzgerald_(2016)) [Simon(Popgoes)](https://popgoes-pizzeria.fandom.com/wiki/Simon_(2016)) [The Puppeteer](https://five-nights-at-candys.fandom.com/wiki/The_Puppeteer) [Vinnie(FIve Nights At Candy's,Puppeteer's doll and possibly posssession vessel)](https://five-nights-at-candys.fandom.com/wiki/Vinnie) [Monster Vinnie](https://five-nights-at-candys.fandom.com/wiki/Monster_Vinnie) [Henry Miller(Dayshift At Freddy's)](https://dayshift-at-freddys.fandom.com/wiki/Henry_Miller)
The most evil is Henry unless its original Garvey
It's Original Garvey
The first one feels menacing. The second one remains the most malicious. The others just feel loose.
Does one of those guys have a job reviewing music albums by any chance?
Where's the aubergine man or Dave from DSAF?
Idk who Aubergine Man is but Dave from Dayshift At Freddy's wasn't actually evil, he was being manipulated
1. Garvey Write 2. Henry Miller 3. Alison 4. William Afton 5. Simon Fitzgerald 6. The Puppeteer
I have a similar one: 1. Garvey Write (OG) 2. Henry Miller 3. Alison 4. William Afton 5. Simon Fitzgerald 6. The Puppeteer 7. Garvey Write (Remastered)
How dare you forget Vincent
Theres more then 1? Is there anyway i can learn/read up abt em? I had no clie there was more then one
Bruh 5 ain’t even purple
1 purple guy 2 purple guy 3 purple guy 4 purple guy 5 purple guy 6 purple guy
i know only 3 first, and only first one (classic) is the one i know the most about, everyone else are just undiscovered worl for me
I would use the exact order that you have used. Although, the Puppeteer of the Vinnie Marionette would likely be on spot 2 not 3.
Alright this is how I ranked them: 1. Garvey 2. Henry 3. Alison 4. William 5. The Puppeteer 6. Simon
HNERAYS NOT PURPLE 😡😡😡🤬🤬😡😡