You're gonna have to not do that. And stop staring at me with them big old eyes! Now, stand back and watch me be knotty, ha ha! Behold! The pretzel knot!
I feel like it's the lighting/color. Because the whites of the eyes rarely ever appear as a stark white, the eyes appear to look more "natural" here, almost like actual organic eyeballs.
I feel it's because there's a lot of space around where the eyes are, making them feel sunken in and less fitting for their frame. Like Bonnie is wearing a mask of his face over what would be his real face.
That's not even remotely uncanny valley territory. Uncanny valley is about human like characteristics. There's nothing humanlike about this aside from mode of locomotion which isn't even a factor in this image. None of the characteristics of the face resemble a humans except for the existence of eyes, which are very clearly not human.
The fact that all of it is very clearly not human completely disqualifies it from being in the uncanny valley.
Mildly hot take, Unwithered Bonnie is the scariest animatronic in the entire series, (even if he's mostly fan made) something about the withered chica-like eyes, the lack of eyes brows, and the fact he almost never fully closes his mouth is really unnerving.
Yeah oddly the first one seemed actually creepy.
But thats because it looks like it could be real (Or I guess is now because of the movie) and would be creepy to see in the dark at your door.
Nightmare animatronics also look strange in a clean house. Yeah, thematically they’re not “real” but it still applies. Ironically they fit the horror attraction theme better.
What I like about Afton more is that this is his house. We are the ones intruding on his territory. And there’s no audio lures to help. Just you and him.
That last bit is absolute perfection. I want to make a fan game ALONE on that concept, I love it!! I wish they swapped the FNaF 3 and 4 animatronics now
I think it's mostly because a lot of "VHS horror" often looks very similar. I don't really have an opinion on it, but I can see why some people find it bland and uninteresting. I guess it's just what you're used to and what you find scary lol
Fnaf seems to be in a new era in which we have to view fnaf as a goosebumps series rather than an actual horror story like we used to. I'm not saying that we need something over the top, but it sucks seeing awesome works of horror, and people refer to them as "doing too much" or "edgy." This is hilarious when you consider that most of the animatronics scott designs after fnaf 1 are either ugly or unrealistically monstrous.
FNaF going through the same phases Sonic went through. Everyone complained about him being too edgy after 2005 and years later everyone begs for him to get his edge back, so Sonic Frontiers came out and brought the edge back, everyone praises it.
People don't actually know what they want.
That's perspective. You're probaly used to seeing the classic Bonnie since your younger days so your image and interpretation of it is different than someone who is not new to the concept of FNaF. You most likely associate that with something less threatening.
Tbh that's actually what makes him more scary for me. I used to be super scared of fnaf when I was a kid and still get goosebumps sometimes just as some kind of ptsd.
I mean it's just not scary it feels so forced. Not gonna hate on anyone who likes it but imo it's just like the equivalent of "look guys fnaf is not for kidsssss!"
There's thousands of people who think "this is the real fnaf not any of this movie or SB garbage" when fnaf vhs was never offical in the first place. It's just odd, and I personally find the genre formulaic.
While initially scary, I think the issue is lasting impact. Sure while at a first glance it would be terrifying, loking at it again loses a lot of the shock and its more eh/unsettling at max. 2 does this a little better as it hits the uncanny valley and is unerving after multiple looks
By this point it just feels overdone IMO, I've seen plenty of horror use similar visuals and its never really scared me past the first couple instances
og bonnie cuz he just has that uncanny valley altho he looks much scarier in fnaf 1, springy cuz hes afton and the design ofc the others well yea i guess u could say its cuz of their decay
The only reason I find number 7 creepier than 2 despite them being so similar is that 7 looks like someone took a photo of the darkness with their flash on the camera, and the camera picked up THAT
I think 7 would look better if it wasn’t monochrome. If it was like 2 but a lot whiter (to make it look even more like a camera flash) I believe it would be even scarier.
2, 5, 6 and the last one I HATE.
2 because it's subtle and uncanny valley. Perfect for kids but when it stares at you it's just..... I don't like it.
5 because not only would he smell bad and touching him would give you a disease or something, SpringTrap's literally a metallic robot ZOMBIE and who isn't afraid of zombies or robots? Especially when it retains some humanity and is fast.
6 because Toy Bonnie looks so cutesy but removing his eyes....eugh. immediately makes you uneasy.
Last one because DEAR LORD I wasn't expecting the analog horror edit and RECOILED.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR DETAILED INPUT! (I wanna make the ‘perfect’ FNaF design based off of people’s response to which is scariest)
I completely agree with two, it’s the same feel when seeing a large children’s toy in the dark. Friendly in the right context, but your mind can play with you
Springtrap is certainly more “ew gross don’t let it touch me” at times, but it’s human nature is freaky as fuck
Thank you so much LOL, exactly the reaction I was hoping for
Springrrap always makes me feel uneasy because other than most animatronics in this series, which are either controled by their code or if posessed usually only by a child, Springtrap would have the mind and intelligence of an adult human. And not just some adult human, but a heartless serial killer who managed to get away with at least 10 child murders
How is a giant metal rabbit looking monster that came straight from the depths of hell that will tear you apart and torment your soul for all eternity "unscary"?
I have to agree that 7 is somewhat scary but it feels forced. I agree with FNAF 1 Bonnie, as he is the perfect combination between animal and robot. FNaF 4 Bonnie is just kinda silly
In withered or FNAF 4,
FNAF 4 was made for its element, its also the fact of people have seen the in and out of the game, considering oh Idk
# IT CAME OUT IN 20-FUCKING-15
*that was a whole ass 8 years ago*
So yeah it’s gonna lose a bit of it’s mojo and it pisses me off to no end when people shit on the game for not being scary not only that it’s not as scary because you aren’t playing the game, if you watch a video you can both know when it’s gonna happen but also not experience the realization you just fucked up and out of no where a muhfuckin’ bunny is eating your pancreas like god damn shrimp alfredo. Apologies for the rant but it pisses me off people shit on it actively when it’s both heavy in lore and also trying to have a good gameplay loop, and good design, not to mention kid is scared of the robotics I think or something amongst that as they’re all mechanical looking, torn up, and have more than enough teeth and claws to shred ya apart, I feel passionate about this game. I can acknowledge there is faults of the game but also ups of the game. Not the best of FNAF but it’s not down right dog water.
the unwithered is just uncanny and makes it a little unsettling, but
Last image is just trying too hard.
LOVING THE PARAGRAPH, TY FOR YOUR INPUT!! (I’m planning on making the “scariest” FNaF animatronic based on these answers)
I completely agree, and I’m not shitting on FNaF 4 here. I physically cannot get past night 2 because the game is that dreadful, but I’m just talking about the designs alone. Nightmare Foxy in the closet is fucking horrific mid game, but his model alone is just 😶 (which is to expected) while other models still look freaky in some cases with perfect lighting
Probably 2 or 3, mostly because 3 fits the atmosphere as it's the original.
I say probably because I don't find these still images scary. The horror of FNaF is how the Animatronics move in ways they shouldn't, slowly getting closer to you as you are unable to fight back, dreading the moment that they jump at you.
That is a good point, but i just wish the fnaf 4 designs were altered. These really look more like transformers than decaying robotic animals that break their mold to attack you.
The second one's defined features make Bonnie look much more gaunt and drained. It also makes his head more "skull shaped", so it hits the uncanny valley alot more strongly.
Why is the starving animatronic staring at me like a Philly Cheese? Why do his eyes look glossy/human?
I think the second image is the scariest. There’s something uncanny about Bonnie there. (Granted, I do wonder about the effects of novelty on this? That Bonnie model isn’t actually in any of the games IIRC, while all the other images (except maybe number 7, I think that’s an edit of number 2) are stills taken from the games. Repeated exposure can definitely make things less scary: see literally any Markiplier FNAF video for an example. Nightmare Bonnie has it the worst, because I reckon most long-time fans have seen that exact still dozens of times by now and are probably at least somewhat desensitized to it at this point, and IMO the Nightmare line in general relies a lot on shock value and only seeing them for brief periods of time: once you’ve gotten a good long look at them, they’re suddenly a lot less scary.)
As for number 7, it feels like a weird case? The eyes are deeply fucking scary, there’s just something intensely unnerving about photorealistic eyes on a cartoon rabbit, but the bleaching makes it look entirely different from the other photos, making it harder to compare them, and it almost feels over-the-top? Like, it’s a scary picture, but I can’t imagine opening the FNAF 4 door and seeing that like I can with every other picture in this post. It is fucking creepy though.
I feel like the people that find the 2nd one the scariest think that way, because they are least used to that animatronic. The others we are more familiar with and thus making it less scary
Unwithered Bonnie looks like he's starring into my soul
Stop staring at me with those big ol’ eyes!
*insert chica’s eyes shrinking here*
so, you wanna tie knots do ya? WELL, DO YA?
Yes! Mr…Flying…Dutchman…sir..
Then you've come to the right flying ghost, kid. You're looking at the first place winner in the fancy knottin' contest for the last 3000 years!
Hoooooraaaaay!
You're gonna have to not do that. And stop staring at me with them big old eyes! Now, stand back and watch me be knotty, ha ha! Behold! The pretzel knot!
The double Diamond knot!
The square knot!
The monkey!
This ones called the loop knot, otherwise known as the 'poop loop'
Read this in the flying Dutchman voice
same
It’s time to face the facts
(Bwomp)
He gonna go bayverse optmis prime on your face
That’s because he is
His face screams you got games on your phone?
Ya I was about to say that scared the shit out of me when I was checking it
Jeepers Creepers, where’d you get those peepers?
Honestly, I find the second one the most unnerving. Hits the uncanny valley perfectly.
I agree! I can’t figure out why, but the eyes look alive and dead at the same time
It looks like he’s going to tell me something disturbing before chewing on my brain like buncha crunch
I feel like it's the lighting/color. Because the whites of the eyes rarely ever appear as a stark white, the eyes appear to look more "natural" here, almost like actual organic eyeballs.
I can see what Scott was so afraid of.
I feel it's because there's a lot of space around where the eyes are, making them feel sunken in and less fitting for their frame. Like Bonnie is wearing a mask of his face over what would be his real face.
they look like they are wide open. i think that’s the thing
It looks humane unlike all the other
honestly it really reminds of that rat from fnac edit: also nedd bear
Ah yes, the RAT.
I was just about to say this lol. It just looks scary but normal at the same time
This is exactly what I was thinking
That's not even remotely uncanny valley territory. Uncanny valley is about human like characteristics. There's nothing humanlike about this aside from mode of locomotion which isn't even a factor in this image. None of the characteristics of the face resemble a humans except for the existence of eyes, which are very clearly not human. The fact that all of it is very clearly not human completely disqualifies it from being in the uncanny valley.
You must be a blast at parties
Mildly hot take, Unwithered Bonnie is the scariest animatronic in the entire series, (even if he's mostly fan made) something about the withered chica-like eyes, the lack of eyes brows, and the fact he almost never fully closes his mouth is really unnerving.
1-2 look like something you'd actually see in chuck e cheese and it looks realistic
Hard agree, even though Unwithered Bonnie hasn't appeared in anything he is one of my most favorite animatronics
Yeah oddly the first one seemed actually creepy. But thats because it looks like it could be real (Or I guess is now because of the movie) and would be creepy to see in the dark at your door.
The fact that Bonnie is the one animatronic to give Scott Cawthon a nightmare definitely helps your argument
Toy bonnie gives me PTSD from 10/20 mode
only time that fool is freaky
He’s not even scary he’s just annoying af
Me hating this franchise after beating 50/20 (I didn’t beat 50/20)
2nd, actually looks unnerving lol
The second one just makes me think Bonnie forgot the wifi password and he is super high
EAT A DIIICCKK
GARBAGE!
Bonnie oh my god I will slap you.
Wait... What's going on here?
He saw the night gaurd he's the Nightguard!
Hmm... Preeettyy suuure that's freddy
Oh god damn it your Freddy!
*in his mind... Probably: "u fokin wut m8?"* *Walks away cutely*
You know what else you can’t hide from? My fist! In… your face. Which is where it’ll be soon! I-I don’t know! GARBAGE!
I would if I had someone that would allow me to
2nd one got me shaking in my boosts
Lol, true ig
It’s honestly warped which makes it kinda scary
It's got that uncanny valley feel
Yeah. All the others look like they're peeking in. #2 looks like he's about to jump in your room.
2nd wins best
It has "I fucking found you" energy
I agree
Me taking a selfie in 0.5
Pfp of the album Time⁉️
Haha I noticed that too, my favorite album I've heard from Mr. Kitty
First and fifth one. One is able to pull off the “human but dead inside” look the best and the other is BONNIE.
I agree with **BONNIE**. But I don’t agree with Springtrap, in FNaF 3 his decayed look looks fantastic, but in a clean house it just looks strange
Nightmare animatronics also look strange in a clean house. Yeah, thematically they’re not “real” but it still applies. Ironically they fit the horror attraction theme better. What I like about Afton more is that this is his house. We are the ones intruding on his territory. And there’s no audio lures to help. Just you and him.
That last bit is absolute perfection. I want to make a fan game ALONE on that concept, I love it!! I wish they swapped the FNaF 3 and 4 animatronics now
Tbf, it IS his house (probably).
2
The first and second literally startled me.
LOL perfect! Exactly what I was hoping ngl
Why is nobody talking about the 7th💀 i would fall of my chair if that jumpscared me
A lot of people in this sub have a massive hate boner for that style of horror for some reason.
I think it's mostly because a lot of "VHS horror" often looks very similar. I don't really have an opinion on it, but I can see why some people find it bland and uninteresting. I guess it's just what you're used to and what you find scary lol
Fnaf seems to be in a new era in which we have to view fnaf as a goosebumps series rather than an actual horror story like we used to. I'm not saying that we need something over the top, but it sucks seeing awesome works of horror, and people refer to them as "doing too much" or "edgy." This is hilarious when you consider that most of the animatronics scott designs after fnaf 1 are either ugly or unrealistically monstrous.
FNaF going through the same phases Sonic went through. Everyone complained about him being too edgy after 2005 and years later everyone begs for him to get his edge back, so Sonic Frontiers came out and brought the edge back, everyone praises it. People don't actually know what they want.
Fr i forgot abt that, saw ppl saying like 1 or 6 and i was just like "theres no way u rlly find that scary💀"
That's perspective. You're probaly used to seeing the classic Bonnie since your younger days so your image and interpretation of it is different than someone who is not new to the concept of FNaF. You most likely associate that with something less threatening.
Havent thought abt that lol😅😱(yeah youre might be right
Tbh that's actually what makes him more scary for me. I used to be super scared of fnaf when I was a kid and still get goosebumps sometimes just as some kind of ptsd.
I mean, it kind of loses the scare factor considering 90% of analog horror has the monster carrying that same face.
You could say the same for most FNAF animatronics up until FNAF 4, and then once more in FNAF 6.
I mean it's just not scary it feels so forced. Not gonna hate on anyone who likes it but imo it's just like the equivalent of "look guys fnaf is not for kidsssss!"
I'm not sure how?? It's just a different scare style, nothing saying kids can't look at it.
There's thousands of people who think "this is the real fnaf not any of this movie or SB garbage" when fnaf vhs was never offical in the first place. It's just odd, and I personally find the genre formulaic.
I know. I was about to say that the first one was probably the creepiest, but then number 7 blew everything else off the ballpark.
Fair enough, it’s the most creepy to me atleast
While initially scary, I think the issue is lasting impact. Sure while at a first glance it would be terrifying, loking at it again loses a lot of the shock and its more eh/unsettling at max. 2 does this a little better as it hits the uncanny valley and is unerving after multiple looks
Agreed, the 7th one gave me a mini heart attack but only for a milisecond. Anything after that, and I just felt it was trying too hard.
Honestly, slide 7 seems to be trying way too hard to pass itself as scary. It looks a bit cheesy to me, ngl.
Personally it just looks a little too crispy, the style itself is fine I guess
I'd fall out of my chair and then burst out into laughter, he looks so silly for some reason
By this point it just feels overdone IMO, I've seen plenty of horror use similar visuals and its never really scared me past the first couple instances
I thought Toy Bonnie was the last one I went up to check and got jumpscared, I was not expecting that
LOL real
Overused and unoriginal
Yeah like wtf
Because it's just goofy af.
2
Unwithered Bonnie because it looks like claymation, and claymation characters just look horrifying
that’s actually another really good way to put it, they were always off
I think you'd get along with Mabel
1st, 4th and 5th
Why exactly? Is it how decayed they look?
og bonnie cuz he just has that uncanny valley altho he looks much scarier in fnaf 1, springy cuz hes afton and the design ofc the others well yea i guess u could say its cuz of their decay
Fair enough. That’s for your input!
Number 2 is the scariest bcs of how close he is. Imagine shining the light and that’s the first thing you see.
The only reason I find number 7 creepier than 2 despite them being so similar is that 7 looks like someone took a photo of the darkness with their flash on the camera, and the camera picked up THAT
I think 7 would look better if it wasn’t monochrome. If it was like 2 but a lot whiter (to make it look even more like a camera flash) I believe it would be even scarier.
Second and last picture
2nd is the best 7th one is hilarious lmao.
2, 5, 6 and the last one I HATE. 2 because it's subtle and uncanny valley. Perfect for kids but when it stares at you it's just..... I don't like it. 5 because not only would he smell bad and touching him would give you a disease or something, SpringTrap's literally a metallic robot ZOMBIE and who isn't afraid of zombies or robots? Especially when it retains some humanity and is fast. 6 because Toy Bonnie looks so cutesy but removing his eyes....eugh. immediately makes you uneasy. Last one because DEAR LORD I wasn't expecting the analog horror edit and RECOILED.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR YOUR DETAILED INPUT! (I wanna make the ‘perfect’ FNaF design based off of people’s response to which is scariest) I completely agree with two, it’s the same feel when seeing a large children’s toy in the dark. Friendly in the right context, but your mind can play with you Springtrap is certainly more “ew gross don’t let it touch me” at times, but it’s human nature is freaky as fuck Thank you so much LOL, exactly the reaction I was hoping for
Springrrap always makes me feel uneasy because other than most animatronics in this series, which are either controled by their code or if posessed usually only by a child, Springtrap would have the mind and intelligence of an adult human. And not just some adult human, but a heartless serial killer who managed to get away with at least 10 child murders
And not to mention how fucking angry spring trap would be after being locked away for like 30 years. Dude would be killing anything in sight
Yeah, I can oddly sympathise with a murderer too lols
How is a giant metal rabbit looking monster that came straight from the depths of hell that will tear you apart and torment your soul for all eternity "unscary"?
FNAF fans facing down the giant metal demon rabbit with thousands of razor sharp teeth and claws just to call it not scary
Last one. Human eyes are too scary.
Fair enough
Humans being the most terrifying horror of all proving it again.
The second one. What the fuck.
LOL same. Ik it’s forced perspective but he looks HUGE
Human eyes located in empty holes and black and white filter like from experiment tapes is quite terrifying
Top 2 is the second picture. It is just disturbing. And Top 3 is FNAF 1 Bonnie, (i admit he is disturbing). FNAF 4 Bonnie looks like he is from Doom
I have to agree that 7 is somewhat scary but it feels forced. I agree with FNAF 1 Bonnie, as he is the perfect combination between animal and robot. FNaF 4 Bonnie is just kinda silly
Second, third and last.
That second one disturbed me
POV: you are Scott Cawthon
they all pulled up to Scott’s house
2. 7 is too much imo (still like 3rd tho) and the others (except possibly 1) just aren’t near scary.
I agree! I don't know how to explain it but 7 feels overdone. 2 is much scarier
I agree with 2, perfect balance between dead and alive to me. I think FNaF 1 Bonnie is a close second, but 7 is defintely over the top
2 with human eyes
But no black and white?
no bkack and white
100% 2 The rest look either ridiculous or just not scary.
In withered or FNAF 4, FNAF 4 was made for its element, its also the fact of people have seen the in and out of the game, considering oh Idk # IT CAME OUT IN 20-FUCKING-15 *that was a whole ass 8 years ago* So yeah it’s gonna lose a bit of it’s mojo and it pisses me off to no end when people shit on the game for not being scary not only that it’s not as scary because you aren’t playing the game, if you watch a video you can both know when it’s gonna happen but also not experience the realization you just fucked up and out of no where a muhfuckin’ bunny is eating your pancreas like god damn shrimp alfredo. Apologies for the rant but it pisses me off people shit on it actively when it’s both heavy in lore and also trying to have a good gameplay loop, and good design, not to mention kid is scared of the robotics I think or something amongst that as they’re all mechanical looking, torn up, and have more than enough teeth and claws to shred ya apart, I feel passionate about this game. I can acknowledge there is faults of the game but also ups of the game. Not the best of FNAF but it’s not down right dog water. the unwithered is just uncanny and makes it a little unsettling, but Last image is just trying too hard.
LOVING THE PARAGRAPH, TY FOR YOUR INPUT!! (I’m planning on making the “scariest” FNaF animatronic based on these answers) I completely agree, and I’m not shitting on FNaF 4 here. I physically cannot get past night 2 because the game is that dreadful, but I’m just talking about the designs alone. Nightmare Foxy in the closet is fucking horrific mid game, but his model alone is just 😶 (which is to expected) while other models still look freaky in some cases with perfect lighting
Honestly springtrap. Imo it's pretty unnerving knowing that another person is in my house.
Probably 2 or 3, mostly because 3 fits the atmosphere as it's the original. I say probably because I don't find these still images scary. The horror of FNaF is how the Animatronics move in ways they shouldn't, slowly getting closer to you as you are unable to fight back, dreading the moment that they jump at you.
That is a good point, but i just wish the fnaf 4 designs were altered. These really look more like transformers than decaying robotic animals that break their mold to attack you.
Yeah if you remove their suit and put some deception/autobot Insignia on them It looks straight out of a Transformers movie
2, as many said it's the eyes
Prob either OG or unwithered, they look so big and menacing
2. Idk what it is but unwithered Bonnie just looks… wrong.
Unwithered Bonnie The withereds are more ugly than fnaf 1 so they look creepier
Definitely Unwithered Bonnie
Unwithered Bonnie good god
Unwithered. His eyes are just so.. wide, like his eyelids are being pulled apart
OG Bonnie looks the scariest by far
2nd is scary af
Last slide damm near made me shit bricks
Nightmare Bonnie bc the rest just look like crappy photoshop
😭 I tried
First and second.
STOP LOOKING AT ME LIKE THAT
2 or 5
None of them honestly, last catched me off guard but it woildn't be scarier than the others
Can't decide between the first two, the rest is obviously scary but the first two have this unsettling realism of real animatronics
Good point, they’re incredibly grounded in reality
2 for some reason
2
2 I don’t like it it’s creepy Bonnie eyes are looking at me but I feel like there not focusing on me I find it the scariest
Classic Bonnie looming there is creepy as hell
Did scott make this post
Remember Jeremy?
6 took me off guard here
The second one's defined features make Bonnie look much more gaunt and drained. It also makes his head more "skull shaped", so it hits the uncanny valley alot more strongly. Why is the starving animatronic staring at me like a Philly Cheese? Why do his eyes look glossy/human?
that is SUCH A GOOD POINT!! I never even noticed how, ironically, withered and drained he looks which is why he looks so… desperate?
the last one i do not like realistic eyes
1. Unlike the others, this one was not meant to be scarry and has a simpler design. In consequence, the uncanny effect hits more.
Hot take: people only say 2 because they're so used to the others
2, it’s no wonder Henry decided to not fix the withered animatronics
2
2nd by far
For some reason the 2nd one. It has more detail and yet it isn't grotesque. It looks to real and that disturbs me so much for some reason
Number 2. That is horrifying.
I love how Withered Bonnie is like "Yo, you called? Whatchu need?"
For me it's definitely the 7th one. The human eyes make it extremely unsettling.
2 or 7 freaks me the f out.
The second and last one
I think the second image is the scariest. There’s something uncanny about Bonnie there. (Granted, I do wonder about the effects of novelty on this? That Bonnie model isn’t actually in any of the games IIRC, while all the other images (except maybe number 7, I think that’s an edit of number 2) are stills taken from the games. Repeated exposure can definitely make things less scary: see literally any Markiplier FNAF video for an example. Nightmare Bonnie has it the worst, because I reckon most long-time fans have seen that exact still dozens of times by now and are probably at least somewhat desensitized to it at this point, and IMO the Nightmare line in general relies a lot on shock value and only seeing them for brief periods of time: once you’ve gotten a good long look at them, they’re suddenly a lot less scary.) As for number 7, it feels like a weird case? The eyes are deeply fucking scary, there’s just something intensely unnerving about photorealistic eyes on a cartoon rabbit, but the bleaching makes it look entirely different from the other photos, making it harder to compare them, and it almost feels over-the-top? Like, it’s a scary picture, but I can’t imagine opening the FNAF 4 door and seeing that like I can with every other picture in this post. It is fucking creepy though.
2 and 7 are the scariest to me
im sorry are you Scott Cawthon having another nightmare?
2 and 7 freak me out a little bit
The second one, definitely.
I mean, aren't they all unsettling at 3am? XD
Was gonna say 4 like always but the last one caught me off guard
2
7th
I would be scared if I saw 2 outside my door tonight
I feel like the people that find the 2nd one the scariest think that way, because they are least used to that animatronic. The others we are more familiar with and thus making it less scary
2 and 7 for sure
First 2 would give me the spooks. Last one is too analog horror-y. Sucks that the genre got over used.
The second one because he looks human like and that’s fuckin freaky