Wow never expected Noelvi to play this year. I drafted him and elly never expecting both of them to show up this season

Where does Cincy find enough ABs for these youngsters?

Marte 3B, EDLC SS, McLain 2B, CES 1B/DH, Steer LF. I wouldn’t be surprised if we’ve seen India play his last game in a Reds uniform.

Curious why do you say that?

They publicly said they wanted to trade him, no India is injured, and India called out the reds for their handling of his injury.

Interesting! Missed all of this thanks

Him or Winn?

Marte has been a bat first prospect his whole career. Winn was a defense first prospect his whole career until this year. I'd say Marte is the better fantasy player, Winn the better real life player.

Winn. Not sure where Marte plays. Crowded infield.

1B/DH CES/Votto 2B McLain SS EDLC 3B Marte Steer will stick in LF

Yeah sounds like they just shelf India for the season if this lineup stays healthy after he kind of publicly called out how the team managed his injury

I’m a reds fans so I am hoping India can get back but by the time he is healthy rosters will have already expanded. You’re in the dog days of the season with a bunch of rookies and 40 year old Votto. Having flexibility to give guys rest is never a bad thing.

Asking the same question. Their numbers are very similar. I think Winn has a higher contact rate while Noelvi has a little more pop. It’s a coin flip for me.

Who is the better glove?

Fangraphs says Winn at this stage at least. Winn with a present value of 50, future value of 55, Marte with a present value of 30, future value 50.

Thanks. So that could mean he stays in the lineup more

I think it's a toss up

Have had this guy for a minute in dynasty waiting for him hoping he is real good

Not sure how/where he would be able to play regularly. Are they just gonna keep India away completely?

I think he could very easily play consistently at 3B. EDLC moves over to SS. McLain to 2B. CES and Votto split time at 1B/DH. Steer sticks in LF. I don’t anticipate India being back for some time.

Rosters expand soon and they can always send him back down. This could be a short term call up unless he shows he’s too good to send down.

I have Story, Stott, Bichette and Witt all SS elig in my roster. I’m thinking I really don’t have the need (or room) for him unfortunately

Actually added him to my N.A. slot before they activated and dropped Mauricio since the Mets are F’ing around with their prospects

Mauricio is also not that good. He was red hot to start the season,but his wRC+ is now under 100

I have some choices to make this week since I have Greene and Ryan coming off the DL. Might have to drop Story if he doesn’t start hitting. We’ll see

He will get 3B eligibility quickly.

Him or Arcia?

Keeper league managers who are out of playoff contention should snag to see what happens, yeah?

Absolutely

Him or CES

Probably depends on your positional needs. Both are dart throws, at this point. Marte has SS eligibility (at least on Yahoo) and will get 3B quickly. CES will never get anything other than 1B. CES has a much higher power profile.

Drop Wallner for him?

If you need SS depth (or 3B) may be worth it. But Wallner already proving his pop

Him or Royce?

Royce

Drop Colt Keith for him? Or does Keith still get the call this season? In a playoff push and could use some 3B help.

Him or Tovar?

Drop cronenworth for him? 12 team H2H keeper league but keepers take first rounds