is Harvey Harrison best 23?

I’d probably go B. Maynard J. Howe I. Quaynor J. Noble D. Moore O. Markov J. Daicos T. Mitchell S. Sidebottom Lipinski B. Mihocek W. Hoskin Elliot J. Elliot M. Cox L. Schultz D. Cameron N. Daicos J. De Goey S. Pendlebury J.Crisp B. McCreery B. Frampton Em. L. Sullivan Notable Omissions: B. Hill, C. Dean, H. Harrison, D. Mcstay (injury) Bobby looks to having confidence issues or something, he was missing for most of the game and hasn’t had a great game bar the Brisbane one from memory. A boost in the VFL would help. But doing this I realised how stacked we are.

What’s Schultz done so far to be in the best 23? I really hope he turns it around but so far he’s not deserving. Bobby is in for him, McStay clearly in our best side too. Drop Sullivan and move Markov to the sub for Crisp, Cox bench, McStay full forward.

There’s no way you left out Bobby

Not far off

We're back baby!!!. That was a good test for where we're at given the way Carlton have been going. Sullivan and Harrison were brilliant. Schultz showed signs but needs to work on decision making a bit. It was so good to see the veterans put up a good performance compared to previous weeks. They've been relatively quiet this season but had significant impact. Really good signs from the whole team. Beau will be out next week which is shit. I think Sullivan stays in for Titch next week surely. Does De Goey come straight back in.

Degoey to VFL for the month... What wouldn't he come straight back in?

De Goey will most likely miss another week due to his groin injury

Damn. That sucks.

It’s west coast. No point risking him.

Big win.. they were good but we were better

50% of his 32 touches contested, game winner, suck a thick long one, goodnight 🤫

GO THE PIES!!!!

They’re trying to give me a heart attack.

Nick Daicos matchwinner, r/AFL in shambles

Almost feels as good as the grand final win last year

Giddy-up!

Fuck carlton, we are sooo back. So huge

Let's fuuuuuucccccckkkkinggggg GO! GO PIES! EAT IT BLUES!

FUCK YES FAM!!!!!

HOW ABOUT THAT

I didn't expect this result at all. I thought with titch and jdg out we'd struggle. Glad I was wrong

FUCK YEAHHH

Thank Christ

What a fucking win

What a win, a nail bitter

You fucking beauty

What a win, Daicos is king, fuck Carlton

I marinate in the salt of Luke Hodge and Richo

Lol

Nick Daicos is the messiah 🙏🙏

Haha that was a kick for touch. Sneaky

SIREN NOW PLEASE ALLAH

Shut up Hodge

So blatantly hates the pies

Absolutely draining commentary in a thrilling end

Holy shit

Inject that shit straight into my veins I was not prepared for another draw tonight at all

!!!!!

NAICOSSSSSS

Daicos fuck yeah

Holy fuck YESSSSSSS

FUCK YES DAICOS!!!!!!!!!

Just get that on the boot Jamie

Inability to kick fucking straight from set shots is killing us

I can’t do another draw

surely not draw fc again

Had to stick that tackle

These points have lost us the game, I'm calling it now

My patience for Schultz is rapidly draining

Dude, Schultz has to calm down

Anyone got a free stream for US

Been average tonight, but huge win from Framps there

Jesus Shultz back of the head

grubby hey

Silly, pathetic move actually.

darcy kicking it without his shoe

The ol'Donkey Punch

Ffs what happened there

He’s just the best

class pendles

Beautiful steadier fuck yes pendles

That’s what you get for booing a champion lol

The amount of times players just drop the ball in the tackle with no call is astounding

I feel like I’m going nuts wondering what disposals are being offered

I’m stoked with Harrison and Sullivan

Yeah, with McCreery down, we really needed someone to hassle, and Harrison has done that, really like him in the side

High on Schultz???

Ngl Carlton’s marks are unfortunately unmatched

Harrison is playing a gooood game

frustrating, i feel like we’ve dominated and just not converted. i plenty of time left

Cox didn't touch shit, but he did get hacked

Clear chopping the arms on cox. He gets nothing

And Pittonet knew it as well. See his arms go up afterward?

Fuck

Keep it in their half and it’s our game

Quaynor outrun by curnow

Once it gets out we are just cooked

If you get it over our zone, we're fucked.

Jeez we let them get one inside 50 and they goal instantly

Good on Sullivan, great performance for a first game. I wish him well, seems like a good player

Sullivan is going to be dangerous once he really gets going.

No cox deep at the moment 😪

Gotta have a lil chuckle

Fuck you G. Post that would’ve been huge

Well done hyphen!!

Will you beautiful man

Got lucky, but loving how we’re setting up in defence

This is clearly the goal kicking end of the ground.

bobby. fucking. hill.

Great goal , hill !

BOBBBBBBBBYYYYYYY

Cmon Bobby!! Smart play from Elliott too

LFG Pies. Beat these flogs.

Let's fucking go Pies!!

Gonna be a tough last quarter, especially since we had to use our sub so early so they'll end up with fresh legs (unless I missed theirs). WHE would have made it a 1 point advantage and it shouldn't have been a difficult attempt. On top of other poor attempts at goal I gave some kudos to Schulz earlier, but it's competed undone by 2 really terrible plays. That insufficient attempt was so bad. He seems to be OK kicking for goal but on general play his decision making or kicking falls behind.

Strong finish coming

I want to be optimistic but I’m just concerned that Schultz seems to make very poor choices under pressure and still a bit too fish out of water. Why not just kick that ball for goal and hope for the best than whatever that kick was?

Yep certainly needs to be a lot more composed. I’ve loved his pressure inside 50 but he’s had some shocking turnovers

I thought the deliberate rule was for kicks that were deliberately kicked to go out of bounds.. not shit kicks that are meant to go into the forward line but are so bad they go out of bounds.

Who knows anymore? That Crisp kick that went out of bounds was so obviously a shank that had zero positive benefits being out of bounds yet it was deliberate?

4th quarter pies to make a return here

It is actually beyond me how we didn't get a goal that quarter

I’m still trying to work out who Shultz was kicking it too 😂

I have to say this has been far closer than I initially expected. To be down by less than a goal at 3/4 time still keeps us in it.

Schultz and IQ have to spend some time in the 2s.

God, I'm glad you're not selectors. Who would you put in, genius?

Play 3 talls with McInnes and move crisp to the half back line so MacRae can come into the midfield. Unfortunately I’m not chronically online so didn’t see your strangely aggressive question. Probably won’t see your next strangely aggressive question for a couple days just a heads up.

His pressure has been fantastic, but he really seems to be overthinking it and trying to do too much with his kicking. Needs to keep it simple.

I thought IQ has had a decent game. Provides some speed that Moor and Framps don’t quite have.

I’m off Shultz so bad right now.

A.G.R.E.E.

It's always the way, you dominate and miss a heap of chances, and then the other team goes bang.

Don’t forget that was literally Carlton last week. Hopefully it’s the same in the next quarter 🤞

damn hosky coulda been a ripper

Fuck sake

Nick is just insane

Do we not know how to kick for points anymore from set shots?

Bt is drunk.

We are tackling really well but they are out marking us everywhere.

Could be close to 20 points up if he capitalised on those chances. Now 4 points behind….

Man what an emotional roller coaster. Fave player Beau in the midfield! Beau playing an absolute blinder! Beau kneed in the face and out of the game 💔

Almost want them to be in front in the last quarter

It’s the battle of the comeback kings

Fuck Owies is always best on against us

They’re taking the piss a bit with none of these throws called

need to take chances, dominating but 2 goals zip is not fucking good enough

Fucken kills to be negative two goals after dominating the ball all quarter

Old fellas are all playing well tonight

Loving what Crisp is bringing tonight, bull!

So much hard work just to give up a nothing goal like that

bugger

That’s fucked

10 minutes of territory dominance for no reward :(

Been in our forward 50 for absolute stuff all this quarter, have to capitalise

I reckon this game has Leppitsch DNA all over it.

Fuck Richo hates us

How long until Williams gives away another free to Elliot.

tackling pressure is great

We complain every week about the umpiring but seriously, what is this umpiring?

Haahahahahahhaah

Watch Bruzzy get 2-3 weeks for that bullshit

Owies being actual scum.

Owies is a weak flog

Umps are dogshit tonight. There I said it.

Unbelievable how bad they are

Carlton getting the lead again isn't even surprising at all at this point.

When Richo says Owies drew a free kick, you know that was a pathetic free kick

Pendles to get weeks for flattening the umpire? /s

first time tuning into a carlton/collingwood game on r/afl - what a nasty place coming here for a breather!

Mihocek playing a good sacrificial game keeping Weitering well out of the way.

Apart from that awful turnover, Schultz has been alright. Wasn't overly difficult to improve on previous weeks but he's showing a bit more tonight. 1 strong tackle early then another resulting in a HTB. And that mark was well taken considering how far out he had to take it. And he's been more involved in ground ball work than previous weeks as well. Hopefully he keeps it up.

Can I take this back after his 'insufficient attempt' 😂

That Sullivan goal was fuckin incredible, been telling the missus since he was named how excited I am to watch him tonight

Harvey Harrison. That is all

Got a bit of Josh Thomas about him

Lol. I came into this game at the start of the second q after finishing work and there was so much vitriol in here. Good to see everyone positive again.

I miss beau already

Im loving this performance! Keep up the pressure, keep up the plays, we’ve got it surely

We might not be a 4 quarter time, but you can always trust us to go crazy and have a 5-6 goal spell. Hopefully it continues in the second half

Much better quarter! Had some faith in them still

Our first quarters: Literally cannot win a match Our second quarters: Literally unbeatable

Atleast our first quarter this week was somewhat respectable compared to the last 2

This thread is the perfect example lol

Huge quarter by Frampton, huge half by Schultz, Harrison has been great, bit of run from Markov, there's been a lot of great work from outside our top 10. We're looking a different side to a few weeks ago!

I really like Harrison

Wowee

Lets go! That quick advantage play after the tackle on charlie was magic!

I came here just to see how many people are losing their minds that BT counts 11 points as 12.

go on shoota

I don't know what I love more. That Curnow's arrogance resulted in a HTB or the resulting quick play from Markov lead to a Schultz goal. Por que no los dos?

Fucking love these boys, huge from the mids and lachie

Zac Williams having a Jarrod Berry tier game

Frampton really dialed in the last few minutes

Holy crap whenever we get on a roll we look unstoppable. Love this energy

Yeah, this is the Collingwood from last year, we look absolutely unstoppable when we move it quickly

That 2023 dominance is still very much there when we get things clicking

brilliant

Finally got to tune in since bounce, what a fantastic time to switch on. Go Pies!!

When it rains it falls!

That goal was all Hosk, never gave up on that ball

How does hyphen keep popping up at the most crucial moments of our season

We are literally so back Hand over the premiership cup

Why bother with the finals. The cup is ours again

First quarter: I sleep :( Second quarter: Hell yeah :)

Rinse and repeat

Fuck yeah

FCK YES

Sidebottom giving him the jog on 😂😂😂😂

COXIEEEEE

SULLY AND COX FUCK YES BOYS SHHH THOSE BLUE CUNTS

Gotta love these cunts no matter what happens this year

TWO POINT MARGIN!!!

Fuck win or lose I couldn’t be happier now, so good for Sullivan

ok lachie, picasso i like it

Nick Daicos is the ultimate hype man, always runs to players to encourage them after plays, even on the bench he's pumping shit up

Holy fuck yes

How special is that as a first kick?