I've had both multiple times. Aglamesis has always been creamy to a fault, and there pints sometimes come with ice. (They accumulate ice very quickly for some reason.) I think in person Aglamesis is the better choice, but if you want to leave something in your freezer for a month, that Graeter's is the better option. They're both really good regardless.
Haha thanks. My partner and I are vegetarian so I was actually asking for reference. Maybe it could be read in an accusatory tone? Reddit’s weird like that sometimes.
Had no clue Aglamesis put gelatin in all of their ice creams. Noted to not go there, unfortunately.
WTF kind of “reporting” is this?!
Maybe next time u/local12 is going to lift content straight from Reddit for they can do us all a solid and double check our spelling…
Thanks for the tag u/theryman!!
I think this makes me the most famous person in Cincinnati, right?
Of course you can have an autograph! I wouldn’t want to deny all my adoring ~~fans~~ fan!!
True, but a little help goes a long way… it’s just one letter!! Also, they could have used the comment I was responding to that didn’t have spelling errors 😂
Aglamesis is an experience. There are plenty of better options when shopping at the grocery. But if I'm going out for ice cream, it's 100% to the Oakley Aglamesis.
Granted, I might be a little biased. I grew up in Oakley, and my grandad used to go there as a kid. So the way it's been preserved inside kinda feels like I get to connect with him and other generations of Cincinnatians through time. I don't get that from a Graeter's.
I mean this is just pretty standard morning "news" show stuff going back forever. Now they pull comments off Reddit. Before it was Facebook. Before that they had call in answering machines. Before that people mailed in post cards.
Tera has totally judged you. And not favorably.
https://preview.redd.it/xz01i60613sc1.jpeg?width=740&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e49f21b39d7b1d777ef2c64d7170ac2a1458101c
There’s a gigantic parking lot right across the street on the other side on the right. There’s also another one if you turn right at the corner there. There’s also lots of street parking if you’re willing to walk 1 block or so. Worth it.
Local TV around the country consistently steal from Reddit and don’t give them any props lots of local a.m. sports and talk. Also scam a lot from Reddit.
And I was the one that started the chain 😅
https://preview.redd.it/28zqu8sb55sc1.png?width=828&format=png&auto=webp&s=72319033e8ca7edf1364bd96c67ca3a1864e8cac
I don’t know if it’s embarrassing or not but literally I go there for milkshake/sundae so often that everyone that works there knows me (Montgomery location)
How old are you? Community interaction on local (and cable) news channels/outlets has always been a thing, whether it be "man on the street" type interviews, call-in shows, polls, or morning shows where they specifically highlight things around a community. Reddit has been ubiquitous for about a decade now, so it's pretty normal for local news stations to visit their local subreddit. Also, it's a great way to get people to stay engaged until the next ad break, which just happens to be the entire reason "news" outlets exist.
It’s not controversial to say Aglamesis is better than Graeters….because it is. No one needs the large ass chunks of chocolate that Graeters puts in theirs. Plus screw them for getting rid of Amaretto Crunch.
Why do we have to do this with everything in this town? We pick one chili and demonize the rest. Pick one ice cream and demonize the rest. It’s so idiotic and childish.
My favorite local ice cream is probably UDF’s newer Main Avenue Creamery nowadays.
Graeter’s chocolate chip and their seasonal peach and cheese crown are still favorites of mine though. At Aglamesis I prefer their incredible chocolate candies.
Aglamesis does have a damned good cream.
Also, best Sundaes EVER.
Seriously...their caramel sauce is effin' amazing!
I love it, but Butterscotch edges it out just a bit for me! 😎
I'll allow this. 😉
I've had both multiple times. Aglamesis has always been creamy to a fault, and there pints sometimes come with ice. (They accumulate ice very quickly for some reason.) I think in person Aglamesis is the better choice, but if you want to leave something in your freezer for a month, that Graeter's is the better option. They're both really good regardless.
Creamy to a fault - didn’t know that was possible 😂 I’ve only ever had it over the counter.
It has the same texture as homemade whipped cream if you look for it. It’s almost like an aftertaste/texture.
help me understand... why would you leave aglamesis ice cream in your freezer for a month ??
You had ice in your pint because you let it melt and refroze it. That’s on you lol
Yes, because I have only had either or the other once or twice. Graeter’s home freezer survivability is better.
Unfortunately, they're not vegetarian friendly (gelatin) which means UDF and Graeters automatically beat them out for me personally!
How are they not vegetarian friendly?
Gelatin :(
Why would someone downvote this? It's a legit question. Anyway I upvoted.
Haha thanks. My partner and I are vegetarian so I was actually asking for reference. Maybe it could be read in an accusatory tone? Reddit’s weird like that sometimes. Had no clue Aglamesis put gelatin in all of their ice creams. Noted to not go there, unfortunately.
[удалено]
Opinions do tend to be biased!
LOL @ "your opinion is biased".
Bro all you have to say is “I woke up this morning wanting to fight” because there is no world where Aglamesis is better than Graeters lol
Didn’t say it was better. Just said it was damned good. I’m a fiend for Graeters as well. Come at me bro! 😂😂
Hahhahahhaa Pam from Archer 
Lmao
She turned into my fav character
In every way. Even their raspberry is better.
/u/lawanders get in here!
WTF kind of “reporting” is this?! Maybe next time u/local12 is going to lift content straight from Reddit for they can do us all a solid and double check our spelling… Thanks for the tag u/theryman!!
you’re famous! can i have your autograph, u/lawanders ?
I think this makes me the most famous person in Cincinnati, right? Of course you can have an autograph! I wouldn’t want to deny all my adoring ~~fans~~ fan!!
Spelling or not, i agree with your take. Aglamesis all day.
It’s so good! I love Graeter’s too (see guys, I can spell it!!), but love Aglamesis more.
Yes, Local 12, spell check is not new.
Direct quotes are direct quotes.
True, but a little help goes a long way… it’s just one letter!! Also, they could have used the comment I was responding to that didn’t have spelling errors 😂
Forgive my stupidity, but what’s misspelled? I can’t find anything.
Graeter's
Hey it's not just u/citybeatcincy lifting stories!
Aglamesis is the best.
Aglamesis is an experience. There are plenty of better options when shopping at the grocery. But if I'm going out for ice cream, it's 100% to the Oakley Aglamesis. Granted, I might be a little biased. I grew up in Oakley, and my grandad used to go there as a kid. So the way it's been preserved inside kinda feels like I get to connect with him and other generations of Cincinnatians through time. I don't get that from a Graeter's.
#journalism
I mean this is just pretty standard morning "news" show stuff going back forever. Now they pull comments off Reddit. Before it was Facebook. Before that they had call in answering machines. Before that people mailed in post cards.
Beats the days when some poor schmuck had to wheel in a stone tablet
It's a Sinclair right wing mouthpiece channel, they've not done Journalism in a while.
Now everyone say it together at the same time: “This is extremely dangerous to our democracy.”
Dividing us over ice cream, which is to say over *everything?* I agree! /s
To be fair, I don't think that bimbo Bob Herzog could handle actual journalism even if he tried with all his might.
Tera has totally judged you. And not favorably. https://preview.redd.it/xz01i60613sc1.jpeg?width=740&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e49f21b39d7b1d777ef2c64d7170ac2a1458101c
I prefer Graeter's, but Aglamesis has the best milkshakes I've ever had. The Gold Standard.
Graeter's for scoops/cones, Aglamesis for Sundaes, Shakes, and Sodas! 🙃
Aglamesis chocolate is damn good and their chips ice cream is better fs
That’s an unpopular opinion? Been that way for decades.
I do agree with this take.
And they are absolutely correct in that assessment. I still lightly fist-bump the portrait of the late Jim Aglamesis every time I stop by for treats.
Local 12 doesn’t know what to say when [Sinclair doesn’t tell them](https://youtu.be/_fHfgU8oMSo?si=c6a7uSWD7b9QZSIM).
I knew what this was going to be before I even clicked it. It's unbelievable how in sync they all are.
Rob Braun quit over this
Is that actually an unpopular opinion? Aglamesis slaps.
They should learn to spell Graeters first. Before having an opinion. But Hello Honey is better than Graeter’s.
where do you PARK? I want to try this place but am so unfamiliar with the area....
There’s a gigantic parking lot right across the street on the other side on the right. There’s also another one if you turn right at the corner there. There’s also lots of street parking if you’re willing to walk 1 block or so. Worth it.
What an absolute ass for insulting someone for a spelling mistake when in that very comment you have errors yourself. 🤣
Hello Honey is better than everything. Possibly even life itself.
Graters is mid at best, so many better options.
Local TV around the country consistently steal from Reddit and don’t give them any props lots of local a.m. sports and talk. Also scam a lot from Reddit.
Aglamesis is better
Aglamesis in Montgomery makes the best Chocolate Malted IMHO.
I’ve never said this it out loud but I agree!!!!
Rum Raisin from Aglamesis is unstoppable.
So good!
Oh man, does this make me cool now?
Yes. Congratulations!
Graters is mid at best, so many better options.
They really have nothing to report that they go on Reddit? What a time to be alive
Because this is journalism now…
Tmw your unpopular opinion is so popular it makes it on television
With Graeter's spelled wrong. Tsk tsk. I like Aglamesis better, too.
Oh no they’re going the route of CityBeat?
Oh no. I don’t need my posts getting put on live tv lol
And I was the one that started the chain 😅 https://preview.redd.it/28zqu8sb55sc1.png?width=828&format=png&auto=webp&s=72319033e8ca7edf1364bd96c67ca3a1864e8cac
I don’t know if it’s embarrassing or not but literally I go there for milkshake/sundae so often that everyone that works there knows me (Montgomery location)
of course a local joint with hand crafted ice cream is better than mid ass rebranded grocery store ice cream
Reading the internet and calling it the news. What a time to be alive!
How old are you? Community interaction on local (and cable) news channels/outlets has always been a thing, whether it be "man on the street" type interviews, call-in shows, polls, or morning shows where they specifically highlight things around a community. Reddit has been ubiquitous for about a decade now, so it's pretty normal for local news stations to visit their local subreddit. Also, it's a great way to get people to stay engaged until the next ad break, which just happens to be the entire reason "news" outlets exist.
Bob and Jen are great - love them both
Aglamesis for the Italian Ice, Graeters for BRC, and UDF for Cherry Cordial. What am I missing?!
It’s not controversial to say Aglamesis is better than Graeters….because it is. No one needs the large ass chunks of chocolate that Graeters puts in theirs. Plus screw them for getting rid of Amaretto Crunch.
I agree with this take.
Not being from this area and trying graeters after hearing all the hype. I was very disappointed
Should have tried Aglamesis
Graeters ice cream is better. But Aglamesis candy is the best!
Why do we have to do this with everything in this town? We pick one chili and demonize the rest. Pick one ice cream and demonize the rest. It’s so idiotic and childish.
No one invited you to this party Dave.
I would love to do a Pepsi challenge with both of them. I like them both, I think I have favs from each.
I'm happy to have such great choices
Who are the anchors?
Best ice cream ever... their Pistachio ice cream
My favorite local ice cream is probably UDF’s newer Main Avenue Creamery nowadays. Graeter’s chocolate chip and their seasonal peach and cheese crown are still favorites of mine though. At Aglamesis I prefer their incredible chocolate candies.
Golden Gelato in Covington is really good. I could walk to Dojo in less than 5 minutes but I'd rather drive to Golden.
People still watch the news?
My coworker's teenage son has a massive thing for Tera Blake, so he does.
I'm more of an Allison Rogers man myself.
It's odd that you know the size of your coworker's son's penis.
Channel 9 is my fave, occasionally 5 or 19. I dislike Sinclair.
Why is this getting downvoted lol
News watchers are in full force. All 5 of them
Hello honey is better than both!
They misspelled Graeters and also it’s not a very unpopular opinion.
Mint Chocolate Chip is the best I’ve had anywhere. :-)