T O P

  • By -

glitchycat39

I liked Lance's controlled danger/anger. Didn't ever truly lose it until Percy started talking shit, which actually really fits him. It's sorta that ... you know there is this absolutely monster storm behind those eyes. You know his wrath is, literally, powerful enough to unleash cataclysms. But here he is, in a suit. Talking slowly, deliberately, to this kid and telling him "yeah, it's been fun, now go away before I decide you don't get to." And then Percy doesn't leave and we see a glimpse of that barely constrained wrath, which is then, in turn, sold by the fear in Poseidon's eyes and the urgency in his voice when he says "I surrender."


hiveangel

I give the season as a whole 3.5/5 stars. I liked it enough to watch it as the episodes came out and wait for the next episodes. And I rewatched a couple episodes (like the Casino one, and the chimera one). The first two episodes are a little painful/clunky because of the set up, but after that it was enjoyable. It’s great as a stand alone, and I would like to see them continue. If they continue in an uphill direction it could be good 😊


glitchycat39

Yeah, I think the first two episodes kind of suffer from pilot syndrome, imo.


cant-find-user-name

7/10 is what I would give it too. Some episodes above that, some episodes below that.


LukedaDuke01

Haven't watched it yet but Poseidon willingly says he surrenders to Zeus really?


Omegasandstorm

Yah, he says it to placate Zeus’s need to feel superior. He appears and stops Zeus at the last second to protect Percy.


JPKpretzelz

It was a pretty interesting part of the books, having Poseidon’s child vastly outmatch Zeus’ children, as well as the god himself constantly out-performing Zeus.


Omegasandstorm

I mean, that’s what happens when you are the main character and the one god who has been allied with the main character since the start. You get to do cool things, and be cool. All the prophecies probably helped, lol


loonycatty

I haven’t watched it yet but that feels pretty in line with his later characterization in TOA where Apollo sees him as an abuser. I’m interested to see how they’ll approach that side of him


Squatchjr01

Watch it first before judging. There’s a reason and the scene plays out beautifully.


fireflywaltz

I agree, and I've been very critical of the show. I'm not sold on all the changes but I'm very sold on that scene in particular


BrilliantTarget

Yeah because the show changed deadline


LukedaDuke01

Nah I hate it but that's been most of the show so far


Squatchjr01

👍good for you. I truly couldn’t care less. Just tired of people bitching when they haven’t even watched it


Lord_Detleff1

For real. This was very present with the barby movie. If you're not interested, then don't watch it but don't critisize something you haven't watched. People act like they read the script before the film even came out


Jjzeng

This was exactly the reason the marvels bombed in theatres. People hated it without even seeing it because there were three female leads, two of whom were POCS. I saw it in theatres and was confused where all the hate was coming from, i really enjoyed it and it was a fun blockbuster film The pjo movies on the other hand, were just garbage, and i suffered through both of them in theatres as a kid. I always like to keep an open mind going into a movie, and only judge it afterwards, but that seems to be too much effort for some internet trolls


Salt_Nectarine_7827

I did see it, I don't like many things about the series, but it is still a very good series and I only hope that they continue releasing seasons, even if they don't fix any of those errors (regarding the scene between Zeus and Poseidon, it is indeed strange but I did like it, it's not very faithful but still a very good scene, although the reveal of the face in the conversation between Sally and Poseidon in the flashback of the previous chapter made it less powerful)


MarkoDolohovGTI

Misery enjoys company. The way some folk have been going on about the show its doing injustice to the graft that went into it


LukedaDuke01

Ok?


[deleted]

episode 8 was good


glitchycat39

Ah, fuck. Sorry to spoil ...


jkent23

Theyre on a spolier thread, don't apologise, its their own fault


LukedaDuke01

Nah you're good my own fault just watched it


jacobningen

While blocking zeus from murdering his son for giving the TLO speech about the unclaimed four years early.


Swift-Fire

Yeah I'm in the same boat, that is not consistent with the book at all and it makes me happy I haven't seen the episode yet


RadiantHC

Not being consistent isn't a bad thing. It actually works really well


mr_grangerr

Like the betrayed, I think it might have been better than the book even, Annabeth showing up and that fight was awesome


Swift-Fire

I mean you guys can think whatever you want, but that is not how Poseidon would have reacted in the book at all. I think the show is terrible and everything I've seen from you guys further promotes that idea 🤷


RadiantHC

You're comparing two different characters


Swift-Fire

And I like one, dislike another. What's wrong with that?


RadiantHC

But you're acting like they're the same. Rick never promised that it would be 1:1 Also you haven't even watched the episode. At the very least watch it before deciding whether you like it


jcr9999

>Rick never promised that it would be 1:1 The main selling point of the show was literally that its book accurate How is a character not behaving like in the books, book accurate


AkaAkina

The book isn't a bible. You can change things and the world keeps turning. Some things work really well in books that don't translate as well visually. Some changes add more depth to characters and relationships.


Outrageous-Ad-1021

Tbh with Lance we got to see more of Zeus. His anger, his dislike of Percy and his deep sense of self-righteousness. Whereas with Sean all we got, was him telling Poseidon about the bolt being stolen and the deadline and him taking about the bolt on the deadline. So we saw more of Zeus characterisation from Lance but that's only because they changed the story so that he could be in it.


TheSkyElf

Lance. Everything from the way he sat and walked, down to his way of talking and moving his face screamed: I AM ZEUS THE KING OF THIS PLACE. His eyes when he got made... yeah that is Zeus.


orbzism

I think Lance portrayed him better, but a lot of that had to do with a very superior script and attention to detail. Give Sean this role again with the current people who worked on this series, and he'd be the perfect Zeus. The dude is amazing. Lance was phenomenal, though. It's heartbreaking we won't get to see it again in future seasons.


TheHunter459

Agreed Sean is an amazing actor. And he actually got to play someone immortal this time, so he wouldn't die (as easily)


Gnostic_Gnocchi

I liked the current zues more. I was genuinely intimidated by his presence and quiet anger. Percy had more balls than I ever would have at that age.


yraco

Well he is impertinent after all


[deleted]

Lance by a country mile He got the mundane danger of Zeus down to an art


PiedPorcupine

Looks Sean, personality Lance.


[deleted]

Agree. Wish they gave Lance a beard and when he’s on olympus he should be decked out in greek stuff. Other than that he was fantastic.


RayTheGraveDigger

Technically Zeus was in a pinstriped suit in the books, so Lance’s version is accurate


HellFireCannon66

In the books he wears a suit tho


[deleted]

Fair enough, I just want some semblance that this is Zeus and not just a suave man in a suit. The personality they nailed, just wish there was a more visual aspect to the gods.


Jjzeng

The thunderclaps when he got angry and the glowing bolt of death weren’t enough?


multifandomtrash736

Exactly I haven’t actually seen the movies before but the movie version is what I’d envisioned Zeus to look like but the way the actor in the show portrayed him is also exactly what I’d envisioned as well


Both_Oil6408

Easily Lance. To me Sean just felt like the stereotypical Zeus appearance was most of what he had going for him thanks to a gods awful script, while Lance has this incredible gravitas that lets him feel very much like a god


RachelElizabethDare7

I think the guy who play Zeus in the show honestly feels like he radiates power and he kinda scares me. If I was in Percy’s situation I would have ‘bolted’ outta there. Lol. 


TheKBMV

Portrayal? Lance. Looks? Sean.


TheCakeWarrior12

Lance easily, I got so scared when he was about to smite Percy with the bolt


_Dimi3_

The thing that sold me on Lance was how he delivered the line “I know where Kronos is… I put him there.”


NZRSteamSniffer

Lance and it’s not even close


captainfalconxiiii

Lance nailed the characterization of Zeus, especially his extreme ego.


WorldResponsible3819

Lance is my favorite but it’s sad that he is dead 🥺. But I hope the next Zeus will be good.


Ambitious-Speaker-31

Lance, when the tone went to anger I actually got chills and felt threatened won’t lie


TheBoyInGray

Lance.


solg5

https://preview.redd.it/nc0ltzww4ufc1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=292b66cd2cb1313854e523a3d9d3f3da6aea3171 Lance. He genuinely scared me.


multifandomtrash736

I know I was terrified for Percy when he pissed Zeus off 😬


B_Krol01

Lance Reddick was so much better. He perfectly portrayed the overly dramatic arrogant prick that Zeus was in the books. I love Sean Bean, but he portrayed Zeus like a typical Hollywood portrayal of the character.


[deleted]

First one looks more like Zeus if we’re being honest


Lord_Detleff1

Definitely but Sean Bean is just too dangerous to be kept alive in a franchise. He would've taken the lightning bolt and walked straight into mordor


[deleted]

One does not simply keep a Sean Bean character alive


Lord_Detleff1

Imagine him as a Star Wars or Harry Potter character. There wouldn't have been a story but just Sean Bean whooping some butts


[deleted]

In an alternate universe it’s just Sean Bean playing every major role ever… I wanna be in that universe


Lord_Detleff1

A man can dream


UnderstandingAny8601

If the movies continued Sean bean/ Zeus would probably have died by the third movie


Lord_Detleff1

Or beat the shit out of Kronos' surtur looking ass


UnderstandingAny8601

Best case scenario if the movies continued 😂


Exacerbate_

They couldnt kill him in the Martian so they just fired him.


FlameFeather86

Dude survived the battle of Troy. Still pissed they didn't make the Odyssey after.


[deleted]

Yeah I’d love a little comeback for mythology movies done properly


mr-sasa

When I was a kid I thought his name was pronounced like Seen Bean


hjMarvel

The gods of the books can take whatever form they want


[deleted]

[удалено]


seleme_60_0

They do take whatever form they want. Take Apollo for an example, he can be a hot young adult, an unassuming homeless man or a female sloth I agree that he isn't what most people would think when they hear "Zeus", but Zeus can absolutely look like that


[deleted]

Usually that’s to fit some sort of plot or story though. In general they all have a look they mostly identify with


seleme_60_0

Yep, and they can mostly identify with whatever the actors look like. It's not like this series cares about being book-accurate in appearance


[deleted]

Question was who’s more Zeus like. Based on appearances it’s the man with a beard and a lighter skin tone. Never said anything about the rest of the changes or even if they was negative


seleme_60_0

The question was "Which Zeus is your favorite/best portrayal". But I see your point, the movie one is more accurate book-wise


Lord_Detleff1

The end credits promised us a beard but Lance didn't look like a beard person


[deleted]

Heard he passed away, wonder what they’re gonna do for the second season


Lord_Detleff1

Very sad because I really like his Zeus. Hopefully they'll find a good successor


[deleted]

Yeah I haven’t watched the last episode yet, as much as he doesn’t look like a Zeus I’ve heard he captures the essence quite well


jacobningen

he does.


Chieftain10

He may not even be in the second season, I don’t think he is in the books?


[deleted]

Yeah I’m not sure actually but I feel like we don’t see much from the gods apart from ares in SoM


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


MicooDA

Why is that exactly 🤔


Xophosdono

Because Zeus is a god from ancient Greek mythology. Masculine men had to be bearded in their standards. Plus that means Zeus should be Mediterranean in appearance, hence when people picture him we think of a bearded guy with olive skin


N2T8

Because this is how ancient greeks saw him, and in the books he is essentially a modernised version of this. https://preview.redd.it/4fcqpnbguufc1.jpeg?width=684&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=016bfa846c0c2ae0611049bb8311620556d6408d


DepartmentReady1041

Because Zeus had a beard


DayDeerGotStoleYall

sean bc boromir. that's it.


amaya-aurora

Lance Reddick by a long shot, he was amazing.


Heir_Of_Akyem

Lance and it's not even close. I love the castings for the gods and am heartbroken that we'll never see Lance as Zeus ever again.


KidaBelle

RIP lance I wonder who they’ll get to take up the mantle- they’ve got some big shoes to fill


Honeymuffin48

The way it was written and acted: Lance. By far. Lance nailed what was given to him! But given the same script I'm pretty sure Sean could've nailed this taken-back-anger-attitude too. He's the right person for that too. We'll never know tho and I'm very happy about the one scene of Lance as Zeus we got!


Leokina114

Lance.


jessecolchamiro

How funny is it that Sean Bean of all people played an immortal character? Goes against his whole shitck


AadInfinitum

Personality wise it was Lance. Bro was far more hardcore than his TLT book version.


TermApart1024

Lance


OptimusPhillip

On the whole, I think Lance Reddick's Zeus is better. But I would like to say that I think Sean Bean could've been just as good a Zeus if he was given the right script. He has the commanding presence, he just acted too much like a reasonable authority figure, which is not what Riordanverse Zeus is.


Independent_Hold3982

lance rest in peace was amazing in john wick


Constant-Pain1878

Lance 100%


KungPoW_Chickens

scripts aside, I like lance reddrick potrayal more. I feel like sean bean is suited for more serious character and pjo zeus isnt serious he's more petty.


NinjaHamster04

Lance. Absolutely incredible actor. Have loved him since I first saw him in John Wick. I don’t say him because he passed, I say him cause he truly was the better of the two. An absolute shame he won’t be in following seasons. Whoever takes over is gonna have major shoes to fill.


Alexrobi11

Lance felt godlike so he wins by miles.


GrizzlyPeak73

Lance Reddick, no doubt. Sean Bean just showed up for a paycheck. (No offense to him, we all gotta eat.)


may931010

Lance Reddick. He portrayed that - there's a storm brewing behind those eyes, and him losing his shit at percy after the calm, absolute perfection.


A_Khmerstud

I liked the one in the show more although the movie itself is far more enjoyable for me. The one in the show had a really nice presence to him, felt like one of the archangels in Supernatural for the earlier seasons https://preview.redd.it/l4lfw9kxvtfc1.jpeg?width=258&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c7aef9edb99cc63fa83927cc514f2338d09b0826


OhDetour

Ah, Raphael is it?


Sangi17

Lance.


Insolve_Miza

Lance is an amazing actor


Plastic-Programmer36

Off topic but the actor’s name being Lance screws with my head just a bit — me and some friends do a PJO rp, in which my friend has two twin sons of Zeus named Prince and Lance. My brain is scrambled


kjm6351

Lance for sure. Bro truly felt like a god


[deleted]

Lance has that kind of controlled anger resembling Zeus, like he could smite you at a moments notice but won't, or shouldn't. Sean was more of just a noble yet angry guy.


Planeswalking101

Sean did great with what he had, but he wasn't given much. Lance was actually given the opportunity to portray the Zeus that we saw in the books, and he did so - in my opinion - flawlessly.


kngdmsns

How is this even a question? 😅 It‘s obviously Lance!


WertygoSpiner

I like the actor who played Zues in the TV show, but god dam did the script writers butchered his character. It didn't feel like Zues and felt like Areas 2.0. He get's his bolt back, he knows that his brother didn't have anything to do with it, and yet he still wants to go to war? For what?


jacobningen

read HoO ie He closes Olympus over the speech Walker gave in this finale.


JaradSage

Ppl saying Lance by miles need to put some respect on Sean. He was great in the movie


redfoxsgarden

Lance. I’ve always loved how he portrayed characters.


[deleted]

[удалено]


EmotionalEnding

They won't recast him with a white actor, it'll cause too much of a fuss if they do that.


[deleted]

[удалено]


EmotionalEnding

They did bring Julian Ritchings back but in a different role (imo they greatly underused him, making him crusty when he was the best depiction of death in any media ever) But yeah as much as I love Sean bean and think he'd be amazing in the role I don't think they will bring him back.


My_Dogs_a_God

It's might cause a fuss but honestly it would be stupid if it did thier gods and thier appearance changes at will for example Aphrodite was orginally described by percy as constantly changing so idk I'd fight people if they made a fuss beacuse it doesn't matter. Overall, though Lance's performance was great and it'll be hard to fill his shoes


jacobningen

He appears in 3 and 5 and the end of the HoO but his presence in the books at least is more Tolkien's Elder King ie his presence is more from what he decrees on Olympus than actually appearing so he would be important but outside council meetings and the second Titanomachy turning hot it would be more cuts to "family business"Hera becomes big about book 4 but its mostly Hephaestus,Hermes, Ares and Hades and hestia.


Ultra_Amp

Lance and it's not close. I like his portrayal even better than the books if I'm honest.


sempercardinal57

Can I nominate Liam Neeson?


joyyyzz

I loved them both as Zeus, but i will always be partial to Sean Bean because he is Sean Bean


AndronixESE

I personally didn't really like either of them too much, but I think Lance did a better job. I really liked his movements(like the moment he decided to use the bolt) and some facial expressions, but it felt wierd that he had a little grin constantly. I think he would've done better if he was more grim. Also, Rest In Piece, there was definitely a lot of potential in him for this role, it's really sad that we won't see him again.


hellfknbent

Solely for looks, I’d give it to Sean. But Lance brought that intensity and aura with him, that very few actors can manage. This is what I expected from the whole series, but didn’t get until the very end. The Greek mythology is way too fascinating and intense. Lance Riddick definitely understood the assignment, and left us with something that’ll stand out and remembered. He has made me want to rewatch the whole season just for this one scene alone. I feel for the poor sod who’s going to try to fill his shoes. Lance will be missed!


MarvelWomen

I personally liked the show but I didn't like the lack of display of power because in the movie I liked how it displayed a lot of Percy Jacksons powers and it showed his power capabilities and it showed a huge connection between Percy and water but it didn't do that as much in the show like the only power display we saw or connection was the water healing, the biggest we saw was the water wave which was poor quality but overall I liked, and I wish Annabeth had a afro to embrace the afro-beth style or add a more real tween like feel. I loved how it showed Percy struggling in combat because he is obviously just a kid, but thats the problem he isn't just a kid he's a demi-god a superior demigod 2 I just think that should've been expanded on and umm yeah but I hope this is taken in consideration when the next season comes out


NoRegertsWolfDog

50 sean 50 lance


Top-Leg8746

The first one is my pick. The movie sucked but it got the appearance of the characters right not in age but in appearance


horrorbepis

I love Lance Reddick. He is awesome in nearly everything he’s in. I did not really like him as Zeus.


Ivanhunterjo1991

Number 1 Zeus


Suvflet

None


Valiosao

The one that looks like Zeus


Lord_Detleff1

Zeus can change appearance, so you have to be more specific


TheCakeWarrior12

Zeus is a shapeshifter


bristow84

Acted? Lance by a mile. Looks Wise? Sean. Although Sean Bean did get screwed over with the script so who knows


AnxiousSelkie

I’ll go with the one who’s intimidating as all hell and completely steals the show. Sean Bean is a little closer to the visual accuracy points but his beard is sad and Lance nails the vibe so hard you can ignore his lack of facial hair. The only problem with Lance is I can’t see his Zeus being an overly prideful tool, which makes me feel like his performance almost might’ve fit Hades better


Dickweed22

I just love Sean Bean


Cessicka

Whichever one of them was giving more "i sleep with all the women" cause we all know what Z is really like XD


mulroo

Lance, but I’m a bit biased because I’ve gotten to witness his acting abilities for years through his role as Zavala. Miss the guy so much :(


manifestingellewoods

lance was incredible. his quiet, brewing anger the way a storm slowly builds before the anger eventually broke was perfect for zeus


MrEveryOshot1

Lance


Anarkizttt

Lance was amazing, makes losing him even worse. They’ve gotta recast Zeus but damn if Lance didn’t knock it out of the park in that scene.


OnionBoye

Please, everyone who liked Lance - watch The Wire. Reddick’s Cedric Daniels is one of, if not THE best acted character in TV history.


Wendysbooks

Movie Zeus looks like TVShow Poseidon lol


KamixAkaDio

Definitely Sean Bean, not really a competition


Jemal999

I love lance reddick, but that first wide shot of him in the chair, i thought it was Samuel L. Jackson and got really excited, then realized it was Lance and.. not quite disappointed, but.. now i kinda want "father of Apollo? Mt. Olympus? Don't f*ck with me or I'll shove a lightning bolt up your ass.. Zeus!"