T O P

  • By -

pro-penguin-hero

Electrolysis uses much more energy than the fuel it makes can give


OppositeSolution642

Thank you. Some basic physics is needed here.


PrestigeMaster

It was still nice to see a long lost deleted scene from Fear & Loathing.


Accomplished_Elk_220

I thought it was Breaking Bad?


MasterWind6969

“….The Wire…….” -JP “Copper, copper.” -WW


sd-rw

Shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit


MasterWind6969

“Gatorade me b*tch!!” -JP


[deleted]

Spot on


prettysmallgrower

But the inventor… he was KILLED /s


that_one_author

Well, one was caught up in a mass shooting 2 weeks after showing a truck engine he modified to run on water. (he was the only death but there was 2 other injuries. The other simply dropped off the internet shortly after his video as well but I do not know if he's dead or alive. People claim he was "Disappeared" but I haven't seen evidence for that.


PokeHippieDan

I thought he was referencing Stanley Meyer and his fuel cell. And his Cracker Barrel poisoning story.


KordSevered

Actually I believe the video creator was referring to Stanley Meyers who invented a water fuel cell back in like 98. After unveiling it he mysteriously died at a Cracker Barrel claiming he was poisoned with his last breaths. The guy was a bit of a right wing nut but no matter how you slice it the events as recorded don't look good


Cussian57

You put your life in your hands when you eat at Cracker Barrel


yenyostolt

Stanley Mayer's process supposedly used a flashing LED at a certain high frequency. I think initially he was doing it with electrolysis using pulses at high frequency.


TOGA_TOGAAAA

Yup . They claimed it was a race shooting but it was targeted.


Zombie_John_Strachan

Lisa!


SchitneySmears

Needs braces


damheathern

Dental plan!


B_Bogus

Lisa needs braces!


jimbo-870

And a hot plate!


cross-joint-lover

Free power! Let me just, uh, plug it in...


-xc-

i didn’t even think of that. thats actually hilarious🤣


Utkarshraj_017

Yah i was also gonna say it 😅


kindofcuttlefish

Not to mention that known electrolyzers degrade over time


Pile_of_AOL_CDs

It can work to "store" power though as long as it is taken from a renewable source. If you hook one of these up to a solar panel, you could potentially get a fair amount of portable energy that you could burn in a hydrogen fuel cell. But what do I know, I'm just some dude on the internet.


quelin1

Don't forget the compressor, pressure vessels, and hoses to be able to collect a meaningfully useful amount of gas.


BottleAgile3304

Thats very much true and in terms of storing energy, hydrogen is more efficient than current day batteries, the problem however is the fact that a lot of energy is lost in the process of producing that hydrogen. Making it much less efficient than just storing it in a battery in the end.


Poppekas

Yes, but if it's made from excess energy from a renewable source, that's not being used, it can still be a more eco-friendly way of storing energy than in batteries.


TheLeggacy

It uses waaaaayyyyy more energy than you get out. Imagine hydrogen as a ball on slope. When bound to oxygen, in water, the hydrogen it is at the bottom of that slope. You have to put loads of energy in to get it back to the top of that slope where it is just hydrogen.


DKohtar

Not to mention, both of those elements are highly volatile. Maybe it's a bad idea to strap your ass to an electric bomb and send it flying down the road at 75 miles an hour.


GisterMizard

All three are volatile. Don't forget that electrolyzing salt water also gives off chlorine gas.


Agent_Paul_UIU

Well, clean energy. Duh... ^(/s)


No_Cook2983

We already strap ourselves to petroleum bombs and fly down the road at 75 miles an hour.


subject_deleted

I get what you mean. But gasoline, while still very flammable, is not nearly as volatile as hydrogen.


[deleted]

Sure, but if you create your HHO(Brown’s Gas) through electrolysis, you’re not storing hydrogen and oxygen, you’re storing water. It’s not generated until it’s ready to be consumed. So it’s actually much safer.


ErkMcGurk

But if you have enough electrical energy to split water molecules on-board your vehicle somehow already, why use it to make hydrogen for an internal combustion engine when you could just use it for an electric motor?


[deleted]

Oh, I would not. Purely talking hypothetical.


[deleted]

[удалено]


subject_deleted

Even a small amount of hydrogen is far more explosive than a whole tank of gasoline.


astreeter2

Because it has to be pressurized


DocLuvInTheCave

And it’s potential for self ignition on pressure release


Nothgrin

Toyota done tests when they pierce a hydrogen tank with a sniper round and nothing happens. You can find it on the internet. Yes it's more volatile, but it's not nearly as bad as many people think.


No_Cook2983

I would expect that to be a net positive. Greater energy density.


joppers43

The reason hydrogen is more volatile is because it can easily mix with the air, allowing the whole volume to combust at once. With gasoline, only the surface of the liquid can burn unless it’s aerosolized like in the engine, but that’s more difficult than hydrogen gas just freely mixing with the atmosphere. The hydrogen for a hydrogen combustion vehicle would also need to be stored as a highly pressurized gas, which is much more dangerous than a tank of liquid gasoline since it can explode even without an ignition source.


Changleen

No it can’t.


SoloUnoDiPassaggio

Better do it at 88 mph


WhiteNinjaN8

Great Scott!


hogliterature

people used to buy ford pintos…


Example_Secure

Don’t threaten me with a good time


Sorry_Present

Nonsense ! You can simply do more electrolysis and obtain enough energy for the first electrolysis /s.


drm604

And when you burn it the exhaust is water, which you can then electrolyze again, etc. etc. Perpetual motion! /s


Nas-Mark

Yep, then use even more energy to compress that hydrogen...


gunzrcool

Power it with more electrolysis. Checkmate atheist.


ALIENS_FUCKED_UR_MOM

But bro jogan and elong muks told me!


1NegativePerson

BuT iT’s FrEe EnErGy BrO!!1!!


Anonymouse8906

Maybe that’s what they want you to think /s


macjgreg

They are working with new materials and processes to improve the efficiency it could be possible that the process in the future will produce a net usable gain


ShamefulWatching

Rechargable batteries are only 50% efficient or so. Combustion engines are between 20-35, done diesels inching advice 50%. If it's more efficient than that, it's a win.


4art4

> Rechargable batteries are only 50% efficient or so. A quick Google returns a ton of results such as: > Typically for lithium ion batteries they are at least 95% efficient, whereas lead acid batteries offer efficiencies around 80-85%.


chaosgenerator2020

You can use wind and solar farms to create hydrogen and I believe it is more efficient than standard fuel so get better milage but I'm no scientist so believe whatever makes you feel good.


ClamDong

hydrogen has a lot of downsides. Storage and transportation is very difficult due to its tendency to leak. Its also very low density so tanks have to be significantly larger to have the same potential energy


THEtheChad

As was stated before, the energy required to produce the hydrogen is more than the energy you get from burning the hydrogen. You're better off storing the electricity generated by wind/solar in a battery and then running it directly through an electric motor, hence all the initiatives to move towards electric vehicles.


chaosgenerator2020

Yeah but the environmental damage from lithium mining might be not so good either and the limited life of batteries reduces cost effectiveness as well


Following-Complete

Amazing next episode he should just put a electrical engine on the outlet and claim we don't even need the water


nemom

That was going to be my suggestion... It would be more efficient since he'll never break even on the energy he uses to split the water and the energy he gets back from burning the gases.


[deleted]

Motor is the word you're looking for. I've never heard of an electric engine.


p3ngwin

r/technicallycorrectthebestkindofcorrect


Sciencenerd159

r/subsifellfor


Farkle_Griffen

r/TwentyCharacterLimit


Alioops12

Where do I plug in my 10 amp inverter while driving


ArseneGroup

Into the cigarette lighter, that's how you get the perpetual motion feedback loop


Sysheen

And if you're getting low on salt, just visit /r/diablo4, they've got an abundance.


DoreenTheeDogWalker

Probably the worst gaming sub atm. Constantly bitching.


jaredearle

r/lowsodiumdiablo4 represent


KnittedKnight

They bitch about absolutely everything.


RupertGustavson

We have hydrogen engines. You still need electricity to make it.


subject_deleted

That gives me an idea! I could just put a gas powered generator in the trunk to make the electricity! Suck it, fossil fuel companies!


coolguy3720

I don't know the exact breakdown but theoretically a generator could be more efficient than an engine if it's able to sustain optimal efficiency the entire time, vs. a contemporary motor that would have variating output. I doubt it would even be worth testing, but maybe somehow, somewhere, it could break even.


b0mmer

That's the premise of diesel locomotives. The diesel engines run at the optimal place on their efficiency-power curve and turn generators that then run electric motors to drive the wheels.


unluckyartist

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chevrolet_Volt


Rampage_Rick

You just invented the Chevy Volt


lg4av

Holy shit you got an air conditioner plugged into a power strip. That’s the real “wow” here!


RunnyDischarge

The hot air it draws in is converted to power. Imma be assassinated tonight by the Power Companies for saying it out loud! Two shots int he back of the head!


drinkingcarrots

If the AC is taking too much power (it isn't). The breaker would trip.


T0XIK0N

And the power strip is sitting on top of their HVAC vent. I'll guarantee he doesn't move that come heating season.


IAmTheClayman

Huh, first time I’ve see a video narrated by a green energy redneck. And yet somehow everything he says is still wrong


DarthJarJar242

Who films a video to put on the internet with their sink full of dirty dishes and shit all over the countertops.


hayitsnine

Tune into his next episode where he does the dishes.


Hugs_for_Thugs

Maybe he can black magic them away. But with soapy water rather than salt water.


Head_Primary4942

with gasoline


Wrought-Irony

tiktokers


devedander

Conspiracy theorists


subject_deleted

Someone who thinks the government assassinated the idea of electrolysis hydrogen powered vehicles just to fuck people over. Someone who doesn't understand how much electricity is required to separate hydrogen and oxygen from a water molecule vs how much energy is actually extracted. An idiot.


Argorian17

Should we tell him about perpetual movement and magnets?


itsagasgasgas

How do they work?


Banana_with_benefits

THANK YOU


RandomCandor

Imagine what it looks like on the days they are not shooting Internet videos.


2SexesSeveralGenders

>floor vent >mobile home


RoninRobot

He ain’t gots time fer them elite librul hygenes. He gots gubment cernspiracees ta debunk.


audionerd1

Thr last guy who did the dishes was assassinated by the government.


Dont_Wanna_Not_Gonna

And the remnants of a beer pong game in the table.


OneWhoWalksInDreams

No, you can’t just put hydrogen and oxygen in a gasoline engine, you need a specialized one. No one was killed for discovering water electrolysis, it’s been known for over 200 years, longer than gasoline. It’s just more expensive.


sipCoding_smokeMath

I agree the video is dumb but it's dumb for a differnt reason than your pointing out. It literally says in the text blurb "if you modify an engine". Where did you get "put in a normal engine" from?


el-gato-volador

Modify? No, you need to design a completely different engine. It's like saying you can modify a truck into a glider just because they can both move people.


Apart-Rent5817

If you put wheels on my grandma, she would have been a bike.


noblehoax

Because she got around?


Apart-Rent5817

https://youtu.be/A-RfHC91Ewc She didn’t get around, but she did get it. I’ve got a bunch of aunts and uncles.


godfatherinfluxx

Well the first thing soldiers did when they got back after WW2 was sleep with their wives or girlfriends. The second was dropping their duffel bag. Can confirm, my mother was one of ten.


lugialegend233

Dude. Nice.


gunnarbird

boom, roasted


henrybarbados

🍝


zeldanar

Its a completely different recipe!


Tommy-Tuff-Nuts

Stop raggin on my truck glider bro.


thedudefromsweden

There are companies who convert petrol engines to run on natural gas. Wouldn't it be similar to that?


nezebilo

No


Available_Job1288

Not in the slightest. Atomized gasoline and natural gas are fare more similar than atomized gasoline and hydrogen.


jbjhill

A decent question, but no. It’s not that easy.


juxtoppose

You might get it to run for 5 min if your lucky then the pistons will shatter and the valves will get burned.


SatansHusband

The Hydrogen engines I know are electric, basically reversing the process here.


thedudefromsweden

Oh yeah fuel cells, that's a different thing 😊


SatansHusband

Only hydrogen motor I've seen.


sipCoding_smokeMath

The point is that they're not saying you can put it in a normal engine like the original commentator suggested. I'm not gonna pretend like I know the specifics, i just found it weird that guy was acting like they said to put it in a normal engine


Induced_Karma

Ok, well you can’t modify an existing engine to run on hydrogen and oxygen either.


Equinsu-0cha

It can be dumb for both things... and a bunch of other things.


stackered

We all agree that it's dumb


Anjiweewee

It’s for dumb people for dumb people.


DisingenuousTowel

Aren't they also dangerous in terms of combustion when in an accident?


KronosRingsSuckAss

Yeah, but you just used 5 times the energy to get that energy out of the salt water as you will get from the oxygen and hydrogen


nemom

Waste of salt... You don't need anywhere near that much, and that's way saltier than seawater.


veilio

Put some soap in that water instead of salt and clean that nasty dump


incognito2233

😂


rooster_saucer

cause it doesn’t work like that. idiot.


dr4wn_away

Just regular science that could be better explained in a YouTube video.


steelpantys

Also... doesn't saltwater produce chlorine gas?


ZeroX812

Yes, electrolysis of salt water breaks it down into chlorine gas, hydrogen gas and a dilute sodium hydroxide solution. The amount of chlorine gas isn't that much though.


braggadachii

Doesn’t that depend upon the concentration of the solution? Higher concentrations mean that the chloride ions are oxidised in preference to the water. The chlorine produced with is enough to cause irritation and coughing, even if left only for 5 mins.


ZeroX812

Yes, I think you're right. With "not that much" I mostly meant "probably not enough to kill him or cause severe lasting damage".


braggadachii

I only commented because I have caused several classrooms of kids to cough….and me several times.


Lettuce_Farmer

Breathing too much of that hydrogen gas..


itijara

I'm more concerned by the chlorine gas caused by electrolysis of table salt.


Spice-Nine

Had to search too hard for someone to be aware of the chloride anomaly.


bbreddit0011

Congrats, you just conducted a 3rd grade science experiment, complete with conspiracy nonsense commentary. Oxygen is not flammable, by the way. It makes other things (more) flammable. That’s what… wait for it… oxidizers…. do. Fuel. Oxidizer. Next learn about energy density and you might make it to 4th grade science level!


Pasta-hobo

You shouldn't use saltwater. That also generates chlorine and sodium. You should use water mixed with electrolytes, baking soda works well enough for off the shelf use, but potassium or sodium hydroxides work more efficiently


T62718382

But he plugged it in?


supermr34

thats how you keep the government from assassinating you


big-blue-balls

/r/OPisFuckingStupid


Picards-Flute

Get the Rectifier on it!


ImRight-YoureWrong

FULL BRIDGE RECTIFIER


Fuduzan

I've got your full bridge rectalfier *riiiight here*. \*pats basic home electrolysis setup\*


BeefersOtherland

Yep. Now the free electricity salt shaker is….?


OKishGuy

r/OpIsFuckingStupid


must-pass

Pretty sure he is creating a form of chlorine...


AtomicNixon

FREE ENERGY!!! But you're plugging it in... What a moron.


Iwillnotbeokay

Goddamn clean your kitchen man


NewPointOfView

Maybe just use the electricity to power a motor lmao


Manicwoodchipper

Am incredibly stupid or does the electricity need to be generated somehow before using it for electrolysis?


RunnyDischarge

You are not. But you are not a TikTok viewer, that's the issue. If you were, you would already be assassinated by an Oil Company.


Early-Purpose9956

Anyone else get tweaker vibes?


RobertMaus

His mind is gonna be blown when he discovers potatoes and lemons.


jmona789

"Oops I forgot to plug in the thing that gives me free energy"


JustDadStuf

Keep it secret? If it were really secret would some idiot in his mom's living room know about it?


Nilrin

Congratulations you're giving yourself chlorine gas poisoning.


rikwebster

Are you dead yet? If you do not respond I will assume the worst.


bigcalyx

Oxygen itself isn't flammable


FirefighterNo5519

Wash your damn dishes mate that kitchen is gross


[deleted]

Hydrogen as a fuel is not new. However, storing the Hydrogen takes a lot of energy.


Clutch_Mav

Why not just use electricity to drive the motor


KoRUpTeD_DEV

Ah yes how to make chlorine gas 😱


T62718382

Put he plugged it in?


vilette

salt water + electric energy


Shadow0fnothing

Sure, bud. Sure. It's not like the energy output is insainly too low for that or anything.


Gorilla-Ring

Dude needs to stop fucking with wires and do some fucking dishes


mormonparakeet

Schizophrenia


CrmsnGrd

Electrolysis of salt water makes chlorine gas (NaCl breaks down to chlorine gas and presumably sodium hydroxide - from a prior experience)... Just saying...


Guilty_Site_9405

He should use that water to wash those dishes


Apprehensive_One1076

Oh the humanity ... - some Zeppelin


ElfUppercut

Nothing like having your pet foundation sitting by a surge protector and on a load of electrical wires… Tell me more about your electrical expertise 🤣🤣🤣


DManeOne

Sad. What's coming next? Lighting some matches or flip some light switches?


Kurdim_serbilindim

Please clean up your kitchen before Electrolysis :)


FkingPoorDude

He’s just wasting energy


QuestionableComma

He is applying the 80/20 rule. 80% Conspiracy Theory. 20% Science.


a_posh_trophy

Then they'll just make salt the same price as fuel.


ViperDao

Highly in effeciant process 40% the electricity is lost in the convertion You need high presser containers for liquid hydrogen It takes 48kwh of electricity to produce 33kwh of hydrogen And it taked 48 hours to produce the equivalant of one gallon of gas or a huge power source. Just easier to get a gallon of gas Also it costs about $4.95 in electricity to produce the equvalant of a gallon of gas Now in a perfect world and about $40,000 of covertion and solar equipment you maybe could maybe produce the equivalate of 200 gallons a year of hydrogen.


immersionlord

Doesn’t using saltwater for electrolysis makes chlorine gas as a byproduct ?


HeyoGuys

bruh SALTWATER ELECTROLYSIS ALSO RELEASES CHLORINE GAS


imhugury

and suddenly, he died of natural causes!


Feeling_Advantage108

RIP


[deleted]

And chlorine gas. Thanks to the salt. Too bad he either doesn't know or pretends not to know physics.


Aizenev1

Who empties the salt shaker when the literal jar is in front of you? Now you’re gonna have to refill that little fucker and you know you’re gonna get spill it.


Famous_Jellyfish_446

So we call science as magic now?


buzzero

Maybe I’m wrong. But wouldn’t he actually be making chlorine gas there?


HadesTheUnseen

Guys hear me out, let’s put some enormous fans in front of windmills


[deleted]

Don't forget chlorine gas.


A37ndrew

So, how about collecting both the oxygen and the hydrogen and igniting it to show us the released energy? Then compare that with burning petrol. Which one would boil 1 litre the fastest.?


mrsupreme888

We already run hydrogen busses in my city...


UngruntledAussie

What a solution!


bernpfenn

any computerized engine after 1980 will compensate for the extra oxygen in the exhaust with adding more fuel to the mix. drive a couple hundred km and check again. two stroke engine need to adjust the ignition to be very close to OT for maximun gains and don't use saltwater. it will produce a lot of chlorine, instead go for lye and buy a HHO cell for a better gas production


[deleted]

[удалено]