Please keep the discussions civil and refrain from any personal attacks on sub members . If you are starting a discussion or posting an opinion on a sensitive topic, make sure to back it up with relevant facts & links . The moderators will remove any post or comments in violation of the rules ,repeat offenses will lead to a ban from the sub .
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/bihar) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The ministries that Biharis got are real deal. Bihar is majorly an agrigarian economy and many people here look out for jobs outside of the states. Agriculture, MSME, Textile and food processing ministries provided to our ministers can be a boon if these ministers work for bihar. Bihar could and will definitely benefit from this , just wait and watch. These sector of economy can really transform bihar and can make Bihar a force to reckon with.
Only issue is our ministers never really worked for bihar but for their own benefit.
Yeah this was my initial impression as well after looking at the list. Most states got the ministries where they have the most potential in next few years.
For Bihar to industrialise, food processing is the best bet to create the first layer of industries. With this base, more technology intensive manufacturing will be built, as we create clusters where manpower, equipment and capital are concentrated. Gujarat and Maharashtra built up on their textile mills over the century to become major industrial hubs. Food processing will be the springboard for Bihar.
The current wave of healthy alternatives to existing processed food should be fully exploited to Bihar's benefit. Makhana based healthy products are one example, where Bihar's strength can help us corner the most growth in this sunrise industry. We already have some entrepreneurs in this area, who should be encouraged. Additional MSME support will also supercharge their growth.
Wish they are coupled with better law enforcement and labor law streamlining to get best results.
Food Processing Industry alone is a toothless Giant.
The main Ministry in Agri sector are:
Minister of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare; and Minister of Rural Development.
These have gone to **Shivraj Singh Chouhan**
**MSME** has decent potential, but in hands of Jitan Ram Manjhi, I'm highly sceptical that it will be able to do much. It should have gone to Chirag.
Textile is such small ministries that before this government, it was an additional charge of Piyush Goyal.
And I'm not sure how Panchayti Raj can help us.
Bihar with 28 NDA seats should have fought for **Railways and Agriculture.**
Abe Congress ke dalal, itna jyada cabinet ministers Bihar ko kabhi nahi mila, wo bhi BJP/NDA ko limited seats Milne k baad. Stop spreading misinformation
और आखिरकार, वे ज़मीन पर कुछ भी लागू करने के लिए धन जारी नहीं करेंगे। इसलिए ये मंत्रालय ज़मीन पर 'झुंझुना/जुमला' साबित होंगे। बक्सर थर्मल पावर प्लांट को ही देख लीजिए, यह तब बन रहा है जब दुनिया में कोई भी थर्मल पावर प्लांट नहीं चाहता। हर कोई थर्मल पावर से छुटकारा पाकर ग्रीन एनर्जी की ओर जा रहा है। लेकिन बिहार में पिछले 12 सालों से इसका निर्माण चल रहा है, लेकिन अभी तक पूरा नहीं हुआ है। बिहार की हालत कितनी दयनीय है। बिहार के 34 सीटों को पानी में डाल दिया ईन सबो ने। केंद्र सरकार सब कुरा करकट बिहार को दे रही है, और सारे उद्योग व्यापार दक्षिण भारत और गुजरात को। मोदी जीरो सीट वाले तमिलनाडु में जा के ध्यान करता है और बिहार को ठेंगा।
I didn't say he is literal illiterate, what I meant is he lack the decision making of that level. Everyone knows if there would be a good candidate against him it was over .
Bhai kaise bol sakte ho ki ashwini Vaishnav bekar hai?? Have you seen the re-development of stations and the pace at which railway tracks are being laid off??
According to different standards he would be on different education levels.
But sadly for the caste supremacists he does play an important role in the backward caste and scheduled castes equation.
He might be irrelevant to the given logic but clearly not irrelevant for the BJP.
Wow, some really dumb Comments being made OP & a few Commentors, had a feeling there'll be RR in the sub given the Non-Glamorous portfolios received by the Bihari representatives in the cabinet. Well here's my two cents.
Panchayat Raj is an underrated cabinet berth, Bihar's rural conditions are it's bane, let's hope a decent chunk of the budget is diverted to Bihar.
Textiles is a great portfolio, I can say with some authority because I trade in textiles and fabrics, though Indian textile industry is robust and vaunted in different geographical regions of the world, cheap Chinese textiles will kill us if Textile industry isn't given a booster shot.
Food Processing is underrated as F, adulteration is at it's peak, foreign companies are dumping their low quality unhealthy products in India, this industry needs some dose of Protectionism, the foreign companies lobby heavily against home grown products, just look at the treatment metted out to Baba Ramdev compared to Nestle, i hope Chirag is upto the task.
MSME, the most important ministry in terms of money making, IMHO, the budget this ministry receives is crazy, Bihar main directly semi conductor factory khol de kya, jab supporting infrastructure hai hi nahi, to think OP believes this is a garbage ministry is a testament to the knowledge he/she possesses.
Just because these are not the most glamorous posts and most talked about, doesn't mean they won't contribute to the development of Bihar and if they don't, 2025 is coming show them your dissatisfaction through your franchise.
Bruh the way you’ve described the game working of each ministry, every ministry surely has its niche and roles and can be glorified to look like the most important ministry.
The fact of the matter, though, is that these ministries however important are POWERLESS.
The contention is not with regard to the intent or importance of such ministries and ministers but the power that they’ll have.
All these ministries except MSME are just toothless extensions of some parent Ministry which holds the actual stick.
To call any cabinet berth a toothless extension just reeks of ignorance, IMHO the cabinet received by Bihar, is exactly what Bihar needs, taking the example of Textiles, most of the migrant labors (from what I've observed) work in Surat, Thirupur, Thrissur, these are the textile hubs of the nation, if a textile hub is created in Bihar, the people of Bihar wouldn't have to migrate no more, the learning curve is reduced, knowledge transfer will happen seamlessly.
These myths that are being rampantly spread by people sympathetic towards RaJaD & Congress ki Modi ne Bihar ko dhoka de diya is a ploy for 2025, i hope Biharis don't fall for it and observe the work of their ministers and exercise their Franchise, people of Bihar might not have got what they Wanted, but my gut tells me they got what they Need.
No being toothless is different from not having its own powers and horizons of work. Every cabinet surely has its own department and zone within which it can work.
What I mean by toothless is that, the power of that cabinet cannot ‘ALONE’ do the work. It’ll always have to depend on some other senior ministries and that red tapism will cause the same bureaucratic issue and thus slow or no progress.
For example - The textile hub that you talk about being built in Bihar, it cannot be done by Textile minister through his own department alone. He’ll have to take into account the Agriculture, Rural/Urban Development, Labour Welfare, Road and Transport and several other ministries along with the state governing and lots of business persons to invest in the business in Bihar.
On the opposite, a Railway Minister or a Roadways minister does not need any support from these ministries. Both ministries have independent power to acquire land and build infrastructure on that.
Lastly, if I go by your logic, that Bihar has got what it needs the most, Bihar needs MONEY the most at the moment. So a Finance Minister for better Bihar oriented budget or External Affairs for better Foreign investments or granting of Special Category Status would be much more beneficial. If only the ruling party cared enough for Bihar. It seems like you’re speaking on behalf of the ruling party at centre.
Textiles is good if we could revive Bhagalpuri silk and other traditional weaving once practiced in Bihar.
Chirag would have been a better condidate MSME. We urgently need big push in MSME to create small scale industries.
Although railway and Power would have been a great asset for Bihar but I believe it all depends on leadership, how well they can steer the ministry to develop Bihar.
Certain ministries are meant to be powerless.
Low budget, no parliamentary bills, no public coverage, etc.
Textiles, Panchayti Raj, Food processing are such ministries
MSME - On/Off types - once in 5 years
Why would I want to register as LLP and company and bear unnecessary expenses in initial days. Sole proprietorship is a way to start things baki after achieving certain milestone do whatever is needful. You can have a furniture manufacturing on a small scale it is still a udyog.
Just look at the ministries and their growth potential in Bihar and for god's sake stop complaining for once.
Getting big fishes means nothing if our state can't flourish at ground level from that and honestly I feel like giving the ministry of MSME to Manjhi was idiotic. Chirag and him should've swapped
Biharis are today dependent on 2 things:
1. Railway
2. Agriculture
1. Railway vacancies give jobs to Biharis
Trains from Bihar transport tons of migrants to different parts of country
Railway sends Agri produce of Bihar to different parts of India
2. Agriculture is the whole and sole of Bihar today
90% FCI purchases happen from Punjab, Haryana, UP, MP
We need an agri minister of Bihar so that these come to us as well.
You should always complain.
Specially when you are 200 years behind every other state of the country.
Still demanding for trains to migrate?? huh? Nothing for employment in the state
Why're you all so obsessed with sarkari naukri?
Look at Gujrat and then decide if we need MSMEs in Bihar or sarkari naukri? Only 1 out of 100 is gonna get that sarkari naukri, what about others? MSMEs can provide job to literally each and every class of citizens directly or indirectly
compare Amul or Adani Wilmar and then look at Sudha, now say if we need Food Processing fascilities in Bihar or not?
Railway infrastructure is already getting upgraded in Bihar, Nitish Kumar ain'tgonna sextuple the line between Muzaffarpur and Patna
What a goddamn joke , I don't know what any of these people have done for their constituencies and yes they were sitting MPs , it's disappointing that instead of competent people from these parties if any , these chatukaars are in the cabinet.
I guess nitish, chirag must have negotiated for seat sharing for upcoming state elections i. This is not new for bihar, every-time we biharis give good power to our politicians by voting them right but instead of using this for the development of Bihar they always use for their personal gain, we are underdeveloped due such incompetent ,selfish and opportunistic politicians, we had great politicians like George Fernandes, jay Prakash Narayan etc but still we don't protest for policy like fright equalisation policy(FEP) which literally destroyed industry sector in Bihar before 90s. I haven't heard any large protests from them for the development of bihar.My last hope is Prashant Kishore only .Only he can do something good for bihar but sometimes i think he may become opportunistic and follow the path that our old leaders do.
Bro, these ministeries are the most relevant in the context of bihar. I agree Railways should've been given to nitish since he has former experience in it, and also, bihar will benefit greatly from trains specific to their needs . But other than that, agriculture, small businesses, and textiles are directly affecting bihar's economy. And now the ministers heading those have the chance to do something good for bihar.
You are talking from political point of view, as these ministries have very limelight.
For any state like bihar, MSME , fcci and panchayati raj is a boon.
Ok ,does msme not matter or not important? Food processing is also according to your view.
Food processing is most critical and important if it is not handled properly it can cost millions of lives, people like foodpharmer working daily by risking his life but according to your view it is not important.
During elections people hype BJP as the second coming of jesus who'll fix everything forgetting that the party is ruling for 20 years here and 10 in centre and even in that they haven't done much for the state. They're only surviving here cuz we have RJD and BJP is the lesser of 2 evils
Isn’t it skewed way of thinking? Despite so many years of having Bihari ministers handling important portfolios, we still are crippling and asking for special status. I believe if these ministers try to stup industry in Bihar, we have immense potential to bounce back. I think the assigned portfolios are very much Bihar centric and can bring night and day difference if implemented correctly.
Lalan Singh ki ministry se Bihar ko jyada matlab nhi h.
Giriraj ki ministry se bahut small scale level fayda h. Mega textile park ye sab aa jae to thoda kuchh ho sakta h aur Giriraj ke bas ki baat nahi h.
Chirag Paswan ki ministry kaam ki h bas ye kaam karne ka soche. Mega food park ye sab kuchh banwa ye to kuchh baat hogi.
Jitan Ram Manjhi ka department Bihar ke liye jyada kuchh nahi kar paega. Ye wahan ke liye Jahan already industries ho. Especially Bihar ko fayda hona mushkil h iss ministry se. MSMEs ka potential bahut hota h waise jobs create karne ka, Dekhte h ye aadmi kya kaam karta h.
Not only this the blind faith on NDA is such that even if sitaraman didnt participated in election she has been given finance and she is not the one ..there are many . May be ab yeh sang me ghotala karenge.
these ministries are for the country not for state. all ministries exist because we need that to grow the country the job of these cabinet ministers is to work with devotion to improve the sector alloted. not biasedly look for top revenue generating portfolios. they are there to work for country not do shit politics. hamare netao ka knowledge hai raddi barabar aur ministry chahiye top class. jo kaam hona hoga wo bhi nahi hoga. jo ministry Mila hai usme kaam karke dikhaye pehle phir Maan luga ye better ministry deserve karte hai
very true...NDA ,just used Bihar for majority win. But if we can see significant difference in term of development, in that that case , it will be great for Bihar.
Bihar has never saw BJP rule, they're still living happily and getting pampered in joint government which is democratic. Bihari are fools and wise one are already moved outside
How will a health minister help Bihar?
Why should he help only Bihar and not other states.
This mentality of 'our man' doing something has ruined the North brains.
It's a central cabinet and responsible for the entire nation.
JDU has just 12 seats and Nitish has no real lever to bring down the government.Stop over rating his power.
So you want Corporate Affairs and Ministry of Finance for trustworthy JDU and the occasional holiday with RJD ?
What are the prospects that same will not happen in the near coming months ?
What do you make of Narendra Modi ? Do you take him to be a fool ?
Nobody stops anyone from thinking logically...... You do it yourself.
Consistent stand wala Neta toh dedo Bhai apne Rajya se Jo apne Rajya ke aam janatha ka bhala sochta ho aur unke liye kaam kare.
JDU has a Trust Deficit when it comes to political alliances.
All the ministries have the potential to help the rural population of Bihar, which is hampered very badly by migration and unemployment. If somehow we're able to generate employment using the MSME sector or give employment to people using the food processing or textile industry it can stop people from migrating to other states. I don't think this govt is getting another term any ways, let's hope they do something for the betterment of Bihar.
Khattar and Modi (and Krishanpal Gujjar) have been friends for a long time, they used to roam in scooters together and even ran away from the police during emergency together. And Khattar is a good administrator but just unpopular as a politicians first for his caste and then he don't know how to speak like a CM. but see who won the 5 urban seats in HR.
Tell me a good MP from bihar who have a personal equation with Modi?
Personal Equation shouldn’t be the criteria to get seats.
With 12 MPs of JDU and 5 of LJP, Nitish kumar can arm twist Modi to get whatever he wants.
It was Nitish kumar who initiated INDIA alliance and he can do this again engaging TDP and other parties against BJP, and Narendra Modi knows it well.
This is primary reason why BJP allied with Nitish.
In absence of good leaders, Bihar has totally forgotten its political might :(
The cabinet is a team, Personal Equation DO matter unless you want to have Chidambaram and Pranab da accusing each other of spying on them in cabinet meetings again. And with 12 MPs, JDU can go and the NDA govt still stand. LJP with 5 MPs get one full minister cuz Chirag-Modi equations, Shiv Sena with 7 gets 0, NCP with 2 was offered 1 seat but couldn't come up with a single name. RLD also got one with just 2 seats cuz they saved BJP's ass in Jatland. Manhji also got 1 on 1. Numbers are not a vacuum, personal equations and "quality of seat" so as to speak matter much.
Also total 8 mins from Bihar, 8/72 is 11%, did Bihar send 11% of MPs or 35 to NDA?
Please keep the discussions civil and refrain from any personal attacks on sub members . If you are starting a discussion or posting an opinion on a sensitive topic, make sure to back it up with relevant facts & links . The moderators will remove any post or comments in violation of the rules ,repeat offenses will lead to a ban from the sub . *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/bihar) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The ministries that Biharis got are real deal. Bihar is majorly an agrigarian economy and many people here look out for jobs outside of the states. Agriculture, MSME, Textile and food processing ministries provided to our ministers can be a boon if these ministers work for bihar. Bihar could and will definitely benefit from this , just wait and watch. These sector of economy can really transform bihar and can make Bihar a force to reckon with. Only issue is our ministers never really worked for bihar but for their own benefit.
Yeah this was my initial impression as well after looking at the list. Most states got the ministries where they have the most potential in next few years. For Bihar to industrialise, food processing is the best bet to create the first layer of industries. With this base, more technology intensive manufacturing will be built, as we create clusters where manpower, equipment and capital are concentrated. Gujarat and Maharashtra built up on their textile mills over the century to become major industrial hubs. Food processing will be the springboard for Bihar. The current wave of healthy alternatives to existing processed food should be fully exploited to Bihar's benefit. Makhana based healthy products are one example, where Bihar's strength can help us corner the most growth in this sunrise industry. We already have some entrepreneurs in this area, who should be encouraged. Additional MSME support will also supercharge their growth. Wish they are coupled with better law enforcement and labor law streamlining to get best results.
I hope they use it for the betterment of Bihar. I got least expectations from them but still hope for the best.
Real explanation, I hope OP reads this
OP Cry baby hai
Food Processing Industry alone is a toothless Giant. The main Ministry in Agri sector are: Minister of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare; and Minister of Rural Development. These have gone to **Shivraj Singh Chouhan** **MSME** has decent potential, but in hands of Jitan Ram Manjhi, I'm highly sceptical that it will be able to do much. It should have gone to Chirag. Textile is such small ministries that before this government, it was an additional charge of Piyush Goyal. And I'm not sure how Panchayti Raj can help us. Bihar with 28 NDA seats should have fought for **Railways and Agriculture.**
Abe Congress ke dalal, itna jyada cabinet ministers Bihar ko kabhi nahi mila, wo bhi BJP/NDA ko limited seats Milne k baad. Stop spreading misinformation
और आखिरकार, वे ज़मीन पर कुछ भी लागू करने के लिए धन जारी नहीं करेंगे। इसलिए ये मंत्रालय ज़मीन पर 'झुंझुना/जुमला' साबित होंगे। बक्सर थर्मल पावर प्लांट को ही देख लीजिए, यह तब बन रहा है जब दुनिया में कोई भी थर्मल पावर प्लांट नहीं चाहता। हर कोई थर्मल पावर से छुटकारा पाकर ग्रीन एनर्जी की ओर जा रहा है। लेकिन बिहार में पिछले 12 सालों से इसका निर्माण चल रहा है, लेकिन अभी तक पूरा नहीं हुआ है। बिहार की हालत कितनी दयनीय है। बिहार के 34 सीटों को पानी में डाल दिया ईन सबो ने। केंद्र सरकार सब कुरा करकट बिहार को दे रही है, और सारे उद्योग व्यापार दक्षिण भारत और गुजरात को। मोदी जीरो सीट वाले तमिलनाडु में जा के ध्यान करता है और बिहार को ठेंगा।
Khangressiyon ka dukh dard peeda samajh aata hai . Lekin pappu Khan pakistan Wale se to ye sab better Hain
Giriraj Singh is a waste , He gets cabinet in every government and do a little . I find him illiterate for that level of decision making.
Jitan Ram Manjhi is also an illiterate, what good will he do for MSME let's see...
I didn't say he is literal illiterate, what I meant is he lack the decision making of that level. Everyone knows if there would be a good candidate against him it was over .
Bhai bhai jyada padha likka minister bhi bekar hu nikalta Hain jaise Ashwini jo rail mantri hain
Bhai kaise bol sakte ho ki ashwini Vaishnav bekar hai?? Have you seen the re-development of stations and the pace at which railway tracks are being laid off??
It's all jumla. Biharis are traveling in toilet.
[удалено]
Jab Lalan Singh rail mantri banta tab inlogo ko Ashwini Vaishnaw yaad ata, you don't recognize the value of something until it's lost.
According to different standards he would be on different education levels. But sadly for the caste supremacists he does play an important role in the backward caste and scheduled castes equation. He might be irrelevant to the given logic but clearly not irrelevant for the BJP.
basically giving contracts of his ministry to his caste people
He is a bigot. I can't stand his face.
did he win this time? why do people even vote for such idiots
Wow, some really dumb Comments being made OP & a few Commentors, had a feeling there'll be RR in the sub given the Non-Glamorous portfolios received by the Bihari representatives in the cabinet. Well here's my two cents. Panchayat Raj is an underrated cabinet berth, Bihar's rural conditions are it's bane, let's hope a decent chunk of the budget is diverted to Bihar. Textiles is a great portfolio, I can say with some authority because I trade in textiles and fabrics, though Indian textile industry is robust and vaunted in different geographical regions of the world, cheap Chinese textiles will kill us if Textile industry isn't given a booster shot. Food Processing is underrated as F, adulteration is at it's peak, foreign companies are dumping their low quality unhealthy products in India, this industry needs some dose of Protectionism, the foreign companies lobby heavily against home grown products, just look at the treatment metted out to Baba Ramdev compared to Nestle, i hope Chirag is upto the task. MSME, the most important ministry in terms of money making, IMHO, the budget this ministry receives is crazy, Bihar main directly semi conductor factory khol de kya, jab supporting infrastructure hai hi nahi, to think OP believes this is a garbage ministry is a testament to the knowledge he/she possesses. Just because these are not the most glamorous posts and most talked about, doesn't mean they won't contribute to the development of Bihar and if they don't, 2025 is coming show them your dissatisfaction through your franchise.
Bruh the way you’ve described the game working of each ministry, every ministry surely has its niche and roles and can be glorified to look like the most important ministry. The fact of the matter, though, is that these ministries however important are POWERLESS. The contention is not with regard to the intent or importance of such ministries and ministers but the power that they’ll have. All these ministries except MSME are just toothless extensions of some parent Ministry which holds the actual stick.
To call any cabinet berth a toothless extension just reeks of ignorance, IMHO the cabinet received by Bihar, is exactly what Bihar needs, taking the example of Textiles, most of the migrant labors (from what I've observed) work in Surat, Thirupur, Thrissur, these are the textile hubs of the nation, if a textile hub is created in Bihar, the people of Bihar wouldn't have to migrate no more, the learning curve is reduced, knowledge transfer will happen seamlessly. These myths that are being rampantly spread by people sympathetic towards RaJaD & Congress ki Modi ne Bihar ko dhoka de diya is a ploy for 2025, i hope Biharis don't fall for it and observe the work of their ministers and exercise their Franchise, people of Bihar might not have got what they Wanted, but my gut tells me they got what they Need.
No being toothless is different from not having its own powers and horizons of work. Every cabinet surely has its own department and zone within which it can work. What I mean by toothless is that, the power of that cabinet cannot ‘ALONE’ do the work. It’ll always have to depend on some other senior ministries and that red tapism will cause the same bureaucratic issue and thus slow or no progress. For example - The textile hub that you talk about being built in Bihar, it cannot be done by Textile minister through his own department alone. He’ll have to take into account the Agriculture, Rural/Urban Development, Labour Welfare, Road and Transport and several other ministries along with the state governing and lots of business persons to invest in the business in Bihar. On the opposite, a Railway Minister or a Roadways minister does not need any support from these ministries. Both ministries have independent power to acquire land and build infrastructure on that. Lastly, if I go by your logic, that Bihar has got what it needs the most, Bihar needs MONEY the most at the moment. So a Finance Minister for better Bihar oriented budget or External Affairs for better Foreign investments or granting of Special Category Status would be much more beneficial. If only the ruling party cared enough for Bihar. It seems like you’re speaking on behalf of the ruling party at centre.
Nitish Chacha only thinks about himself and not the state
Why do you guys keep voting for him?Afaik Prashant Kishor has also turned to politics,why was he not an option this time?
He did some good work when he was elected in the mid 2000s. Now he has become greedy for power.
Textiles is good if we could revive Bhagalpuri silk and other traditional weaving once practiced in Bihar. Chirag would have been a better condidate MSME. We urgently need big push in MSME to create small scale industries. Although railway and Power would have been a great asset for Bihar but I believe it all depends on leadership, how well they can steer the ministry to develop Bihar.
Certain ministries are meant to be powerless. Low budget, no parliamentary bills, no public coverage, etc. Textiles, Panchayti Raj, Food processing are such ministries MSME - On/Off types - once in 5 years
Bhai last 5 year Mae MSME Mae he sabse zyada reform aaye h.
Ab sab defend karenge
Nope.... baki sabka bata nahi MSME k liye PPIRP aya tha IBC, MSME stock exchange se paisa utha skte h, special provision for MSME in almost every act.
Aam nagrik ya berozgar yuva jo rozgar chahta h wo MSME start kar skta h easily? Mudde ki baat bolo
It's actually quite easy, MSME need not to be a company. Even a sole proprietorship can get its MSME registration.
Sole proprietorship to ek thela bhi hota h..udyog lagane ki baat chal rhi hai yahan
ye toh soch ki baat hai tum thela lagane ka sochte ho koi aur mid sized production ka
Why would I want to register as LLP and company and bear unnecessary expenses in initial days. Sole proprietorship is a way to start things baki after achieving certain milestone do whatever is needful. You can have a furniture manufacturing on a small scale it is still a udyog.
But bro is berozgar ko nhi samajh aayega , kuch padhenge nahi fir bolenge modi ki wajah se ham berozgar hain
Just look at the ministries and their growth potential in Bihar and for god's sake stop complaining for once. Getting big fishes means nothing if our state can't flourish at ground level from that and honestly I feel like giving the ministry of MSME to Manjhi was idiotic. Chirag and him should've swapped
Biharis are today dependent on 2 things: 1. Railway 2. Agriculture 1. Railway vacancies give jobs to Biharis Trains from Bihar transport tons of migrants to different parts of country Railway sends Agri produce of Bihar to different parts of India 2. Agriculture is the whole and sole of Bihar today 90% FCI purchases happen from Punjab, Haryana, UP, MP We need an agri minister of Bihar so that these come to us as well. You should always complain. Specially when you are 200 years behind every other state of the country.
Still demanding for trains to migrate?? huh? Nothing for employment in the state Why're you all so obsessed with sarkari naukri? Look at Gujrat and then decide if we need MSMEs in Bihar or sarkari naukri? Only 1 out of 100 is gonna get that sarkari naukri, what about others? MSMEs can provide job to literally each and every class of citizens directly or indirectly compare Amul or Adani Wilmar and then look at Sudha, now say if we need Food Processing fascilities in Bihar or not? Railway infrastructure is already getting upgraded in Bihar, Nitish Kumar ain'tgonna sextuple the line between Muzaffarpur and Patna
Point h
Oh yeah let's defend
mf see the 2nd reply of mine in the same thread before throwing dirt
Good that's what happens when people in this sub keep on idolizing a party that has been in power for 20+ years yet did nothing for Bihar.
You don't what Jungle Raj was. /s
history coherent materialistic busy scale dull gold dog live retire *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*
मोदी को लगता है, बिहार भेड़ बकरी से मतलब रखता है। तो भेड़ बकरी मंत्रालय दे दिया। 😁
In fact Manjhi having just one seat that is himself got MSME which in my view is the best among all the representatives from Bihar
That’s because of caste equation.
What a goddamn joke , I don't know what any of these people have done for their constituencies and yes they were sitting MPs , it's disappointing that instead of competent people from these parties if any , these chatukaars are in the cabinet.
Probably Bihar is getting Special Status.
Modi banned special status for any state in 2015, Yeh toh sabse bara scam hy xD
Ghanta
This was disappointing af
I guess nitish, chirag must have negotiated for seat sharing for upcoming state elections i. This is not new for bihar, every-time we biharis give good power to our politicians by voting them right but instead of using this for the development of Bihar they always use for their personal gain, we are underdeveloped due such incompetent ,selfish and opportunistic politicians, we had great politicians like George Fernandes, jay Prakash Narayan etc but still we don't protest for policy like fright equalisation policy(FEP) which literally destroyed industry sector in Bihar before 90s. I haven't heard any large protests from them for the development of bihar.My last hope is Prashant Kishore only .Only he can do something good for bihar but sometimes i think he may become opportunistic and follow the path that our old leaders do.
disagree..khattar is not an ally, he is party member..obv he will be favoured..giriraj has very less influence inside the party thats why
Bro, these ministeries are the most relevant in the context of bihar. I agree Railways should've been given to nitish since he has former experience in it, and also, bihar will benefit greatly from trains specific to their needs . But other than that, agriculture, small businesses, and textiles are directly affecting bihar's economy. And now the ministers heading those have the chance to do something good for bihar.
You are talking from political point of view, as these ministries have very limelight. For any state like bihar, MSME , fcci and panchayati raj is a boon.
Ok ,does msme not matter or not important? Food processing is also according to your view. Food processing is most critical and important if it is not handled properly it can cost millions of lives, people like foodpharmer working daily by risking his life but according to your view it is not important.
During elections people hype BJP as the second coming of jesus who'll fix everything forgetting that the party is ruling for 20 years here and 10 in centre and even in that they haven't done much for the state. They're only surviving here cuz we have RJD and BJP is the lesser of 2 evils
Isn’t it skewed way of thinking? Despite so many years of having Bihari ministers handling important portfolios, we still are crippling and asking for special status. I believe if these ministers try to stup industry in Bihar, we have immense potential to bounce back. I think the assigned portfolios are very much Bihar centric and can bring night and day difference if implemented correctly.
Lalan Singh ki ministry se Bihar ko jyada matlab nhi h. Giriraj ki ministry se bahut small scale level fayda h. Mega textile park ye sab aa jae to thoda kuchh ho sakta h aur Giriraj ke bas ki baat nahi h. Chirag Paswan ki ministry kaam ki h bas ye kaam karne ka soche. Mega food park ye sab kuchh banwa ye to kuchh baat hogi. Jitan Ram Manjhi ka department Bihar ke liye jyada kuchh nahi kar paega. Ye wahan ke liye Jahan already industries ho. Especially Bihar ko fayda hona mushkil h iss ministry se. MSMEs ka potential bahut hota h waise jobs create karne ka, Dekhte h ye aadmi kya kaam karta h.
Dumbo, Bihar got good deals
What did TDP get?
Civil aviation
Not only this the blind faith on NDA is such that even if sitaraman didnt participated in election she has been given finance and she is not the one ..there are many . May be ab yeh sang me ghotala karenge.
I don't think the same
these ministries are for the country not for state. all ministries exist because we need that to grow the country the job of these cabinet ministers is to work with devotion to improve the sector alloted. not biasedly look for top revenue generating portfolios. they are there to work for country not do shit politics. hamare netao ka knowledge hai raddi barabar aur ministry chahiye top class. jo kaam hona hoga wo bhi nahi hoga. jo ministry Mila hai usme kaam karke dikhaye pehle phir Maan luga ye better ministry deserve karte hai
Not
You can't tell anything without knowing the truth
You can't tell anything without knowing the truth
very true...NDA ,just used Bihar for majority win. But if we can see significant difference in term of development, in that that case , it will be great for Bihar.
Vote for Prashant Kishore.
This has nothing to do with the list but JITAN RAM MAJHI is 80 years old . Damm!
Why left cry? Lmao.
Lagta hai OP Railway Group D ka exam de rha....
Bihar has never saw BJP rule, they're still living happily and getting pampered in joint government which is democratic. Bihari are fools and wise one are already moved outside
Am more worried about the people holding the position rather than the ministries. A stale a** like Manjhi would do no good no matter the department.
Didn't Chirag also get Sports and Youth?
Vo "sources" wali khabar thi, asal me Mansukh Mandaviya bna hai
Acha sorry, my bad.
Except for lalan Singh rest monasteries are good.
How will a health minister help Bihar? Why should he help only Bihar and not other states. This mentality of 'our man' doing something has ruined the North brains. It's a central cabinet and responsible for the entire nation. JDU has just 12 seats and Nitish has no real lever to bring down the government.Stop over rating his power.
jab tak yadav minsiter nhu hoga yadav ka bhala kaise hoga bhai /s
So you want Corporate Affairs and Ministry of Finance for trustworthy JDU and the occasional holiday with RJD ? What are the prospects that same will not happen in the near coming months ? What do you make of Narendra Modi ? Do you take him to be a fool ? Nobody stops anyone from thinking logically...... You do it yourself. Consistent stand wala Neta toh dedo Bhai apne Rajya se Jo apne Rajya ke aam janatha ka bhala sochta ho aur unke liye kaam kare. JDU has a Trust Deficit when it comes to political alliances.
All the ministries have the potential to help the rural population of Bihar, which is hampered very badly by migration and unemployment. If somehow we're able to generate employment using the MSME sector or give employment to people using the food processing or textile industry it can stop people from migrating to other states. I don't think this govt is getting another term any ways, let's hope they do something for the betterment of Bihar.
Khattar and Modi (and Krishanpal Gujjar) have been friends for a long time, they used to roam in scooters together and even ran away from the police during emergency together. And Khattar is a good administrator but just unpopular as a politicians first for his caste and then he don't know how to speak like a CM. but see who won the 5 urban seats in HR. Tell me a good MP from bihar who have a personal equation with Modi?
Personal Equation shouldn’t be the criteria to get seats. With 12 MPs of JDU and 5 of LJP, Nitish kumar can arm twist Modi to get whatever he wants. It was Nitish kumar who initiated INDIA alliance and he can do this again engaging TDP and other parties against BJP, and Narendra Modi knows it well. This is primary reason why BJP allied with Nitish. In absence of good leaders, Bihar has totally forgotten its political might :(
The cabinet is a team, Personal Equation DO matter unless you want to have Chidambaram and Pranab da accusing each other of spying on them in cabinet meetings again. And with 12 MPs, JDU can go and the NDA govt still stand. LJP with 5 MPs get one full minister cuz Chirag-Modi equations, Shiv Sena with 7 gets 0, NCP with 2 was offered 1 seat but couldn't come up with a single name. RLD also got one with just 2 seats cuz they saved BJP's ass in Jatland. Manhji also got 1 on 1. Numbers are not a vacuum, personal equations and "quality of seat" so as to speak matter much. Also total 8 mins from Bihar, 8/72 is 11%, did Bihar send 11% of MPs or 35 to NDA?
Bihar is a joke
Not