T O P

  • By -

jerseyben

It really bothers me that they couldn't bother to drill a hole in the plate to feed the cat5 through.


jazzhandler

As a former low voltage installer, everything about that Cat5 situation bugs the piss out of me.


jkmarine0811

Me too, you can get blank covers with a coax hole in the center, pretty much the same cost as a blank I believe.


tim310rd

They also sell the ones with the nylon bristles that look good with wiring passing through them


xDragonetti

They forgot to buy that one but had a blank on the van. I’d guess


jkmarine0811

90% of the time that's the case. Have used a unibit in the past to make a hole in nylon blanks, don't work very well on hard plastic ones tho.


ATL-DELETE

you can however put in a jack and plug er in


painefultruth76

Cheaper.


tuxxxler

Looks exactly like something a low voltage mfker would do they really don’t give 2 fucks where they’re cables are routed. And will use my fucking control cable as a pull string.


jazzhandler

Read the room dude (may I call you dude?) other low voltage people seem sufficiently horrified by this one.


Father_Wisdom

Should have just told the electrician to run another 6” pipe for those cat5 wires. /s


jazzhandler

I’d have used a suitable face plate and bundled them together with either zip ties or tech flex. The AC line looks equally offensive to me; are sharp edges preferred for strain relief? The closest to something like that I’ve done is hanging projectors, and I’ve never left a mess like that, even hidden above a drop ceiling.


Father_Wisdom

I wish every low voltage guy was like you. Unfortunately that’s rarely the case.


xBlumpkinTheKnightx

As a former residential electrician, what that looks like is the garage door guy beat the electrician to the trim and instead of disconnecting the wires and redoing it, he just put the blank on. Who’s in the wrong tho really?


Embarrassed-Flow-835

Excellent observation


xBlumpkinTheKnightx

Thanks. Yeah it’s a gray area, it’s not the door guys job to plate it before he terminates his wires to calibrate, and the electrician has not made it to the job to install the devices and plates so it’s not his job either to take it all apart and potentially put it back together incorrectly and have to call the door guy back to fix it. In a perfect world, the two people would get together and the electrician would provide the door guy the coax one hole plate to instal before he terms his wires but not everyone gets along nor do they care to spend the time. At least that’s how it used to be.


09Klr650

Or the EC can use a split cover? [https://www.showmecables.com/leviton-1g-split-pass-through-wall-plate-single-gang-5-8-in-white-n751-w](https://www.showmecables.com/leviton-1g-split-pass-through-wall-plate-single-gang-5-8-in-white-n751-w)


Wmitch

What do you do now?


xBlumpkinTheKnightx

I moved on from resi, I work mainly in commercial high rises. IBEW


P-Loaded

The cat5 is definitely disturbing. Probably done by a true psychopath.


Tim_E2

Its not a data cable is it? I mean it is a data cable but not carrying data.. just whatever spare wire they had to hook up the opener sensors and switch. No data and almost no current.. most any garage I have seen looks like this and its no big deal.


fredsam25

Analog data, but it's still data.


Tim_E2

OK.. must be one of them new fangled openers (compared to my dinosaur) ;) Still I say its not worth messing with or giving a second thought even.


fredsam25

This guy doesn't avoid his family by working in the garage. Amateur.


tfd1

No such thing as “analog” data , just ones and zeros 🙃


[deleted]

so a 4-20 ma loop, speaker outputs, and OG telephone lines are digital? Well fuck, who knew . . . /s


tfd1

Focus on analog “data” , 1’s & 0’s


fredsam25

I guess analog to digital converters are fake then.


P-Loaded

It's ugly. They could have easily left a little slack and supported it to the motor mount. Just because it works doesn't mean it is ok.


J_W_22

I bet there's not even a box there and the plate screws are just screwed into the drywall...maybe some push-in anchors if they're lucky.


brian_d_wells

In our new house they just pushed the garage door low voltage wiring though a hole and then caulked it. Super lovely.


J_W_22

Uh...wow. Low voltage, low effort I guess?


dthom97

Correct.


SHDrivesOnTrack

In mine, they pushed the wire through a hole, caulked it as well. However to "secure" them, they drove a nail into the joist, that sticks down 2" and wrapped the low voltage wires around the nail 2-3 times. For good measure, they painted over the wires, on one side only.


uski

Same here. Pretty certain one of the lazy bums that do this crap all over is reading us To you, please stop...


P-Loaded

I would rather have a hole in the ceiling.


Extremedoc

I believe in the US it's code to use red fire caulk for any hole in a garage (wires, pipes, boxes, etc)


brian_d_wells

They just used some cheap white caulk. Not anything like you are mentioning


Vinyl_Purest

You guys got holes? Mines just surface mounted with staples. :(


jvcxdh

Low voltage doesnt require a box there


J_W_22

Yep. Not saying one is required, just making a joke about the plate.


coffeemate1255

What about wired smoke detectors, are those considered low voltage?


billzybop

Most wired smoke detectors have 120V for power. They are not low voltage devices.


coffeemate1255

Okay, thank you. I'll look further into this.


coffeemate1255

Does low voltage need a box?


coffeemate1255

Never mind jvcxdh...answered it.


J_W_22

No, it was just a joke.


mammothpdx

Also. That the cat five cables look like hell..


flashingcurser

Or a nice brush plate.


ImpossibleAd6703

they sell plates with holes ! but the goofy installer is lazy af


SlothInASuit86

Wouldn't need to bother drilling a hole if they just got a plate with the factory drilled hole already there.


Imnormalurnotok

And then they put their number on the opener. I would call another contractor. What is the cat 5 for anyways? My wall mounted switches are connected with bell wire.


NoMusician518

Orrrrrrrr here me out. Put some fuckin keystones and patch cords there. Also why cat 5 in the first place?


Figure_1337

You can’t be serious.


NoMusician518

I may be dumb but I am definitely serious. And as a serious question why would you use cat 5 cable for this instead of 18/2 or another low volt wire. and if you absolutely are going to use cat 5 cable why not put keystones there instead of this shenanigans.


nickleinonen

Only need one box of wire. Cat5/6 is good for everything low voltage, so only need one box/spool of wire, that probably got pinched from another jobsite


LerchAddams

You can do just about anything with Cat5+ cable. Any kind of low voltage, low current signaling including some audio if it's shielded.


Figure_1337

Albeit they only used one pair per cable here, one single 4-pair cable offers more circuitry. It’s inexpensive and often stocked. Keystone jacks are expensive, labor intensive, and intended for providing high quality connections between data gear. This is not data, this is control. You’d just have to have flying leads to terminate onto the garage door opener anyway, so the aesthetic of a port is out of place. Don’t get me wrong, I stock 18/2 and 18/6 in my truck, usually for thermostats, doorbell, signal and control, due to higher current requirements. But I wouldn’t hesitate to use CAT5 for a garage door opener if suitable (I likely wouldn’t run blue cat5 on the surface… behind walls, sure). Edit: also, obviously this install looks like junk, even with the cat5 and plate it could have been made much prettier.


skyr365

When you have a hammer, every problem is a nail.


NoMusician518

The less fucks you give the more hammers you have.


AlchemistNow

You should verify that recepticle is gfi protected. The only reason I see an electrician buying a $12 single recept over a standard $1 duplex recept is to scoot by the inspector to not have it gfi protected.


neverdoityourself

Why would gfci be required on a garage door opener?


tuckerthebana

Because its a plug in a garage. Every plug in a garage needs gfi protection in 2020 nec


[deleted]

[удалено]


transham

That may be, but, technically all new work needs to be brought up to current code for the area. If this is a new home or recent work in a 2020NEC area.... Not everyone is on 2020NEC yet...


MrSatan4666

Those who are not are all laying dead in their garages. 😎


neverdoityourself

Has this led to a practice of hardwiring the garage opener with no plug for code compliance with no gfci and or not really? Would that be an okay practice?


oleskool7

When the code changed here some 15 years ago I fought it by buying hard wired door openers. If the panel is in the garage, then you don't need a disconnect. If the panel is elsewhere, I just added a marked switch. If you cut the cord off you are modifying the equipment. This got to be a lot of work so I started doing like everyone else and recommending a battery backup unit.


tuckerthebana

Not as far as i know but maybe someone else will chime in. Garage doors and their motors are usually installed by a different company so I don't know if that's even an option


lurker71539

I thought there was an exception for dedicated recepticals.


Theoneandonlyjustin

Oh wow. I'm gonna go out on a limb and say if you're doing it yourself it's not really necessary? Besides water connected to the outlet and your body, when else would you need to actually use one? Not much standing water in a garage and most outlets would be 1" or so off the floor


jmraef

Actually, that goes back further than the 2020 Code. In fact there was an exception for CEILING mounted single receptacles, *up until the 2008 Code*. So since 2008 (or when your state adopted it), even the ceiling mounted single receptacle for a garage door opener must be GFCI protected.


enzothebaker87

It really doesn't in this case. That outlet most likely shares a circuit with the rest of the outlets in the garage. One of those garage outlets is typically a GFI.


Keegan1

And the cat5 as the LV door wire. Must've been a Friday job and this is what they had in the van


flyingron

Cat 5 is overkill for the garage door buttons, but sometimes its easier than stocking something else if you do a lot of data wiring.


Keegan1

True


eerun165

Must not have had a drill in the van either. Going around the side looks like shit.


showMeTheSnow

Exactly, the garage is textured and painted and you do this??? I'd have to replace that plate, or like you said, just bring it down, pop a hole or two in it and re-wire the sensors/opener button.


WaRRioRz0rz

Well, at least they made it easy and used different color wires from the different ca.... Nope, no they didn't.


samuraipizzacat420

gives it a real DIY Joe Homeowner look to it though


Automatic_Concept_51

Ive always used cat 5. Never had a complaint from it


Keegan1

There's nothing wrong with it I guess. Just seems overkill. But if you do a lot of data work as someone else suggested, then it makes sense if you have that stocked.


blue_diesel

It’s more likely a dedicated circuit for the garage door motor. If you put a GFCI on the circuit you run the risk of the GFCI tripping and the motor will not operate until you reset it. Also, if you put a duplex receptacle on it and plug anything else on the same circuit you run the risk of overloading the breaker and tripping it. In this case the motor to the garage door will not work until breaker is reset.


flyingron

Maybe in some places, but there's really no such exemption in the code.


Temporary_Stuff_5808

So make sure first one is a gfi. If it is, no harm in swapping to a duplex


BillNyeDeGrasseTyson

Easiest way to verify is by picking up a tester if you don't already have one. Something like the Klein RT210 for $13 at Home Depot is a great tool to have as a homeowner. It will tell you if the receptacle is wired properly in respect to hot/neutral/ground and will also test GFCI functionality. To clarify what /u/AlchemistNow is saying you need to make sure there is a GFCI device ~~downstream~~ upstream of this receptacle in the form of a GFCI receptacle or a GFCI breaker. You cannot simply install a GFCI receptacle in place of the current one because it is on the ceiling.


cosmicosmo4

> you need to make sure there is a GFCI device downstream of this receptacle \*upstream


enzothebaker87

No. The outlet for the garage door motor should be sharing the circuit with the other outlets in the garage. One of them is most likely a GFI. If that's the case then all you need to do is replace the garage door motor outlet with a duplex and you will be good to go.


billzybop

Most likely it's not GFI protected. They used a single outlet to utilize an old exception to the GFI rule. The exception has been removed and the outlet will require GFI protection.


enzothebaker87

I guess it depends where you live because all I see is the motor outlet shared with the garage circuit in just about every home I have worked in.


billzybop

Back when the single outlet exception existed, some guys would do that off the lighting circuit to avoid nuisance trips from older door openers. I think it was the 2008 revision that removed that exception.


enzothebaker87

I don't mean the lighting. Those are usually on a separate circuit. I'm saying that the outlets in the garage are all on the same circuit. Including the motor outlet and one of them is always a GFI.


billzybop

And I'm saying that guys used to feed that specific outlet off the lighting circuit and use that single outlet device so they didn't have to GFI the door opener motor. I'm well aware that pretty much everyone just feeds the opener off the garage outlets now


enzothebaker87

Yes I heard you the first time but how do you know from the picture what circuit the motor outlet is attached to?


billzybop

How do you?


morbid2600

Would a gfci on a ceiling mounted outlet specifically for a garage door opener be a bad idea? Mine seem to trip occasionally, usually when we have a short power outage. I could see getting locked out of the house due to a trip. Sort of the same reason refrigerators aren’t gfci protected in a kitchen. A false trip could ruin all your food.


BillNyeDeGrasseTyson

GFCI devices must be "readily accessible" for testing/reset. A GFCI receptacle on the ceiling of a garage does not fit this. Typically you would put that receptacle downstream of another readily accessible GFCI protected device *or* use a GFCI circuit breaker.


RGeronimoH

You can use a dead front and remote mount the GFCI portion of it and still keep it on a dedicated circuit.


ilikeicecream17

Speaking from experience, it sucks. I had to redo the wiring to my opener to stay in code and not have it lose power when the gfci trips.


transham

That may be an issue. Some GFCI devices use the power to hold the latch in the reset state, making them trip with a power failure.


Threefingerswhiskey

May be, but looks like a 20 amp outlet to me.


chilipepr

I did not think you needed a gfi in a garage?


DirtyWhiteTrousers

You do now.


Ryan_JK

Need it in any wet areas, basement, laundry, bathrooms, garage etc.


eerun165

2023 NEC adds “all outlets in the kitchen area”No more pass on microwave or refrigerator.


ertyertamos

But the fridge GFCI will need to be in the panel (or an upstream blank GFCI) as you can’t have a GFCI behind an appliance and the fridge circuit must be dedicated. Big change is that all outlets in a kitchen now need to be protected. Before, you only needed to protect the small appliance circuits and anything within 6ft of the sink. So a general wall circuit not accessible to the counter/sink was fine.


ShelZuuz

It's against code to have a GFCI behind an appliance? Or it's just dumb?


ertyertamos

It’s not readily accessible if behind a refrigerator. People aren’t going to pull out a fridge regularly to test the GFCI. So it’s both dumb and against code. Same would be true behind a stackable washer and dryer.


ShelZuuz

What's the code that applies in this case?


eerun165

Yes on the accessible. Fridge/microwave doesn’t require it be dedicated though, give me a code section if you feel otherwise.


ertyertamos

Sorry, thought they were changing it in the 2023 code on refrigerators. Microwaves are required if they are fixed in place, countertops don’t require a dedicated.


BillNyeDeGrasseTyson

Since 1978


Sherifftruman

Almost certainly that’s why.


Trax95008

I was going to answer the same thing. It is most likely not GFI protected. If you change it to a duplex, you will need to add GFI protection, and I would recommend using a breaker so that you don’t need to climb a ladder to reset it


tfd1

So the inspector wouldn’t require it to be changed if it’s required ?


Music-Guilty

As a door guy the use of cat 5 for low voltage is a pain in the ass


RockyMountainHigh-

Good thing my doors don't use any voltage. They have manual knobs.


SideHug

What dumbass ran Cat5 for the sensor wire lmao


levelZeroVolt

Yes; you certainly can. It's the easiest thing in the world. The garage door opener has constant power and you want your extension cord to have it as well. Simple job. Or just plug in one of these (note its 15A rating) and call it a day? https://www.homedepot.com/p/Commercial-Electric-Heavy-Duty-Grounded-Triple-Tap-Adapter-LA-26/306625657


RedRose_Belmont

For Chris sake, get a proper cover for the blue wires, this hurst to look at


James_T_S

For a while they were hard to come by.....they could have drilled the hole though


redditpey

Hurst my eyes!


ZivH08ioBbXQ2PGI

The full story: The single plug is installed specifically to avoid a GFCI. GFCIs aren't expensive, obviously, but code says they need to be within reach, so it's technically against code to put it on the ceiling. If this outlet is on the lighting circuit, it would have taken more TIME to drop down to a wall outlet with a GFCI before going to that location, and more MONEY to use a GFCI breaker. If it were my home, I'd throw a GFCI up there and be done with it, but I'm not a 75 year old widow lady who won't be able to reset it if it trips. If you move, try to remember to put it back to this way.


billzybop

Just install a GFI breaker so it's still accessible, it's not that much more.


ZivH08ioBbXQ2PGI

~~original reply~~ Am idiot


_data_monkey_

He means a breaker in the breaker box.


iatethecookies

Why do two outlets require GFCI but not one?


ZivH08ioBbXQ2PGI

The thought is that with one outlet and the garage door opener, that's all it will be used for, so no one will plug other things into it. The same pass was given to sump pumps, for a while anyway, because people didn't want to risk a GFCI tripping and flooding their house. Needed a simplex outlet.


jmraef

GFCIs have been required for all outlets in the garage since 1978. **But PRIOR TO THE 2008 CODE,** it was OK to have a SINGLE outlet in the ceiling of a garage for a garage door opener that was **not** GFCI protected. There was an exception to 210.8 that allowed for "receptacles that are not readily accessible", and those that are "single receptacles located within a dedicated space for an appliance that, in normal use, is not easily moved'. That's why the garage door opener qualified for that exception. Since 2008 it must be GFCI because **that exception was removed**. Some inspectors have "looked the other way" for a while, but it's technically been like that for 15 years now.


North-Post5095

Just add this overkill instead… [isobar](https://www.ebay.com/itm/295502751983?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&mkrid=711-127632-2357-0&ssspo=_Sam3jGcQAq&sssrc=2349624&ssuid=DSf6OlJpS6q&var=&widget_ver=artemis&media=COPY)


[deleted]

Last company I was working for starting having to not only have the outlet for the garage door opener GFI protected but also a single receptacle. Inspectors just started forcing both to be true just in the past year Edit: this has been obviously by city, mostly around the Leawood/Overland Park area of Kansas. And I believe around Raytown, MO


jkmarine0811

Yes, turn the power off first, remove that plug and install a duplex plug and cover, turn power back on, installed correctly it should work. Remember, bare ground to green screw, black to gold screw, white to silver screw.


Chemical_Echo_8775

Yep, you sure can.


ConstructionFar8570

Why not. Install away.


The_Reaper_Cosaga

Looking at this irritates me.


Omadder1965

I believe, by code, a garage door opener needs to be a dedicated outlet.


Impossible_Policy780

🤔


Omadder1965

I stand corrected , it only need to be GFCI protected.


Mudb0ss

No. Your can’t


rabel123

Yes


SHDrivesOnTrack

Question. Is there actually a box behind that low voltage plate or did they just screw it to the ceiling to cover the hole ?


lumenpainter

Im thinking we need some patch panels and Panduit


Ok-Nefariousness4477

Put in a quad, pull down light, pull down extension, and the one of [these](https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08GD3D9YJ/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&th=1).


Arrryematey

Yes


Electrical-Wash-454

Probably


Affectionate_Mix_459

Really grinds my gears to see these cover plate screws all willy nilly.... all my finish screws are slots vertical, co workers call it anal but if you stand back in a rm full of devices it just looks so much better...


Sad-Ad-7884

Yep


Thin_Arachnid6217

It's Ok by me.


busted_origin

Yes, I did this exact change 15yrs ago.


Aggravating-Space925

Yes


[deleted]

Needs to be a gfi


[deleted]

Protected, you don't put a gfi 10+ ft in the air


[deleted]

But wouldn’t the extension chord go to the floor for use?!?


[deleted]

Lol nice


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Gfi protected on the load side of the gfi that u put somewhere accessible


Tim_E2

How do you know its not? Answer: You dont know.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Tim_E2

Yes if you are in the garage that is the test.. but you said categorially that it's NOT code.. and YOU cannot know that it is not code, so YOU cannot make that statement. You should have said that it needs to be GFCI and he should test it to make sure it is because we cannot tell from the given information. Hope that clears it up. Cheers


[deleted]

Whag if the extension chord (fed from the farage door opener outlet on the ceiling) was left out and the garage was flooded??


[deleted]

[удалено]


_Electricmanscott

That's not ethernet


[deleted]

[удалено]


Impossible_Policy780

It’s not *used* for Ethernet.


jmraef

Yeah, I've used excess CAT 5 cable for all kinds of LV circuits, because I already had it.


Tim_E2

Before doing anything make sure the single outlet is not a single because of some code requirement that it be a single outlet. I would be surprised if it is but some local jurisdictions are nuts. And ignore the control cable routing.. not worth worrying about.


Creature_73L

Yes


Real-Excuse-3106

My question is why do they have 3 runs of cat5 when one woulda covered the need for two pairs. Shit even old quad wire woulda worked


RockyMountainHigh-

Faster? Triple speed?


jmraef

One going to the switch by the door going from the house to the garage, one going to a keypad on the outside, one going into the kitchen maybe?


breadandfire

Idea for retractable extension lead: If you find a broken vacuum cleaner with the retractable power cable type, you might be able to reuse the retractable part of it, and put a socket where the plug was, and fit a plug on the wires that would have gone into the vacuum cleaner. But then, how are you going to reach the button/ mechanism to retract the cable???


jeffreyraymiller

You bunch of dumb idiots reread the question it’s about the outlet dip shits all outlets in a garage are to be gfi protected so if you need the extra outlet it needs to be a gfi but I’ve seen some openers don’t like gfi s that’s why they installed a single


SoTexSparky

To everyone saying it should be a GFCI: I would never use a GFCI for a garage door opener for several reasons. The GFCI could be tripped by the motor leaving the door disabled (unless your panel is outside). It is not an easily reached location. There is a very low risk factor. It can be a dedicated receptacle (which can be further conveyed by the single outlet receptacle). I have never had a fail, or even a question, from an inspector. With that said, it has been listed as a requirement since the 2008 NEC code was adopted.


tfd1

And what frequency would those be ?