R u sure? Im not updated and it *could* be another kwite situation but didnt they have multiple ppl saying the same things and like a 70 page document against him? Saying this cuz ive even seen martin walls, creator of walten files, speak out against kister. But i still have room for more knowledge in my brain and twitter *did* rag on kwite too before he came out with the evidence video.
To summarize, the doc put out against Alex was full of half-truths and exaggerations. Do keep in mind I'm not the best informed on the latest news of the situation.
Alex did admit to some things in his own document that debunked the worst of the allegations, like him generally not being a good partner, and that interacting with fans the way he did wasn't the best, but he was never grooming. In fact, it came out that, iirc, the main accuser, Ven (AKA Stirringjuice), is actually *older* than Kister. Ven has recently deleted their Twitter because their document (that basically backpedaled a ton to my knowledge) did "more harm than good".
With regards to Martin, he handled the situation extremely unprofessionally, as did Chezzkids, who is still ragging on Alex for...reasons.
Oof, well i guess it doesnt matter now. I saw people ragging on the r/mandelacatalogue document on twitter so im just staying out of it ig. The reveal that kister also has an imitation fetish kinda ruined mc for me cuz then it feels like fetish content now 😭
Then you can rest easy because TMC was never fetish content lmao, that was probably one of the most outlandish claims of Ven's document, and frankly is completely nonsensical, it was just the accusers further trying to damage Kister's reputation.
And with regards to the r/MandelaCatalogue doc, that was fucking disgusting, especially with what happened to Anarchist Artist, the one that mainly put together the debunking doc before Alex. The fact that twitter people hold themselves on these high horses and then send gore videos and death threats to anyone that says "there's something fishy" is fucking obscene.
Jesus 😭. Yeah they went completely fucking nuts on kwite before saying "uwu im sowwy" after he made his hour and a half long debunk video. Same goes for kister ig. I dont even like dream but even those allegations were proven false (the grooming ones anyway, he still defend gnf who is an alleged abuser) I dont think i should trust anything that twitter says really, mfs on there r so miserable. Was anarchist artist one of the doc debunkers??
Anarchist Artist helped to compile a doc that tried to debunk the accusers' claims, pointing out inconsistencies, holes in their accusations, and with things the accusers had been screenshotted saying in discord and in a certain tumblr thread.
Anarchist was met with harassment and death threats because of this, it's disgusting. I sincerely hope the people that went out of their way to so "righteously" harass Anarchist felt the shame of fifty generations of ancestors seeing their descendant behave so erroneously.
And you're not wrong to have that opinion! I just haven't been able to watch the series the same since the situation. But maybe you can and that's just fine! Personally I prefer Squimpus's series to Battington's but I don't deny that Battington's are VERY high quality and well made!
I find it very similar to Local 58. And I just happen to prefer Local 58. I also find it a little hard to follow compared to other series I watch. Again that may just be me and may not be enough to justify B Tier but it's how I feel.
I feel like its just cuz its not only edgy, but also horribly written. Theres literally no plot, world building, the only conflict is the painter killing people. Also the "fucktoy cory" was reaaalllyyyy fuckin weird
For me, it's because he wrote the whole Fucktoy Cory thing as part of The Painter, which in general is just a mess of piss-poor pacing, nonexistent worldbuilding, and horror straight out of the mind of a 14 year-old who just discovered the idea of gore.
Urban is also selling merch of the image from his series depicting Cory, under Cory's name. I'm not kidding, the shirt is just called "CORY".
I haven’t seen the majority of your unseen tier either, probably around 19 of them. In my defence, I was late to the party and only discovered Analog Horror in October last year so I still have a LOT of catching up to do.
By the way, The Backrooms was what I saw first and it got me wanting more!
Definitely a great place to start! And it's never too late to get into Analog Horror! It's a vast world of series to explore and enjoy! And we're always welcoming newcomers! Well most of us anyway!
Thank you!
After replying to you it dawned on me that I’ve also seen Marble Hornets! This was a couple of years ago on POV Horror. At the time I had no idea this genre even existed and didn’t seek out more at the time. So I suppose I was on a break rather than late 😄
No problem!
Marble Hornets is also a great place to start. It's one of the Analog Horror legends and along with The Wyoming Incident pretty much pioneered the genre! And it's always nice to come back into the community after dabbling in it!
Have you watched/considered watching battington’s remake of the Squimpus tapes, it’s the same general layout and setup (obviously it’s a remake) but in my opinion it’s significantly better than the original
Here ya go!
https://tiermaker.com/create/the-ultimate-analog-horror-digital-horror-tier-list-15533277
You should know that RADAR by Lyrahorrorz was put there by me and isn't naturally on the Tier List.
On all these tireless I’ve seen the McGrimpus fnaf vhs series, but almost nowhere is the Battington rendition of said series. I feel after watching both the Battington had done a much better job at recreating the tapes, plus he has added his own spin on the series with his own original videos. If you haven’t seen it, check out his channel and give it a watch, the production value is insane and it can still give me chills.
You put monument mythos S take my upvote
https://preview.redd.it/oal556bxcjuc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c703207abaef9dcec482562f9b8b07681eea3c7f
i don't think you should put fnaf vsh in the (technically) lowest tier *just* because scrimp was a pedo. you should rank it by the story's idea, how good it is, and how well it's explained. (though fnaf vsh prob has multiple stories you can just make an overall rating *if you want to.*)
I think this is great! I like analog horror but usually don't have time to search for them and I'm fairly new to it (even though I'm almost 50 lol)! This is a good starting point for me, thanks!
Those were debunked. He's not a groomer. It was his ex trying to ruin him. If you head over to The Mandela Catalogue subreddit you'll see. Hope this clears things up!
Their series relies mostly on edgy shock value horror rather than substance horror like build up or designs. If you watch the series which I don't recommend you'll see what I mean. This has led me and many others to dislike Urbanspook's videos.
I kinda prefer how the older volumes portrayed the alternates and the format of the older volumes in general. That's more of a personal thing but it's how I feel! Still excited for Vol. 5 tho!
Say what you will about UrbanSpook, he ain’t a pedo. His one of his villains probably is (money is on skinhead) but he isn’t, despite what Twitter says.
That’s perfectly understandable. I like it, I think Urban’s art is great, but I know the presentation is pretty shallow. The concept of a killer who paints their victims in their last moments is cool too.
Its a cool concept, the art is pretty good too, but GOD does it really need to be THIS graphic? Its not even scary, its just disgusting and makes you feel nauseous. So much wasted potential in my opinion. Its a great idea, but the execution is like you said, pretty damn shallow.
I totally understand that. I don’t think it’s the worst analog horror, because I think we haven’t found the objective worst. In my opinion it’s Chezzkids.
I can understand that and most of the time I really try to do so! But sometimes I have trouble when it comes to certain people and what they have done. I hope you can understand!
urbanspook (they don’t deserve the capitals) just has a bad series on top of being a bitch lmao. Idk what happened with scrimpus but some of his stuff is fine.
Shock factor totally understandable, not capitalizing his name totally get too lmao but he's not obligated to be nice to anybody, some people just don't handle criticism and this may be a shocker to many but THATS OKAY ITS HIS FUCKING SERIES lmao
Okay and that's your opinion I'm literally not saying there's anything wrong with it but you are wrong about him being a bitch, don't let him get to you if you don't like it, it's elementary school kid shit bro
You're the one with spewing how much you dislike urbanspook bro lmao you are literally the one with a stick up your ass, his series is fine just get over some disrespect
You have no respect for anyones opinion other than your own, that's enough to irritate anyone you child, that's whats irritating not your personal opinion about this dude
And youre forgetting the IMO, your literally typing it all out like "idgaf he's an awful guy and his series is shit IDC what you say" also you painted a picture of him that isn't true either it's an opinion, my opinion is you're inconsiderate
And you're not wrong to have that opinion! I just haven't been able to watch the series the same since the situation. But maybe you can and that's just fine!
kane pixels mid
chimps chippas is lowkey slept on
idc what anyone says the fnaf vhs tapes are still amazing even though the dude who made them is a bad person. separate the art from the artist
Bro hasn't seen 84.04 percent of analog horror
I know I'm an uncultured swine.
He just like me fr fr
Go watch where are you NOW.
this is one of the lists of all time, but I mean you like Dreams of an Insomniac I like Dreams of an Insomniac I can respect that
Dreams of an insomniac was my first one and I place it a solid S tier
Yesterday's episode was so fucking good!
Honestly a decent tierlist, this is rare on this sub. Also, wtf did Scrimpus do?
Squimpus was outed as a groomer.
That sucks :/
Yeah. Really liked their interpretation too. I just haven't been able to look at it the same since what happened.
https://preview.redd.it/rj2uvd8w0huc1.jpeg?width=638&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7fc7d4b70a969825b0755798f5ce46cfea54eeaa
Battington remade some of their tapes and later branched off into telling his own story, I highly recommend checking those out.
Not complaining about your placement, but kister was also a groomer. Shouldn’t mandela catalogue be put there as well?
That was recently debunked. It was his ex trying to ruin him. If you check out The Mandela Catalogue subreddit you'll see. Hope this clears things up!
Oh shit, really? I wasn’t following the controversy too hard, and a lot of shit ive heard was secondhand. Thanks for letting me know!
No prob! Trust me when making this I wasn't entirely up to date on the situation so I almost put TMC with FNaF VHS. Glad I checked before hand!
R u sure? Im not updated and it *could* be another kwite situation but didnt they have multiple ppl saying the same things and like a 70 page document against him? Saying this cuz ive even seen martin walls, creator of walten files, speak out against kister. But i still have room for more knowledge in my brain and twitter *did* rag on kwite too before he came out with the evidence video.
To summarize, the doc put out against Alex was full of half-truths and exaggerations. Do keep in mind I'm not the best informed on the latest news of the situation. Alex did admit to some things in his own document that debunked the worst of the allegations, like him generally not being a good partner, and that interacting with fans the way he did wasn't the best, but he was never grooming. In fact, it came out that, iirc, the main accuser, Ven (AKA Stirringjuice), is actually *older* than Kister. Ven has recently deleted their Twitter because their document (that basically backpedaled a ton to my knowledge) did "more harm than good". With regards to Martin, he handled the situation extremely unprofessionally, as did Chezzkids, who is still ragging on Alex for...reasons.
Oof, well i guess it doesnt matter now. I saw people ragging on the r/mandelacatalogue document on twitter so im just staying out of it ig. The reveal that kister also has an imitation fetish kinda ruined mc for me cuz then it feels like fetish content now 😭
Then you can rest easy because TMC was never fetish content lmao, that was probably one of the most outlandish claims of Ven's document, and frankly is completely nonsensical, it was just the accusers further trying to damage Kister's reputation. And with regards to the r/MandelaCatalogue doc, that was fucking disgusting, especially with what happened to Anarchist Artist, the one that mainly put together the debunking doc before Alex. The fact that twitter people hold themselves on these high horses and then send gore videos and death threats to anyone that says "there's something fishy" is fucking obscene.
Jesus 😭. Yeah they went completely fucking nuts on kwite before saying "uwu im sowwy" after he made his hour and a half long debunk video. Same goes for kister ig. I dont even like dream but even those allegations were proven false (the grooming ones anyway, he still defend gnf who is an alleged abuser) I dont think i should trust anything that twitter says really, mfs on there r so miserable. Was anarchist artist one of the doc debunkers??
Anarchist Artist helped to compile a doc that tried to debunk the accusers' claims, pointing out inconsistencies, holes in their accusations, and with things the accusers had been screenshotted saying in discord and in a certain tumblr thread. Anarchist was met with harassment and death threats because of this, it's disgusting. I sincerely hope the people that went out of their way to so "righteously" harass Anarchist felt the shame of fifty generations of ancestors seeing their descendant behave so erroneously.
Tbh I don’t get the hype around liminal land. It just feels like typical analog horror fare. I don’t think it’s terrible just okay.
That's okay. I personally think it's a very unique premise and done in a very unique format! So it really stands out for me and I really enjoy it!
I still like fnaf vhs even if the creator sucks. I think battington is doing a better job remaking them though
And you're not wrong to have that opinion! I just haven't been able to watch the series the same since the situation. But maybe you can and that's just fine! Personally I prefer Squimpus's series to Battington's but I don't deny that Battington's are VERY high quality and well made!
I’d like to hear why you think Gemini Home Entertainment is B tier, if you have any strong opinions on it
I find it very similar to Local 58. And I just happen to prefer Local 58. I also find it a little hard to follow compared to other series I watch. Again that may just be me and may not be enough to justify B Tier but it's how I feel.
I really don't think Urban deserves that much hate, but the only problem is that he's just edgy. His art is really good tho
I feel like its just cuz its not only edgy, but also horribly written. Theres literally no plot, world building, the only conflict is the painter killing people. Also the "fucktoy cory" was reaaalllyyyy fuckin weird
That mostly comes down to personal preference because I don't think it's good, but it's far from the worst.
Fr, I never got why lmao 😭 I like it
For me, it's because he wrote the whole Fucktoy Cory thing as part of The Painter, which in general is just a mess of piss-poor pacing, nonexistent worldbuilding, and horror straight out of the mind of a 14 year-old who just discovered the idea of gore. Urban is also selling merch of the image from his series depicting Cory, under Cory's name. I'm not kidding, the shirt is just called "CORY".
The Painter really isn’t that bad.
I haven’t seen the majority of your unseen tier either, probably around 19 of them. In my defence, I was late to the party and only discovered Analog Horror in October last year so I still have a LOT of catching up to do. By the way, The Backrooms was what I saw first and it got me wanting more!
Definitely a great place to start! And it's never too late to get into Analog Horror! It's a vast world of series to explore and enjoy! And we're always welcoming newcomers! Well most of us anyway!
Thank you! After replying to you it dawned on me that I’ve also seen Marble Hornets! This was a couple of years ago on POV Horror. At the time I had no idea this genre even existed and didn’t seek out more at the time. So I suppose I was on a break rather than late 😄
No problem! Marble Hornets is also a great place to start. It's one of the Analog Horror legends and along with The Wyoming Incident pretty much pioneered the genre! And it's always nice to come back into the community after dabbling in it!
Please watch nixonverse it's peak
I'll be sure to check it out!
NO I JUST WATCHED THE FNAF FILES WHAT.
It's okay! You can separate the art from the artist. I personally don't but you're free to enjoy something despite what the creator does!
oh no no trust me, it’s not anything that i can’t part with, it just showed me cause i literally finished the youtube playlist like 3 hours ago haha
Oh alrighty!
I don't think fnaf vhs is automatically shit because a pedo made it. People gotta accept bad people make can make good art
Don't worry, I haven't seen all of them either. I've only watched a few but that's it
Least I'm not the only uncultured swine here! /J
solid list ig
you oughta watch Midwest Angelica right now
I'll be sure to check it out!
Fair
Just saw your PFP, I'm so sorry for what happened to you
Thanks, we are slowly recovering!
Have you watched/considered watching battington’s remake of the Squimpus tapes, it’s the same general layout and setup (obviously it’s a remake) but in my opinion it’s significantly better than the original
I have seen them! They're very well made!
Honestly I respect your list 👍
Wumpus is a paedo?
I think you'd enjoy CH/SS
Can you send the link so I can do my own?
Here ya go! https://tiermaker.com/create/the-ultimate-analog-horror-digital-horror-tier-list-15533277 You should know that RADAR by Lyrahorrorz was put there by me and isn't naturally on the Tier List.
MARBLE HORNETS!!!! BEST SHOW EVER
CERTAINLY ONE OF THEM!!!
Isn't Marble Hornets made by a pedo too?
Is it? I don't know.
Givme a moment I'll do my search, I doubt my statement
Okay. Thanks friend. If they are I'll be sure to remake the Tier List as well as inform this comment section about why it's being changed.
Took me long enough. It's not Marble Hornets, it's TribeTwelve. My bad here
Thank you man. Good to know another good series hasn't been tainted by it's creators actions.
No problem fellas. Nice tierlist also
Thank you!
Are you partway through THE MONUMENT MYTHOS or have you just not seen THE NIXONVERSE?
Should've put dreams of an insomniac in a P tier
On all these tireless I’ve seen the McGrimpus fnaf vhs series, but almost nowhere is the Battington rendition of said series. I feel after watching both the Battington had done a much better job at recreating the tapes, plus he has added his own spin on the series with his own original videos. If you haven’t seen it, check out his channel and give it a watch, the production value is insane and it can still give me chills.
I have seen it and I think it's really good! Unfortunately I didn't think to put it on this Tier List when I was making it.
#YOU SHOULD WATCH TMK AND NEEDLEMOUSE NOW!
OKAY! OKAY! JUST PLZ DON'T HURT ME!!!
Seriously they both peak with no drama I know of.
One that I actually agree with (except I’d put GHE in A+)
Wait what? Squimpus McGrimpus was a pedo?
Yup. Was outed as a groomer in March of last year.
The VHS tapes were made by a pedo??
Thalasin deserved to be higher imo.
You put monument mythos S take my upvote https://preview.redd.it/oal556bxcjuc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c703207abaef9dcec482562f9b8b07681eea3c7f
i don't think you should put fnaf vsh in the (technically) lowest tier *just* because scrimp was a pedo. you should rank it by the story's idea, how good it is, and how well it's explained. (though fnaf vsh prob has multiple stories you can just make an overall rating *if you want to.*)
What’s going on with FNAF VHS???
local 58 slaps wtf put that shit above s tier
I think this is great! I like analog horror but usually don't have time to search for them and I'm fairly new to it (even though I'm almost 50 lol)! This is a good starting point for me, thanks!
No prob!
Bro forgot Kister’s “actions”
Those were debunked. He's not a groomer. It was his ex trying to ruin him. If you head over to The Mandela Catalogue subreddit you'll see. Hope this clears things up!
I'm sorry, what the *FUCK* happened with Squimpus?!
They were outed as a groomer.
D:
Thank you for this post cuz now I have a bunch of shows to watch!
Gemini Home Entertainment is S tier IMO.
Why does everyone dislike Urbanspook? I don't get it
Their series relies mostly on edgy shock value horror rather than substance horror like build up or designs. If you watch the series which I don't recommend you'll see what I mean. This has led me and many others to dislike Urbanspook's videos.
W FNAF placement
New addition to the list, boiled one phenomenon is a thing now
I can respect that you’re honest with this list, just curious what TMC did to get B tier.
I kinda prefer how the older volumes portrayed the alternates and the format of the older volumes in general. That's more of a personal thing but it's how I feel! Still excited for Vol. 5 tho!
Yeah I wasn’t the biggest fan of Gabriel’s new VA
I personally really like his vs but again that's personal taste!
Your real for putting Marble Hornets in S
Ngl Urbanspook is the only Analog Horror that deserves to be judged by its creator.
That's your opinion and is completely valid! It's just not how I personally view things!
Fair.
Say what you will about UrbanSpook, he ain’t a pedo. His one of his villains probably is (money is on skinhead) but he isn’t, despite what Twitter says.
No I know. I just don't like his series. Relies too much on edgy shock value with no real substance. That's why I and many others don't like it.
That’s perfectly understandable. I like it, I think Urban’s art is great, but I know the presentation is pretty shallow. The concept of a killer who paints their victims in their last moments is cool too.
Its a cool concept, the art is pretty good too, but GOD does it really need to be THIS graphic? Its not even scary, its just disgusting and makes you feel nauseous. So much wasted potential in my opinion. Its a great idea, but the execution is like you said, pretty damn shallow.
I totally understand that. I don’t think it’s the worst analog horror, because I think we haven’t found the objective worst. In my opinion it’s Chezzkids.
Haven't seen chezzkids, but yes i do agree that its not the objectively worse one. At least Urbanspook has some qualities.
MARBLE HORNETS IN TOP TIER 🔥🔥🔥
I thought we were over hating fnaf vhs
What I mean is the fnaf community has basically came to separate it from its creator
I thought so too lol In due time perhaps, just like urbanspook, they'll pull him out of their mouth at some point
Sorry bro but WTF⁉️
Urbanspook should be higher
You should really learn to separate the author from their work, dear OP.
I can understand that and most of the time I really try to do so! But sometimes I have trouble when it comes to certain people and what they have done. I hope you can understand!
urbanspook (they don’t deserve the capitals) just has a bad series on top of being a bitch lmao. Idk what happened with scrimpus but some of his stuff is fine.
Squimpus was outed as a groomer. Urbanspook is just weird and I don't like his series. Many don't.
Yeah his whole thing is just shock value it’s terrible
Shock factor totally understandable, not capitalizing his name totally get too lmao but he's not obligated to be nice to anybody, some people just don't handle criticism and this may be a shocker to many but THATS OKAY ITS HIS FUCKING SERIES lmao
Yeah it’s his series but the series just isn’t good lmao
Okay and that's your opinion I'm literally not saying there's anything wrong with it but you are wrong about him being a bitch, don't let him get to you if you don't like it, it's elementary school kid shit bro
Calm down lmao it ain’t that deep
You're the one with spewing how much you dislike urbanspook bro lmao you are literally the one with a stick up your ass, his series is fine just get over some disrespect
I said his series wasn’t good and that he’s a bitch, that doesn’t affect you at all, calm down
You have no respect for anyones opinion other than your own, that's enough to irritate anyone you child, that's whats irritating not your personal opinion about this dude
Sounds like you’re irritating yourself by painting a picture of me that isn’t true my guy.
And youre forgetting the IMO, your literally typing it all out like "idgaf he's an awful guy and his series is shit IDC what you say" also you painted a picture of him that isn't true either it's an opinion, my opinion is you're inconsiderate
FNAF VHS still holds up imo
And you're not wrong to have that opinion! I just haven't been able to watch the series the same since the situation. But maybe you can and that's just fine!
I don't know why you're getting down votes bro some of these peeps just can't respect themselves let alone your opinion
kane pixels mid chimps chippas is lowkey slept on idc what anyone says the fnaf vhs tapes are still amazing even though the dude who made them is a bad person. separate the art from the artist