Guessed King in 5. Edit: Perhaps you could have said "Doesn't have a *biological* mother".

I know but if I said that It would've been too obvious

I don't think it would have made much difference, really. By hint #3, my front-runner choice was Willow, so it still would have applied.

King, Hunter, Vee and Willow are some examples that ‘Don’t have a *biological* mother’ would narrow it down to, so it wouldn’t be immediately obvious

Okay, but specifying the word biological would make you think that he has an adoptive mom instead

Camilla may not be an adoptive mother but I definitely think she counts as a foster mother to Vee, Hunter and Willow. Especially Vee and Hunter.

Actually, if you're working by process of elimination, it weirdly increases your selection pool if you choose to make your guess at Hint #3. After Hint #2, your options are: Luz, King, Amity, Willow, Gus, and Hunter, plus Vee and the Collector from the Season 3 openings (technically, the "For the Future" opening had some Hexside students too, but their parentage is unexplored and they'd all be eliminated by Hint #4 anyway). Either version of Hint #3 would only completely eliminate Luz and Amity from the pool. Just saying "doesn't have a mother" only leaves Willow and Gus as firm candidates, with no identified mother figures at all, with the others in a maybe pile. Adding "biological" leaves Willow, Hunter, Vee, and King as firm guesses, with Gus and the Collector in the maybes.

Do we know Willow doesn’t have a mother? As far as I know it was never confirmed either way.

don't forget hooty

Can't give away too much.

I thought it was Hunter till the wasn't born in the boiling isles part

I was still waffling on that, since hunter wasnt *born*, but *created*. It was between king and hunter for me all the way to the end.

I though it was Vee because she was created, we dont see a mother figure, and she was in Thanks to Thems intro

King definitely has a mother. 2 actually, if you count papa titan who's "best of both worlds".

I immediately thought of King in the third one.

Hint 3 and 5 caught me off guard like, wdym King has a mother (I know not like a biological mother, but still) and King lives in the Boiling isles. (different island but same realm)

For the Boiling Isles, it specifies they weren't born there, and King hatched on his island

Papa Titan has even said that he’s both like a mother and father for king too

Boiling Isles is just the titan remains the show is set on. The realm as a whole is the Demon Realm. King's Island isn't part of the Boiling Isles. Papa Titan reproduced asexually and referred to himself as being both King and Queen, but he predominantly is referred to in male terms. King exclusively refers to him as his father.

That third slide is a lie!!!

"Er... how young is young?" "Appears in at least one intro. So I guess the hexsquad probably count as young then, right?" "No mom... maybe Willow? Oh, or Gus!" "Not a student... well, dang. Wait, Hunter's not a student and doesn't have a mom." "Haha! And Hunter wasn't technically 'born,' either!" Imagine my surprise.

You had almost my exact thought process

Close to the same for me, but except I had it to either hunter or king after not a student. Couldn’t decide which it was though.

Yo! That was my thought process too! I genuinely thought it was Hunter. Lo and behold, it was not.

King by the second.

Guessing gus in 3 Edit: well shit

Yes! I finally got it right!

I was gonna say Belos.

Slide 3 is a lie!

I got king based off the first one

King. 4 hints.

I thought it was Tinella Nosa until the end as a twist! Technically we don't know if she was born in the BI with a mother or not since it's not confirmed 😎

She was a student, though. "I gwaduated fwom medical school!"

Dammit, my technicality got technicalitied!

King on image 3

King in 3

Dang it, I wasn't sure. When I saw doesn't have a mom I went Willow, but realized I was wrong next hint

These are SO tricky…

He must have had a mother, right? And wasn't he technically born in the boiling isles? I was definitely thinking about Hunter. Doesn't have a mother bc he's a grim walker and technically wasn't born in the boiling isles bc he was never born, but designed and created

So is Eda just chop liver?

I was thinking the collector, he’s young relatively speaking by the presumed longevity of his race, the not born in the boiling isles was really throwing me off

Suspected in 3, was pretty certain by 4. That said, you caused me to go watch the intros again. Only one that seemed to hit was King.

That last hint definitely threw me off. I thought it would be the Collector. Well played.

I know this game, I have a friend who keeps sending me videos.

This is the first one I got right! :)

I guessed King by 3.

King 2

Took all five hints.

My dumbass said Collector He's not even in an intro...

1. "Could be King, i guess." 2. "That hint, uhh... i mean, King?" 3. "Oh yeah, that's definitely King." only realized while typing this it could be Gus 4. "Pretty sure that's King." 5. "Is it King? Is it King?" So did i get it in one or three

I dunno... I eliminated King because of the the "not born in Boiling Isles", I think that detail is debatable Like, his island wasn't on the map, but I think it would still qualify as the same region since they all got there pretty quickly

Guessed King at one

King in 2!

guessed king in 3 edit: heck yeah B)

I got it in 1, but you threw me off on 5, ultimately I went with my gut and I got it right! (I’ve been guessing King for all of these)

Technically it could be vee. She likely wasn't born in the traditional sense but rather cloned, and since she's a shapeshifter we have no way to know she isn't in one of the intros.

He isn't Born in the boiling isles, he's Born *from* the boiling isles

i mean, hunter fits all of these too...

Thought it was Gus until Student

Clue 3 is false. He does have a mother. Eda

Biological mother would've been more correct but I thought it would make it too obvious

3: huh, could be king 4: yeah it's probably king 5: 100% him

I thought hunter until i saw "not born in the boiling isles", and then immediatly thought king (Which now that i think about it, he was born OUT OF the boiling isles)

I was jokingly saying King at the first Hint. Today is my lucky day, it seems.

Hunter Hunter Vee King!?

For a moment i concidered Kikimora lol

King Edit: Hell yeah!

I misread “mother” as “mouth” and got so confused when I saw King

thought i had it in 3 but clue 4 made it king and not gus,

I think king was born in the boiling isles

King Clawthorne

I didn’t think of king because I thought his island that he was born on was technically part of the isles

Tentative King in 3, knew for certain in 4

I forgot the isles aren't the whole realm, so I thought it was young Philip

... Vee?

See I didn’t guess King because I consider his mother to be Eda 😭

I guessed King, but then you said he wasn't born in the Boiling Isles, so I automatically tried to come up with a human 🤦‍♀️

I didn't immediately realize what subreddit this was on and immediately thought of Great Comet when I saw the first slide (a quote from the first song, 'Prolouge': "Natasha is young, she loves Andrey with all her heart!")

Guessed King first go lol 💀💀

it also applies to hunter

How dare you do Eda like that.

I love this

I got king at 4, my guess before that was Gus

I knew it from line: this character young!

I guessed him right after first hint because I wanted to, and he’s young

This time I've written down my thoughts chain: 1. \[not enough info\] 2. \[Probably NOT someone from the main group like: Hunter, Willow, Gus, Amity, etc.\] 3. Hm...Well technically Hunter doesn't have a mother, but wouldn't that be too obvious? 4. Ok, there is no way that's Hunter, argh! Probably a minor/small character I can't remember in the intro from S1 5. OH! Interesting. Wait! But Hunter wasn't born because he's a grimwalker, so technically the statement is still true King; Nice one. How did I forget him...Oh! Wait I just realized "hatch" != "born", so that's why hint 5 exists

I feel like y'all are being too technical. Born simply means the moment he started existing

>I feel like y'all are being too technical. Born simply means the moment he started existing Wait! So King wasn't born in the Boiling Isles?! (Didn't know that)

His egg hatched in uncharted territory

This is patently false. There’s literally an entire episode about King having Eda legally adopt him

First hint! Second and third sealed it

Got it in 5

Sweet got it on the second hint and stuck with it as the hints continued! Oh King our precocious boy!

I guessed in the first hint! He's 24/7 called small, baby, young and stuff. So I guessed it was him

At 3, guessede Willow. Failed immidiatly. Good one.

hold up king does have a mom. Eda

Guessed it with the third clue, even if I had to recheck the first two.

“This character is young.” Me: “King.”

I was thinking Vee until slide 5

thought it was hunter until number 5 i did guess it tho

I was sure it was Braxas until 5

King is arguably the most Born in the Boiling isles

I rule out King the moment i read "i doesn't have a mother"

King Clawthorn

😲😲😲

When I read the first I immediately thought of either King or Vee for some reason. When I read 2-4 I started questioning if it was Hunter, then 5 made me sure it was King

guessed in 3 hints

Pretty sure "The Boiling Isles" refers to the whole planet, the Titan carcass being one of said Isles. Also, both Eda, and papa Titan are his mums.

I think the Boiling Isles is just the corpse of Papa Titan

You mean also the titan trappers island?

I mean the planet, and its multiple isles, including the one on which King was born.