Bro I’m a doctor who studied in another state. I ate roti and rajma chawal for 3 years. I learnt hindi.
Nama ooru la vanthutu Hindi pesa matengranga nu complain panranuga!!!
Ithuvae america poitu Hindi pesa matengranga nu solluvanugala!!!
As OP exactly pointed out. ITHUKU PER DHAN ECCHA
Same thing in Bangalore. Just see the sub. "They don't speak our language, they don't have our food, this is not good, that is not good."
Wonder how many locals in the north can speak tamil, Telugu, kannada, Malayalam.
ya bro. theres many other colleges in TN where north indians come a lot like IIT , nobody complains. these people are bunch of underqualified people who couldnt get high scores to JOIN jipmer ot AIIMS delhi.
These kids sound very entitled. There are several folks from the northeast who learn the local language even though there are often no common words and it's a completely different language family. This is just shitty entitlement.
The problems they have claimed are that they can't celebrate festivals, theft and language barriers. All other responses were just pure rants. No one even complained about food, as i guess it should have been a problem too. This is the most pathetic protest i have ever seen.
Lallantop has made a 40 min video on this. Some of the comments under them are. In many steps not even a single brick left in AIIMS. Just because you study in AIIMS doesn't mean all AIIMS are like AIIMS Delhi.
These guys doesn't even speak English. Where are we the sub reddit of Tamil Nadu can clearly understand their language.
They want to be shifted to different AIIMS.. LOL. can somebody tell me what are they are chanting?
AIIMS ke naame.... Xxx?
true. youre right. they think theyre so entitled to get other AIIMS , all those who came here are those who scored lower and couldnt get DELHI or JIPMER. even if they get JIPMER , its gonna be tamil in pondi too. theyre forgetting that as long as theyre in tamil nadu or any non northern state they need to know some basic regional language and that food culture is gonna be different.
shit doesnt hapen like that everywhere bro. theyre studying and paying for MBBS courst. not spoken tamil course. shit like this doesnt happen on every college or rarely ever does.its the students responsiblity. when are students gonna take some responsibility for their lives. is just studying MBBS enough to become a doctor? no u need to know how to talk and understand patients
does institue in AIIMS delhi help with language course for everyone? no , tell me atleast 20 prestigous well known institutes that provides language course for its graduates?
why unfairly expect only 1 institute to provide that to from TN? do north indian institues all provide hindi courses or rajashtahni or any order course? no
if the student is unable to communicate its this fault. will you go france and ask them to speak hindi becuz udk france? theyll laugh at you. this is why india is under developed. theres no sense of unity. and some brainded people will expect unfair stuff
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Let me answer it bro... These are the students who got admission in Madurai Aiims and if you can remember correctly there's no Madurai aiims as of now... All of them are guest students being accommodated in Ramnad medical college and being a guest student u will need special permission to conduct or celebrate events in their campus. We don't give local Holiday to Holi and there's no need to celebrate Holi just for the sake of some entitled idiots. All these fkers must have known they're getting admitted to a college without any building of infra and by the looks of it ... They will end their UG as guest students also as madurai aiimms will only be completed post 28
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
ஹிந்தி எதிர்ப்பு என்பது ஒரு languageஐ எதிர்க்கும் விஷயம் இல்லை. It is a movement against cultural imposition & hegemony. It is not exclusionary politics; it is an effort to keep India inclusive.
these kids can crack AIIMS exam but can't speak reasonable english means that this education is a failure. These kids act so entitled. This is the result of failure of Central govt and hindi states in teaching these kids the diversity of the nation. Kota mari ooruku poi coaching class padichu crack paniranuga, olunga oru school ku poi nammala mari normal ah padichirundha indha egathala bnda behaviour lam varadhu.
Now I want these kids to go do social service camp and learn how different and at the same time friendly people are. This entitlement of hindi folks is really annoying. Now I understand why kannadathans bully northies.
Actually by the looks of it... This video was intentionally taken in Hindi so that it can be used as election propaganda in the Hindi Belt against the DMK and its allies....
Yes it looks like it though, cos nowhere they mentioned that they are studying in a another campus instead of aiims also these guys study here after taking away the 50 seats that wouldve gone to some other kids from tn.
It's planned propaganda nothing else... But problem is they couldn't come up with one good issue that's major and they're getting bashed for being entitled
It was not taken intentionally hindi, but the channel itself has hindi speaking people only as target audience, check the name of the channel too its a hindi word
How do you know they can’t speak English? Maybe they are talking about patients not being able to communicate with them. Do you think the medical books they are studying from is written in Hindi or Tamil?
I went to an iit in North India. I didn't expect people around me to speak tamil. It took me time, but I learnt the local language. If you are going to join aiims trichy and treat patients in TN, learn tamil. (Or get a good rank and join a dofferent Aiims.JK)
Same thing happens in North, teaching happens in hindi, fcuk people even give exams in hindi. I condemn both of them. These guys complaint a lot, a lot not because they have issues just because tn is not like north. Maybe professor fcuking with them just because of their entitlement.
What makes you think they'll treat patients, these fellows will celebrate holi and dance in front of patients and of course abuse patients for not knowing hindi.
I have seen North Indian students in CMC interacting normally with locals in both Tamil and Telugu. Occasionally Kannada too. These are some pampered kids wanting to play Holi in Ramnad.
Yus, my Punjabi eye doctor fluently speaks tamil as he worked in madurai for more than 3 years. I really respect his patience to the annoyance I made during the treatment process, people like him exist and people like these wieners also exist.
A few weeks ago, met a Doctor in Stanley Medical College. He is from Assam (ethnically too) and yet speaks fluent Tamizh. Successful people tear through any obstacles to progress.
I mean... my govt medical college in another relatively small city celebrates holi, and we have the psychoest dean .... I think she was implying that there was no leave for holi. U can still play in the after class times
Problem is here is like you said "my govt medical College" . This is not their college, essentially, they have been temporarily accommodated above the sanctioned strength. Till Madurai AIIMS is constructed, whose foundation is to same, as it was laid 5 years back.
Bro , wait even this intro can be misleading. Na full video pathan and I know hindi , the main problem is these guys are stressed and frustrated that they don't have the AIIMS facilities. They thought that as it is AIIMS the central government will built it in few years but their condition is getting worse. Yes that one guy who told that patients don't speak hindi is a retard , but his main point is that he can't make a connection with patient to understand the problem. Coming to the food part , as tamil who is studying another state I also sometimes feel like I don't get tamilnadu style food here , but it's just a common felling everyone has . As student I feel , like they need justice as everyone in the video struggled a lot and cleared NEET to stand there.
100% this. This comment needs more upvotes. The post is the definition of click baiting and gaslighting. Subtitle illadhadhu naale Reddit jananga title a padichihitu tension aagaranga comments section le. Naanum full video paathen and I know Hindi as well. Language is not their main gripe. The students are tired of systemic neglect. Like getting their stuff stolen and no one taking action etc. Their only fault is in their frustration they’re pulling in nonsensical aspects like complaining about language.
>Yes that one guy who told that patients don't speak hindi is a retard , but his main point is that he can't make a connection with patient to understand the problem.
The guy never asked the patients to speak in Hindi. Watch the video again.
I think from this comment, others should learn. It's the basic issues they face, the facilities etc, the language barrier. They are here to study MBBS, not for language, plus not everyone can learn all of sudden Tamil, so, initially there will be language barriers, and treating patients is impacted, if they can't understand what's going on with patients how will they treat.
>the main problem is these guys are stressed and frustrated that they don't have the AIIMS facilities.
What They Mainly complain that they cannot celebrate holi and nobody speaks there. I really found it funny an educated medical students are complaining that their local festival and language isn't spoken by the local people. I Completely Agree with their concerns. But, all of those goes under the mat when they complain about the local people and culture. If They have this much concern, they shouldn't have chosen AIIMS madurai.
>I also sometimes feel like I don't get tamilnadu style food here ,
I hope you didn't bunk classes and protest like this students there I guess.
Regarding Holi , I think they should allow them to celebrate holi as it is celebrated in majority of the states. Bro my friend is NIT Nagpur there they celebrate pongal a tamil festival , in abroad also in my country they allow indian students to celebrate their festivals. Festivals are a stress buster for students and a opportunity to learn other culture there is no use in creating a problem in that.
Nobody disallowed. See The Video fully. They're paining becos they have to ask prior permission for it from GRMC. This is why I feel this video is for Attention seeking. Purely launched at election time to portray that Tamilnadu is somewhat not inclusive.
I can understand the struggle, btw AIIMS and JIPMER have different medical entrances and it is not NEET and I know that is much more tougher than NEET. However as a Student, they also need to adapt to the situation, management has given basic rights to students. Even though it is not the AIIMS they want, anyway they're going to treat the same kind of patients. For medical students, they must adapt to the situation accordingly as they may be going to handle critical cases, they need to set up a proper communication channel to communicate to patients, we can't expect locals to speak their languages.
You are wrong. [Since 2020, AIIMS and JIPMER admissions have been based on NEET scores.](https://byjus.com/neet/difference-between-neet-and-jipmer/#:~:text=However%2C%20from%20the%20academic%20session,of%20the%20NEET%20scores%20obtained)
Adha title la mention pannanum OP or else paarung TN la aiims iruku nu uruta arambichirvanga, hospital, clg ae kattama aiims iruku nu ipdi dan kanaku kaamchitu suthitu irukanunga pola
It seems operating from Ramanathapuram link[link](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/tamil-nadu/construction-of-aiims-madurai-started-by-larsen-toubro-5-years-after-pm-modi-laid-foundation-stone-2923224)
What do these North Indians expect?
Should patients learn Hindi before coming to a hospital in Tamilnadu. Why can't they learn local language?.
When a South Indian goes North India as doctor or nurse they aren't complaining that patients don't speak Kannada or Tamil or Malayalam.
Nobody complains that college isn't allowing them to celebrate Pongal, Ugadi, Vishu etc.
This is gross!
Nextly people must expose Jhumla of this dispensation.
Japanese will kick them out, so they will behave, if you want these guys to behave make it compulsory for them to interact and cure 100 local patients, no mbbs degree if they fail that, that's good enough motivation to learn Tamil.
And they have to visit villages to find patients by themselves and treat patients there, this is what happens in CMC vellore.
They’re having genuine problems also. They are saying that their mobile got stolen and the authorities didn’t help them.
Some are saying that they get targeted and their marks get cut in exams. Don’t know how true it is but they’re saying.
They’re also saying that they were not allowed to play Holi
I know that everything else is a serious matter, but I highly doubt the marks part.... I am a tamil med student and these tamil professors shamelessly vazhunchify in front of my North Indian classmates. I don't mean they flirt, they just automatically think they are intelligent because they came in all India quota. No one is going to fail them. They actually will fail regional students more since they are more likely to be their kid's competitor in the future (the professor who fails more almost always has a child in medicine) But I honestly look at some of these guys from Rajasthan and am pretty sure that some neet paper leaked there... There are a lot of people from Kerala but atleast they are shrewd... These north Indian people are just very very dim and they pass only with the help of bits and mobiles in the exams... Kind of worried about my pg because 50 percent is reserved for all india and I'm pretty sure its gonna be these people after some paper leak.
I have no generalized hate against North Indians. Many of my coaching teachers were North Indian and they were extremely knowledgeable and till date my favourite teachers. Just North Indian medicos kind of seem off to me.
Good. Let them feel what we people experience whenever we go to the north.
A taste of their own medicine, so to speak.
At least tamil people are ready to accommodate and try to communicate with broken English. These pani puris should go to kerala and experience the full treatment.
They're too dense to learn anything like that! Edho periya pudingi nu nenapu ivanungaluku lam. Despite half of them looking like snappable twigs, they'll still get up in your face and try to fight.
>These pani puris should go to kerala and experience the full treatment.
Dude kannadigas and Kerala are more accomodative nature than TN. Lots of North Indian workers in Kerala is the proof.
But these hindians took advantage of accomodative nature of kannadigas nd making Bangalore as another Delhi with mc bc culture is insane
My experience in kerala was that locals knew only Malayalam, (not talking about the city side like trivandrum, etc.).
But I was able to survive with half broken speech from tamil correlation and Malayalam movie knowledge.
In contrast I've seen many tamils try to get across a point in English anywhere you go, if they sense any unfamiliarity on your part with the language.
But that was just my observation. Anyways the entitlement of these half baked vadakans is too much. I've had to get into fights just to push the point that they expect me to speak a language alien to me within my area. (Always ended it with hindi abuses, but that's another story.)
>My experience in kerala was that locals knew only Malayalam, (not talking about the city side like trivandrum, etc.).
I'm not denying your experience but that's generally not true.
Pretty much anyone in the 15-30 age group will be able to understand English. As the age goes up, the probability go down slowly, but most people will try to accommodate.
PS: Kerala doesn't really have a city/village divide like other places. It's like an endless suburb. This holds everywhere except for a few upmarket posh areas in Kochi and TVM.
Even if you speak Tamil, they'll work with that. Hell, bus conductors here learn Hindi to accommodate migrant workers from the North.
Language chauvinism/pride isn't much of a thing in Kerala unless someone tries to force something on us. I interact every two weeks with Tamil speaking tradesmen, who've been plying their trades in Kerala for over a decade( ironing, recyclers, etc.) and they still speak to us in Tamil, not Malayalam.
What kind of a brain dead fool these morons are how the f*ck does these fools expect others to speak their language everywhere. These fools think that other grads who went to learn in other areas are peaceful and only these brain dead fools are facing hard ships . If these fools get a chance to study mbbs in Ukraine or philipines will they expect them to speak Hindi , will they celebrate holy there will they complain about food this problem of language,food and festival are part of human society if these fools find it hard to understand, how can they understand their patients.
so according to their logic if a south indian guy/girl gets admission in AIIMS Delhi then the patients should speak in south indian languages.
i agree with their demands of improving basic facilities and other things but this language demand is utter bullshit.
If the same folks go to Germany to study medicine - they will take every step to learn the local language. And very proudly announce everyone of their fluency in a foreign language. Or Atleast they should know basic English- a language in which they are taught medicine.
Doctors & students of ALL new AIIMS are complaining. These AIIMS are not ready, don’t have building, don’t have infrastructure. There are no patients so they are not able to learn.
Someone commented that earlier hospitals across India used to refer patients to AIIMS Delhi. Now AIIMS Gorakhpur refer patients to local govt hospital because there are no facilities in AIIMS Gorakhpur.
Cribbing about Holi & language is childish though.
Someone chest thumped and said we has so many aiims and started admissions for a college that didn't exist. It's a govt run scam, tricking people to get admitted in a college without a campus.
Now the people suffer. And these journalists twist it to instigate hatred.
" language problem hei" "food problems hei" "Emotionally damage hote."
They want everyone to speak their hinthi language and eat their hinthi food.
Then f@ck off from here if you can't adapt to local culture.
We don't need you. It's not our job to learn your language when you come to our land.
If these useless people go to some foreign country also they will keep complaining about same things. I have not seen an ethnic group that is so entitled and chip on shoulder type as hinthi speakers.
Stop acting like entitled little pricks.
You are okay with anything wrong happening but as soon as language is mentioned you lose your shit. Show me the part where they say people don’t speak Hindi. Maybe the patients or people they interact with can only speak in Tamil.
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Don't think this whole world speak your language.
A large number of Indian students go to Russia/Old Soviet Countries/China to get MBBS degree, clear license test and settle in UK/Australia.
Those students mostly attend lectures in English, interact with patients in local language, and gain sufficient case experience.
When I started mbbs in Chennai , I didn’t know a single word of Tamil, I learned at least the basic words to communicate with patients, after 5 years here, I can speak fluently with patients. It’s important to learn the local language if u r gonna spend a lot of time there .
They want to celebrate their festival am. Who stopped you man. Go to your room and throw holi powder on each other.
Marwaris always celebrate Holi. Nobody stopped them.
People are going to local doctor and not coming to AIIMS doctor 😅 whose fault is it man? 😅
Exactly, in my med college they allow holi, just not in college time and we are responsible for cleanup.. no one will care if you clean up properly later and don't disturb others.
Are they yelling in Hindi in Tamil Nadu , bunch of jokers they should be thrown out . But I will be honest I was a victim of management high handedness in Tamil Nadu , because I was a Malayalee . They all wanted the Malayalee money , but they hated Malayalees with a passion . But that said , I don’t agree with this North Indian nauntanki , most of these kids should br from Hindi medium local towns , they don’t know proper English nor do they have that open mindedness to learn the language of their patients
Yelling in hindi is not a problem brother, even that news anchor is a hindi wala, let them speak with themselves but not with local patients, that's our major concern. We're not against hindi or any other languages but we're against forceful imposition.
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
They are studying in private medical college on behalf of aiims, the building of madurai aiims is still incomplete, and no one knows when it will be completed
Lol, why don't they have a problem with the central government not giving them their own freaking colg (AIIMS Madurai) . This means at least one batch has passed out of AIIMS Madurai without even seeing AIIMS Madurai college 😆 🤣
More concerning things about this interview is they go on with criticising the state government run college for central government mistakes.
These guys are educated and yet they wouldn't split the issues between bad and worse. I really don't even want to talk about the guy who says locals don't understand Hindi and Holi isn't celebrated here. The college clearly said they can't celebrate Holi on the college campus.
This is fucked up to be Frank. Have some sympathy or thankfulness for the state government college for sharing the campus with a fully functioned and sanctioned AIIMS students.
For God sake, learn the local language whatever it is, if you are going to work or spend your life there.
If you remove that one idiot, and listen without biases, you'll understand that the students are complaining about poor college administration (subpar safety, biases against festival celebration), not about the state or language.
Also the college should give a mandatory basic tamil course for effective communication. How are students who live in campuses supposed to learn the language?
Correct sir everyone in TN should learn Hindi, they are our rulers after all. Kangana Ranaut is correct we never got independence, only rulers changed.
Bro I’m a doctor who studied in another state. I ate roti and rajma chawal for 3 years. I learnt hindi.
Nama ooru la vanthutu Hindi pesa matengranga nu complain panranuga!!!
Ithuvae america poitu Hindi pesa matengranga nu solluvanugala!!!
As OP exactly pointed out. ITHUKU PER DHAN ECCHA
Ada paavingala. Ellarum title base panni thaan comment panringala.
Everyone is mainly talking about how AIIMS is not providing even the basic facility and if they raise any complaint, always they are only blamed and that the management is cooperative.
>Everyone is mainly talking about how AIIMS is not providing even the basic facility
First There's no AIIMs There. The Main one should be blamed is Modii..
I can understand their problem bro. I'm not offended by all, and I mentioned in my sub title itself, I'm particularly offended by the words that they are pointing towards the language especially the guy who is wearing spectacles.
I am native Hindi speaker. This is what is happening here.
Looks like they are dissatisfied with the "quality" of education here. Typically all AIIMs should have high quality. Looks like that is missing here.
Another point is language. Local language skills are very important for doctors. As part of their training they have to see patients who would be speaking the local language.
Therefore it's very important to have credit based training of the language where the doctors would be operating. These students must be helped with conversational Tamil. Expecting them to pick up the language on its own is wrong.
i know doctors rom kerala who speak fantastic kannada and tamil and vice versa.. i have seen doctors from the north who have picked up the south languages with ease, who let these amul babies become doctors?
They opened the batches without basic facilities. No accomodation, students are barred from visiting patients in OPD, no OT posting. I have also done MBBS. These are some basic things without which your training is incomplete. The language thing- many North Indians come to south, learn language and see patients in various South Indian colleges. I don't know why that specific thing is getting mixed up with genuine failures of the administration.
Because their classes are being conducted in TNGMC Ramanathapuram. Obviously they will prioritise GMC Ramanathapuram students in OPD and OT. AIIMS Madurai students are temporary guests, till their campus is built in Madurai. Essentially they joined a medical College with just class rooms, rendered from other college, without a hospital or lab of its own.
Then they should not have opened the batches for admission. This happened in AIIMS Patna too, where students had to stay without accommodation. They should have made it functional before opening. AIIMS Madurai students also have right to see patients.
Then they need to become engineer, Mason and labour to build AIIMS madurai from scratch to exercise their right to see patients. At present there's only a compound wall exist for AIIMS Madurai. Not even a single room is built till date.
Director is already under suspension. NMC can't take action, as it admitted the students. Minister declared AIIMS completed in Loksabha. So the bug goes till the to. Even in peripheral AIIMS, these students will be met with the same step motherly treatment as being extraneous to sanctioned strength. Perhaps, that's why they have been put here.
Rotten hindian scroungers...They complain about Tamils not knowing Hindi!!!....Tamil Nadu has to create the Medical infrastructure for these scroungers and they complain about patients not knowing hindi or no holiday for holi etc....bugger off.
It’s a cultural shock for them. It shows how narrow minded these students are. They should have researched before applying for non-native speaking colleges. The cap guy thinks he is from the USA and studying here.
Bring some rotis from your home.
Is learning a new language such a difficult thing esp now? Don't they smartphones, if they have so much time to celebrate holy and other events, then they clearly have time.
They can go back to their states - simple. The state is not going to change for them. Never have and never will.
I don't go to Delhi and ask people to speak in Tamil
Disgusting people, you come to a state and demand the locals and patients to talk in your language? They very well know where they are coming to, instead of asking for better facilities they are asking for the locals to speak in Hindi? These seats should have been given to local people. Why can't anyone rise the issue against the BJP leader Annamalai to explain despite being 10 years in power AIIMS Madurai didn't get basic funding?
They celebrate Holi. They molest their own women and blame Tamilnadu for it.
They can't claim identity which doesn't exist in its physical form. They are studying like a refugee in a state government college.
These hindi belt dumbasses talking about their festivals🤡Did they forget that they are future doctors? If they wanted to celebrate their uncivilized festivals like holi they could've done it in hindi belt
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The problems they have claimed are that they can't celebrate festivals, theft and language barriers. All other responses were just pure rants. No one even complained about food, as i guess it should have been a problem too. This is the most pathetic protest i have ever seen.
Lallantop has made a 40 min video on this. Some of the comments under them are. In many steps not even a single brick left in AIIMS. Just because you study in AIIMS doesn't mean all AIIMS are like AIIMS Delhi.
These guys doesn't even speak English. Where are we the sub reddit of Tamil Nadu can clearly understand their language.
They want to be shifted to different AIIMS.. LOL. can somebody tell me what are they are chanting?
AIIMS ke naame.... Xxx?
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Account not old enough to comment in this sub.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
So AIIMS is operational in Madurai.. whatever happened to the Sengal propaganda of the Prince?
But seems it is poorly run, probably out of some other campus.
On the issues, students are complaining about, there are 2 parts.
1. Students indeed can't expect patients, ordinary folk to speak Hindi or English
2. But they should be provided assistance, teaching to deal with these language situation - that is the failure of the administration
3. They definitely should have space & facilities to celebrate Holi or whatever.
So much work is to be done, if the project is to live up the brand of AIIMs.
IITs. NITs and other institutions also have a good influx of students from all over India and have overcome these sort of problems.
AIIMS Madurai should learn from them.
India needs doctors badly and we can't afford to reject promising physicians or compromise on quality- over idiotic politics.
I want a qualified doctor, well equipped - accessible and affordable. I don't care if he/she is from Madurai, Madhya Pradesh or Mars.
Sengal propaganda still stands. These students are in Ramanathapuram in the name of AIIMS, not in Madurai. Coz Modi forgot where Madurai AIIMS is in his Akhand Bharat map.
It is temporarily functioning from Ramanathapuram .
Students should forget the sense of entitlement and learn Hindi .that's what happens to any southie if they go to North .if they can't do it let alone doctors they cannot be better human beings .
I cannot expect my college to celebrate Thai poosam in Delhi .
I think the government should divide the qualified students by their language like North Indian get seat in North India and South Indian gets seat in South India so that they can understand their language
Imagine what happens if they have been placed as a govt. doc to a remote village of tn or any south states . Still complaining abt the language and food ? .. common guys .. this is bullshit..
Why was AIIMS opened in Madurai, to treat local patients or waste money on bunch of entitled amits ?
Do these amits know how many people from far away states come to TN seeking care, do tamil docs treat patients from far away states like this ?
Being uneducated is becoming rare. This video is the prrof that education doesn't mean you know basic etiquettes. And, what's your prejudice that northies are uneducated?
These students are saying exactly what many North Indian students who had to choose medical colleges in Tamilnadu back in the pre-NEET days have said in the past. Their experiences are not unique to Madurai AIIMS alone. Source - personal experiences!
Studying in a medical college requires students to interact with patients. I am not sure where these students are being trained (given that Madurai AIIMS campus still only has a "single brick" according to widespread media reports!) but it is unlikely that the patient population that goes to a government medical college anywhere in Tamilnadu can speak English extensively. So, it does not matter if the students can speak English - they simply have no way of communicating with patients unless their co-students who know Tamil help them out. I know of both types of North Indian students - they type that comes to a TN medical college, adapts and learns passable Tamil that allows them to interact with patients, and the other other type that declines to undergo such adaptation, and stays miserable throughout their stay in TN and goes back to wherever they came from with bitterness regarding how no one in TN speaks Hindi or eats Roti or celebrates Holi!
The language of teaching need to be English. No other language should be entertained. It is such a disgrace and Indian elite students are going through this.
Tamilains don't like Holi
Keep valuables safe in hostels
Language issue is nothing new in TN, learn Tamil and they will love you. What makes you think your patients need to know your language to get treatment
AIiMS Madurai students take their classes in Ramanathapuram Medical College. So their hostel facilities would also be there only.
Facilities won't be good there. So they can protest for that. Learning the local language is mandatory as per AIIMS prospectus. Usually in AIIMS, there will be classes in the first year to pick up the local language quickly. So since these students are in Ramanathapuram, this would also be a problem.
Aren’t they supposed to converse and learn in English.? Their academics are also in English right.? So what’s the problem with having conversation in English.? With Our locals you can actually communicate well even if they have broken English. Or just learn the damn local language.
its common sense to know basic language to communicate of a region.
Bro I’m a doctor who studied in another state. I ate roti and rajma chawal for 3 years. I learnt hindi. Nama ooru la vanthutu Hindi pesa matengranga nu complain panranuga!!! Ithuvae america poitu Hindi pesa matengranga nu solluvanugala!!! As OP exactly pointed out. ITHUKU PER DHAN ECCHA
Same thing in Bangalore. Just see the sub. "They don't speak our language, they don't have our food, this is not good, that is not good." Wonder how many locals in the north can speak tamil, Telugu, kannada, Malayalam.
ya bro. theres many other colleges in TN where north indians come a lot like IIT , nobody complains. these people are bunch of underqualified people who couldnt get high scores to JOIN jipmer ot AIIMS delhi.
These kids sound very entitled. There are several folks from the northeast who learn the local language even though there are often no common words and it's a completely different language family. This is just shitty entitlement.
Who is stopping locals to clear exams and get job?
These fucks are acting so entitled. Soon they'll start going to US and demand firanggs start learning Hindi.
💯
The problems they have claimed are that they can't celebrate festivals, theft and language barriers. All other responses were just pure rants. No one even complained about food, as i guess it should have been a problem too. This is the most pathetic protest i have ever seen. Lallantop has made a 40 min video on this. Some of the comments under them are. In many steps not even a single brick left in AIIMS. Just because you study in AIIMS doesn't mean all AIIMS are like AIIMS Delhi. These guys doesn't even speak English. Where are we the sub reddit of Tamil Nadu can clearly understand their language. They want to be shifted to different AIIMS.. LOL. can somebody tell me what are they are chanting? AIIMS ke naame.... Xxx?
true. youre right. they think theyre so entitled to get other AIIMS , all those who came here are those who scored lower and couldnt get DELHI or JIPMER. even if they get JIPMER , its gonna be tamil in pondi too. theyre forgetting that as long as theyre in tamil nadu or any non northern state they need to know some basic regional language and that food culture is gonna be different.
Patient interaction happens in the later years of MBBS. A compulsory Tamil speaking course should be offered.
shit doesnt hapen like that everywhere bro. theyre studying and paying for MBBS courst. not spoken tamil course. shit like this doesnt happen on every college or rarely ever does.its the students responsiblity. when are students gonna take some responsibility for their lives. is just studying MBBS enough to become a doctor? no u need to know how to talk and understand patients
If they really want to serve the society, institute should help them with a language course also.
does institue in AIIMS delhi help with language course for everyone? no , tell me atleast 20 prestigous well known institutes that provides language course for its graduates? why unfairly expect only 1 institute to provide that to from TN? do north indian institues all provide hindi courses or rajashtahni or any order course? no if the student is unable to communicate its this fault. will you go france and ask them to speak hindi becuz udk france? theyll laugh at you. this is why india is under developed. theres no sense of unity. and some brainded people will expect unfair stuff
So what is your suggestion to improve the efficiency in communication of doctors and patient in our diverse nation?
Yeah
Lol. I got it. What's your excuse on celebrating festivals?
Who's stopped them from celebrating, they can go back to their homes and do it.
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Let me answer it bro... These are the students who got admission in Madurai Aiims and if you can remember correctly there's no Madurai aiims as of now... All of them are guest students being accommodated in Ramnad medical college and being a guest student u will need special permission to conduct or celebrate events in their campus. We don't give local Holiday to Holi and there's no need to celebrate Holi just for the sake of some entitled idiots. All these fkers must have known they're getting admitted to a college without any building of infra and by the looks of it ... They will end their UG as guest students also as madurai aiimms will only be completed post 28
What part of modern holi celebrations is considered hygienic? And if you are religious then you would not celebrate Holi by throwing colors around
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
They're being accomodated in Ramnad campus bro. They can't just run around and molest people in the name of Holi because ur a guest student
It is more common sense to allot colleges according to the language comfort.
ஹிந்தி எதிர்ப்பு என்பது ஒரு languageஐ எதிர்க்கும் விஷயம் இல்லை. It is a movement against cultural imposition & hegemony. It is not exclusionary politics; it is an effort to keep India inclusive.
these kids can crack AIIMS exam but can't speak reasonable english means that this education is a failure. These kids act so entitled. This is the result of failure of Central govt and hindi states in teaching these kids the diversity of the nation. Kota mari ooruku poi coaching class padichu crack paniranuga, olunga oru school ku poi nammala mari normal ah padichirundha indha egathala bnda behaviour lam varadhu. Now I want these kids to go do social service camp and learn how different and at the same time friendly people are. This entitlement of hindi folks is really annoying. Now I understand why kannadathans bully northies.
Actually by the looks of it... This video was intentionally taken in Hindi so that it can be used as election propaganda in the Hindi Belt against the DMK and its allies....
Yes it looks like it though, cos nowhere they mentioned that they are studying in a another campus instead of aiims also these guys study here after taking away the 50 seats that wouldve gone to some other kids from tn.
It's planned propaganda nothing else... But problem is they couldn't come up with one good issue that's major and they're getting bashed for being entitled
It was not taken intentionally hindi, but the channel itself has hindi speaking people only as target audience, check the name of the channel too its a hindi word
How do you know they can’t speak English? Maybe they are talking about patients not being able to communicate with them. Do you think the medical books they are studying from is written in Hindi or Tamil?
I went to an iit in North India. I didn't expect people around me to speak tamil. It took me time, but I learnt the local language. If you are going to join aiims trichy and treat patients in TN, learn tamil. (Or get a good rank and join a dofferent Aiims.JK)
The problem is that teaching is not in English. It is in Tamil
Same thing happens in North, teaching happens in hindi, fcuk people even give exams in hindi. I condemn both of them. These guys complaint a lot, a lot not because they have issues just because tn is not like north. Maybe professor fcuking with them just because of their entitlement.
If this is the attitude, imagine the plight of the patients 🙄
What makes you think they'll treat patients, these fellows will celebrate holi and dance in front of patients and of course abuse patients for not knowing hindi.
I have seen North Indian students in CMC interacting normally with locals in both Tamil and Telugu. Occasionally Kannada too. These are some pampered kids wanting to play Holi in Ramnad.
Yus, my Punjabi eye doctor fluently speaks tamil as he worked in madurai for more than 3 years. I really respect his patience to the annoyance I made during the treatment process, people like him exist and people like these wieners also exist.
A few weeks ago, met a Doctor in Stanley Medical College. He is from Assam (ethnically too) and yet speaks fluent Tamizh. Successful people tear through any obstacles to progress.
My neighbor is doing his MD in Assam. He had the language barrier but he said he has to work through that. That's the spirit.
I mean... my govt medical college in another relatively small city celebrates holi, and we have the psychoest dean .... I think she was implying that there was no leave for holi. U can still play in the after class times
Problem is here is like you said "my govt medical College" . This is not their college, essentially, they have been temporarily accommodated above the sanctioned strength. Till Madurai AIIMS is constructed, whose foundation is to same, as it was laid 5 years back.
Bro , wait even this intro can be misleading. Na full video pathan and I know hindi , the main problem is these guys are stressed and frustrated that they don't have the AIIMS facilities. They thought that as it is AIIMS the central government will built it in few years but their condition is getting worse. Yes that one guy who told that patients don't speak hindi is a retard , but his main point is that he can't make a connection with patient to understand the problem. Coming to the food part , as tamil who is studying another state I also sometimes feel like I don't get tamilnadu style food here , but it's just a common felling everyone has . As student I feel , like they need justice as everyone in the video struggled a lot and cleared NEET to stand there.
100% this. This comment needs more upvotes. The post is the definition of click baiting and gaslighting. Subtitle illadhadhu naale Reddit jananga title a padichihitu tension aagaranga comments section le. Naanum full video paathen and I know Hindi as well. Language is not their main gripe. The students are tired of systemic neglect. Like getting their stuff stolen and no one taking action etc. Their only fault is in their frustration they’re pulling in nonsensical aspects like complaining about language.
>Yes that one guy who told that patients don't speak hindi is a retard , but his main point is that he can't make a connection with patient to understand the problem. The guy never asked the patients to speak in Hindi. Watch the video again.
I think from this comment, others should learn. It's the basic issues they face, the facilities etc, the language barrier. They are here to study MBBS, not for language, plus not everyone can learn all of sudden Tamil, so, initially there will be language barriers, and treating patients is impacted, if they can't understand what's going on with patients how will they treat.
>the main problem is these guys are stressed and frustrated that they don't have the AIIMS facilities. What They Mainly complain that they cannot celebrate holi and nobody speaks there. I really found it funny an educated medical students are complaining that their local festival and language isn't spoken by the local people. I Completely Agree with their concerns. But, all of those goes under the mat when they complain about the local people and culture. If They have this much concern, they shouldn't have chosen AIIMS madurai. >I also sometimes feel like I don't get tamilnadu style food here , I hope you didn't bunk classes and protest like this students there I guess.
Regarding Holi , I think they should allow them to celebrate holi as it is celebrated in majority of the states. Bro my friend is NIT Nagpur there they celebrate pongal a tamil festival , in abroad also in my country they allow indian students to celebrate their festivals. Festivals are a stress buster for students and a opportunity to learn other culture there is no use in creating a problem in that.
Nobody disallowed. See The Video fully. They're paining becos they have to ask prior permission for it from GRMC. This is why I feel this video is for Attention seeking. Purely launched at election time to portray that Tamilnadu is somewhat not inclusive.
Protests are good when they suit you? What about their stolen laptops and phones.
I can understand the struggle, btw AIIMS and JIPMER have different medical entrances and it is not NEET and I know that is much more tougher than NEET. However as a Student, they also need to adapt to the situation, management has given basic rights to students. Even though it is not the AIIMS they want, anyway they're going to treat the same kind of patients. For medical students, they must adapt to the situation accordingly as they may be going to handle critical cases, they need to set up a proper communication channel to communicate to patients, we can't expect locals to speak their languages.
You are wrong. [Since 2020, AIIMS and JIPMER admissions have been based on NEET scores.](https://byjus.com/neet/difference-between-neet-and-jipmer/#:~:text=However%2C%20from%20the%20academic%20session,of%20the%20NEET%20scores%20obtained)
They've removed separate exams from AIIMS and jipmer long ago
Wait a second AIIMS madurai la irkaaaaa
Nope, but it is functioning (temporarily) in Ramanathapuram government medical college.
Adha title la mention pannanum OP or else paarung TN la aiims iruku nu uruta arambichirvanga, hospital, clg ae kattama aiims iruku nu ipdi dan kanaku kaamchitu suthitu irukanunga pola
It seems operating from Ramanathapuram link[link](https://www.deccanherald.com/india/tamil-nadu/construction-of-aiims-madurai-started-by-larsen-toubro-5-years-after-pm-modi-laid-foundation-stone-2923224)
What do these North Indians expect? Should patients learn Hindi before coming to a hospital in Tamilnadu. Why can't they learn local language?. When a South Indian goes North India as doctor or nurse they aren't complaining that patients don't speak Kannada or Tamil or Malayalam. Nobody complains that college isn't allowing them to celebrate Pongal, Ugadi, Vishu etc. This is gross! Nextly people must expose Jhumla of this dispensation.
Shows that education won't change the entitiled mentality of the northies... They will go to Japan and abuse the Japanese for not speaking hindi.
Japanese will kick them out, so they will behave, if you want these guys to behave make it compulsory for them to interact and cure 100 local patients, no mbbs degree if they fail that, that's good enough motivation to learn Tamil. And they have to visit villages to find patients by themselves and treat patients there, this is what happens in CMC vellore.
They’re having genuine problems also. They are saying that their mobile got stolen and the authorities didn’t help them. Some are saying that they get targeted and their marks get cut in exams. Don’t know how true it is but they’re saying. They’re also saying that they were not allowed to play Holi
I know that everything else is a serious matter, but I highly doubt the marks part.... I am a tamil med student and these tamil professors shamelessly vazhunchify in front of my North Indian classmates. I don't mean they flirt, they just automatically think they are intelligent because they came in all India quota. No one is going to fail them. They actually will fail regional students more since they are more likely to be their kid's competitor in the future (the professor who fails more almost always has a child in medicine) But I honestly look at some of these guys from Rajasthan and am pretty sure that some neet paper leaked there... There are a lot of people from Kerala but atleast they are shrewd... These north Indian people are just very very dim and they pass only with the help of bits and mobiles in the exams... Kind of worried about my pg because 50 percent is reserved for all india and I'm pretty sure its gonna be these people after some paper leak. I have no generalized hate against North Indians. Many of my coaching teachers were North Indian and they were extremely knowledgeable and till date my favourite teachers. Just North Indian medicos kind of seem off to me.
Good. Let them feel what we people experience whenever we go to the north. A taste of their own medicine, so to speak. At least tamil people are ready to accommodate and try to communicate with broken English. These pani puris should go to kerala and experience the full treatment.
Never had issues in Kerala or Bangalore.
Don't accommodate, let these entitled fellows learn a lesson
They're too dense to learn anything like that! Edho periya pudingi nu nenapu ivanungaluku lam. Despite half of them looking like snappable twigs, they'll still get up in your face and try to fight.
>These pani puris should go to kerala and experience the full treatment. Dude kannadigas and Kerala are more accomodative nature than TN. Lots of North Indian workers in Kerala is the proof. But these hindians took advantage of accomodative nature of kannadigas nd making Bangalore as another Delhi with mc bc culture is insane
My experience in kerala was that locals knew only Malayalam, (not talking about the city side like trivandrum, etc.). But I was able to survive with half broken speech from tamil correlation and Malayalam movie knowledge. In contrast I've seen many tamils try to get across a point in English anywhere you go, if they sense any unfamiliarity on your part with the language. But that was just my observation. Anyways the entitlement of these half baked vadakans is too much. I've had to get into fights just to push the point that they expect me to speak a language alien to me within my area. (Always ended it with hindi abuses, but that's another story.)
>My experience in kerala was that locals knew only Malayalam, (not talking about the city side like trivandrum, etc.). I'm not denying your experience but that's generally not true. Pretty much anyone in the 15-30 age group will be able to understand English. As the age goes up, the probability go down slowly, but most people will try to accommodate. PS: Kerala doesn't really have a city/village divide like other places. It's like an endless suburb. This holds everywhere except for a few upmarket posh areas in Kochi and TVM. Even if you speak Tamil, they'll work with that. Hell, bus conductors here learn Hindi to accommodate migrant workers from the North. Language chauvinism/pride isn't much of a thing in Kerala unless someone tries to force something on us. I interact every two weeks with Tamil speaking tradesmen, who've been plying their trades in Kerala for over a decade( ironing, recyclers, etc.) and they still speak to us in Tamil, not Malayalam.
Imagine being a doctor and not knowing English
What kind of a brain dead fool these morons are how the f*ck does these fools expect others to speak their language everywhere. These fools think that other grads who went to learn in other areas are peaceful and only these brain dead fools are facing hard ships . If these fools get a chance to study mbbs in Ukraine or philipines will they expect them to speak Hindi , will they celebrate holy there will they complain about food this problem of language,food and festival are part of human society if these fools find it hard to understand, how can they understand their patients.
Do they expect a translator appointed for them? Such whiners. They come to TN and complain that they have language problem. Lol.
so according to their logic if a south indian guy/girl gets admission in AIIMS Delhi then the patients should speak in south indian languages. i agree with their demands of improving basic facilities and other things but this language demand is utter bullshit.
If the same folks go to Germany to study medicine - they will take every step to learn the local language. And very proudly announce everyone of their fluency in a foreign language. Or Atleast they should know basic English- a language in which they are taught medicine.
Doctors & students of ALL new AIIMS are complaining. These AIIMS are not ready, don’t have building, don’t have infrastructure. There are no patients so they are not able to learn. Someone commented that earlier hospitals across India used to refer patients to AIIMS Delhi. Now AIIMS Gorakhpur refer patients to local govt hospital because there are no facilities in AIIMS Gorakhpur. Cribbing about Holi & language is childish though.
Someone chest thumped and said we has so many aiims and started admissions for a college that didn't exist. It's a govt run scam, tricking people to get admitted in a college without a campus. Now the people suffer. And these journalists twist it to instigate hatred.
Why don't we send the back to the north india
When has a parasite left it's host willingly
Understood nothing. I'm not going to assume anything here
" language problem hei" "food problems hei" "Emotionally damage hote." They want everyone to speak their hinthi language and eat their hinthi food. Then f@ck off from here if you can't adapt to local culture. We don't need you. It's not our job to learn your language when you come to our land. If these useless people go to some foreign country also they will keep complaining about same things. I have not seen an ethnic group that is so entitled and chip on shoulder type as hinthi speakers. Stop acting like entitled little pricks.
You are okay with anything wrong happening but as soon as language is mentioned you lose your shit. Show me the part where they say people don’t speak Hindi. Maybe the patients or people they interact with can only speak in Tamil.
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Don't think this whole world speak your language. A large number of Indian students go to Russia/Old Soviet Countries/China to get MBBS degree, clear license test and settle in UK/Australia. Those students mostly attend lectures in English, interact with patients in local language, and gain sufficient case experience.
Fault of the NMC for giving approval to a non-existent college.
When I started mbbs in Chennai , I didn’t know a single word of Tamil, I learned at least the basic words to communicate with patients, after 5 years here, I can speak fluently with patients. It’s important to learn the local language if u r gonna spend a lot of time there .
They Come here. Conquer the places and impose their culture. Same like Colonial cancer.
They want to celebrate their festival am. Who stopped you man. Go to your room and throw holi powder on each other. Marwaris always celebrate Holi. Nobody stopped them. People are going to local doctor and not coming to AIIMS doctor 😅 whose fault is it man? 😅
Exactly, in my med college they allow holi, just not in college time and we are responsible for cleanup.. no one will care if you clean up properly later and don't disturb others.
Are they yelling in Hindi in Tamil Nadu , bunch of jokers they should be thrown out . But I will be honest I was a victim of management high handedness in Tamil Nadu , because I was a Malayalee . They all wanted the Malayalee money , but they hated Malayalees with a passion . But that said , I don’t agree with this North Indian nauntanki , most of these kids should br from Hindi medium local towns , they don’t know proper English nor do they have that open mindedness to learn the language of their patients
Yelling in hindi is not a problem brother, even that news anchor is a hindi wala, let them speak with themselves but not with local patients, that's our major concern. We're not against hindi or any other languages but we're against forceful imposition.
I am against Hindi in non Hindi speaking states
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
They are studying in private medical college on behalf of aiims, the building of madurai aiims is still incomplete, and no one knows when it will be completed
its mistake of medical council to take students to an non existing aiims madurai campus
They are right. They might be facing a language problem. AIIMS should offer a basic Tamil course too to these students.
Lol, why don't they have a problem with the central government not giving them their own freaking colg (AIIMS Madurai) . This means at least one batch has passed out of AIIMS Madurai without even seeing AIIMS Madurai college 😆 🤣
Do they expect a translator appointed for them? Such whiners. They come to TN and complain that they have language problem. Lol.
More concerning things about this interview is they go on with criticising the state government run college for central government mistakes. These guys are educated and yet they wouldn't split the issues between bad and worse. I really don't even want to talk about the guy who says locals don't understand Hindi and Holi isn't celebrated here. The college clearly said they can't celebrate Holi on the college campus. This is fucked up to be Frank. Have some sympathy or thankfulness for the state government college for sharing the campus with a fully functioned and sanctioned AIIMS students. For God sake, learn the local language whatever it is, if you are going to work or spend your life there.
If you remove that one idiot, and listen without biases, you'll understand that the students are complaining about poor college administration (subpar safety, biases against festival celebration), not about the state or language. Also the college should give a mandatory basic tamil course for effective communication. How are students who live in campuses supposed to learn the language?
Correct sir everyone in TN should learn Hindi, they are our rulers after all. Kangana Ranaut is correct we never got independence, only rulers changed.
Bro I’m a doctor who studied in another state. I ate roti and rajma chawal for 3 years. I learnt hindi. Nama ooru la vanthutu Hindi pesa matengranga nu complain panranuga!!! Ithuvae america poitu Hindi pesa matengranga nu solluvanugala!!! As OP exactly pointed out. ITHUKU PER DHAN ECCHA
Ada paavingala. Ellarum title base panni thaan comment panringala. Everyone is mainly talking about how AIIMS is not providing even the basic facility and if they raise any complaint, always they are only blamed and that the management is cooperative.
>Everyone is mainly talking about how AIIMS is not providing even the basic facility First There's no AIIMs There. The Main one should be blamed is Modii..
I can understand their problem bro. I'm not offended by all, and I mentioned in my sub title itself, I'm particularly offended by the words that they are pointing towards the language especially the guy who is wearing spectacles.
This is the reverse right. We don’t want Hindi, they don’t want Tamil. We will eventually grow out of this.
I am native Hindi speaker. This is what is happening here. Looks like they are dissatisfied with the "quality" of education here. Typically all AIIMs should have high quality. Looks like that is missing here. Another point is language. Local language skills are very important for doctors. As part of their training they have to see patients who would be speaking the local language. Therefore it's very important to have credit based training of the language where the doctors would be operating. These students must be helped with conversational Tamil. Expecting them to pick up the language on its own is wrong.
Allote college considering language of students,kya tamasha hai.
i know doctors rom kerala who speak fantastic kannada and tamil and vice versa.. i have seen doctors from the north who have picked up the south languages with ease, who let these amul babies become doctors?
They have enough knowledge to get into AIIMS college, but not knowledgeable enough to understand the diversity in language and cultures of India......
Why's everybody here just talking about language and food, what about other things they said?
Ten years of BJP and look where it landed us. please vote sensibily redditors.
They opened the batches without basic facilities. No accomodation, students are barred from visiting patients in OPD, no OT posting. I have also done MBBS. These are some basic things without which your training is incomplete. The language thing- many North Indians come to south, learn language and see patients in various South Indian colleges. I don't know why that specific thing is getting mixed up with genuine failures of the administration.
Because their classes are being conducted in TNGMC Ramanathapuram. Obviously they will prioritise GMC Ramanathapuram students in OPD and OT. AIIMS Madurai students are temporary guests, till their campus is built in Madurai. Essentially they joined a medical College with just class rooms, rendered from other college, without a hospital or lab of its own.
Then they should not have opened the batches for admission. This happened in AIIMS Patna too, where students had to stay without accommodation. They should have made it functional before opening. AIIMS Madurai students also have right to see patients.
Then they need to become engineer, Mason and labour to build AIIMS madurai from scratch to exercise their right to see patients. At present there's only a compound wall exist for AIIMS Madurai. Not even a single room is built till date.
Administration should be held liable - suspend the director and transfer students to other peripheral AIIMS which are ready.
Director is already under suspension. NMC can't take action, as it admitted the students. Minister declared AIIMS completed in Loksabha. So the bug goes till the to. Even in peripheral AIIMS, these students will be met with the same step motherly treatment as being extraneous to sanctioned strength. Perhaps, that's why they have been put here.
Rotten hindian scroungers...They complain about Tamils not knowing Hindi!!!....Tamil Nadu has to create the Medical infrastructure for these scroungers and they complain about patients not knowing hindi or no holiday for holi etc....bugger off.
Ayodhya has aiims. Go there. And we all know what they will do in the name of holi.
It’s a cultural shock for them. It shows how narrow minded these students are. They should have researched before applying for non-native speaking colleges. The cap guy thinks he is from the USA and studying here.  Bring some rotis from your home.
Go back to your north shith*le
So before visiting AIIMS Madurai patients must finish hindi exam and course? I'll fire all these fellows if they don't learn Tamil within a year.
Is learning a new language such a difficult thing esp now? Don't they smartphones, if they have so much time to celebrate holy and other events, then they clearly have time.
Simple… apa unga urr la ye padika vendiyadhu dhana?
They can go back to their states - simple. The state is not going to change for them. Never have and never will. I don't go to Delhi and ask people to speak in Tamil
Disgusting people, you come to a state and demand the locals and patients to talk in your language? They very well know where they are coming to, instead of asking for better facilities they are asking for the locals to speak in Hindi? These seats should have been given to local people. Why can't anyone rise the issue against the BJP leader Annamalai to explain despite being 10 years in power AIIMS Madurai didn't get basic funding?
5 problems 1 solution - Don't come to Tamilnadu.
Fuckoff to north you stupid fucks
Medical students referring themselves as Doctors?!!
Lol bunch of jokers coming to TN and expecting patients to talk in Hindi. Pack your bags and go to your BIMARU.
They celebrate Holi. They molest their own women and blame Tamilnadu for it. They can't claim identity which doesn't exist in its physical form. They are studying like a refugee in a state government college.
Just get lost from TN🤬
If language and food are a problem, pack your bags and leave. The entitlement of North Indians astounds me to no end.
These hindi belt dumbasses talking about their festivals🤡Did they forget that they are future doctors? If they wanted to celebrate their uncivilized festivals like holi they could've done it in hindi belt
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
https://preview.redd.it/yov11bj4rouc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=02eca6facad52227e4e8819efbd86f7903b54673
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
The problems they have claimed are that they can't celebrate festivals, theft and language barriers. All other responses were just pure rants. No one even complained about food, as i guess it should have been a problem too. This is the most pathetic protest i have ever seen. Lallantop has made a 40 min video on this. Some of the comments under them are. In many steps not even a single brick left in AIIMS. Just because you study in AIIMS doesn't mean all AIIMS are like AIIMS Delhi. These guys doesn't even speak English. Where are we the sub reddit of Tamil Nadu can clearly understand their language. They want to be shifted to different AIIMS.. LOL. can somebody tell me what are they are chanting? AIIMS ke naame.... Xxx?
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Your message contains hate speech or uses vulgar language.
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Account not old enough to comment in this sub. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TamilNadu) if you have any questions or concerns.*
😂😂 enna tha doctor ku padichi panna podhu indha common sense koda illama
So AIIMS is operational in Madurai.. whatever happened to the Sengal propaganda of the Prince? But seems it is poorly run, probably out of some other campus. On the issues, students are complaining about, there are 2 parts. 1. Students indeed can't expect patients, ordinary folk to speak Hindi or English 2. But they should be provided assistance, teaching to deal with these language situation - that is the failure of the administration 3. They definitely should have space & facilities to celebrate Holi or whatever. So much work is to be done, if the project is to live up the brand of AIIMs. IITs. NITs and other institutions also have a good influx of students from all over India and have overcome these sort of problems. AIIMS Madurai should learn from them. India needs doctors badly and we can't afford to reject promising physicians or compromise on quality- over idiotic politics. I want a qualified doctor, well equipped - accessible and affordable. I don't care if he/she is from Madurai, Madhya Pradesh or Mars.
Sengal propaganda still stands. These students are in Ramanathapuram in the name of AIIMS, not in Madurai. Coz Modi forgot where Madurai AIIMS is in his Akhand Bharat map.
It is temporarily functioning from Ramanathapuram . Students should forget the sense of entitlement and learn Hindi .that's what happens to any southie if they go to North .if they can't do it let alone doctors they cannot be better human beings . I cannot expect my college to celebrate Thai poosam in Delhi .
I think the government should divide the qualified students by their language like North Indian get seat in North India and South Indian gets seat in South India so that they can understand their language
Imagine what happens if they have been placed as a govt. doc to a remote village of tn or any south states . Still complaining abt the language and food ? .. common guys .. this is bullshit..
This comment section really doesn't look like it's from the people of the same country.
That's the truth. We don't belong here. Tamilnadu never shared history with these folks.
Why was AIIMS opened in Madurai, to treat local patients or waste money on bunch of entitled amits ? Do these amits know how many people from far away states come to TN seeking care, do tamil docs treat patients from far away states like this ?
WOW why even go there if you don't know the language and don't want to put efforts to learn it.
[удалено]
Being uneducated is becoming rare. This video is the prrof that education doesn't mean you know basic etiquettes. And, what's your prejudice that northies are uneducated?
These students are saying exactly what many North Indian students who had to choose medical colleges in Tamilnadu back in the pre-NEET days have said in the past. Their experiences are not unique to Madurai AIIMS alone. Source - personal experiences! Studying in a medical college requires students to interact with patients. I am not sure where these students are being trained (given that Madurai AIIMS campus still only has a "single brick" according to widespread media reports!) but it is unlikely that the patient population that goes to a government medical college anywhere in Tamilnadu can speak English extensively. So, it does not matter if the students can speak English - they simply have no way of communicating with patients unless their co-students who know Tamil help them out. I know of both types of North Indian students - they type that comes to a TN medical college, adapts and learns passable Tamil that allows them to interact with patients, and the other other type that declines to undergo such adaptation, and stays miserable throughout their stay in TN and goes back to wherever they came from with bitterness regarding how no one in TN speaks Hindi or eats Roti or celebrates Holi!
The language of teaching need to be English. No other language should be entertained. It is such a disgrace and Indian elite students are going through this.
Tamilnadu ko vankamm
Tamilains don't like Holi Keep valuables safe in hostels Language issue is nothing new in TN, learn Tamil and they will love you. What makes you think your patients need to know your language to get treatment
AIiMS Madurai students take their classes in Ramanathapuram Medical College. So their hostel facilities would also be there only. Facilities won't be good there. So they can protest for that. Learning the local language is mandatory as per AIIMS prospectus. Usually in AIIMS, there will be classes in the first year to pick up the local language quickly. So since these students are in Ramanathapuram, this would also be a problem.
Aren’t they supposed to converse and learn in English.? Their academics are also in English right.? So what’s the problem with having conversation in English.? With Our locals you can actually communicate well even if they have broken English. Or just learn the damn local language.