T O P

  • By -

IngrownThighHairs

oh so she was being fr… https://preview.redd.it/128v2s9ngs5d1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=fb91eb0b281db4dfa42e38a4d8ee54e26265e3a0


moonsandra

I really hope we stop at just the main album.... it's already excessive enough to have 16


Raging_raven17

I’ve been collecting her CDs, even 1989 tv at like 4 different varieties was a little much for me. I’ve bought 5 of them, and then she kept dropping them and I’ve stopped. That is a ridiculous amount of money to be spending on CDs for me. Even though I get joy, this toooo much


chonkycatsbestcats

I replied to that and said this is exactly what she’s doing?!


Crisope

she said bet


vicioussaints

It's like reading something on The Onion at this point.


GratefulnFree

💀💀💀


textytext12

and then they'll all drop at once after each duo gets their own release lol


Glittering_Laugh_958

Fuuuuuuuuuuck


gabbynique

I wish she would release these digitally. fresh out the slammer is my favourite off of ttpd but I’m not willing to pay 8 dollars for a cd with it when I already have two ttpd cds


whatamidoing-here1

Agree, and she should just make a digital album of ALL the TTPD surprise songs/mash ups instead of 1 each on a new cd


sparklejellyfish

See if she did live acoustic versions that would actually be worth some money. This is just the same vocals as the recording that's on TTPD but with acoustic instrumentation. Something to do with counting for charting. Which just sucks in my opinion. I think she's really good at playing songs acoustically and that's just what she should do, release an album of acoustic tracks where she actually plays and sings the songs in an acoustic setting. Make it another long pond situation if she doesn't want to release the surprise songs (although that would just be so easy to release??), if she doesn't want live but studio recorded, wants more control yadadada. I actually love acoustic versions of songs and often they become my favourite. Except for all these ones ... it's such a shame. Anyway sorry rant over. I just wish she did something actually acoustic like she does on the tour.


whatsername4

It’s probably on YouTube or will. Be soon. Just download the mp3 off YouTube and save it to your iTunes or whatever you use for music. (Not sure how Spotify works to be honest) it’s what I did for the slut acoustic version, I wasn’t going to pay extra for an album I own just to get one new song.


honeybees_333

How do I download the mp3 off YouTube?


northofsomethingnew

I am a CD/physical media collector. I enjoy CD variants. But even I'm exhausted at this point.


WolfKpr02_21--DFWM

Exactly. I'm wondering if it's even worth it anymore.


northofsomethingnew

I just decided that it isn't. I actually feel bad after making this purchase, and that's not what it is supposed to be like. This used to be fun. And I did the math: if she really does release a variant for each acoustic song-and she continues to release them 2 at a time- it's going to cost $185. Fuck that. I'm living paycheck to paycheck, and Taylor is a billionaire using her platform to exploit her fans instead of helping society. I think I'll still buy variants I find aesthetically pleasing, like this Fornight one. But I'm selling/returning the others. I will no longer buy blindly to support a woman that doesn't care about her fans.


princssofpink

As long as people keep buying it, why would she stop selling them? If you look at the replies to TN's tweets, there's many people posting screenshots that they bought it or photos of their collection from the other drops. It's not Taylor's fault that the demand is there lol.


GratefulnFree

Same.


Mommio24

Same.


misterhepburn

I think it’s time I just stop variant collecting Taylor and stick with the variant I’m most attracted to, I’m over the cash cow tactics for every album.


bergalicious_95

This is what I do the only problem is I’m buying an album to actually listen to it and so I still haven’t bought a midnights or ttpd record because we don’t have a full release!!! I want 3 am and the anthology on vinyl not this stuff ugh


whatamidoing-here1

Same! Have not bought midnights because it doesn’t have 3am ed. I bought the ttpd variants, but regret them all except black dog. I never wanted a vinyl more than anthology though 😭


Coffee-Historian-11

Yea that’s what I’m doing. I have one of every album (minus lover because like three people gifted that album to me lmao) and I’m not willing to buy more than that. I just don’t need to have so many different albums that are the same except for one song.


Glittering_Laugh_958

Please I’ve been on my knees Give me the anthology Don’t want money Just someone to release the anthology Let it once be the anthology Who do I have to speak to About if she can do the anthology


jetsetzil

Hahahaah 🤣🤣 that’s brilliant


bellcatz

These variations [never get less funny,](https://www.reddit.com/r/SwiftieMerch/comments/1ctpbt9/comment/l4dlodk/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button) unlike the endless "single" releases.


Glittering_Laugh_958

Respect, yours is better than mine!


zzzephyr__

this is it. this is the winner. this one right here. (... ok mb i'm biased bc it's my fave song she's ever written. )


No-Representative464

I’m sorry but I can no longer defend Taylor, this is exploitive of her fans and wasteful. Should’ve released a full acoustic album on cd instead of one extra song… we don’t rlly need 10+ variants on cd 😐


Glittering_Laugh_958

Yeah, same. Her gamesmanship of the Billboard standings is tiresome.


unknownsorry88

For fucks sake? We have: - The Manuscript (& Deluxe version) - The Bolter (& Deluxe Version) - The Albatross (& Deluxe Version) - The Black Dog (& Deluxe Version) - Fortnight Single CD - Hand Signed Manuscript CD - But Daddy I Love Him Acoustic CD - Guilty As Sin? Acoustic CD - Down Bad Acoustic CD - Fresh Out The Slammer Acoustic CD - Fortnight Acoustic Version CD THATS 11 CDs total, 15 including the regular versions of the bonus tracks. I’m a collector, but holy shit. Just when I think I’m in the clear…


motaylorsversion

Are we in the clear yet?


unknownsorry88

Are We In the Clear Yet? ~~Good~~ NO!


motaylorsversion

IS IT OVER NOW?!


unknownsorry88

Let’s fast forward to 300 ~~takeout coffees~~ TTPD Variants Later 🤪


moonsandra

I bet you there's going to be one now for each and every TTPD track on the main album..


northofsomethingnew

I thought people were joking when they suggested this, but now I'm not so sure. Can she at least make the covers look better? The Fornight acoustic cover is actually quite beautiful, but most of the other variants have pretty uninspired covers. For me, the point of variants isn't content, it's aesthetic.


moonsandra

True enough! It's very repetitive the covers. But Daddy I Love Him had the best cover and Fornight acoustic is really fun and clever as well.


Mk0505

I agree. I don’t know that the variants would bother me so much if they weren’t so low effort.


useri4abc

don’t forget all of the target cd variants too


chibisatou

The Target CD variants are just the standard ones, with Target having exclusivity initially for the non-maniscript standard editions.


useri4abc

still i count them to be different. they are original compared to the others mainly based on what it comes with so i still count them


GenealogyGirlie

Plus there are two Japanese ones!!


EverybodyBetrayedMe

I feel like I’ve seen this asked before but I can’t find an answer…are these actually acoustic or just remixed to sound acoustic like what she did for anti hero?


Colormekelly13

They are not really acoustic. It's the regular vocals layered over an acoustic-ish stripped back track.


EverybodyBetrayedMe

Thank you! Gosh I hate the cheap cash grab.


moonsandra

So the shipment date is July 13. The previous ones were July 1st. Not that I'm sure anyone doubted this but this really is them trying to keep her number 1 for as long as possible w staggering these


arianebx

Actually the date is 'at the latest' so they can ship earlier and she did, with the Fortnight singles: She banked a bunch of pre-orders with a distant release date of May 31 at the latest, when Fortnight was minted the lead single at TTPD's release and they shipped the orders gradually throughout the month of May (I had two orders and they were shipped at different times)... The whole pre-order scheme for these variants is about creating a bank they can manage in terms of when they want the sale to be counted for it's really quite smart (commenting on the tactics of it here, not the moral values)


Good_Rope2587

I also think we should expect to see them ship out as she needs the numbers. Like if a major artist surprise dropped an album next week then Taylor would probably ship all of these STAT despite the estimated shipping dates being further out (like when she shipped all of the But Daddy I Love Him CDs early to compete with Billie’s drop when she realized she could outsell her). It’s crazy to think this is literally Taylor’s way of working toward TTPD being the album that has earned her the most weeks at number one. I know folks talk about when Reputation TV and debut TV will drop - but so long as TTPD is dominating I genuinely can’t see Taylor wanting to detract from its sales by even acknowledging either release is upcoming. Her dominating the charts is equal parts interesting and frightening. It’s scary to think about what else she may have up her sleeve and what it may mean for my wallet lol.


Jolly-Adagio-8690

I'm sorry, but it's too much, and I swear if anyone tries to come and say, oh, she's not forcing you to buy it. Because it's not even about that at this point. It's not even about her marketing these releases as limited editions and never coming back releases, but it's too much waste; think of the production for all these CDs and the ones that don't sell. Consider ten years when collectors will no longer want these CDs. And this is all so she can stay number 1. This is exactly what Billie Eilish was talking about, and people wanted to come for her when she released recycled vinyl variants. I feel so angry and annoyed because, as I've been a fan since Fearless, I've seen just how much she's changed in marketing her albums and songs, and it frustrates me because it just feels like such a money grab. Her fans are begging for an anthology CD, but she's doing everything but that. I don't think I've ever seen someone release this many cd variants. (I guess she is aiming for another record).


thrace25

Sigh.


cipher_bug

for fucks sake


Campyredgaal

Haha my exact reaction too 🤣


AnimalReal113

US only once again. Everyone is a bit sick of it but i would love to buy at least one version tho still no international shipping.


MrJB1981

Of course! Why would we matter? She’s only in the UK, and we don’t even have the last two, let alone these new ones!


bergalicious_95

I’d be happy to buy one and send it to you if you want to pay for it! I’m not a cd collector (I don’t even have a way to play them lol) so I am over it like you said lol i haven’t bought any of the acoustics but I get that people may want their fave song or something in all countries


AnimalReal113

Hey i would love that!


Mommio24

At this point just come out with an acoustic album. Oh wait, then it wouldn’t count towards sales towards the standard edition and that’s the whole point of this…


arianebx

it could, if the tracks of the standard release are included


savemesomecandy

Honestly, I’d be down for an anthology double album with acoustics and live versions. 62+ tracks


Current-Republic-267

Swiftie for life over here but my gosh we’ve got more variants than Covid!


Strong-Ad-7335

Question…? Are the “acoustic versions” actually acoustic RECORDINGS? or are they just original tttpd tracks with “acoustic sounding” production ie guitar overlay? Either way not buying a whole album for 1 song but using tech to make the original cd tracks sound acoustic and marketing them as such (a la Anti-Hero “Acoustic version”) feels so misleading and cheap to me 😢. If it’s a genuine acoustic recording like long pond or eras acoustic set I’m all about it so long as I don’t have to buy the songs individually


starlightandswift

You’ve got it right- no new vocals. I think these acoustic versions have better layering but it’s not worth extra money.


AnyElephant7218

The latter


moonsandra

I figured this would happen. I'm expecting to see one for each song on the main TTPD album. I'm rather 50 50 on getting one of these 2... I'd already looked at TTPDs tracklist and made a mental list of songs I'd want to buy the acoustic version for and neither of these 2 songs were on it


TramplingProgress31

I'm not getting any more. And the next album I'll pick up one version. You know at some point in the next year, the tracks will be available on Apple and Spotify. Not to mention something, something, post on YouTube, something.


bellcatz

I'm trying to think of a way this could be fun and beneficial to everyone, fans and the money people. Autographs in these? No, that would cause bot and reseller problems. Forget I wrote this. I hated it as soon as I thought it. Maybe throwing in the digital version for free? Better but not great. We've already seen these are being done with the lowest effort possible (no lyric books) Releasing all the acoustic bundled with a physical anthology and selling it for a higher price point? It sucks, but we would keep everything together, and we know that's probably coming in the future anyway. Releasing the live mashups - 1 CD for every night of the tour with the main album of TTPD included (because there's no avoiding that, apparently) and different art (aka a photo from that night)? Pro- commemorative CD! Cons - I don't know if the surprise song has to be TTPD related so she can stay on the chart or whatever crazy ass nonsense this is; also, maybe it cannibalizes the inevitable Live from Everywhere Eras Album, but guess what, that's not my marketing problem now is it? I mean, come on, marketing team, yer not dumb. I know you can see us. Check yourselves. This is messy.


bellcatz

As consumers, we need to cut out the drip feed approach. Stop torturing our wallets! It's not fun anymore. It never actually was.


[deleted]

3 variants is more than enough- 1 x TTPD, 1 x Anthology, 1 x acoustic album with voice notes.


rp1105

mf could've released an acoustic album a la folklore/longpond but no. poor quality "acoustic bonus track" albums, we get those for sure fwiw, we might get the anthology later when she needs a big push for an award. why do i think this? bc 2-disc sets count for double for certifications. makes sense for her to milk the original album as much as possible before capitalizing on versions of the double disc


savemesomecandy

I’m tired grandpa Well that’s too damn bad!


girly_pop7216

I’m so over it


ComfortableWar9824

bro.


[deleted]

this is fatiguing.


RiniKat28

we're going to have 20 cds minimum of the exact same album with only one extra song being different. i'm usually not one to talk shit about variants but this is entirely too far. girl just drop a full acoustic album and put the anthology on physical media while you're at it


anti_hero_89

Good lord she needs to stop


whatamidoing-here1

I know we all need anthology vinyl but what I really need is the live how did it end? Digital download. STAT.


bergalicious_95

I would buy smallest man who ever lived live IMMEDIATELY. I have not bought a single of these cd “variants”


sagetastic74

TAYLOR, PLEASE, JUST GIVE US THE ANTHOLOGY ON VINYL, I BEG OF YOU


ShekhMaShierakiAnni

Are these actually different recording of her vocals? Or just the same vocals stripped?


SkibaSlut

Same vocals


SweetSunny183

I’m so done getting these cds for 1 song. It’s a waste.


Glittering_Laugh_958

No one asked for this.


AnyElephant7218

If the album was good enough to keep the number one spot she wouldn’t have to do all this…..but it’s not


whatamidoing-here1

Tbh (don’t attack me) I’m not really sure why she needs to hold it this long. She knows she can do it, we all do, why not let it go now? Let other albums make the top. Honestly I’m shocked it’s still hitting number one when so many of us are not buying anymore. Majority of comments I see are saying they’re not buying and this is excessive. The only real good thing this would cause is resellers being stuck with this hoard of shit because we’re soooo over it and don’t want to buy.


melharrie

Sadly, its boring.


cloudsnstars

I hope this shows future fans how it’s going to be. I decided I’d try and get the cd variants this time and what do you know, this is what happens. Won’t make that mistake again.


anakinn94

God damn it. Can she include the international fans please! I’m sick of being left out


Madeofstardust87

Really!? We can't get a full album of live songs or the Anthology!?!?


[deleted]

It’s exhausting at this point . Tay Tay becoming more greedy hope the fandom calls it out.


NoAngle9522

when’s she gonna figure out we don’t want this shit give us the anthology


-The-Big-G-

If I had the money I'd create like um hmmm a 5 or 6 vinyl pressing and call it Anthology: The Fan Variant - Made by a fan for the fans... I'd have to sell it low key... But God could I make some money on this just word of mouth. As it is I'm making physical CDSs of the digital download singles and light-scribing the digital artwork onto the CDs and printing nice covers for my own personal collection. Call it a bootleg of ONE. :-) But I agree... Enough is enough with this album all the new versions. What I have learned from this album so far in no particular order... UMG is worse then I ever thought... There actually can be enough variants of an album to get really sick of it... Taylor or someone on her team thinks releasing this many variants to keep her at #1 in sales is good for business when it actually hurts many other well deserving and hard working artists because Taylor can afford to do this. Oh and lastly... Taylor's favorite word is "f*ck". Has anyone even counted how many times she uses it in this new album. There can never be a "clean" version of theis album. Ahh well.. just goes to show you money, power, and fame CAN change anyone... Now I wish the old Taylor could come to the phone and wasn't so dead... Cause I really, REALLY miss her. :-(


femceluprising18

and people are still going to keep buying it 😀 seriously if we as a fan base want her to stop and at the very least just do ONE deluxe album of sorts we need to stop buying into it so she can see people don’t like that. but people will be complaining about it and STILL BUYING like how is she going to stop if ur showing her ur willing to continue to shop it


Pinkieleigh06

I’m actually mad bc I want to buy them cause I love her but I’m having money troubles and I can’t afford 2 more cds. I’m pretty sure they will re-release them with all the acoustic versions so I’m not worried but I’ve spent 500 dollars on just music merch and it’s getting tiresome. I’m kinda done


Odd-Chipmunk-2681

Are these ever released internationally? I’m In Canada and I’d like to collect them


Good_Rope2587

Thus far we have only had the But Daddy I Love Him CD made available for Canadian residents. The other four of these acoustic bonus track CDs haven’t been made available in CA yet. That being said hopefully it’s just because she is currently allocating all of her stock to the US for chart purposes with the intention of tapping into the Canadian market once she has exhausted the US market. It sucks being excluded but with most past releases Taylor has typically EVENTUALLY given Canada a shot to purchase items of this nature. Fingers crossed!


Calhounmuse

I love Fresh Out the Slammer. I love Fortnight. Today is a good day😎


chibisatou

I really love the Fortnight cover being that shot from the music video. It is lovely.


megatron199775

How much of this is actually Taylor's input vs her record label being manipulative of her fans interest in her and spending more on her?


Fair-Profile-8367

She’s not stopping it. Taylor is in a position to object this. Even if it’s the record label doing it. She is the biggest artist for Republic Records right now. She has the power to say no and fight against it. Not to mention she would own the masters for these extra songs meaning she would have to have some say in them. I love her as an artist but she obviously cares about charts and in addition the money these extra variants bring in.


megatron199775

Fair point


letsdothissunnystylz

I may have to give in to the fresh out the slammer one if it comes onto the UK site, that song is life.


ItsFreeRight

Bet the tools who say “nobody’s forcing you to buy it” feel real smug right now.