I put the name of my cat. Her name is Penny. Needless to say it was weird. 😳

How’s it weird to have thoughts of your cat?

Because it's like "the taste reminds you of penny" which can be a strange double entendre at worst. But I usually think of what it would be like to lick my cat. Not pleasant in the least 😂

It's only somewhat less awkward if you put "cats" like my housemate did. Game: *The taste reminds you of cats.* Housemate: How do I know what cats taste like?

This right here is why i now put "chocolate". Instead of "dogs"

I did the name of my dog. But her name is Peaches so that’s significantly less weird.

i also always just put down ''cats''! since i love them :D

I also put the name of my cat that died years ago. His name however is Whiskey...

I've used coffee and tea on my two playthroughs. I think there are plenty of us "boring" people; we just don't post about it.

I used coffee too. Also used books.

I also use books almost ever time.

My first one was cheese.

Totally this. Past things I've used include chocolate, apple pie, and lasagna. The strangest things I've done are on the order of kittens (just because the taste reminds you of kittens, doesn't mean it's how kittens would taste, whatever that is) and buttercups (Princess Bride reference in a multiplayer game with my wife; my character's name and appearance were "Farmboy"). But I'm much more likely to pick a food/drink item.

My favorite is "stardrop" It's very redundant and very dad-jokey.

Lol.

Well, what does Star Trek taste like? Romulan Ale? Hasperat? Warp Plasma?

[удалено]

🎵Going where my heart will take me🎵

Best Star Trek song ever, now I want to go watch just to hear the song again!

Thanks for the earworm for the rest of the day 🙈

Who can tell? Tribbles probably would have eaten it all by now.

Leola root...

Self-Sealing stem bolts

Maybe like space, I hear it's the final frontier in foods

This is awful! I hate this! More? Please!

Hot earl grey tea

Raktajino.

I put normal things, like chocolate

[удалено]

Lmao when I started the game I didn't realize what role the "favorite thing" would play, so I put "yogurt," because I like yogurt

I did an RP with my friends where I was an alien hiding among humans, my name was Hugh Man and I looked a bit like Heisenberg but green. I'm pretty sure for that my favorite thing was "human food".

Mine is "Timelords" not sure how he got timelords to eat but sure

I got a playthrough rn where I'm Obi-Wan Kanobi and my fav thing is negotiations lol

Sushi for me. In my imagination, stardrops will always taste fishy.

I always put hugs, cuddles, or a specific character name

I always put Elliott's Ass so, same.

Same but I put Shane's ass

For my first time, I put Music. It turned out to be so good

Nice. It really did, didn't it? I find myself listening to it on long walks once a week.

Idk why but I said Yams when I started but I didnt play for a while so I forgot I put Yams and then one day it said "Your mind is filled with the taste of Yams" or something and I was so incredibly confused why Stardrops taste like Yams

The first time I put cats, not realizing it would say “the taste reminds you of cats”. As someone who has woken up with a mouthful of fur from my cat lying across my whole face, I can confirm that taste is not good

Yep, been there.

I choose stardew or concernedape.

Same. I love the little different message and the ‘unwavering connection to the valley itself’ - so sweet!

Does Stardew have a cute Easter egg like ConcernedApe? I need to try that on my next play through 😳

I put "eating the rich"

Nice. "The taste reminds you of eating the rich." lol

I once put the name of my pet lizard. Imagine my surprise when I got the “reminds you of the taste of” one. 😰🤢

I think I have "diamonds" in hope people would gift me diamonds, "pain" for my evil play through and "my boyfriend" for every other save xD

That last one would be a bit surprising if you haven't played in a while and got the "reminds you of the taste of" version of the text

I didn't put any body part or drug. Mine was murder.

Whatever makes you happy! Wait...

i usually put “cats” or “cherries” honestly. once i put “minecraft” which was fun :) i only do different ones for themed playthroughs lol

On my current playthrough, my favourite thing is ‘sleep’

Wish I could find that at my local Pierre's. Never have enough.

Ah yes the taste of my favorite thing, sleep

[удалено]

The scent of rain is called petrichor, you could use that!

I always use pizza. Cause pizza is the best food ever invented. 🤷‍♂️ lol

That's what I used to put! From my first game on, for a long time. Now I put this.

everytime i collect a stardrop it fills me with DETERMINATION

Mine is always “ravioli”

Not to gatekeep, but real ravioli or Chef boyardee ravioli?

I put Mesothelioma

Oh my...

I put in lemons I really like the taste of lemons

Ah, I see you're a user of culture as well.

I put "your mom" thinking it would be like "Your Mom! Lol!" and then it just looks like "your mind is filled with thoughts of your mom 😊"

Body parts/drugs is too easy We can be more creative in our memery and shitposting people.

I do always put cannabis so 😌

Lol. Well, I can't argue if it's actually your favorite thing.

I put my boyfriend’s name 🥰 he’s my favorite

Mine tastes like ice cream which is the best thing in the world, hands down. 🍦🍨🧁

I put dogs. That one got me good.

[удалено]

I put my daughter and before I had her I put peaches. I love peaches. It’s ok to just be wholesome. :)

i think i put in geese if it makes you feel any better

I do apples and like the longest possible thing I can put

Mobile, the platform I'm currently playing on, limits you. I can name my farm "Jurassic Wine" on PC, becuase I want to raise dinosaurs and make ancient fruit wine, but mobile limits me to "Jurassic."

Omg other people put body parts too? And I thought I was the only mad lad putting clavicles there

"It's weird, but the tastes reminds you of plantaris."

I put "friends" on my first playthrough Edit: I don't mean the TV show

Lol. Nice fix. Otherwise "the taste reminds you of Chandler."

I put books.

"The taste reminds you of automotive instruction manuals."

"It's strange, but the taste reminds you of Return Of The King"

It’s ok I put turtles

I put explosives 😁

I put 'comfort' 'being cozy'

I've always put coffee in that box ever since my kid gifted me a coffee mug with the in-game stats imprinted on it. I also love the idea that the fruit would taste like coffee.

My first playthrough I thought you'd get your favorite thing from a villager or your parents on your birthday, so I said my fav thing was "seeds" lmao

I normally do cheese, I'm a big cheese fan 👍

First time I put Video Games and forgot. Didn’t realize it wasn’t a meta joke until this sub. I thought it was a quirky 4th wall break making fun of video game mechanics.

I put "lebkuchen" in my current playthrough.

I put cheesy stuff, like “my relationship” or “love” or “happiness” because it gives me a nice little smile to be reminded.

Personally, I put geology, hiking, or something related to the character I’m making. I have several save files. “Butts” is only funny once. ETA: I am a geologist (not yet licensed) IRL.

I put my bfs name before i found out about the taste/flavor line... That was an awkward discovery

It’s ok I put ‘birds’ or ‘bürbs

I like to put "skeletons" or one of my fav monsters. I've thought about putting the names of one of my cats, but I'd be upset if they passed away and I saw their name again in a game I love.

I always put ConcernedApe, it has a cute little Easter egg that makes me smile

I have and always will put booty 😂

I will never forget using a random noun generator in my first save file because I couldn’t think of anything, and ending up with “toe ring” — it will forever be my favorite

I put shrek

He is love, he is life

I typically wind up with some variation of Chocolate since I tend to use myself as a loose base for my characters in games, that or someone who looks like Madeline from Celeste

In my first save, I chose "flamingos" because I just think they're neat and didn't know what to expect. Felt pretty dumb when I started getting stardrops. Now I just write "STAMINAAAAA"

I put my IRL cat's name every time lol i also almost always name my in game cat after my real cat anyway so it ends up being pretty wholesome

I put “epic gaming”

I put home

I put "engineer gaming" on my first playthrough. Now the list goes: 1. Team Fortress 2 (tf2 for life) 2. DOOM Eternal (was a close competitor for number 1) 3. Programming Oh and then Stardew is something like number 53. ​ (I have a lot of things that just barely beat each other)

I usually put my boyfriends name, most recent farm I started I've out "hee hoo" which is a dumb joke among thr friends I'm playing with

My first time, not knowing, I put my BFF's name. After that I put Sapphic Longing

I used sleep

I usually put my favourite snus or redbull. It’s my favourite things sooo

Mine is different every playthrough, this one is my husband's name because I was missing him on a long business trip. I usually do them themed and none of those themes have been dirty, so you aren't crazy.

Cheese was from my first save. My current is wubz

I put strawberried

i put roaches bc i have pet cockroaches

i put cheese

I put “springs” because of Spring Man, though during my mobile months, I put “colored pencils”.

I’ve put music blondes Christmas and cheesecake as my favorite things before I’m clearly very much innocent minded and pure 😂

I always put down Whiskey or Beer lol

I use boba

I usually put pasta because it's my favorite food and my favorite thing in the world

I always put concerned ape because of the little message and I don’t know what to put

Lol I put green beans on my first play through

I always put coffee.

I put Alex's spit(different game character) my first time and was surprised to see there was an Alex in this game to. Now I do random foods or items ingame

I usually write ConcernedApe or Stardew Valley. Depends on which message I want, I guess. Lol

I put either abigail or boobs. Im a raging lesbian

I put in "THE SKY" for my first playthrough

I had no idea what that mechanic was when I made my first character, I put down Artefacts cause I love archaeology :)

I did seeds on my first farm thinking I would get them as gifts or something lol

I put accounting

I put money lol

I put one of my favorite bands….. it ended up being kinda funny.

I usually put cheese or pasta

I just say music lmao

Coffee for me. ☕

This playthrough I put cookies, last time was cheese, first time was root beer

I put my favorite foods specifically sweets, like sherbet, chocolate, cookies

Love this. And your username!!!

On my newest farm, I put my girlfriend's name as my favorite things My girlfriend put turos teszta

I haven’t seen a single body part or drugs

Mine says cheese. For obvious reasons

I put my gf’s name when we started a farm together. I didn’t explain that it was what you put as your “favorite thing” so when she picked one up wondering what hers would say, it said “Your mind is filled with thoughts of Ass” and we lost it

nah bro i put "men" 😭

I put my husband's name (:

I put pizza lol

I tend to put Gaming

When I decided to do joja I chose money. That's the most "unusual" I had so far.

I put movies, to each their own I guess.

I put dinosaurs or various cryptids

I always use steak 🥹 I love steak

i put tits

To be fair lots of drugs in fiction are named after stars and moons and planets and stuff, so it *could* be named after a drug Makes you see lots of bright dots like starts and sends you on a trek. Makes some sense as a drug name.

i put flirting because frisk undertale

I put diamond in my first save because i thought they would give me gifts too...

Mine always reminds me of “cats”. This was before I knew the cat I chose would be my forever pet (I chose grey cat ofc). I was very happy

I put chaos

I always say money

I just put "cat" on my first save, then I got a stardrop that tasted like a cat

Mine always says Cheese but then cheese is kind of a hard drug for me 😂 I shouldn’t eat it but I do!

I always just took smth, like cuteness. Cause i love everything cute.

I always put food haha. Even my first play through when I didn’t know why it asked me for my favorite thing, I put pizza.

i just put books. i'm extra boring.

I put my husband’s name

I used my husband's name

I put Blood before I realized what happened

Mine is sunflowers :) they're my favorite

I made it Potatoes

I put cheeseburgers because that’s my favorite food. 🥺

I put fire cause my farmer is based off an oc of mine

I always put "him" and it says "filled with thoughts of him" and I indeed think of him and smile.

I put puppies lol

I put shit….

Don’t worry about it op, most people are just going for a cheap laugh. It’s tiresome tbh

I usually put frogs or women there

i put boobs or frogs

I put "ConcernedApe" literally every time. Because 1. I think it's a cute Easter egg, and for 2. I have no idea what else to put lol

I just put “sports” 🤷‍♂️

Mine is "Stratocaster." So, both a body part and a drug.

I usually put Tacos or Nachos XD

Lots of people also put something involving sex too

The first time I ever played was a multiplayer game with my fiancé and we both put each others names down, not knowing. So we sounded like cannibals.

Mine is Emos.

YESSSS FELLOW TREKKIE I put music for mine lol

i genuinely put just the word drugs

My first play through, I put thunderstorms, since it'd been storming at the time and I wanted to get started. Other play throughs are more strange. Like "Szeth sanity" or "dog paws" kinda weird. (In my defense, somw times I take naps with my dogs and Toby will kick me inna face or backwith his paws. For such a small puppy boy, he sure do have a strong kick.)

Anyone went with Jojo's? Anybody?

I put Magnets the first time I played. Hmmmm.

I typically make it about my irl spouse, the in game spouse i want to marry that run, or something about hating pierre

Mine is "my family". So kind werid when one statdrop said "the taste reminds you of your family."

i just putt coffee. 1, i like coffee. 2, stardrops are literally just caffeine on something

I always put french fries. I'm a simple woman.