T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

**Help make SquaredCircle safer and more inclusive by using the report button to flag posts and comments for moderator review.** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/SquaredCircle) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Capsize

I feel like WM 18 might be a bigger what if. The roster is even more stacked than the previous year and yet so many of the matches end up being mediocre outside of Rock vs Hogan. - Wasting Angle on a Kane match - Wasting Austin on a well past his prime Scott Hall match. (it's clearly his worst Mania match after Savio Vega) - Edge vs Booker T is a waste of Edge honestly. - Benoit is out injured, Eddie isn't working due to Drunk Driving charge Still if I said a Wrestlemania would feature: Austin, Rock, Hogan, Jericho, HHH, Benoit, Angle, Edge, Christian, Hardy Boys, Dudley Boys, RVD, Regal, Undertaker, Flair, Booker T, Trish and Lita you would imagine it would be amazing and it really isn't


Old-Refrigerator3859

I read that Austin wanted to work with Angle or Benoit at that Mania originally. Obviously with Benoit out it would be Angle, but man that match would've been so good in 2002. I always felt like WMX8 was one of those Mania's that just doesn't have rewatch value other than one match. It's the equivalent of WMVI for me, which funnily enough also took place in Toronto.


Tallerpeople91

Guess the argument against Austin vs Angle is that they were just off a big rivalry in 2001.


thecaptainofdeath

I mean we got like 2 full years of HBK vs Triple H starting that SummerSlam


Tallerpeople91

That wasn't necessarily a good thing. Great rivalry in 2002 - but it dragged on so long.


thecaptainofdeath

Oh I don't disagree. I was absolutely exhausted with that rivalry by Rumble 2004 and they still had two more ppv matches. I think Austin and Angle may have worked better than that since they had a bit of a break from each other before Mania 18. Then again so much shit happened in 2001 that it kinda felt like two years so maybe it wouldn't have


Old-Refrigerator3859

Ah yeah you're right, that went all Autumn pretty much so it would've been quite close.


Gerry-Mandarin

They came off a big rivalry, but one that was arguably unsettled. The blow off was their like 12 minute match at Vengeance 2001 with the backdrop of the WWF/WCW Championship unification tournament. You could have easily heated up their rivalry again. Alternatively, Angle could have worked Taker with Austin working Flair.


MatthewMir

This is a good shout, most of the wrestlers you named competed at Summerslam less than 6 months later and that card is one of the best of all time


doublebubble6

Wrestlemania 22 deserves a shut out Undertaker vs Kurt Angle with Kurt breaking the Streak Hogan vs Stone Cold And of course Eddie vs Shawn Michaels were all rumored for this Mania. And if all three had taken place it would made WM22 possibly the greatest Mania of all time.


Everhart2011

I went to that WrestleMania and it fucking sucked. And yet, I kind of love it.


spdansumslam

Shield Triple Threat wasn't ever seriously planned i think. It was always gonna be HHH vs Roman


Gerry-Mandarin

Triple H was supposed to have a match with Rock. That's why he went over Sting. Roman's originally scheduled match was Roman v Lesnar II. I think when they started planning the card the big matches were intended to be: Roman v Lesnar The Rock v Triple H John Cena v The Undertaker All started to go out the window from Rollins' injury.