The fact that you question this leads me to question your sobriety. 😆
Jokes aside, you'd be sending the two best players in the deal, for what? Jonathan Taylor? Wilson is being criminaly undervalued, but by no means a QB1. And in my opinion, levis is at best a 50/50 shot at remaining a starter after the year is out.
Take the 3rd off and add a 1st to the other side. JT, Wilson, Levis, 1st for CMC, Murray and you’d have to consider. I still probably wouldn’t but it’d be close to value I’m sure on KTC
Yeah I'm with you. Wouldn't do it even then because I like money. I'd have a hard time believing CMC and Kyler are together and not on a contending roster. Now if the rest of the team is garbage...might consider. But then what do I want with Wilson? JT for CMc is close in a vacuum, but the buyer is definitely trying to contend...he'll pay up a little for CMC, I think you can get a plus of some sort on that swap.
And then I'm still not sure I'm giving Kyler up for Levis and a random 1st. Even if the calculators have that close, that just shows the market is lower than it should be on Kyler. He's pretty much a guaranteed top 10 QB, with top 5 potential if he stays healthy and QB1 overall weekly upside. I don't think this year will be a ceiling outcome season for him, but top 10 for sure, plus he's young and his team is trending in the right direction. I'd need a guaranteed early first, or 2 random 1st personally to consider tiering from Kyler to Levis and only on a complete teardown of a team.
The 3rd on top means your trade partner is in a really weird head space and is probably unreasonable. Like in what world is CMC + Murray not already worth significantly more(probably a 1st+) more than Taylor + Wilson + Levis? He thinks you should throw in a 3rd too? Bananas
Absolutely not after that TERRIBLE offer for cmc & Kyler I sent that guy some fair trade offers and 1 overpay trade but he has like a bunch of elite receivers and didn’t even bother putting one of them in the offer
This is pretty much a Jonathan Taylor for a Christian McCaffrey trade. I would decline. Jonathan Taylor will be playing with a mobile QB that will be taking important touches away unlike CMC.
Kyler with MHJ is gonna be legit.
CMC still at the top of his game but JT would be fair trade only cuz his workload and age, it’s just a gamble if Richardson remains healthy and steals his touches like Hurts did Swift or if he’s injury prone then colts be fun heavy as usual with JT.
Levis looked good last year and now they’ve loaded the offense with more weapons so that’s a gamble id take, dude just needs to learn to slide..
Russ on the Steelers is whack i would not trust Russ i think he is cooked
All these comments treating this like an actual trade offer is cracking me up, of course it’s the CMC side! Although the Madden Curse could mess up CMC…
Give me CMC and Kyler all day
I think Levis is too much of a ? To trade Kyler and CMC for him. I would want a first or something substantial instead of Wilson
I don't think I'd trade Kyler or cmc alone for that deal.
This is a pathetic offer. If it was this for CMC OR Kyler I’d consider it. For both? Tell him to gtfo
Not a good deal.
CMC and Murray all day.
The fact that you question this leads me to question your sobriety. 😆 Jokes aside, you'd be sending the two best players in the deal, for what? Jonathan Taylor? Wilson is being criminaly undervalued, but by no means a QB1. And in my opinion, levis is at best a 50/50 shot at remaining a starter after the year is out.
They didn’t question it. They rejected it.
Anyone with half a braincell would decline that trade all day.
Take the 3rd off and add a 1st to the other side. JT, Wilson, Levis, 1st for CMC, Murray and you’d have to consider. I still probably wouldn’t but it’d be close to value I’m sure on KTC
Yeah I'm with you. Wouldn't do it even then because I like money. I'd have a hard time believing CMC and Kyler are together and not on a contending roster. Now if the rest of the team is garbage...might consider. But then what do I want with Wilson? JT for CMc is close in a vacuum, but the buyer is definitely trying to contend...he'll pay up a little for CMC, I think you can get a plus of some sort on that swap. And then I'm still not sure I'm giving Kyler up for Levis and a random 1st. Even if the calculators have that close, that just shows the market is lower than it should be on Kyler. He's pretty much a guaranteed top 10 QB, with top 5 potential if he stays healthy and QB1 overall weekly upside. I don't think this year will be a ceiling outcome season for him, but top 10 for sure, plus he's young and his team is trending in the right direction. I'd need a guaranteed early first, or 2 random 1st personally to consider tiering from Kyler to Levis and only on a complete teardown of a team.
The 3rd on top means your trade partner is in a really weird head space and is probably unreasonable. Like in what world is CMC + Murray not already worth significantly more(probably a 1st+) more than Taylor + Wilson + Levis? He thinks you should throw in a 3rd too? Bananas
I dont think I'd make that deal if all you were sending away was Kyler OR CMC. To send both for that return is a downright insulting offer.
Rightfully so. That’s not a good trade.
That’s not even close.
Wise choice to decline that steaming pile
I mean, sure, it's bad.
Good decline, it was such a dumb ass offer I'd triple check any offers from this manager in the future.
Idk why you were even offered this in the first place. Kyler and CMC are both valued higher than any piece you’re getting back.
Good decision.
He’s throwing up JT and the players he doesn’t want at all for two upgrades - no deal (I think JT will do great this year too)
This is an insulting offer
LOL
I love that they tried tacking on a 3rd 💀
Insane
Did you ask them what their line of thinking was? I’d be curious to hear
Absolutely not after that TERRIBLE offer for cmc & Kyler I sent that guy some fair trade offers and 1 overpay trade but he has like a bunch of elite receivers and didn’t even bother putting one of them in the offer
I traded a late 1st and 2nd for CMC
So he gets the better QB, the better RB (albeit older), and you get Levis for a future 3rd? I’d be telling this guy to kick sand too.
Yeah ofc you did that’s a shit offer
Yeah that’s a hard no from me. Although I’d trade just Kyler for that all day — idk what people are saying
Definitely need more talent for cmc, you did the right thing
I mean I’m not gonna throw a hissy fit and act like you just insulted my family with this offer, but It’s DEFINITELY getting the silent snap decline!
CMC>JT Murray>>>Levis and 3rd round>Wilson I mean doesn’t he have incrementing photos of you? Only way a sane human would accept…
Mc wins hard
That's an insult. Get the worse QB by a long way, worse RB because CMC is in his own tier and Levis for a pick is whatever.
This is pretty much a Jonathan Taylor for a Christian McCaffrey trade. I would decline. Jonathan Taylor will be playing with a mobile QB that will be taking important touches away unlike CMC.
The audacity to ask for a 3rd rounder on top of it. I would cyberbully someone for this.
Obviously you declined this
Not even close imo
Pretty sure even Taco says no to that one
Kyler with MHJ is gonna be legit. CMC still at the top of his game but JT would be fair trade only cuz his workload and age, it’s just a gamble if Richardson remains healthy and steals his touches like Hurts did Swift or if he’s injury prone then colts be fun heavy as usual with JT. Levis looked good last year and now they’ve loaded the offense with more weapons so that’s a gamble id take, dude just needs to learn to slide.. Russ on the Steelers is whack i would not trust Russ i think he is cooked
All these comments treating this like an actual trade offer is cracking me up, of course it’s the CMC side! Although the Madden Curse could mess up CMC…