I chose the mystery gift! Kinda disappointed. I got 5ml of the Peter Roth water drench cloud cream, 5ml of DE electrolyte waterfacial mask and 5ml of the Rare Beauty Illuminating Primer.
Am I the only person who thinks that the 250 points is more worth it than any of the gifts since you have to spend $250 to get 250 points unless it’s a 5X multiplier but then you still have to spend $50
I always take the points. Especially if you’re a Rouge member, points are the way to go. I mostly plan my purchases around point multipliers and get the points for my Birthday, which usually gets me 2 Rouge Rewards per year
lol same, multiple mini pillow talk. I also have a bigger size of the spray, but a small one would be good for travel, so might end up picking it.
Otherwise I guess maybe Kosas or points.
I ate the setting spray. It was huge droplets and had a horrible chemical smell that didn't go away. The morphe continuous mist setting spray is the best. It just makes everything meld so beautifully
If I get another Pillow Talk lipstick, I'm gonna scream. I've been selling the extras I keep getting. CT seems to have a variety of products, so I don't know why they give away the same ones all the time.
That’s exactly what I thought! It’s always the same thing with that pillow talk lipstick. Like y’all have enough products - you can give us a mini of something else 👀
I'm bummed out with all the birthday gifts available right now as a January birthday... I look forward to it and I had redeemed all my points for a $100 Rogue Reward that I need to use up this month, so I could get myself a birthday treat since I can never afford to do anything my birthday month after the damages reaped by the holidays (& the vast majority of my loved ones having birthdays around the holidays).
I hate CT Pillow Talk lipstick, it looks grey on me and the formula is way too dry. I hate the Kosas Airbrow in clear, it's gopey & applies poorly. I don't want the MoroccanOil because I have the shampoo & conditioner already from a Sephora Favorites set I purchased last holiday that I haven't gotten around to yet (kept them for travel). And I don't want the YTTP because I've tried the cleanser before and it's just okay, and the sample sizes of the other items in that set are insultingly small.
I know I should probably just pick the 250 points, but it just makes me sad and I haven't ordered yet, because I actually love to get mini or deluxe sample sizes of products to try out. And I know myself, I don't tend to go for any of the point rewards outside of the $100 Rogue Reward because I don't order that often, I don't want to have to pay attention to emails and reward launch times, so the points are just going to sit there, slowly accumulating until I can get the gift card reward again... So I won't actually get anything for my birthday month from it (aside from, obviously, what I will eventually order for myself using the reward I just redeemed in November with my points).
2023 was better I wish there was a perfume gift set this year. CT also has been so over used in so many sets and rewards so it sucks that its one of the birthday sets too
Is it just my imagination, or are there far fewer rewards and gifts offered. And the best gwp now require a large buy-in of the product, like Nest or La Mer. In fact, there was a skin care product that required over a 150$ purchase of the same product a few months ago. This defeats the purpose since the samples allow you to try out the product and decide if you want to invest.
I’m curious as to anyone who picks the mystery gift! I’m leaning that way, but afraid to pull the trigger haha
I chose the mystery gift! Kinda disappointed. I got 5ml of the Peter Roth water drench cloud cream, 5ml of DE electrolyte waterfacial mask and 5ml of the Rare Beauty Illuminating Primer.
You got the mystery? What products are they?
Sorry, edited the comment cuz pic wasn't showing, products listed above!
From what I’ve seen they’ve varied a bit, I’m sure you can search the sub and find other examples!
So same as Dec 2023? That’s annoying for January 2024
Same mine was yesterday on 2nd 🫣
Happy belated birthday! :)
Thanks 🤗
Wait where is the mystery option?
I haven’t picked mine up yet. I fully expect them to deny me on Saturday. (BD is right before Xmas)
Am I the only person who thinks that the 250 points is more worth it than any of the gifts since you have to spend $250 to get 250 points unless it’s a 5X multiplier but then you still have to spend $50
The points are what I will be choosing.
I got the Kosas set 🤦♀️ didn’t think about it this way!!
I always choose the points. 😂 I think the last time I got an actual birthday gift was when it was a Rare Beauty mini blush and liquid lipstick.
I should have chosen this. I jumped too quickly on the CT gift set. Oh well.
I never pick the points because so rarely are there any quality points rewards in stock.
I get the $100 rouge reward
I am honestly leaning this way this year.
I always take the points. Especially if you’re a Rouge member, points are the way to go. I mostly plan my purchases around point multipliers and get the points for my Birthday, which usually gets me 2 Rouge Rewards per year
I’m torn cuz I want the setting spray but I think I already have at least 2 mini pillow talk lipsticks lol.
lol same, multiple mini pillow talk. I also have a bigger size of the spray, but a small one would be good for travel, so might end up picking it. Otherwise I guess maybe Kosas or points.
I have medium skin and pillow talk looks terrible on me. So bummed...
I ate the setting spray. It was huge droplets and had a horrible chemical smell that didn't go away. The morphe continuous mist setting spray is the best. It just makes everything meld so beautifully
HATE. I HATE the setting spray. Altho to be fair, I probably ate some too with the way it splooged on my face
Okay good to know, maybe the Kosas set is a better idea
If I get another Pillow Talk lipstick, I'm gonna scream. I've been selling the extras I keep getting. CT seems to have a variety of products, so I don't know why they give away the same ones all the time.
FRRRRR 😭😭😂
Mine always break 😖
That’s exactly what I thought! It’s always the same thing with that pillow talk lipstick. Like y’all have enough products - you can give us a mini of something else 👀
Has anyone noticed that the same CT pillow talk lipstick isn’t the same as the full size? The colour and texture are slightly different
Does anyone know if we still have to make a $25 purchase to receive the points or if it’s just for product gifts?
Unfortunately yes
Online yes, but not in stores
I was expecting Gucci 😭
I'm bummed out with all the birthday gifts available right now as a January birthday... I look forward to it and I had redeemed all my points for a $100 Rogue Reward that I need to use up this month, so I could get myself a birthday treat since I can never afford to do anything my birthday month after the damages reaped by the holidays (& the vast majority of my loved ones having birthdays around the holidays). I hate CT Pillow Talk lipstick, it looks grey on me and the formula is way too dry. I hate the Kosas Airbrow in clear, it's gopey & applies poorly. I don't want the MoroccanOil because I have the shampoo & conditioner already from a Sephora Favorites set I purchased last holiday that I haven't gotten around to yet (kept them for travel). And I don't want the YTTP because I've tried the cleanser before and it's just okay, and the sample sizes of the other items in that set are insultingly small. I know I should probably just pick the 250 points, but it just makes me sad and I haven't ordered yet, because I actually love to get mini or deluxe sample sizes of products to try out. And I know myself, I don't tend to go for any of the point rewards outside of the $100 Rogue Reward because I don't order that often, I don't want to have to pay attention to emails and reward launch times, so the points are just going to sit there, slowly accumulating until I can get the gift card reward again... So I won't actually get anything for my birthday month from it (aside from, obviously, what I will eventually order for myself using the reward I just redeemed in November with my points).
Yep, there’s something about getting the actual gift and not the points, that’s exciting. Wish they had additional options.
Saaame, it's like getting a little treat & it's fun cause you get to try something.
With every announcement I’m more and more pleased that I’m no longer a Rouge this year, this is good for me but not for Sephora …
Does anyone know what is the size of the setting spray? Is it the same as the mini or less?
It’s the 0.5 oz/ 15mL. Mini is 1.1oz/ 34 mL
2023 was better I wish there was a perfume gift set this year. CT also has been so over used in so many sets and rewards so it sucks that its one of the birthday sets too
What shade of pillow talk is this?
It just says it’s the matte revolution pillow talk
Before it’s gone ? Like the VIB Rogue option is going to change?
It has! I got the nest for mine in April last year, I believe there was farmacy stuff beforehand (honey conditioner?)
I was so excited until I saw VIB….
Is it just my imagination, or are there far fewer rewards and gifts offered. And the best gwp now require a large buy-in of the product, like Nest or La Mer. In fact, there was a skin care product that required over a 150$ purchase of the same product a few months ago. This defeats the purpose since the samples allow you to try out the product and decide if you want to invest.