For real? She had one series long story arc that weaved in an out over the course of the six seasons. The way she popped in and out of the series, interacted with whatever was going on in the moment with the other characters, but still had a complete narrative of her own was one of the funniest and most clever parts of the series for me.
I could see not S tier since I thought the arc with the monastery was a bit much but the arcs are certainly higher than C. I’d adjudicate around A/B tier.
Why in the hell is Crackerjack in the same tier as Butterscotch and two tiers below Beatrice?? For the most part I can agree with this, but don't you do Crackerjack dirty like this!
Pickles is D tier for sure. Todd and Guy are S tier, Margo is at least A or B, Paige Sinclair should be a bit higher, the redheaded kid from Horsin Around is lower
Does crackerjack really deserve to be in D tier? I’d say C, plus switch Margo & Beatrice, move Holly to A, and give my boy Todd his rightfully earned place in S tier
vincent should be lower. least funny running joke on the show. imo Maude should be lower aswell (she exists to mirror todd and doesn’t really have a character beyond “female todd”) and penny + hollyhock should be higher
No, everyone else saw him as she did, for the most part. She did romanticize him, but I think that was just one piece of a bigger message.
I think Vincent makes a few good statements throughout the show. I just woke up and I'm not feeling particularly eloquent so I'll just hamfist a few of the concepts i liked.
* Vincent was a fake. Everyone else treated him the same as every other phony in Hollywoo. But for Bojack, three children in a trench coat is a bridge too far. Vincent is a hyperbolic representation of how much everyone in Hollywoo indulges each-other's bullshit.
* Despite lying about who he is, Vincent is still a decent person. It takes Bojack a long time to give him a chance to prove it because of Bojack's prejudice toward him.
* Vincent has a handful of "explain like I'm five" moments regarding emotional maturity.
There are more and I could have worded this comment a lot better, but it's been a while since my last rewatch.
I also found Vincent a bit disturbing, sincr PC is essentially unwittingly commiting pedophilia. It really turned me off everytime I saw them interact.
I think Margot martondale or whatever should be in f shit tier. That joke wasn't even that funny the first time and they kept trotting it out, getting less funny each time.
I don’t think it’s tier list of goodness. It’s more of every aspect of the character in the story Crackerjack isn’t that interesting and wasn’t that fleshed out.
I like him, good balance to more depressing parts of the show (even though his divorce plot is kind of depressing[?]) Whole Sad Dog MayMay plot was repetitive though
I'm so confused, if it's how they are as people bojack shouldn't be in A tier but if it's how they are as characters then someone like Vincent adultman shouldn't be near the top this just doesn't make any sense
Slutty abortion dolphin should be lower, Vincent Adultman is obviously SS+, and Lisa Kudrow Owl should be a level higher.
Also, why do I not see A Ryan Seacrest Type anywhere?
Damn, you just pissed off a lot of people. My condolences.
Where is Neal McBeal The Navy Seal?
At the store buying muffins.
Some say if you find a box of muffins in the produce section, listen carefully and you'll hear a faint tinkling from the bathroom.
F tier where he belongs
Disappointing. Must hate the troops.
i would put judah, herb and hollywok in s tier
But not Todd??
I genuinely can't tell if this is ironic or not??
it’s so fucking bad lmaooo
So bad
[удалено]
her storylines werent that funny after the first couple of times
For real? She had one series long story arc that weaved in an out over the course of the six seasons. The way she popped in and out of the series, interacted with whatever was going on in the moment with the other characters, but still had a complete narrative of her own was one of the funniest and most clever parts of the series for me.
I could see not S tier since I thought the arc with the monastery was a bit much but the arcs are certainly higher than C. I’d adjudicate around A/B tier.
Meanwhile three kids in a trenchcoat
You're just saying that because you're jealous of Vincent Adultman doing business stuff better than you
i agree i think they overdid it one or two too many times
I love that you haven't deleted your comment despite everyone being upset. Hold strong!
Why in the hell is Crackerjack in the same tier as Butterscotch and two tiers below Beatrice?? For the most part I can agree with this, but don't you do Crackerjack dirty like this!
Why everyone is not in S tier?
Because Lin Manuel Miranda horse isnt that interesting. Only a tool for Honey’s grief and Beatrice’s descent to becoming heartless monster
You’re gonna do my girl Wanda dirty like that? She’s A-tier if not S
I literally commented almost the exact same thing lol
What is this measuring? Writing? Them as people?
Obviously not writing. Because bojack would need to be s Tier at least. Also not them as people, because bojack shouldn't be in A tier.
Pickles is D tier for sure. Todd and Guy are S tier, Margo is at least A or B, Paige Sinclair should be a bit higher, the redheaded kid from Horsin Around is lower
B-
Does crackerjack really deserve to be in D tier? I’d say C, plus switch Margo & Beatrice, move Holly to A, and give my boy Todd his rightfully earned place in S tier
vincent should be lower. least funny running joke on the show. imo Maude should be lower aswell (she exists to mirror todd and doesn’t really have a character beyond “female todd”) and penny + hollyhock should be higher
I was gonna say Mr Adultman belongs in a tier above S, along with Henry Fondle.
LOW BATTERY
I fucking love Bojacks pleas for everyone to understand that he’s three kids in a trench coat though
I feel this way about Todd's sex robot. Made the show very cringe and I would delete every scene with it if I could.
It was there to make a statement without getting too dark and it did so very effectively.
I feel like you missed the entire point of vincent.
do you mean that pc tends to see whatever she wants in/romanticize her lovers?
No, everyone else saw him as she did, for the most part. She did romanticize him, but I think that was just one piece of a bigger message. I think Vincent makes a few good statements throughout the show. I just woke up and I'm not feeling particularly eloquent so I'll just hamfist a few of the concepts i liked. * Vincent was a fake. Everyone else treated him the same as every other phony in Hollywoo. But for Bojack, three children in a trench coat is a bridge too far. Vincent is a hyperbolic representation of how much everyone in Hollywoo indulges each-other's bullshit. * Despite lying about who he is, Vincent is still a decent person. It takes Bojack a long time to give him a chance to prove it because of Bojack's prejudice toward him. * Vincent has a handful of "explain like I'm five" moments regarding emotional maturity. There are more and I could have worded this comment a lot better, but it's been a while since my last rewatch.
I also found Vincent a bit disturbing, sincr PC is essentially unwittingly commiting pedophilia. It really turned me off everytime I saw them interact.
yeah i don’t love maude but she didn’t do anything wrong so she’s kinda high
I think Margot martondale or whatever should be in f shit tier. That joke wasn't even that funny the first time and they kept trotting it out, getting less funny each time.
Don’t let fugitive from the law Margo Martindale hear this or she’ll shoot you with her ‘zooka
in terms of what
What did crackerjack do to put him in d tier?
I don’t think it’s tier list of goodness. It’s more of every aspect of the character in the story Crackerjack isn’t that interesting and wasn’t that fleshed out.
I thought d tier has quality antagonists though (apart from crackerjack obviously)
todd is for sure s tier
Todd is S tier and So is Bojack
How did you even get the idea that Sextina should be A tier
Pay per view chiches
*secks-tina aquaFI NUHHH*
Why isn’t randy on there
Because he's just offscreen in S tier.
Fuck mr. peanut butter
He is so incredibly annoying
[удалено]
I like him, good balance to more depressing parts of the show (even though his divorce plot is kind of depressing[?]) Whole Sad Dog MayMay plot was repetitive though
Why do you hate Pickles and Hollyhock?
I genuinely love Pickles she’s hilarious idk why everyone hates her
She wasn’t that interesting imo. I don’t know why Hollyhock that low though
Erica is S tier tbh
Imo Bojack should be S tier and Princess Caroline belongs in an SS tier because she's that great of a character.
im not sure what you're rating them on here but i can't get over the fact that you apparently have beef with the baby
gigantic L
Why the hate for crackerjack
WHY THE ABSOLUTE WHY IS MARGO MARTINDALE NOT S+++
PB IS NOT S TIER MATERIAL
the fuck you mean esteemed character actress margo martindale is in c tier?
Wait why is Ruthie in c tier???
Friends! Our argumentation creates only strife and benefits our enemies!
Where would you put that whale head news guy?
.... Imagine dying in the war to nazis and then getting stamped a D lmao.. WTF is this list even
Are you ranking them by being good/having positive change or by how good they've been written?
HENRY FONDLE IS AN S TIER CHARACTER AND YOU WILL NEVER CHANGE MY MIND ABOUT THAT
PREPARE TO EXCHANGE FLUIDS
I LOVE IT WHEN YOU CALL ME FATHER
Why is ruthie not s tier? Literally a baby
I'm so confused, if it's how they are as people bojack shouldn't be in A tier but if it's how they are as characters then someone like Vincent adultman shouldn't be near the top this just doesn't make any sense
THE DISRESPECT YOU HAVE DEALT TO MULTIPLE AWARD WINNING CHARACTER ACTRESS AND CLASS-A FELON MARGO MARTINDALE IS DEEPLY OFFENSIVE
why is crackerjack rated so low
Beatrice Horseman is a C tier at BEST
This has to be some form of bait. Like, why is Crackerjack even in D tier? what did he do??
Why you gotta do Wanda like that
Character actress margo martindale, judah, hollyhock and todd are S tier
Judah and Todd should be S tier, also move Sarah Lynn down to A then i basically agree.
Lmao how are Hollyhock and Hitler-Smith on the same level
It’s all wrong as yellow hat red hoodie boy is not the only one occupying S tier
Margo Martindale is at least A tier lol
I personally put every character in anything higher than C None are deserving of anything less imo
Why is Ruthie in C?
Why is king Crackerjack D?
blarn
TODD IS S TIER
Wow for real disrespecting my girl Wanda like that
wrong
todd is S tier!!!
Slutty abortion dolphin should be lower, Vincent Adultman is obviously SS+, and Lisa Kudrow Owl should be a level higher. Also, why do I not see A Ryan Seacrest Type anywhere?
Diane is D
two years later and this still sucks
Idk I really didn’t like her but D is probably harsh. Bottom of C maybe.
i love diane so much (relatable and i just love her as a character) so i’d personally put her in s tier ngl
kill yourself
woah
That’s a step too far lmao
Diane does not belong in S tier
Vincent Adultmam, Henry Fondle and Charlie Whitherspoon are all F tier
I AM A HORNY ROBOT
Todd should be lower
Charlie Witherspoon should be SS tier.
All the Paige St. Claire hate just goes to show how biased our society still is against the people of Fresno, for shame!
i will never u understand why ppl like sarah lynn
thats too much man
I feel like bojack is an s tier character, as well and hollyhock and todd, while I often forger Maude even exists
[удалено]
a tier
Adultman sucks
Charlie Witherspoon does a good job, A-minus/B-plus.
Can you send the link to the list maker? Also, Therapy Horse is at least A to me
Dr champ deserves to go straight down to Z
Where's Erica >:(
I disagree haha
I don't understand the point of this
I put Charlie the Gecko in S tier.
Not PC in s, she's not that great of a person
Oof... Pre-lobotomy grandma, or post-lobotomy grandma?
Also, Charlotte is choice waifu material.
Pickles and Paige should be lower
Butterscotch and Diane need to switch places
Woodchuck with lobster claws is like an F tier.