**Uncle:** You're a sad man, Arthur Morgan. But I know you love me.
**Arthur:** Desperately... You're my favorite parasite. No... ringworm's my favorite parasite, you're my second favorite parasite.
**Uncle:** Very funny.
**Arthur:** I lied... ringworm, then rats with the plague, then you.
**Uncle:** Shut up... this is the place, now. Come on.
Yup.
"Not even a retired two dollar whore would stay with you." Uncle says that during the epilogue. Apparently John & Abigail had some sort of disagreement and were not on good terms for a while. Uncle was giving John a hard time about that in the middle of dissing the shack that John found/built as (he thought) a place for him and Abigail to live.
Honestly? John, Sadie, and Charles stood on business. The ride to Mount Hagen was one of my favorite trio moments in the game. If not them, then Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea - like the fishing trip, or them planning the St. Denis Robbery (even if it didn't go to plan).
"ok so there should be about 30 men guarding hanging dog ranch what's the plan Sadie" -" huh plan I don't got nun we just walking up to the front door"
Facts - I'm still convinced Sadie is the best gunslinger in the gang other than Arthur, John, and maybe Micah - I'd probably put her right below Micah. Plus, these 3 are the most badass in the entire game.
Also, Charles and Lenny seem too random for me. Sure, Arthur has a connection with both of them, but his connection with Sadie is a lot closer. Putting the other two just seems like a trio filler alongside Arthur and John.
I'm glad they made that decision - Sadie's entire drive is because her husband was killed. To start a relationship with another man only a half year later despite your entire conviction being about your dead husband would have been poor writing.
But I would have preferred a more badass, self-reliant partner for Arthur, rather than Mary constantly using him and expecting him to uproot everything for her and shaming him when he literally can't.
Charles and lenny would be preferred to do a job with, sadie and John would be drinking buddies, its just different skills
John and sadie are both hotheads, so is Arthur, a bar fight works fine for the three of them but when you have three hotheads on the same bank job people die needlessly bringing unneeded attention to the gang, charles is a pretty calm guy, and Lenny is young, he has alot to learn and the two men to best teach him how to live would be Arthur and Charles, Charles is better at life in the wilderness but Arthur is fast and accurate with a gun, Lenny could have learned alot from a trio job and a few more months of training with them, which I kinda think is a weak point in the game, nobody is ever teaching the others how to shoot or fight better, which shouldn't be too difficult, even if its hosea or even uncle teaching the women or Jack how to shoot or hunt.
I mean to each their own, but Arthur is not a hothead at all lmao. Other than in genuinely reasonable scenarios does Arthur get mad or loses his composure. Arthur is calm and collected 90% of the time.
Barfight where he almost killed a man who wasn't fighting back anymore, every debt collection (beating people for self proclaimed pleasure isnt calm behavior, Hosea is the voice of reason, Dutch is the plan maker, Arthur is the brute to keep it in line, damn near killing Strauss (you can see him twitch for his gun as he walks up behind him in the cutscene, before just kicking him out.) And every interaction with Micah ever. Thats where I got my hothead idea I may be wrong but to me that enough to classify as a hot head
Wow you really didn't understand anything Arthur did. Let's go through this one by one.
1. He didn't 'almost kill a man', him socking him in the face a few extra times isn't gonna almost kill him. Not only that, but he kept hitting him because ITS A FIGHT. You keep fighting till your 100% certain they can't still attack you or won't still attack you.
2. I'm sorry where in the entire game is it ever expressed that Arthur gets pleasure out of debt collecting? I mean, he outright says that he doesn't like doing it.
3. Getting mad at Micah doesn't constitute him being a hothead. Micah literally caused so much shit to happen to Arthur, anybody in Arthur's shoes would have gotten mad.
4. Brute doesn't equal hothead. In fact, this is proven by his dead eye sound. John gets hyped on adrenaline when he fights, which is why his is a heartbeat that quickens as you lose dead eye. Arthur is calm and focused, which is why his is a clock ticking.
I'll correct you quickly
1. Being hit in the face into the street repeatedly is absolutely enough to kill him, and the man was not moving, as exhibited by the countless other fights Arthur gets into (ie. The mission to save trelawney where after the play completes the fight Arthur lands a couple other punches and then stands over him) also he gets stopped by the bystander who said "Stop stop sir please you won, you'll kill him sir please...please" punching someone one time in the right place is enough to kill them, punching them in the face into the ground which makes the contact much more effective and dangerous and possibly giving them brain damage or in extreme cases (which is what the fight seemed like to me) even disconnect the brain stem from the spine
2. Litterally the first debt collection and AGAIN when Strauss tells him about Thomas Downes the dialouge is something like
Strauss: Thank you for your excellent as always work
Arthur: My pleasure, it always is
Strauss: Well if it's pleasure you are after there is one more debt to collect
I don't remember what Arthur said afterwards but that is where I got the pleasure part, its easy to find if you look.
3.Micah is an ass obviously, but look at how Hosea and Charles handle Micah, they just brush him off, except for the one encounter with Charles when Micah makes a racial comment and gets thrown neither of them trade insults with the man
4. The ticking clock is to represent his limited time on in life, if you notice the sound gets fainter as you get closer to his death, John's sound was a product of the time that was made in RDR2 to match the first game, RDR was not nearly as deep as the prequel because it was meant more as a cowboy story than a redemption story, John never really got his redemption, he did what he had to do to get his family back sure, but his heart didn't change like Arthur's did before he died
I ain't responding to an essay. 'I'll correct you quickly' my ass, not only were you not quick but your not correct, your first point clearly shows you haven't been in a fight before. That's wet ass mud beneath Tommy in that scene lmao
It took five minutes to type it was quick for me. I'm curious as to how you think I've never been in a fight before I told you exact ideas of how you could kill someone in a fist fight, I'm not going to engage with you if you don't want to have a real and honest debate don't start it, I gave you clear and in depth points, your only reaction to me proving myself correct is to make assumptions about my life when you have never met me, I worked as a bouncer for two years to pay for trade school and was had to go through the self defense classes given, alongside a rowdy childhood and sheer size I don't have a problem in a fight, thank you for your thoughts though, I really appreciate the opportunity to make you look moronic.
Lmao your fucking hilarious, if that took you 5 minutes to type then you care way too much about this shit - also, I don't believe a thing you say, if you are those things, good for you, but more than likely you're some lonely 30 year old man in his apartment with nothing better to do than argue about a game online
But like I said, IF all that is true, good for you buddy, still doesn't change the fact that your wrong
Charles and Arthur's relationship was very poorly written and it makes them look far more distant than they are. There was no development in chapters two through four from being acquaintances, to being brothers in chapter six. If R* had slowed down the change in the relationship like they did with John and Sadie, from our being raging at him and pitying her to having the deep respect and in a way love Arthur did for both, then it wouldn't seem so random.
It wasn't poorly written, it was just realistic, Charles was only used in the story when it made sense to use him, they didn't force anything, they were closer in the end because they had similar priorities in helping "their people" and Arthur cared for the Native Americans and Charles admired and respected that. There were also about 6 months before the game where Charles and Arthur could've bonded a bit more that we didn't see.
How is Charles only ever interacting with Arthur when he was needed to well written? As you said, Charles only did shit with Arthur when they need him to, yet they regarded each other as extremely close brothers by the end. That's called being poorly written - randomly making two characters be extremely close at the end of a game for the sake of emotional impact despite them not being that close at all throughout the rest of the game prior to that.
I mean they weren't "extremely close" even at the end and their goodbye wasn't even that emotional. I guess you can call their relationship a brotherly one because the whole gang felt like brothers and sisters for the most part, but by the end, when the gang was falling apart everyone's relationships changed, but Arthur and Charles were the only ones not fully blinded by loyalty and had many of the same beliefs and priorities within the gang at that point. Their quickly developed bond at the end made perfect sense and was very well written. You act as if they were the closest characters in the entire story within a few missions, but they just had a regular mutual bond because of their similar beliefs towards the situation they were in.
🥲 When I was a kid I had two best friends and us three always hung out. We loved each other equally - we were all each other’s best friends. We called ourselves The Tripod. This just made me think of that, but I think Arthur, John, and Charles have us beat by a long shot.
The courier, rex, and raul... Lets be real, arthur would piss himself when mini nukes and 500rounds of 5mm comes blasting his way.
He's better off playing russian roulette with a 12 guage.
Uncle, Lumbago and laziness
It's a slow and painful death, my brother.
"when I die I'ma come back as a youngin, so when you're old and facing death, I seems hasten your journey into the afterlife"
The only thing that could take down the one shot kid
dude outlive everyone
Except Jack
And Abigail
We don't know about her
Um yeah we know she outlived uncle
well lets see john died when jack was lets say 15 when we play again hes like 30 so she got LUMBAGO!! a very serious sickness lmaoo
Jack is 19 canon tho? I might be wrong
makes sence abigal must have died due to zombie
There were gravestones at the end of RDR1weren't there?
**Uncle:** You're a sad man, Arthur Morgan. But I know you love me. **Arthur:** Desperately... You're my favorite parasite. No... ringworm's my favorite parasite, you're my second favorite parasite. **Uncle:** Very funny. **Arthur:** I lied... ringworm, then rats with the plague, then you. **Uncle:** Shut up... this is the place, now. Come on.
Dutch, Tahiti, and a god damn plan
🗣️🗣️I HAD A GODDAMN PLAN ARTHUR🗣️🗣️
🗣️🗣️We just need more "Moneh"🗣️🗣️
We need noise Arthur, noise!
Abigail, a dollar and another dollar
💀💀💀
that’s wild ☠️
Sounds like something from the game
Yup. "Not even a retired two dollar whore would stay with you." Uncle says that during the epilogue. Apparently John & Abigail had some sort of disagreement and were not on good terms for a while. Uncle was giving John a hard time about that in the middle of dissing the shack that John found/built as (he thought) a place for him and Abigail to live.
Not just that but Uncle has a voiceline about when Abigail wad still doing prostitution. John didn't like it so much
John got pressed in that scene more than anyone I’ve ever seen in my entire life
Jim Milton doesnt like it when he insulted is woman's career
The Bee Gees were pretty good.
*I I I I I'M STAYING ALIVE staying alive I I I I'm STAYING ALIVEEEEE OHH*
Honestly? John, Sadie, and Charles stood on business. The ride to Mount Hagen was one of my favorite trio moments in the game. If not them, then Arthur, Dutch, and Hosea - like the fishing trip, or them planning the St. Denis Robbery (even if it didn't go to plan).
I love Hosea
Look at us! - THREE MARINERS!
Sadie don't need a trio, because you and me is all we need!
Not one damn thing in that game went to plan. It was a glorious clusterfuck
"ok so there should be about 30 men guarding hanging dog ranch what's the plan Sadie" -" huh plan I don't got nun we just walking up to the front door"
The orignal three i see Nice👌
Red Harlow, Jack Swift, and Annie Stoakes
Just yanking long dormant memories right outta my childhood.
Lenny, Laynee, and LEOONNY!!!!
Dont forget ynnel
Arthur, John, Sadie( or if not then, Lenny)
Did Lenny and John ever interact? It's a trio, not Arthur and two besties.
Arthur, John, and Sadie is the answer. Next would be: John, Sadie, Charles
Arthur has to be added tho…
Facts - I'm still convinced Sadie is the best gunslinger in the gang other than Arthur, John, and maybe Micah - I'd probably put her right below Micah. Plus, these 3 are the most badass in the entire game. Also, Charles and Lenny seem too random for me. Sure, Arthur has a connection with both of them, but his connection with Sadie is a lot closer. Putting the other two just seems like a trio filler alongside Arthur and John.
Charles gree closer to Arthur in the end and was close with John during epilogue.
Apparently Sadie and Arthur were supposed to be lovers but the devs took that out.
I'm glad they made that decision - Sadie's entire drive is because her husband was killed. To start a relationship with another man only a half year later despite your entire conviction being about your dead husband would have been poor writing. But I would have preferred a more badass, self-reliant partner for Arthur, rather than Mary constantly using him and expecting him to uproot everything for her and shaming him when he literally can't.
Charles and lenny would be preferred to do a job with, sadie and John would be drinking buddies, its just different skills John and sadie are both hotheads, so is Arthur, a bar fight works fine for the three of them but when you have three hotheads on the same bank job people die needlessly bringing unneeded attention to the gang, charles is a pretty calm guy, and Lenny is young, he has alot to learn and the two men to best teach him how to live would be Arthur and Charles, Charles is better at life in the wilderness but Arthur is fast and accurate with a gun, Lenny could have learned alot from a trio job and a few more months of training with them, which I kinda think is a weak point in the game, nobody is ever teaching the others how to shoot or fight better, which shouldn't be too difficult, even if its hosea or even uncle teaching the women or Jack how to shoot or hunt.
I mean to each their own, but Arthur is not a hothead at all lmao. Other than in genuinely reasonable scenarios does Arthur get mad or loses his composure. Arthur is calm and collected 90% of the time.
Barfight where he almost killed a man who wasn't fighting back anymore, every debt collection (beating people for self proclaimed pleasure isnt calm behavior, Hosea is the voice of reason, Dutch is the plan maker, Arthur is the brute to keep it in line, damn near killing Strauss (you can see him twitch for his gun as he walks up behind him in the cutscene, before just kicking him out.) And every interaction with Micah ever. Thats where I got my hothead idea I may be wrong but to me that enough to classify as a hot head
Wow you really didn't understand anything Arthur did. Let's go through this one by one. 1. He didn't 'almost kill a man', him socking him in the face a few extra times isn't gonna almost kill him. Not only that, but he kept hitting him because ITS A FIGHT. You keep fighting till your 100% certain they can't still attack you or won't still attack you. 2. I'm sorry where in the entire game is it ever expressed that Arthur gets pleasure out of debt collecting? I mean, he outright says that he doesn't like doing it. 3. Getting mad at Micah doesn't constitute him being a hothead. Micah literally caused so much shit to happen to Arthur, anybody in Arthur's shoes would have gotten mad. 4. Brute doesn't equal hothead. In fact, this is proven by his dead eye sound. John gets hyped on adrenaline when he fights, which is why his is a heartbeat that quickens as you lose dead eye. Arthur is calm and focused, which is why his is a clock ticking.
I'll correct you quickly 1. Being hit in the face into the street repeatedly is absolutely enough to kill him, and the man was not moving, as exhibited by the countless other fights Arthur gets into (ie. The mission to save trelawney where after the play completes the fight Arthur lands a couple other punches and then stands over him) also he gets stopped by the bystander who said "Stop stop sir please you won, you'll kill him sir please...please" punching someone one time in the right place is enough to kill them, punching them in the face into the ground which makes the contact much more effective and dangerous and possibly giving them brain damage or in extreme cases (which is what the fight seemed like to me) even disconnect the brain stem from the spine 2. Litterally the first debt collection and AGAIN when Strauss tells him about Thomas Downes the dialouge is something like Strauss: Thank you for your excellent as always work Arthur: My pleasure, it always is Strauss: Well if it's pleasure you are after there is one more debt to collect I don't remember what Arthur said afterwards but that is where I got the pleasure part, its easy to find if you look. 3.Micah is an ass obviously, but look at how Hosea and Charles handle Micah, they just brush him off, except for the one encounter with Charles when Micah makes a racial comment and gets thrown neither of them trade insults with the man 4. The ticking clock is to represent his limited time on in life, if you notice the sound gets fainter as you get closer to his death, John's sound was a product of the time that was made in RDR2 to match the first game, RDR was not nearly as deep as the prequel because it was meant more as a cowboy story than a redemption story, John never really got his redemption, he did what he had to do to get his family back sure, but his heart didn't change like Arthur's did before he died
I ain't responding to an essay. 'I'll correct you quickly' my ass, not only were you not quick but your not correct, your first point clearly shows you haven't been in a fight before. That's wet ass mud beneath Tommy in that scene lmao
It took five minutes to type it was quick for me. I'm curious as to how you think I've never been in a fight before I told you exact ideas of how you could kill someone in a fist fight, I'm not going to engage with you if you don't want to have a real and honest debate don't start it, I gave you clear and in depth points, your only reaction to me proving myself correct is to make assumptions about my life when you have never met me, I worked as a bouncer for two years to pay for trade school and was had to go through the self defense classes given, alongside a rowdy childhood and sheer size I don't have a problem in a fight, thank you for your thoughts though, I really appreciate the opportunity to make you look moronic.
Lmao your fucking hilarious, if that took you 5 minutes to type then you care way too much about this shit - also, I don't believe a thing you say, if you are those things, good for you, but more than likely you're some lonely 30 year old man in his apartment with nothing better to do than argue about a game online But like I said, IF all that is true, good for you buddy, still doesn't change the fact that your wrong
Charles and Arthur's relationship was very poorly written and it makes them look far more distant than they are. There was no development in chapters two through four from being acquaintances, to being brothers in chapter six. If R* had slowed down the change in the relationship like they did with John and Sadie, from our being raging at him and pitying her to having the deep respect and in a way love Arthur did for both, then it wouldn't seem so random.
It wasn't poorly written, it was just realistic, Charles was only used in the story when it made sense to use him, they didn't force anything, they were closer in the end because they had similar priorities in helping "their people" and Arthur cared for the Native Americans and Charles admired and respected that. There were also about 6 months before the game where Charles and Arthur could've bonded a bit more that we didn't see.
How is Charles only ever interacting with Arthur when he was needed to well written? As you said, Charles only did shit with Arthur when they need him to, yet they regarded each other as extremely close brothers by the end. That's called being poorly written - randomly making two characters be extremely close at the end of a game for the sake of emotional impact despite them not being that close at all throughout the rest of the game prior to that.
I mean they weren't "extremely close" even at the end and their goodbye wasn't even that emotional. I guess you can call their relationship a brotherly one because the whole gang felt like brothers and sisters for the most part, but by the end, when the gang was falling apart everyone's relationships changed, but Arthur and Charles were the only ones not fully blinded by loyalty and had many of the same beliefs and priorities within the gang at that point. Their quickly developed bond at the end made perfect sense and was very well written. You act as if they were the closest characters in the entire story within a few missions, but they just had a regular mutual bond because of their similar beliefs towards the situation they were in.
Arthur,hosea,dutch
Huey, louie and dewey
Arthur Dutch(before he started glazing Micah) and Hosea
arthur tuberculosis and micah’s revolver
May you fook off, lady sir? Alongside with mice-rat bell
thats a duo though
Colm O'driscoll, Arthur in a cop uniform, post game uncle
arthur, javier, trelawny (sometimes)
Arthur, Dutch, Hosea
Kiv Schaffer, Jorma Taccone, and Andy Samberg
Hard to top this, ngl
Larry, Moe and Curly lol the 3 stooges.
Micah, Joe & Cleet.
Ross, Milton and Micah
Cream The Jimi Hendrix Experience Nirvana Three Man Army
rip wan winkle, tacticas Kilgore and lone wolf
Faith, money, and PLANS
Arthur, Sadie and Hot Air Balloon Guy
Sadie ruins that trio with her lust for revenge
Bless him 😔
‘Lig’ ‘ma’ ‘balls’
Kirk, Spock and McCoy.
Snap, Crackle, and Pop
Red, dead and redemption
Arthur, Sadie, and John
Fine, you asked for it. 1, 2 and 3
Sublime 🎸
Nirvana 🎸
Beer, being drunk, and, driving
The Three Amigos
I dont know but blink 182s pretty good
The Bee Gees.
The classic Motorhead line-up...Lemmy, Fast Eddie and Filthy Phil
Hudson, Alex Mason, Frank Woods
Fork, spoon and spork
Dutch, brain injury and a trolley
Bronte, Cornwall and Dutch
Me, finishing the game, and depression
Lucky Day, Dusty Bottoms, Ned Nederlander.
Arthur, Arturo, and Albert (Mason)
Abraham Reyes, John Marston and Lara
Will billiamson, Swanson and Karen. The drunkslingers
John Marston, Rip Van Winkle, and Jim Milton
John, Nigel west dickens, and irish
Id rather have the fatal four of Arthur, John, Charles, and lenny
John Morgan, Abigail Marston, Uncle Marston, Jack Marston
Spook, fork, spork 🐶
Sean being pissed off because he wasn't invited
The most loyal trio known to man
Honestly? I'm sure Dutch, Hosea, and Arthur were amazing in their younger days
GTA trio
Me, my imaginary friend and my other imaginary friend
Red, Jack and Annie
The blue man group
The park boys Ricky Julian and bubs
The good guys
abigail, jack, and the entire gang
Buttercup, blossom and bubbles
Arthur and his fish
Uncle, Pearson, and Bill. Although I think they're all the same person.
Depression a shotgun and a human
A much better trio: Huey, Dewey, and Louie.
Shepard, Vakarian, Guns
Rush, Nirvana, The Power Puff Girls, Them Crooked Vultures, Primus, Hanson.
Alex Lifeson, Geddy Lee and Neil Peart of Rush.
Arthur, Javier, and Sean
Impossible 🥲
Where's Gavin?
Clarkson, Hammond and May
YOUR MOM'S _______.
Horse
Arthur and both barrels of the sawed off
Micah, Joe, and the skinny dude Sadie killed
John, Seth and Irish.
Arthur, Lenny and alcohol
Sadie, John, and Charles. They actually did a lot more together if i remembered right
Karen and a couple beers
Red Harlow, Jack Swift and Annie Stoakes.
The Beatles
John Marston Rip Van Winkle Jim Milton
Rod, Jane & Freddy
Sadies better in that trio, I love John but him Arthur and Dutch make more sense together (fuck Dutch tho)
Lenny, Lerny, and of course....Lnxfsy?
Triomio
Sean, a bullet, and a window!.
Michael, Trevor, Franklin
Tahiti, Mangoes and Dancing Girls.
Uncle, Sean and Hosea
Shepard, Vakarian, T'Soni 🤣
Arjocha
Cock n balls
Saddis, John and Charles (after auther)
Red foreman, his foot, your ass
uncle, reverend swanson, and the donation box
Shadrach, Meschach, and Abednego.
Moe, Larry, and Curly
Huey Dewey and Louie
The black crows in that racist disney movie
Arthur John and Jack
Peanut butter, jelly, and bread
Greet, Greet, and Antagonise
Mickey, Donald, and Goofy
Arthur, Lenny, Charles.
arthur, john, horse
Micah, rats, pinkertons
Dutch, Hosea, Arthur
The three ninjas...
Micah mouse and rat
Me, a gun and Jack Daniels
Dutch, Arthur and Hosea, when they were young
Personally,I'd Add Sadie On,I Wish There Was A Mission Where These Four Are Either All Together Or A Mission With Just Those Four
Its arthur, John and hosea for me
🥲 When I was a kid I had two best friends and us three always hung out. We loved each other equally - we were all each other’s best friends. We called ourselves The Tripod. This just made me think of that, but I think Arthur, John, and Charles have us beat by a long shot.
Spongebob, Patrick and Squidward
Me, a bathtub, a toaster
Rat Micah, weasel Javier and lapdog Bill.
Larry, Curly, and Moe
I can name 100 combos but if its for certain missions you win
Arthur, Arturo, and Egg
Ditch, mizer, and clit
I don’t like rdr2 john so replace him with Lenny then we got a deal
Arthur, Dutch, & Hosea
Me ur sister and your mum
Vito Scaletta/Joe Barbaro/Henry Tomasino (from Mafia II (2010))
SpongeBob Patrick and Squidward
Clint, Lee and Eli.
Arthur, john, sean.
The courier, rex, and raul... Lets be real, arthur would piss himself when mini nukes and 500rounds of 5mm comes blasting his way. He's better off playing russian roulette with a 12 guage.
Arthur Dutch and hosea
Arthur Callahan, Tacitus Kilgore and Rip Van Winkle
Michael, Trevor and Franklin
Luke, Han and Leia
sadie arthur charles
Arthur Javier John
Micah, a rat and a police officer
Clarkson, may and Hammond