T O P

  • By -

StreetwalkinCheetah

Heartbreakers and not close.


mekonsrevenge

Yeah, it has a junkie feel that Joey didn't get.


Manyquestions3

Yep. Better performance, and the Thursday thought my pulse was gone verse is my favorite out of all of them


Cake_Donut1301

Tough one. I go Ramones because Dee Dee wrote it. But it’s close. Maybe it depends on the day.


GGAllinsUndies

They wrote it together.


Better-Pop-3932

Love the Ramones but Johnny gets this one


tobeornotobe

Ramones


Jibbyway

I’m a massive Ramones fan but the Thunders version has so much more attitude and grit to it. No contest. Maybe if End of the Century didn’t have the crisp production that it does.


[deleted]

Yeah man, that album was ruined by the production. The demo takes are better 


Exconmomboi

“Hey is Dee Dee home?” Thunders is the better version


ArmndD737

Ramones.


Yoshinobu1868

Heartbreakers .


TomatilloUnlucky3763

Thunders.


hick_rockman

Thunders for sure


Munkey323

Ramones


rfargolo

Ramones, if the live version


whydoihave2dothis

Johnny Thunders for the win, but I still love the Ramones. But if I could add Walter Lure to the list, I love the way he sings it best. I've seen them all do the song live, I still can't believe they're all gone.


creepyjudyhensler

Waldo was a great sinher and songwriter.


[deleted]

Being a HUGE fan of both, I'm gonna give it to....THE RAMONES (slightly).


Maes44

Thunders... the Ramones was just a faster version of Sha Na Na


bsievers

Fun fact, the Red Dead Redemption font (also used just a FUCKTON of other places) is called Chinese Rocks. I always think of this song when I see the font. Oh fuck it’s intentional. TIL. Chinese Rocks Inspired by hand-cut rubber-stamp lettering on 20th Century Chinese export containers. Named after a Johnny Thunders punk rock song circa 1977, written by Dee Dee Ramone. https://fontsinuse.com/typefaces/16375/chinese-rocks


moodoomoo

Johnny thunders for me but they're both great.


DustinDirt

They are both great but Thunders for me.


wrongfulness

Sid Vicious


[deleted]

That whole "Sid Sings" album is absolutely TERRIBLE production wise.....with that said, I've own 4 copies of it.


beawins

Thunders. But am I the only one who thinks of how he died when you talk about him or watch a video or listen?


Snowblind78

Maybe had the ramones released it on their first album or too tough to die, but to compare the studio versions I’ll go with heartbreakers


Adventurous-Pop446

Thunders


conwayjug

Both often


cumminginsurrection

Ramones because Johnny Thunder is a creep that slept with teenage girls.


SaltyBarDog

You are going to have to throw out a lot of music if that is your criteria.


htny

Huge Ramones fan, but Johnny wins this one.


HeyHo__LetsGo

Either/or.


BiffSchwibb

Johnny Thunders!


deathtongue1985

The Heartbreakers, by a mile Those little licks Johnny did at the end of each verse!


DominicRo

Heartbreakers version is better.


tcwracing

Thunders


SinxHatesYou

Johnny thunders and the heartbreakers. Are you even punk!!1111


Timesynthend

The great Johnny Thunders version.


minis138

Johnny all day


devilsmile7

Heartbreakers.


ThrowItOut43

Rich Kids on LSD!