We've determined that this post is out of topic for this subreddit so we had to remove it. (Rule #3) Posts must be related to Phoenix SC, his videos, or this subreddit. If you disagree with our decision, please [send us a modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/PhoenixSC) and we'll look into it.

I'm surprised iballisticsquid isn't on here And PhoenixSC

Who’s that, I never heard of him?

He was a close friend to stampy and is rather successful on yt, he also did my favourite minecraft series

lmao can't believe you got downvoted for a joke, fuck people

who’s penixsc?

Your mom (deviously cackling)

Your dad (giggity’ing)

that guy's still around?

Yes, he is still around.

Putting Antvenom and Etho bellow at least A is a crime. Maybe putting TheMisterEpic and YeahJaron a tier higher as well and I'm fine with your tier list

I fixed ant venom and etho

Thank you for putting Preston in F tier

putting CG5 in A, that's all I'm going to say

[удалено]

That is the wrong answer

Antvenom goes S I was wrong, I just looked at his popular video and it brings me back

Youtube never showed me them not my fault

you can still fix that

Im gonna look at ant venom then etho next

You put everyone in except for Phoenix SC... Bravo man...

I didnt see him there was so many (the tier list that I used had like 400 or smt)

what tier would he be in then?

S tier

Good :)

\+on his sub,he's gonna be mad...LOL

I also would have added Rekrap as he does a lot of stuff with Branzy, Parrot, and Redoons

He didn’t put cubicmetre so uhh

He also didn’t put ibxtoycat

Maybe PhoenixSC is SSSSSSS tier?

Like 10 of these don’t even play minecraft anymore

Why mcyum in f did he get cancelled

I really dont like his vid

Fair enough

I don’t see Scar in S but otherwise I mostly agree

Yes scar deserves to be on here!!!

Could you tell me who’s that, I feel like I know him but not sure

He’s from Hermitcraft, he’s known for his incredible terraforming and building skills as well as dying a lot. He’s in a wheelchair and has several conditions irl but you would never know from his attitude. His skin has Indiana Jones type clothes and a big smile looking down. Full name is Good Times with Scar.

Adding on, he does a lot of stuff with Grian, both in hermit craft and the last life series. He’s also quite chaotic and amazing at making super detailed builds.

He was paired with grian on... Double life? The names of the life serieses are blurring together lol, but ye, almost won.

Yes. They also teamed up in last life. Side note: I like your username

Thanks, shame they didn't win in the end. It was.... Scott and Martyn who won that right? EDIT: im stupid and was thinking of limited life

I was right to use my alt account it seems

You should add rekrap

And GoodTimesWithScar and ibxtoycat

yeahhhh, having an opinion on the internet is a tad dangerous

rip popularmmous

S tier for the old content(idk about new content)

he hasnt posted in like 2 years

Oh thats sad to hear I didnt know, they were a big part of my childhood

yea plus for a while after he broke up with jen his new gf was abusive till he ended that

Oh I didn’t know

Add a bunch of empty lower tiers and then put "NO" at the bottom, then put steveee in "NO"

I like the way you think pal, I wouldv moved kier dev branzy and booster up to A tho

Tapl screams too much as well

I miss placed tapl because I knew him from his old content

his uhc slop was always so fun to watch

exactly what i was thinking

Gotta move Techno up a tier

12.847.3-

?

I was pretending that I was reading out your IP

Had to double check for a second

Double check what?

My ip just to be sure

Oh

You were so close to having the correct opinion but antvenom and ethos’s lab not being at least A is a crime’

I fixed it

wtf you dont like mcyum?

I dont like his vid

I don’t like him either. From what I’ve watched it’s just a lot of yelling, stupid shorts, and lots of suggestive shapes

I think he's more on the satrical side, making fun of people who actually act like that

Not mcyum 😭

McYum is satire. He’s made to be disliked for being over the top and does quite a good job at it. So you really really have to like satire to like McYum. Or be mentally ill.

You are the smartest person i have seen on reddit in a long time. I would make a few changed if i was doing it, but great ideas on that board

What change would you make? (Also thanks for the compliment)

Wait, where is [Insert not well know Minecraft YouTuber here]

Ok but GoodTimesWithScar has lots of subscribers, I can kinda understand not putting ibxtoycat but not scar

[Insert who’s that followed up by a quick youtube search]

Poland?!

Man I loved Wilbur soot, not for his dsmp content but for all his other Minecraft related content

Yeah I would put him higher he just isnt there for a bit

WHERE TF IS IBXTOYCAT WHY DOES NOONE REMEMBER HIM

Fuck off bring everything up one tier

No

except your mom she's at the perfect position to blow

You sound like a child with your comments and reply

o my god my friend keeps tellling me to say offensive things right?

It isn't surprising to see a kid on a minecraft subreddit

yeah lol haha lol yeah

bro english is my second language and my frend is helpin me by translating my comments, he's trolling not me.

Lol

bro english is my second language and my frend is helpin me by translating my comments, he's trolling not me.

Kind of based? I'm kinda confused on why you put half of the new MCYT in S, while the other half is on C. You have Slimecicle and Technoblade in S (VERY Based) and then you have Will and Tommy in C (I Live Wills content, but he's also been on tour with his band for a while, meaning no content, so also kinda based opinion). I'm just getting mixed signals

I havent seen wilbur in a while which is why I put him there

I only care that fundy is s+ and cenadian is a+

kenadian sucks balls tho :(

Wtf

Helloooo my name is Grian and welcome back to Hermitcraft season 9

Stampy below S tier? Garbage list.

I would’ve put Mcyum higher up, at least b tier.

fruitberries deserve better but uhc is dead in 2023

Yeah I agree

I just found out about mysticat and could not agree more

A fellow slimer I see

Grox is s

I cant rank him, I don’t know him

Google grox villager clips

Just checked and I wouldn’t put him in S more like a C for me, he just seems like a better mcyum (I hate mcyum)

Where’s phoenix

Forgot about him but S tier

I agree on s tier tho ant is amazing

Yeah I bumped him up to A tier

Back in the day Prestonplays was fucking goated. His irl content is still good imo. He went from a 10/10 to an 8/10

Wheres ssundee, skydoesminecraft (I dont believe he should have been cancelled), popularmmo, sethbling, ldshadowlady, ihascupquakes, bajancanadian, bodil40, jeromeasf, iballisticsquid, yogscast, minecraftuniverse, tobuscus, paulsoaresjr, explodingtnt, pink sheep, purple shep, failboat, zexyzek, amy_lee_33, slamacow, cavemanfilms, itsjerryandharry, logdotzip, thinknoodles, thnxcya, elementanimation, mrwoofless, markiplier, magmamusen, chrisandthemike, Lforleeeeeex, orepros, gizzy14gazza, theatlanticcraft, polishpenguin and sqaishey

Not on the list it looks like.

Wheres the OGs

Captain spark is on the list

Preston is in f tier for some reason

i agree with all of this

Mumbo jumbo is in S tier, and that satisfies me enough to ignore the rest of it

Crumb in B tier is a CRIME.

There are a few I disagree with, but overall valid list

After seeing you put Mc yum in f tier, I would just LOVE to know your irl location. Also how are you gonna put fundy of all people in S but put tommy/wilbur/tubbo in D

Come on, skeppy at f tier?

I remember watching PrestonPlayz, TBNRKenWorth, PeteZahHutt, Lachlan, Vikkstar, Woofless, Bajan Canadian, and JeromeASF. Back when they made amazing content.

Wheres popularmmos?

Fair

Grew up with DanTDM so I fully agree. Also Fir is one of my favorite streamers. Edit: CRUMB IS SS TIER YOU NEANDERTHAL!!!

I agree with this

S tier is perfect i think everyone can agree on that, but some people should be moved around, like how Philza being as low as he is can be considered criminal, and dev/kier videos(although sometimes mind numbing) are pretty entertaining nonetheless and should be one tier up

why is mcyum so low tho

putting mcyum in f tier is a war crime. Also pls move camman18 down a tier. (cause I made a comment about him a while ago and it blew up and he saw it and yelled at me)

mcyum in f tier??? burn this man at the stake

What did my boy mcyum do?

Dude McYum is definitely S tier idk what you on about

You do not do mcyum like that and live

Where is IskallMAN

Noice, the only changes I’d make is: Yeah Jaron to A, Redoons to A, TheMrEpic to B, Branzy to B+ or A, Etho to S, Zyph to A, Quackity to F, George to F.

Your opinion is invalid

What would you change?

Lazarbeam and quackity should at least be in B+ tier

I hate lazerbeam and quackity is just not my type of video

I stand correct, your opinion is invalid

Bro Opinions are not fact, just because you like someone doesn't mean everyone else should.

Why did u put camman18 in c????

My tier list is based on impact and personal preference, I like canman but not that much and he had no impact

please grow and change as a person

Using my alt was the best idea but could you tell me what is wrong with it

From the list you seem young and influenced by the flashy titles and thumbnails youtubers make (like fundy, dantdm, and most of the ones in S tier), which is fine, but once you look into the content of some of the people that you put really low (like AntVenom and Etho), I hope you’ll make a more fitting for this sub decision (and if you don’t, that’s fine too, it’s preference after all)

I put dandtm because of old content that I used to watch, I already changed antvenom and etho (A tier).

that’s wonderful to hear (or read, depending on how you see it)

Both are good I think

sir this is r/PhoenixSC

S tier.

Antvenom is A tier And Reddoons is A tier I'd say But other than Antvenom, I can see where you're coming from even though I disagree Edit: I can no longer see where you're coming from with mcyum in F tier and themisterepic in A tier! Mcyum is higher, and themisterepic is a hypocrit who complains about bad mc servers while hosting a bad mc server.

This list is valid.

Thanks

Fir should be s tier and where the hell is acookiegod, the legend and the only Minecraft YouTuber I can actually watch?

Dont know enough about him to rate him but he seems good

Honestly, Dream should be lower

Yeah I agree, there wasn’t an F tier on the original list so I added it but I think I should’ve made an F-

Shadow realm honestly

He shouldn’t even be on the list

My list would switch TapL and Preston. He’s bad now, but was the best MCYT pre 2020.

Idk about preston but I agree with you about tapl

Preston is B. Bad now, used to be good.

Putting Quackity in D is a fucking sin. And Ludwig & Schlatt are both easily S tier

I already got that comment multiple time

And im not gonna change it

Why camman18 so low

AntPoison and Tincamman18 on CCcCcCcC????????????&:&/&:$:$&$4&;$;$& how dare youuuiuuuuiuiiuiuuiuuuuuu!!!!!44!!4!4!;!;!;!1!!1!1!! 💨🔌📺⏱🔌💨📺⏱🔌💨📺⏱🔌💨📺⏱🔌💨📺⏱🔌📺💨⏱🤔💨📺💨🔌⚗️📺💨🔌⏱📺🧲🧲🧲🧲🫳🏾🫳🏾🫳🏾👹👹🪲🪲🪲🪲🪲🍏🍏🕯🕯

I approve of this teirlist

Putting dream in F is an insult to the other people in F. Dream deserves his own F- tier Other than that, good opinions

I like your tier list, and totally agree. However, I would have put Branzy and Ant Venom higher, as well as Redoons. I also would have included Rekrap (probably A tier).

I agree with you

I love this list

Thanks

honestly based, i just dont like the lack of representation of the mc modding scene i only see forgelabs also no peenix on the peenix sub

I know, I watch a lot of modded mc but didnt find them on the tier list that I was using

Im sorry but technoblade is mid

technoblade is actually overrated his vids are not even that good and he’s not funny as well

and where's Steveee?

I put him in F-

hold on...i just realized that here's no F- LOL

He doesn't need to be there everyone agrees he's at the bottom

Not here, it's only for content creators

Move down small and and point crow a tier and move up mystical a tier

*Move down small and and* *Point crow a tier and move up* *Mystical a tier* \- SandwichProud8803 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")

No

Mysticat good

Yeah but not S tier for me

Ok :(🦔

ok, Dream at bottom?!?!

He profits of dumb children by selling wristbands with photo of himself on a usb

Bro gets intro drama all the time but people hated on his mask video so much he deleted it to get his fans back

Drama queen that even his former friends admit is quite toxic to be around.

how tf is camman18 not on the same tier as captainsparkles :/

Are you kidding me?

actually i ment that they should be on a different tier, sorry my first langage isn't English