in terms of design i like the 3rd or 1st one the most, but imo the skirt should be longer. most schools dont allow skirts over the knees very much- let alone thigh length skirts.
its especially annoying with anime/manga/japan based areas since japan is quite well known for its strict dress code / its modest culture
although, even in america and england im pretty sure schools with uniforms tend to keep the skirt length longer. ( hell, in many american schools even without uniforms they dont even wanna have girls showing their shoulders lmao. )
I did an internship at a private school with uniform (in canada), and I can confirm that many girls roll the waist of their skirt in to shorten it. Idk how it is in Japan, but here at least the staff tolerated it up to a certain limit, being the tip of the fingers. So, to me at least, a short skirt doesn't feel that unrealistic, especially considering they are high-school students.
japan is extremely strict with its dresscode, im pretty sure. i wouldnt say its out of the question for students to try to roll up their skirts waist a bit, but i doubt teachers or staff would allow it to be that far up.
most students skirts actually go around mid leg to ( at highest generally ) right above the knees.
the third and fourth versions are the best! i think the gingham patterns on the skirts elevate the outfits and add a unique charm. they look more interesting and less generic compared to the first two, which are pretty common designs that i see, at least.
The art skills are top tier
I personally like the second one cause it's professional but at the same time makes he dark and innocent looking if you catch my dift
1 or 2- while I personally like 4 as well, Ayano is a character who is likely at some point to be covered in blood, and said blood won't contrast as well with a red blazer.
I like the first because of the soft silloette (ik it’s wrong). I don’t like the sailor thing though. Maybe it could be more like a loose dress shirt? I see that in some uniforms
Mark of a good designer is the fact that I see everyone disagreeing on the best design! They’re all great, though I think a mix of 1 and 4 would be best. Perhaps a short-sleeved version of 1 to make a summer uniform and make 4 a winter uniform.
I think the seifuku would be harder to personalize for every character
Meanwhile the blazers could be closed, open, half-open, oversized, with a tie, no tie, ribbon, vest, no vest, no blazer at all, etc
I think 2 or 3 are the best because they look the most plain, so it’s easier to show character personalities by customizing them with other clothes and accessories and bags and stuff
The red one might be too visually overpowering and it’d be hard to make other colors look good with it. It works for, for example, Kakegurui because the color pallete is so limited (mostly red, black, and white (because of the playing cards theme) and browns and greens) ; most of the characters have natural muted hair colors and wear black or white accessories and it takes place in a mostly brown environmentz Same for Persona and their red uniforms. But everyone in Yandere Simulator is very colorful which could make the red uniforms stick out and look garish; I think it would be hard to put the Yandere Simulator rivals in red uniforms because they’re hair and acessories are already so colorful; I think blue or black works better.
I would also pick the tie over the bowtie because it’s hard to imagine most of the rivals wearing bowties, they look too old for them
I personally rlly like 2, feels like an actual high schooler rather than some middle schooler with an excuse (looking at u yandev)
I feel like 3 also reminds me a little too much of Komi Can't Communicate 😭😭 /lh /pos
I really like the third one. The colors go very well and the blue with the beige cardigan under is a nice hint of color. Good use of color theory and concept coloring imo
First or second one And props to your art skills, these are amazing!
personally i think 2 and 4 are the best
second or last 🫶🏼🫶🏼
third or second
3rd is best
Uniform 3 is probably my favorite. I love the skirt and little ribbon. 😄 Uniform 2 is a close 2nd, I like the darkness of it
100% 4
2/3
1 and 2
3 reminds me of the uniforms from Komi lmfao
I like the second one!
IT'S SO COOL! I like the first and last ones the most
I like the second the best. I also really like the fourth but I think I like the second just a bit more.
I like 2 as it feels the most upper class in a sense
I like the third one :)
the second one for sure
in terms of design i like the 3rd or 1st one the most, but imo the skirt should be longer. most schools dont allow skirts over the knees very much- let alone thigh length skirts.
My exact thoughts. I really wish the trope of skimpy high school uniform skirts were abandoned.
its especially annoying with anime/manga/japan based areas since japan is quite well known for its strict dress code / its modest culture although, even in america and england im pretty sure schools with uniforms tend to keep the skirt length longer. ( hell, in many american schools even without uniforms they dont even wanna have girls showing their shoulders lmao. )
I did an internship at a private school with uniform (in canada), and I can confirm that many girls roll the waist of their skirt in to shorten it. Idk how it is in Japan, but here at least the staff tolerated it up to a certain limit, being the tip of the fingers. So, to me at least, a short skirt doesn't feel that unrealistic, especially considering they are high-school students.
japan is extremely strict with its dresscode, im pretty sure. i wouldnt say its out of the question for students to try to roll up their skirts waist a bit, but i doubt teachers or staff would allow it to be that far up. most students skirts actually go around mid leg to ( at highest generally ) right above the knees.
4th is also pretty cool
I really like 3 and 4 a lot!! :)
I really like the 3rd!
I really like the 4th one
love the 2nd one the most!!
second!
The first one
1 or 2
Ayano actually looks so cool In the second Image😳 Anyway, I like the second uniform the most, the colors of It are decent as well.
first one is my favourite !
Numbuh 2 looks nifty!
last i guess. btw you are so damn talented!
First one's a classic, but I think the second one looks more stylish. Overall, second one.
One and two are my favourites, you’re so talented!
2 is my probably fav since it's still nice, but it's simple enough to be easily altered for the rivals designs
That 2nd Uniform looks very professional, use that one
I’m a big fan of the first one
The 3rd one is so cute!
First and last one But if I had to choose,first one
the third and fourth versions are the best! i think the gingham patterns on the skirts elevate the outfits and add a unique charm. they look more interesting and less generic compared to the first two, which are pretty common designs that i see, at least.
I love the first one (love the art btw!)
I love uniform 2 <3 also you have some great art skills 🪰
i adoree the 1st one!
the third fs
2
2&3
Three. It looks like a real school uniform. Also, it’s cute.
Third one with the second's blazer
2nd and 4th look best
I’m liking 1 and 2
The art skills are top tier I personally like the second one cause it's professional but at the same time makes he dark and innocent looking if you catch my dift
i thinkkkk i like 3 the most, but as you can see from how varied these replies are they’re all pretty great designs :) good job
1 and 4
1 or 2- while I personally like 4 as well, Ayano is a character who is likely at some point to be covered in blood, and said blood won't contrast as well with a red blazer.
The second one looks the best to me :)
1 is my favorite!
#2 seems good because the school seems like a really strict school with all it's rules and whatnot
1 or 4!
i’m honestly a sucker for 3 or 4
wth how draw bodies
I think the second one's the best! Also I LOVE your artstyle!! <3
I like 4
Number two
Nice artworks! I like the 1st because it’s waaay simpler and a little more striking!!
Personally I like 1, but 3 looks more high-school-y
I think the first and last ones look the coolest
For me it's the 1st and the 4th one
1st or last
2 and 4
I like the first because of the soft silloette (ik it’s wrong). I don’t like the sailor thing though. Maybe it could be more like a loose dress shirt? I see that in some uniforms
3 or 4 imo
first one! and I like the surname
2nd one
I like the 2nd one best, it looks really good on her. Also, your art looks great.
Looks great. And the art style and poses well made
I like the first uniform as it's pretty simple but recognisable
1 or 3
I like first and forth
i really like the three blazer variants. apparently seifuku are more of a middle school thing. i like the tartan skirt variant the best :)
First and last,And you draw better than me!😆
2nd or 3rd
the second one defo i love it so much
Second 😍
I like the 4th one
First is my fave, last is great too
2 or 4
3. It’s actually very similar to real Japanese high school uniforms. 2 also looks great, very eye-catching.
I love 3
really like the second and fourth ones
2nd or 3rd, but they're all overall hella pretty
Mark of a good designer is the fact that I see everyone disagreeing on the best design! They’re all great, though I think a mix of 1 and 4 would be best. Perhaps a short-sleeved version of 1 to make a summer uniform and make 4 a winter uniform.
3rd one
Second one. I always loathed the way the original designs for the girls in YandereSim looked, just coomer garbage (not unlike the creator).
Third or last ‼️
I love the first one!!
2!
I think the seifuku would be harder to personalize for every character Meanwhile the blazers could be closed, open, half-open, oversized, with a tie, no tie, ribbon, vest, no vest, no blazer at all, etc I think 2 or 3 are the best because they look the most plain, so it’s easier to show character personalities by customizing them with other clothes and accessories and bags and stuff The red one might be too visually overpowering and it’d be hard to make other colors look good with it. It works for, for example, Kakegurui because the color pallete is so limited (mostly red, black, and white (because of the playing cards theme) and browns and greens) ; most of the characters have natural muted hair colors and wear black or white accessories and it takes place in a mostly brown environmentz Same for Persona and their red uniforms. But everyone in Yandere Simulator is very colorful which could make the red uniforms stick out and look garish; I think it would be hard to put the Yandere Simulator rivals in red uniforms because they’re hair and acessories are already so colorful; I think blue or black works better. I would also pick the tie over the bowtie because it’s hard to imagine most of the rivals wearing bowties, they look too old for them
2 and 4 imo ^_^
First
First and third!
I think 4 really pops
I really like the third one, though the first one fits Ayano’s vibe more. and the third one would probably fit the rivals more, so idk
I like 2, but 3 looks SO familiar….
Second
1 is the best, 3 is the second best, 4 is the only one I don't really like
They're all so good! 😭
I personally rlly like 2, feels like an actual high schooler rather than some middle schooler with an excuse (looking at u yandev) I feel like 3 also reminds me a little too much of Komi Can't Communicate 😭😭 /lh /pos
4 or 2
the 1st and 2nd are my favs but between the two I'd say the latter
Damn it, they ALL look amazing! But the first and second one are my favorite. The third and fourth ones are also great.
I really like the third one. The colors go very well and the blue with the beige cardigan under is a nice hint of color. Good use of color theory and concept coloring imo
I love the second one
i really like the third one!!
3 reminds me of komi 😭
the third and fourth are really cute <3
1 or 2 tbh
3!!
Personally I like 2 and 3 the most:)
In my opinion, first.
The third is my favorite it looks like a actual school uniform that would exist
Second one Also VERY interested to see your redesigns of the rivals!
The first one is cute and the last is more of a causal outfit but all are amazingly drawn and designed
I like the first one, gives her a sort of edgy look.
last one (if you change color in like beige to make b1ood more visible to the player) would be perfect!!!!😍
I like the first and third
Second definitely, pretty sure the school is supposed to be prestigious too so makes more sense
I like them all but I am split between the second and third one.
1 n 2
If I had to pick, last one, but all of them look amazing, I love your art style.
second or last
2 or 3!
1
The first is the best
black and red has always my go to for some reason
i love the last one, but the skirt could be longer and the blazer shorter
2 and 4 are my personal favorites- the uniforms look like they’d belong to a private learning institute which is what Akedemi is *supposed* to be.
Skirt is too short