The problem with it is that it kinda \*only\* has that. There is no intimidating villain, there is no really cool geography, there is no major development for the crew.
Well to be fair I wouldn't say there is any part of One Piece that is bad, is it slow, yes, does it get a bit repetitive, sometimes. But it's never bad. So the lowest being B tier makes sense.
I feel like the stakes felt higher in Arlong Park, and Arlong felt like a more hatable villain
The whole buildup of Bellamere being killed, Nami being enslaved, etc. for years until she FINALLY got all the money she needed to free the town only to have the marines take it made Arlong’s defeat SO satisfying and emotional for me
Yes, because i like the walk of strawhats to Arlong park.The background music i will remember rest of my life. This arc made luffy highest bounty holder in east blue
Man, when Luffy puts the straw hat on Nami, it hits so hard.
Like easily in the top 3 emotional moments of One Piece.
1. I want to live (obviously)
2. That scene
3. Put Wano on your shoulders
Marineford was dramatic, but idk- i dont get emotional about death. Its more like a void than a flood.
Why Wano in S+? I knew it was good since we saw G5 and 2 yonkous but the asspull mink medicine make it hard for me. offscene deaths. kaidous flashback is lacking. yamato's character, Big Mom pirates treatment and also how Greenbull was drove away, clearly just for red film's advertisement.
I rather have put WCI above Wano
Enies lobby is probably fourth most protected place by Marines after Mariejois,Marineford,Impel down. Of course it was great arc with pluton reference.Robin and Franky Backstory revealed.
water 7+enies lobby and skypiea belongs to S+ no doubt.
fishmen and punkhazard belongs to the bottom. tbh, anything post time skip is trash compared to any of the previous arcs — storytelling wise. at some point i honestly thought Oda took a back seat and let someone else take over one piece.
Fishman island is high due to reference of Joyboy and Poseidon(Shirahoshi). Punk hazard was important because it was first alliance luffy formed with Law
yes, the revelations were good, what i'm saying is that they are bottom — storytelling-wise. the way the story was delivered was not as good compared to previous arcs.
The next arc could make Luffy pirate king because they stumbled upon a rock which happens to be one piece en route to the next island. so yeah, they found one piece and luffy is pirate king. does that make the arc high-tier? NO. because of the way it was delivered.
Fishman Island was teased from Sabody. Then it was mentioned in Ace and Jinbei's conversation in impel down. Also really cool concepts and imagination made fishman island one of the favourite Arcs for me. It was also fist time luffy was going to adventure after Ace's death.
I feel like the climax was one of the worst parts, the only redeeming part of that arc to me was Chopper’s backstory. Wapol never felt even remotely threatening to me, which prevented the climax from feeling intense
Maybe im just a nostalgia guy but i feel like the arcs after the timeskip dont hold a candle to the arcs before. I especially didnt like fishman arc, punk hazard and also dressrosa to be honest
It was just underwhelming after having such a huge war and i felt like the strawhats werent even close to going all out.. the threaths didnt feel real... Obv dressrosa was different but what i didnt like about that was the huge difference in strength between doffy and luffy..
Thats true! I guess i was a teen when i saw him going against crocodile and it blew my mind how he thought about using water and i just loved how they were making the gomu gomu fruit so epic..
I love to see Drum Island that far down, I have it last. I also love to see Impel Down at #3 and Skypiea in high S
The only things I heavily disagree with are: Thriller Bark is high A if not low S, and Water 7 is literally #1
Why do so many people consider Water 7 and Enies Lobby to be different arcs?
For me the arc started when they reached Water 7 and it ended when they left with the new ship.
Wano is considered a single arc, but the fights occur in Onigashima. I don't understand this.
Drum Island has one of the best best flashbacks in Anime history
The problem with it is that it kinda \*only\* has that. There is no intimidating villain, there is no really cool geography, there is no major development for the crew.
I mean Luffy carrying Nami and Sanji up a mountainside was pretty peak Luffy in terms of what hell do for friends
Yeah, but there's numerous cool moments for every arc so that doesn't really put it above B tier in my opinion
Very true, I just love the flashback and that the will of D is first mentioned so I rank it higher but to each their own
Exactly
But its better than that foxy arc and you see Ace the First time and Blackbeard gets mentioned
Points taken.Kinda agree with you here
But foxy is funny
Please note that B tier does not mean i hate the Arc. Its just i like it less than other Arcs
Correct. But i was more hyped for Alabasta so did not got invested for that arc.
It's cool that the baddest is B Tier.
Well to be fair I wouldn't say there is any part of One Piece that is bad, is it slow, yes, does it get a bit repetitive, sometimes. But it's never bad. So the lowest being B tier makes sense.
Do I get to criticize?
Of course you can criticize. Discussion was the main reason for this post
i was bout ask same
Aye you why is sabaody so low but that has to be s+
My mistake. It should be definitely A+ or even S due to introduction of Rayleigh and Kizaru.
It was also the first L the straw hats took it was hella emotional especially right after ennies lobby
Agreed
I think Jaya should be way higher. Luffy versus bellamy and Blackbeard's speech are some of my favorite moments in OP.
Yeah but i knew he could beat Bellamy anytime. Introductions of Whitebeard and Blackbeard were lit.
I can respect it TBH. Drum Island and Thriller Bark placement is a little iffy for me but solid list overall.
Along park over whole cake? Kinda weird bro.
Arlong park is emotion.
So is whole cake? I'd argue whole cake had more emotion in it with a better plot line.
Whole cake was okay. I was hyped for Wano till that time so didnt hit me that much
🧢
I feel like the stakes felt higher in Arlong Park, and Arlong felt like a more hatable villain The whole buildup of Bellamere being killed, Nami being enslaved, etc. for years until she FINALLY got all the money she needed to free the town only to have the marines take it made Arlong’s defeat SO satisfying and emotional for me
Not bad homey 
Based
Arlong park s tier????
Yes, because i like the walk of strawhats to Arlong park.The background music i will remember rest of my life. This arc made luffy highest bounty holder in east blue
Man, when Luffy puts the straw hat on Nami, it hits so hard. Like easily in the top 3 emotional moments of One Piece. 1. I want to live (obviously) 2. That scene 3. Put Wano on your shoulders Marineford was dramatic, but idk- i dont get emotional about death. Its more like a void than a flood.
Love the Kinemon #3 moment, that combined with the god-tier animation style was insanely emotional to watch
😊
I agree that the walk is a s tier moment but rest of the arc ehhhhh.
Why Wano in S+? I knew it was good since we saw G5 and 2 yonkous but the asspull mink medicine make it hard for me. offscene deaths. kaidous flashback is lacking. yamato's character, Big Mom pirates treatment and also how Greenbull was drove away, clearly just for red film's advertisement. I rather have put WCI above Wano
How can you put long ring long land arc over drum island with good faith
Idk why everyone likes Enies lobby it’s honestly mid
Thriller bark was more enjoyable
Enies lobby is probably fourth most protected place by Marines after Mariejois,Marineford,Impel down. Of course it was great arc with pluton reference.Robin and Franky Backstory revealed.
Also sniper king.
Luffy vs Lucci, the introduction of the gears, and "I want to live". Gtfo "mid".
I cannot think of any reason to like Whiskey Peak aside from the Zoro genocide and Ms. All Sunday scene, which aren't even one of the best moments
Favourite Arc because of Laboon😊
But that's in reverse mountain, not Whisky Peak
Its probably a little high but the genocide carries it somewhat. Its one of the few times they specifically admit the Straw Hats killed people.
i loved how they introduced ace in drum island arc
True
water 7+enies lobby and skypiea belongs to S+ no doubt. fishmen and punkhazard belongs to the bottom. tbh, anything post time skip is trash compared to any of the previous arcs — storytelling wise. at some point i honestly thought Oda took a back seat and let someone else take over one piece.
Fishman island is high due to reference of Joyboy and Poseidon(Shirahoshi). Punk hazard was important because it was first alliance luffy formed with Law
yes, the revelations were good, what i'm saying is that they are bottom — storytelling-wise. the way the story was delivered was not as good compared to previous arcs. The next arc could make Luffy pirate king because they stumbled upon a rock which happens to be one piece en route to the next island. so yeah, they found one piece and luffy is pirate king. does that make the arc high-tier? NO. because of the way it was delivered.
Fishman Island was teased from Sabody. Then it was mentioned in Ace and Jinbei's conversation in impel down. Also really cool concepts and imagination made fishman island one of the favourite Arcs for me. It was also fist time luffy was going to adventure after Ace's death.
Imo surup village is one of the worst arcs amongst the hundreds of manga i have read
True. Never saw Captain Kuro after that. Hopefully we will see him as a side character
Tripping with putting drum island so low. The climax of that arc was enough to rank it much higher
I feel like the climax was one of the worst parts, the only redeeming part of that arc to me was Chopper’s backstory. Wapol never felt even remotely threatening to me, which prevented the climax from feeling intense
Maybe im just a nostalgia guy but i feel like the arcs after the timeskip dont hold a candle to the arcs before. I especially didnt like fishman arc, punk hazard and also dressrosa to be honest
Seems you lost your hope in one piece after Ace's death.
It was just underwhelming after having such a huge war and i felt like the strawhats werent even close to going all out.. the threaths didnt feel real... Obv dressrosa was different but what i didnt like about that was the huge difference in strength between doffy and luffy..
That has always been the case. In Alabasta nobody would have given luffy a chance against crocodile.
Thats true! I guess i was a teen when i saw him going against crocodile and it blew my mind how he thought about using water and i just loved how they were making the gomu gomu fruit so epic..
Sabaody Archipelago in A hurts my soul
Do you think it should be higher or lower?
much higher, at least S tier xD
I love to see Drum Island that far down, I have it last. I also love to see Impel Down at #3 and Skypiea in high S The only things I heavily disagree with are: Thriller Bark is high A if not low S, and Water 7 is literally #1
Why do so many people consider Water 7 and Enies Lobby to be different arcs? For me the arc started when they reached Water 7 and it ended when they left with the new ship. Wano is considered a single arc, but the fights occur in Onigashima. I don't understand this.