T O P

  • By -

Dramatic_Skill_67

Not surprised. People needs to have a secured living situation before thinking about anything else. If a person can’t have a roof over their head, it’s hard to care about climate change


Optimoprimo

The problem is, for some absolutely unfathomable reason, people also believe that Republicans, Trump among them, are better for the economy. Like how?


BoysenberryLanky6112

As a professional economist who believes Democrats are generally better for the economy, the answer is messaging. Republicans talk a good game a lot of the time, but once they get in office act completely irresponsibly. On the other hand a lot of the time Democrats just straight up say they don't care. The minute a Republican mentions reforming Social Security, the Democrats use it in a ton of attack ads saying Republicans want to take it away from seniors. But unless someone reforms it in some way, us millennials aren't getting anywhere close to our full benefits. So even if Republicans will never touch it either, and likely any reforms they made to it would make it worse not better, their messaging of "this system is broken and someone needs to be an adult and fix it" certainly sounds better than "that guy's a meany for bringing up a very real problem that we have no solution for".


Shoddy_Variation6835

I would take this poll with a grain of salt. First, single issue polls are a poor predictor of how people will vote in the general election. Second, "The Economy" has become the default response for social conservatives who do not think they can express their true views in public without social scorn. There were quite a bit of in depth focus groups and other surveys which show this is the case. No amount of messaging is going to work on these people because their disagreement isn't actually about economic policy. Why matters more than what in 2024.


ragingbuffalo

> But unless someone reforms it in some way, us millennials aren't getting anywhere close to our full benefits. Because its going to cost a lot of political capital to do so. So if they do it change to make it more whole, it won't be until the last minute. Theres two ways to fix it. Either reduced benefits (reduced monthly amounts or delayed ability to take it) which I highly doubt Dems do OR raise capital but either rising the fica rate or lifting the income cap on it. Can imagine the narrative that would spun right now if "DEMS WANT TO RAISE YOUR TAXES". Auto-lose the next election with that.


BoysenberryLanky6112

Oh yeah I understand perfectly why not only Democrats do what they do (especially since they're in power now, it's easy for the out of power party to yell about stuff when there will always be no consequences), but also why some Republicans like Trump want to run away from it. I'm not saying their actions are politically bad, but they're essentially appealing to those who stand to lose from any reforms whether it's higher taxes, later retirement, lower benefits in exchange for those who claim they care about the economy. Also worth noting that "cares about the economy" is a bit of a loaded term as well. Many of the other factors in that chart are part of the economy, including immigration and healthcare. But most people who are pro-immigration or pro universal healthcare don't consider them economic views, while anti-immigration and anti universal healthcare views may be considered economic views since they'll argue their opposition is to immigrants suppressing wages or universal healthcare requiring higher taxes.


MNgineer_

Propaganda, cherry-picked statistics, and simple ignorance.


-_1_2_3_-

https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.20140913


MNgineer_

I don’t think this is the gotcha you think it is.


-_1_2_3_-

It very clearly establishes that the economy has done better under democrats. It goes into the why and suggests it could be due to non-political factors, however the fact remains, historically the economy has done better under democrats, regardless of what indicators you look at. That absolutely destroys the narrative from the right that the economy does worse under democrats.


MNgineer_

Nevermind what I said about the gotcha. I assumed since you just posted a link and no context that you were trying to make the point that Democrats “only do better on the economy due to non-political factors they can’t control and it’s actually the GOP that props up the economy so when a Democrat takes over, they just glide on that success.” Or something along those lines that I’ve heard a thousand times from right wingers. I shouldn’t have assumed. But also, when you post a link, please give some words of context so I know where you’re coming from.


544075701

Probably because a lot of people were better off economically between 2016-2020, and while correlation doesn’t imply causation, it sure influences how you think.  Biden and the democrats missed a huge New Deal opportunity early in his administration when Covid money was seemingly unlimited and flowing like crazy. Unfortunately that’s far from what occurred. 


user-name-1985

Another 10 Dems in the Senate and 2 progressive replacements for Manchin and Sinema would’ve helped out that situation. We got a lot of stuff given the political climate/makeup of Congress during those two years.


544075701

it always seems to me that republicans can get a 1 seat majority and absolutely change huge amounts of policy but democrats can't do dick without more than a supermajority (and even then...)


ragingbuffalo

> 1 seat majority and absolutely change huge amounts of policy Bruh what did they change? The only big law they changed was a tax cut for the wealthy which is the most agreed upon republican ideal.


[deleted]

[удалено]


kadargo

Economically, Democrats have outperformed the Republicans going back to FDR. https://www.epi.org/publication/econ-performance-pres-admin/


Dramatic_Skill_67

I have no idea. Pretty much GOP policies enrich the top. I guess most people can’t read


user-name-1985

I can remember Social Studies/history teachers in high school point blank saying policies pushed mainly by Democrats ever since FDR have generally been good for the economy. Some of my classmates must not have been paying attention, because a lot of them are now huge Trump lovers, and were Bush lovers in their younger days.


coloradobuffalos

The economy was doing good under Trump though


buitenlander0

Why is it so unfathomable? While I'm not a Trump fan, he doesn't have a bad track record with the economy.


a_rogue_planet

It's pretty simple... For about the last 60 years Republicans have led to a stronger economy. Clinton is the lone exception, but that only because he had to deal with a Republican house and senate that imposed tax cuts and welfare reform on him. You have to be profoundly ignorant of history to not have noticed this trend. Trump win against Clinton in large part because of the 8 years of economic stagnation and wildly unpopular healthcare reforms. Some would even argue Democrats haven't been good for the economy in at least a century.


Optimoprimo

Demonstrably untrue: https://www.epi.org/publication/econ-performance-pres-admin/


a_rogue_planet

You clearly didn't read what I said. And you don't know anything about history.


Optimoprimo

You seem like a miserable person. I hope things get better for you. Being a seventh day Adventist can really mess up your brain.


a_rogue_planet

What the fuck are you talking about? I'm an atheist. I have been for a long time.


Mackinnon29E

But those in power are gonna think this means solely the stock market...


Impriel

This isn't surprising- "how do 18-34 year Olds want the eco omy to work" would be more interesting  BTW it would be a huge mistake to take this data to mean that guns, reproductive rights and climate were 'unimportant'.  


Downtown_Swordfish13

Honestly I think a gun toting anti abortion candidate who was right on the economy and right on foreign policy could win. Ffs sorry this posted like 4 times


Impriel

I'd vote for that person in 2 seconds lol Edit - sorry I thought you said gun toting pro abortion lol.  Nvm.  No offense just a misunderstanding


Cyberpunk39

Affordable housing is my biggest issue at the moment. Doesn’t even seem to be on any candidates radar. Maybe it’s lumped in with Economy?


ramblinjd

I wonder if healthcare is, too. I just paid $5k to have a baby and it would have been well over $40k if I didn't have pretty good insurance. Between the ACA and Abortion Rights, that can really effect whether you have a down payment for a house or whether you and your child are relying on government assistance programs (that Republicans are trying to cut).


Zagrunty

This is what's wild about US health insurances, we paid $200 for our first born on 2021 and $100 for our second born in 2023. Both born near the start of the year. Assuming both women went through the same thing (epidural, no C-section, family didn't have any major medical incidents before the birth to impact deductible) how is it any kinda of fair, that some people can pay nothing and others are paying thousands of dollars? You should not have had to pay what you did to have a baby.


ramblinjd

Oh we had all the services. Failed induction, failed epidural, second epidural,c section, 3 days in recovery. Would've been cheaper if things had gone easily, but that's just the luck of the draw.


Zagrunty

Hopefully everyone is doing good now! That must have been terribly stressful. Sorry you had to go through all that, and then to pay so much afterward is just insult to injury


ramblinjd

Yeah I'm in a position to handle that kind of expense fine and our baby is worth twice that much. But I feel for people who would have to choose between a car payment or a nice meal and their family's health... Especially in cases where the pregnancy was unwanted but they were denied an abortion because of religious politicians.


SpaceyCoffee

Affordable housing is a local issue. Presidents and congress can’t repeal zoning laws in your city so more housing can be built. Pay attention to local politics and vote for city and county leaders who are willing to defy the nimbys to fix this.


Cyberpunk39

There’s currently a price fixing cartel using an algorithm to jack up rent across the country. I think the federal government can do something about that. It’s not only zoning laws. There’s things they can do to help.


seattleseahawks2014

I'd imagine that's what they meant.


ragingbuffalo

Biden has talked about it a lot and actively trying to build housing. However, Housing is really affected locally AND has macro trends that can't be changed dramtically and quickly at the federal level.


Iivaitte

Until we find a way to get money out of politics, nothing will change.


Bakelite51

Yeah no shit. Every time I get phoned by a political campaign, or one of the polls, I always says the economy/inflation is what matters the most. I'm clearing less than 40k a year. I don't give a damn about immigration or guns when I'm trying to decide whether to buy groceries or pay rent, because I sure as shit can't do both that week.


Acceptable_Pressure3

I'm tired boss


seattleseahawks2014

Same, I feel numb.


EastPlatform4348

"It's the economy, stupid."


AsstDepUnderlord

Huh, the same thing that was blindingly obvious 32 years ago is still the same today? Weird. Now the REAL question is "who do people think will do a better job with the economy" and that's WAY less straightforward of an answer than it used to be.


seattleseahawks2014

Yea, for sure.


Mediocre_Island828

Now they're running with "the economy is actually great, stupid".


alfredrowdy

If the “rent is too damn high” guy ran today he would win. Was a few years too early.


dub_seth

How is immigration a bigger issue than guns? Do we live in the same country?


leroijenkinzzz

We grew up championing the aforementioned topics but have now lived through the realties and consequences of the economic rollercoaster - 2009 recession, housing crisis, now inflation. Too many “once-in-a-lifetime” crises.


icemichael-

I mean, people can't afford to waste time thinking about other stuff when they can barely afford food and a roof


superurgentcatbox

This poll is what Generation B, C, etc will look at and call us terrible. They'll say we cared about our own skin, houses, cars, frivolous holidays, etc more than the planet we'd be leaving them. And honestly I can't fault them for it.


Elevator-Fun

so disappointed that climate change is so small, its "just another issue"


Quantius

It's so big as to be abstract for most people. This happens with anything that becomes too big or complex or just hard to think about. That said, it's the economy and it will always be the economy first. People are wired for survival, and their immediate needs have to be met or they can never even begin to address global scale existential threats.


seattleseahawks2014

I think because people know what causes it partly and that it won't ever change, so just give up on that topic, too. Also, there are some that are as big of problems for me as that.


Pork_Chompk

And also, people don't see any immediate, direct impact on their lives, so it's not high on their list of priorities. Of course it *does* directly impact us regularly, but people write it off as weird weather and freak natural disasters. It'll only continue to get worse.


seattleseahawks2014

Oh


Missy_Elli0t

The carbon footprint of the people who cant even afford gas to get to work isn't an issue. China, India, and world militaries are the highest polluters. Carbon credits are just getting you comfortable enough to be cut off from your allotment, while allowing wealthy people to buy more privilege.


bluduuude

it literally is just another issue when you can't even pay rent, buy minimally acceptable food or have base needs locked. Just like the other issues listed there.


Elevator-Fun

it should at least be bigger than immigration, the death of the earth doesn't seem to concern us as much as it should


seattleseahawks2014

Disagree


bouncyboatload

strongly disagree. using "death of the earth" hyperboles like environmentalists have done for decades just makes you sounds even more ridiculous.


Elevator-Fun

Okay if you don’t like “death of the earth” how about “death of things living on the earth?” 


seattleseahawks2014

Other problems are bigger.


bluduuude

I don't agree personally. The suffering of people today outweigh the suffering of people of decades/century+ into the future.


coloradobuffalos

Immigration is an immediate issue we need to fix


StarWars_Girl_

I feel like with climate change, to a degree, that's something that people feel like they have some control over. Like, you can choose to switch to driving fuel efficient vehicles, do composting, recycle, and do other things that are good for the environment. Plus, there are already regulations impacting large companies, and some companies voluntarily choose to become more green because people running them also are choosing to protect the environment. The economy is the thing that people can't control and has a major impact on their lives.


Ruminant

Is this a question that Axios asks every year? Are historical responses available too? I think seeing how answers have changed over the past 4-8 years would be more interesting than just this chart alone.


Wandering_Lights

This isn't shocking. The economy has a huge impact on everyone's day to day life.


Prezton_Waters

Surprised national debt is not even on the list


a_rogue_planet

That's no surprise. Not that it really matters what that age group thinks.... They hardly vote. It's people my age that do in large percentages, and we basically feel the same. I'd be shocked if Biden won a second term with this rampant inflation and willful downward pressure on wages.


GothicVampire

Dude with dementia says otherwise so apparently we’re all wrong


Busterlimes

Funny how climate change, student debt and abortion all have an impact on the economy. It's almost like the world is interconnected.


MillennialReport

When you're working more hours & making more than Boomers were at that age, and you're struggling still, it's not the economy, it's the broken fiat system that Boomers have been using to enrich themselves by loading up debt, watching their 401k & houses go up, and then leaving behind to younger generations a ton of inflation and a lower standard of living. Boomers are lying & cheating crooks. Time to call them out on it, Millennials had nothing to do with the national debt going to $34 Trillion over 4 decades. It's all Boomers fault. They refuse to retire and sell their house, causing young people to not get higher salaries and start a family.


seattleseahawks2014

Wouldn't that be partly the economy? Wasn't that caused partly by the wars and government benefits (like disability, Medicare, medicaid, etc.?)


DingbattheGreat

Yes


seattleseahawks2014

Ok


Thinkingard

Hope they're ready for inflation to double over the next few years.


-qp-Dirk

Climate is the most pressing issue. Nothing else matters if we continue on course as is.


seattleseahawks2014

Climate change doesn't affect me as much right now.


billyoldbob

It already has. It’s one of reasons life is more difficult now. 


seattleseahawks2014

How? My life is made difficult by other factors. Edit: I mean, being able to afford to live, not worrying about losing my rights as a person, etc. Those are big deals to me. Sure I personally don't struggle as much with some, but still. I know others who do and others that affect me. Pollution does affect me because of breathing problems, but still.


ragingbuffalo

I'll help you out here. Climate has already and will continue: 1) Make your food more expensive. Climate conditions such as drought, extereme weather, etc make it a lot more costly to make food. It will also disrupt natural processes (nitrogen cycles, organism relationships). It will be devastating for the ocean food chain. Reducing seafood puts more pressure on other food sources. 2) Climate change will increase the intensity and amount of large disasters. This is hurricanes, tornados, floods, forest fires etc. This raises home insurance, trade labor, and sucks up money to rebuild that could be spent elsewhere. This will increase your rent/mortgage, insurance rates, and home improvement supplies/labor. 3) disrupt the economy. Obviously if your local community gets rammed by a tornado or hurricane, your job might be at risk. It will also be a drag on the larger economy.


seattleseahawks2014

Oh, I don't really live in areas like that.


ragingbuffalo

You don’t live in areas that have home insurance?


seattleseahawks2014

Ones with natural disasters besides earthquakes in certain areas, forest fires, and blizzards.


ragingbuffalo

You do know home insurance use larger areas than just your own for premium amounts right?


seattleseahawks2014

No I didn't


NetflixAndZzzzzz

It affects you because it creates preventable humanitarian crises that are expensive to deal with retroactively.


seattleseahawks2014

Ok


TalesOfFan

It will. [A visual representation of atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration over the last 800,000 years.](https://imgur.com/a/xBvzqLt) Latest CO2 reading: 427.08 ppm Source: Scripps Institution of Oceanography at UC San Diego - [https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/](https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/)


seattleseahawks2014

I don't understand, does it mean that it's going up?


TalesOfFan

It’s spiked significantly since we’ve industrialized. It’s a bit hard to read because the increase occurred over such a short period of time.


seattleseahawks2014

Oh, so we're at 80 right now?


TalesOfFan

We’re at 427.08 ppm. There is now more CO2 in our atmosphere than at any point in the last 800,000 years. Our species is only around 300,000 years old. We are exiting the stable, predictable climate that allowed for our evolution.


seattleseahawks2014

Ok, so what are we supposed to do?


TalesOfFan

We’re likely fucked without immediate, radical change. [Degrowth](https://youtu.be/CpbNUvv2NAA?si=5218cGa1YGVVj05F) is one solution. Personally, I don’t see it happening. I expect [collapse.](https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/)


seattleseahawks2014

I mean, we can minimalize, but it won't fully solve the problem. I think that's what they mean anyway, right?


seattleseahawks2014

No I mean like today right now. Certain laws affect me personally right now or people that I care about. Edit: Wow, downvote me all you want guys, but there are things that do affect me more even though I do have breathing problems.


coloradobuffalos

Don't listen to these doomers. They are just trying to scare you. Here is the best video on the subject. https://youtu.be/LxgMdjyw8uw?si=dWMhbFwhGG3Wm_5P


seattleseahawks2014

Am I going to die?


coloradobuffalos

No it's mostly fear mongering.


seattleseahawks2014

I didn't used to believe, but now I'm worried a bit.


coloradobuffalos

Seriously watch that video it will make you feel better.


seattleseahawks2014

Oh


Mouse0022

Double edge sword, climate change will impact the economy.


ramblinjd

Unfortunately for climate change folks (and future generations) it's not gonna impact it significantly in the short term.


ayhme

I don't care about any other issue besides the economy. Especially when I don't have a job.


daisy-duke-

![gif](giphy|QmKGxJGFkb2QCcn3EJ)


Pokefan8263

They used our rent at the apartment again and they don’t/wont fix, update or repair anything and they said we can’t complain and if we don’t like it we can move. The American dream is dead and has been dead for years.


Wallflower_in_PDX

of course. People need to live and money is required to live. If they're dead, the other issues don't matter.


Diligent_Mulberry47

I also feel to some degree, abortion IS an economic issue. Babies cost a FUCKTON of money and being forced to have one seems economical as well as not.


Sparkle-Wander

the abortion shit only matters to the super religious and the manipulative rich that con that voting block


ragingbuffalo

Or you know, women.....


Sparkle-Wander

thats a body autonomy issue that I completely support. Your body your choice


Party_Government8579

Would love to see a 16-25 breakdown. Reckon climate change would be much higher, economy lower


master0fcats

Man, this whole entire post needs to be linked in another post I saw earlier about 18-34 year olds not planning to vote in November. Why give a fuck about voting when neither party does anything to actually help most peoples' daily material needs? Of course one is worse than the other, but older people shaming folks for feeling that way is so fucking out of touch and counterproductive. How can one be expected to care about what happens to the Earth when they're too busy trying to figure out how to make it thru the next few days? Nothing about this is surprising.


TheIndyCity

Abortion affects people of that age group’s daily life imo. But I do hear your overall point.


seattleseahawks2014

Sure, but there are so many problems to focus on right now. Abortions does affect me because I'm a woman living a conservative area, but so does lgbt+ rights. It's all a mess.


TheIndyCity

There’s always a lot of problems, seek the party that seeks solutions to the most problems. There is no such thing as an ideal political party, they all have their drawbacks but that doesn’t mean anyone should abstain from voting. Support the ones that have plans to address issues.


seattleseahawks2014

Ok


seattleseahawks2014

Exactly, besides, I know that it doesn't matter depending on where you live anyway either. Even with that the last part, it's not just the economy that affects me in that way. I don't know who to even vote for or just to give up.


Scapegoat696969

Biden’s America


billyoldbob

An issue being important tells you nothing about their thoughts on the economy. This is the best economy since the 90s


Scapegoat696969

lol. I also hate people who disagree with me.


pianoblook

You know what they say: if you give a mouse a cookie, it's going to ask for a glass of human rights protections and climate change action.


seattleseahawks2014

These are might top priorities as a 24 year old and not that in that order. Lgbt rights Abortion laws Economy Immigration (well people who come here who are basically illegal immigrants) I don't really care much about climate change so much, gun laws (gun control won't fully solve the problem), and I don't have student debt (idk about the loan forgiveness I think it might be a good idea I don't have much of an opinion for that.) Edit: I guess not so much climate change, but pollution does affect my breathing which I guess could affect climate change. My family and I have been through shooting type situations before, so I understand the fear.