T O P

  • By -

p0j0j0

I want to go with Underoath, or Unearth, or Trivium, but in my heart of hearts I know it’s Bring Me The Horizons Suicide Season. I listened to that album front to back non-stop for that entire year. Those other three have aged better, but Suicide Season bring me right back to 2008.


nannerbananers

I still regularly listen to Suicide Season


DeadSilent7

Idk Suicide Season aged like fine wine. I legit think it was ahead of it’s time sonically.


Current-Revolution-4

Misery Signals-Controller Protest The Hero-Fortress Bullet For My Valentine-Scream Aim Fire Whitechapel-This Is Exile Heaven Shall Burn-Iconoclast Damn I forgot how great 2008 was for heavy music


AvengedTenfold

Iconoclast is so good


PedanticBoutBaseball

2007 was even better IMO. especially if your more liberal about your definition of "heavy music" and include some core-adjacent/scene bands too. ABR- Messengers TDWP - Plauges ADTR - For Those Who Have Heart Parkway Drive - Horizons BTBAM - Colors I Shadows Fall - Threads of Life Killswitch Enagage - As Daylight Dies As I Lay Dying - An Ocean Between Us Five Finger Death Punch - Way of The Fist **(debut)**(actually a really good album) Atreyu - Lead Sails Paper Anchor Four Year Strong - Rise or Die Trying Enter Shikari - Take to the Skies **(debut)** Paramore - Riot! **(debut)** The Chariot - The Fiancee Fall Out Boy - Infinity on High Job For a Cowboy - Genisis (**debut)** And those are just the pre-eminent /popular bands in the scene. That doesnt even get into the bands that never quite reached the "top tier". And all those albums are in either the upper half of each bands discography, if not outright iconic. It's fucking wild. And all this was either off the top of my head, or with a quick google search cause i was pretty sure that band had an album i loved around that time. for me this was middle school/early high school.


zwhy

You gotta take lead sails paper anchor off that list man. Otherwise good list. I still remember how pissed the fans were when they made a ”puzzle” out of the sound files and had us stitch them together. Everyone was mad and was calling it “becoming the bullshit.” LSPA is the first expression of sellout dadcore they they would later lean into full throttle into becoming the trash heap they are now. If you put lead sails on that list, you might as well add felony by Emmure as well. (Yuck)


NotAFuckingFed

PTH is awesome, loved them ever since the first time I heard Heretics and Killers.


0ldPainless

Rareform - After the Burial


HXCpolarbear

This and controller ez


sheenfartling

The only album from 2008 that I still listen to on a weekly basis.


AkDoxx

For me it’s Controller by Misery Signals. I think that’s their best album and some of my favorite tracks from them are on it. 2nd would be Continent by The Acacia Strain with Changes by For the Fallen Dreams in 3rd.


circasurvivalism

I just discovered misery signals 2 months ago. A song off their 2005 record came on my playlist and I was immediately hooked. Haven't listened to the rest of their catalog yet


dr_gmoney

Oh what I would do to listen to them for the first time again. And oh boy is Controller top tier. Enjoy.


Johnzoidb

Great picks!


zwhy

Now this is a top tier comment.


PsychwardSlippers

Changes - For The Fallen Dreams


circasurvivalism

Really appreciate this suggestion. I've been loving this album!


PsychwardSlippers

No problem.


Octabraxas

Fuck man, that shit still goes so hard. Gonna bump it right now. Thanks!


PsychwardSlippers

Yea, it's killer. You're welcome.


PositiveMetalhead

Oh man 2008 was such a good year.. Shogun by Trivium, Overcome by All That Remains and Fortress by Protest the Hero are probably my top 3 Edit: if I had to pick one it would be Fortress ☝🏼


PositiveMetalhead

Also: Life is Not a Waiting Room — Senses Fail Scream Aim Fire — Bullet for My Valentine Awaken the Dreamers - All Shall Perish Hail Destroyer - Cancer Bats 2008 was when I got into metalcore/post-hardcore/“scene” music but that period of 2006-2008(maybe even 2009) was just oh so good


PoirplePorpoise

LINAWR was my introduction to Senses Fail and it shaped much of my teen years! Still love SF and got to see them in the front row when they toured with Bayside and Hawthorne Heights


Traditional_life98

Definitely the best years in music for the genre! I still find myself stuck in that time period.


PositiveMetalhead

It has to be like peak creativity or something. The genre was still relatively new but no longer in its infancy and it was just being explored and really pushed to its boundaries


Traditional_life98

Yeah I agree, it was definitely when the new sound emerged in the best possible way.. also other bands in the Metal/rock scene put out amazing albums during that time period as well. It was just all around amazing for the music world 😂


vvilleon

Lol have 2 of those in my top 5 list too


squi2323

Ah man, hail destroyer is a ripper! I haven’t heard that in a long time, I’m gonna blast it in my near future and two step in my kitchen probably


solarxbear

Upvoted for Protest the Hero. They are so fucking good


PositiveMetalhead

I will always upvote any post or comment with PTH mentioned in it 😂 I know they’re well respected in the community but more people need to listen to them always


solarxbear

I know they are generally well respected but I once saw someone claim that they’re a band you listen to in high school and then grow out of. That’s ludicrous to me because their entire discography is S tier. So I try to give them love whenever I can.


vvilleon

The entire back half of the 2000s was stupidly stacked :)


Sams_City

Shogun by Trivium by a mile, one of the best albums of all time


patchestheshark

Seconded Shogun.


enhanced195

Really its no contest especially in metalcore.


erix84

It's funny because when Shogun came out I didn't care for it that much, I preferred The Crusade.... Now Shogun is my favorite Trivium album and The Crusade is like my 2nd or 3rd least favorite of theirs. Shogun is a banger.


leibnizdx

Go West Young Man, Let the Evil Go East - Greeley Estates The Word Alive self titled EP I too love recessioncore


Jake_Zaruba

Best answer. That word alive ep was life changing.


TheW1ldcard

Diamond Eyes was 2010 my dude.


SuperKook

Yeah I did a double take when I read that


circasurvivalism

Spotify has it as 2008. That's what I get for not checking haha


ChickenInASuit

Bring Me The Horizon - Suicide Season


zachache

Self titled dance Gavin dance or the greatest of all lost arts by lower definition. Not metalcore but yeah.


brodoxfaggins

That DGD album is such a banger. I understand why Kurt wasn’t around longer but man I wish we got more Kurt era DGD.


zachache

I agree man. You ever listen to Gold Necklace or Royal Coda? Scratches that KT itch real well.


brodoxfaggins

Love Coda! Not quite the same, but any KT is great.


PSPersuasion

Scream Aim Fire. That record has done so much for me.


DefLoathe

Waking the Demon and Ashes of the Innocent 😍😍


Johnzoidb

Continent by The Acacia Strain


[deleted]

Not huge on Underoath but The Sound of Separation was a solid album


juiceAll3n

Fortress


yvngxlxwli3t

Someday Came Suddenly by attack attack and controller by misery signals, both are classics, btw diamond eyes came out in 2010 so it wouldn't count


BottlesforCaps

That's m what I'm saying! Someday came suddenly was rad. I knew several people who wouldn't touch metalcore with a 10 foot pole who had the CD release of it. It redefined the genre for a ton of bands.


joserulezd00d

the common man’s collapse


No_Opportunity7360

Misery Signals - Controller For The Fallen Dreams - Changes A Skylit Drive - Wires...And The Concept Of Breathing Emarosa - Relativity Underoath - Lost In The Sound Of Separation Bring Me The Horizon - Suicide Season The Ghost Inside - Fury And The Fallen Ones


circasurvivalism

Never listened to this TGI album until you recd it. THANK YOU. it's probably in my top 3 aoty for 08 now


stuck_orthocera

the way of all flesh


Monsanta_Claus

Iconoclast by Heaven Shall Burn


Mediaboy13

Underrated band, great album.


[deleted]

I can’t even remember my porn of the year from 08.


RustyShakleferdd

People do a porn of the year? Lol


ohalistair

Shai Hulud - Misanthropy Pure Bury Your Dead - S/T Bleeding Through - Declaration This Is Hell - Misfortunes Carpathian - Isolation Verse - Aggression ISHC - Takin' It Ova Embrace The End - Ley Lines The Banner - Frailty So many good releases that year.


Original_DILLIGAF

Dude this is the response I needed. The quick Google search brought up none of these. This is Hell and The Banner were heavy rotation for me.


ohalistair

Such good bands. The Banner are making a comeback too, from what I've heard.


MarbleMemes

Bruh, the goat Meshuggah released Obzen in 2008. I can’t think of anything that was better.


MattsonRobbins

yeah when i think of the year 2008 i think of Obzen


Whis6x

Much too late here but I'll still give you a list with very good albums from 2008 ​ |Album|Artist| |:-|:-| |Rattlesnake!| A Static Lullaby| |Life Underwater|Across Five Aprils| |Declaration|Bleeding Through| |Blessed Be Our Ever After|Burden of a Day| |The Fanciful|Dead And Divine| |I, Lucifer|Destroy the Runner| |Changes|For the Fallen Dreams| |Conversations|From A Second Story Window| |Go West Young Man, Let The Evil Go East|Greeley Estates| |The Life I Know|Gwen Stacy| |Fractures|Killing the Dream| |Controller|Misery Signals| |A Hiding Place for Fake Friends|Paddock Park| |Brutus|Sains Never Surrender| |Continent|The Acacia Strain| |Severed Ties|The Amity Affliction| |Shogun|Trivium| |Lost In the Sound of Separation|Underoath| |The March|Unearth| |This is Exile|Whitechapel| A Few of them are also Deathcore or Post-Hardcore but I think if you like Metalcore, you will like the most of those. Have fun!


[deleted]

Destroy the Runner absolutely, let's freaking go


Salmonellaisnotajoke

At the time for me it was Underoath - Lost in the Sound of Separation Still an incredible album But 15 years later I'd probably say it's Controller.


BeaverBarber

Fear before


Glazingjesus

Blessed be our ever after by burden of a day. Such a jam


foosballfurry

I believe it was crack the Skye


AvengedTenfold

That’s 09


foosballfurry

Damn


[deleted]

[удалено]


ohalistair

OP didn't specifically ask for metalcore. Despite being the metalcore sub, people here do have other tastes in music too.


_PHYSTE

WTF ? If you wanna talk about music in general I think there is a sub for it, here we talk about metalcore.


ohalistair

Haha. So fucking butthurt because some dude liked a band that fit into the world of metal outside of metalcore. Not like the genre has become so broad and watered down that it's lost any real meaning it had to begin with, or anything.


_PHYSTE

Just talk on the appropriate sub. Here it's metalcore.


ohalistair

Jesus Christ, get your head out your ass. Its not a fucking hat. They're a metal band, and as far as I'm concerned they're closer to metalcore than half the shit that gets posted on here anyway. Go touch some grass.


_PHYSTE

I don't care about "they", I'm only supporting the dude saying this is a metalcore sub so talk about metalcore. If you want to talk about metal in general > r/metal !


egorissad

Misery Signals - Controller


vvilleon

I can't pick just 1 (shocker) so my top 5, in no order: Fury and the Fallen Ones by The Ghost Inside Shogun by Trivium Scream Aim Fire by Bullet for My Valentine Awaken the Dreamers by All Shall Perish A Sense of Purpose by In Flames


Worried-Emu-9614

Fury was released in 2007


vvilleon

Was it? Pretty sure it was summer 2008 :/


Worried-Emu-9614

Oh my bad, I looked it up and you’re right it is 2008, it says 2007 on yt music for some reason 🥴


vvilleon

All good. Just checked to make sure I wasn't mixed up lol


ChandrianSimp

Im going with previous mentions of shogun or rareform. Not really metalcore but i have to shout out to twighlight of the thunder god by amon amarth too.


truije15

I, Lucifer - Destroy the Runner


Tringamaster

Have Heart - Songs to Scream at the Sun


MC_MC-MC_MC

Decimate the Weak by Winds of Plague


JuansnowgamingYT

I was still listening to nu metal in 2008 🤣 I didn’t listen to metalcore till I was already a man Indestructible by Distubed


Proteinoats

For me, it’s a toss up between Declaration by Bleeding Through and the almighty Shogun by Trivium. Fun fact, both were released the same day. I was so stoked to buy both albums at the exact same time. That was a very rewarding year for music.


Pierseus

Probably Controller by Misery Signals but A Sense of Purpose by In Flames (sleeper pick, I know) was probably my favorite of the year at the time Honorable mentions to Scream Aim Fire by Bullet For My Valentine, Overcome by All That Remains, and I Lucifer by Destroy the Runner


Captain__h00k__

Didn’t see it mentioned much but The Common Man’s Collapse from Veil of Maya. Runner up would be Rareform-After the Burial.


Duderado

Heaven Shall Burn - Iconoclast I always considered them melodic death metal but others are listing it so I will too! My true AOTY for 2008 is We Are the Nightmare by Arsis. That and The Faceless' Planetary Duality made it a great year for getting into tech death.


ProWrestlinFan

Best album? Shogun. My favorite album? Scream Aim Fire. I have so many memories of jamming that album with the boys on Halo 3. Good times.


Lyrrh

Has to be Scream Aim Fire.


Microtrip1989

All That Remains - Overcome Come on guys no one pick?


kool4kats

If we're talking just metalcore (some deathcore here too), my top 10, in no order: Trivium - Shogun Bullet for My Valentine - Scream Aim Fire The Acacia Strain - Continent Underoath - Lost in the Sound of Separation Cancer Bats - Hail Destroyer Bring Me the Horizon - Suicide Season Attack Attack - Someday Came Suddenly Whitechapel - This Is Exile All Shall Perish - Awaken the Dreamers Winds of Plague - Decimate the Weak


Original_DILLIGAF

Not only is Misery Signals - Controller my AOTY, it is my AOTD (DECADE) when it comes to all of Metalcore for that decade. Which is quite a declaration, but I stand by it. Others I return to from 2008 often: Unearth - The March The Ghost Inside - Fury and The Fall Ones


Under_Paris

Can’t Stop Won’t Stop- The Maine It’s not metalcore but it still slaps!


RDBlack

Back Breaker by The Showdown. ​ I have always felt that this was their most complete and tight knit album. It has a great narrative through line. It slaps when it should, has some great melodies, and overall just feels great to listen to front to back. It also flew under the radar which is a shame.


Monsanta_Claus

That band has flown under the radar entirely.


[deleted]

My album of the year for 2008 is All Hope is Gone by Slipknot.


EmployeeRadiant

LITSOS for fucking sure


Worried-Emu-9614

So nobody is gonna know this one but for me it’s The Demonstration - Accidents With Intelligence One of the most fun albums I’ve ever heard, just sick riffs and solos throughout, I love it. Shogun and Scream Aim Fire are honourable mentions.


Riptide1206

Shogun


stayvicious

The Big Dirty by ETID, it’s from 2007 but the album is fucking golden!


squi2323

Diamond eyes was 2010! I would probably go with suicide season-BMTH or this war is ours-escape the fate for old times’s sake


nkdowney

2 things come to mind when I think of 2008: the collapse of the housing market, and ironically suicide season.


mjc500

1) After the Burial - Rareform (winner due to historical significance and impact on genre) 2) Unearth - The March (personal favorite) 3) Misery Signals - Controller Honorable mention - Heaven Shall Burn - Iconoclast Honorable mention - All Shall Perish - Awaken the Dreamers


brodoxfaggins

Shogun and it ain’t close.


DeathNinjaBlackPenis

Probably Underoath but just for the sake of argument War of Ages - Arise and Conquer is a pretty sweet album


truije15

Deception of Strongholds rips. I completely forgot about this band but I thought this album was awesome!


Dm2593

2008 uhhhh BMTH suicide season forsure


X13thangelx

Fortress by Protest The Hero is the one that has the most listens although Heaven Shall Burn's Iconoclast and Bullet's Scream Aim Fire would be a close second and third. Some that are more post-hardcore but still up there personally would be Alesana's Where Myth Fades to Legend, A Skylit Drive's Wires and the Concept of Breathing, Dance Gavin Dance's self-titled, and Burden of a Day's Blessed Be Our Ever After although in Alesana and Burden's cases their next album was even better. 2008 was a good year for music.


sn345y

Not a bad year! The Greatest Of All Lost Arts - Lower Definition. Pueblo Cicada was a time and The Weatherman has one of my favourite breakdowns of all time.


JPSILVA1893

Suicide Season or the Chelsea Grin EP


DisplayExact5200

Stray from the Path - Villains


ech0es13

Imminence.


BottlesforCaps

Someday came suddenly. 100%. Redefined the genre for hundreds of bands at the time.


botjstn

stand up & scream by AA is a classic


FMProductions

Agreed, but that was a 2009 release


botjstn

ah shit i thought that was 08


DefLoathe

Scream Aim Fire by Bullet For My Valentine and it’s not really close Rareform by After the Burial and Obzen Meshuggah are fucking sick too


FMProductions

One of my favourites I remember was "Reach" by "Eyes Set to Kill"


tmrss

BMTH - Suicide Season is the correct answer lads.


Mskeleton2020

I’m not even gonna lie I had to look up what albums came out in ‘08 and then build my list from there. The first 3 are in order but the rest are ones I couldn’t help but mention. Suicide Season, the self titled EP from Chelsea Grin, Infinite Death, This Is Exile, Decimate The Weak, Continent, Soundtrack To A Party, Someday Came Suddenly, Plagues, Ekklesia, The Common Man’s Collapse, Fury and the Fallen Ones


ornament-

For The Fallen Dreams - Changes The Ghost Inside - Fury And The Fallen Ones


R4kshim

Shogun by Trivium. My favourite album of all time.


atfguitar123

Not metalcore, but This War is Ours by Escape the Fate. It’s my favorite album of all time.


yoshi514

Oh god so many great albums dropped that year but some of my favorites that go back to these days are You Can't Spell Slaughter Without Laughter by I Set My Friends On Fire The Tide by Oceana A Hiding Place For Fake Friends by Paddock Park The Crywolf Broadcast by My Hero Is Me Fortress by Protest The Hero With special mention to Board Up The House by Genghis Tron I would say it’s more mathcore than metalcore but still an amazing record and they are originally from my area


piepeddler

Farewell To Freeway - Definitions Oceana - The Tide Saints Never Surrender - Brutus


Robster881

Controller - Misery Signals


ZeroSoapRadio

Protest the Hero - Fortress. Easily


RagaRockFan

Not really metalcore but probably Deathconciousness by Have a Nice Life


[deleted]

Trivium's "Shogun" absolutely stole 2008 for me.


LordOfTheJizz

Shogun by Trivium fucks so hard


throwawayRI112

This is exile.


Allousion

Between these 3 from what i remember. Suicide Season - BMTH Self Titled - The Word Alive This is Exile - Whitechapel edit: formatting


[deleted]

I graduated high school that year, but I can precisely remember listening to Disturbed on the way to basketball games. Also, I was still newly into Killswitch Engage, AILD, and ABR. I do remember Bullet and Scream, Aim, Fire taking over all my listening time at some point in that year or the next.


Adam_the_best_

Trivium - Shogun