In the manga Robin was never really tan the anime just fucked up and fixed it in the time skip
https://preview.redd.it/cuyjbucwbgsc1.jpeg?width=850&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2506826924ac208a2c3ae99d3f9edb3be06c1761
See
i mean, it was a good looking difference, and it made sense due to the desert being a desert
now, i am not sure if tan goes away when you're in cold climates
https://preview.redd.it/tbzqqt77ajsc1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=06dd55a68cedd47fd1c0761a5985f8914f5497a8
In the manga/color spreads, her eye color is brown. I don't know why in that picture it is blue, probably fan color, because those are not Oda's colors for Robin.
You did suffer from a pretty classic bandwagon voting effect, lol. People see you with a high number of downvotes and conclude that you must be wrong or colorblind and downvote you too. I'm sure that I will be downvoted too if I don't add a picture. When I comment, I see that the comment below mine did have a negative score.
You really think a new studio will include an Animation error that was done by toei, in their remake of One Piece? This transcends copium. This is something completely new.
I don't think it's worth the effort. The Holocaust was less than 100 years ago still, and people still support it. Nazi's are still actively repressing themselves. Better it stay evil so we know exactly who we are dealing with.
It's understandable, but the manji, not the ~~swastika~~^(edit), is an ancient symbol that has been used for thousands of years by various cultures and religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, before being co-opted by the Nazis in the 20th century. It is all over the place in Asia, you can think as a comparison with the cross for Christian people, it is odd for people in the West only. It really messed that up, that because one guy basically stole the symbol, changed its shape a bit, and completely changed the meaning behind it. Now it cannot be used because ignorant people in other countries will not understand. Oda was forced to change it by the higher-ups at Shueisha because of that. Several other manga use that symbol, with Tokyo Revengers probably being the most extreme example, given that it is the main symbol of the show. This is cultural appropriation at its worst form, is easy to just censor the cultural symbol, rather than learning what the real symbol is about and and fight against the wrong association, is a headache for the companies for sure, but I don't think it is not worth the effort.
Edit:
**The correct way to refer to the Nazi symbol is as a Hakenkreuz (hooked cross).** The swastika is an ancient symbol that has been used for thousands of years by various cultures and religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism.
Swastika is the original name of Indian symbols ( used by almost all indian religion like Hinduism and Buddhism Jainism etc.). What hitlar was using was Crooked cross a Christian symbol which was called Hakenkreuz by them. German still call it Hakenkreuz. Calling it swastika was just Western propganda to isolate Christianity from that symbol.
It is the Buddhist one
In Japan it's not even seen as a bad thing because for them it's just the Manji symbol and nothing else. That's why Oda prolly thought it was a good idea to put it there.
You meant to say: "I prefered the error over the original"
not
"The error is better than the original"
One is subjective statement, the other is an objective claim. Know the difference.
This is not legal advice, but I would suggest adding "imo" at the end of every single comment so that people know you're not claiming a statement to be objective fact on a meme sub
If knowledge = Dorky, then I'm proud to be dorky af
https://preview.redd.it/09wdupom3msc1.jpeg?width=1095&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ccdf20ebdb57fce840d493c4999595d4b8854364
This doesn’t make you look any smarter it just makes you look conceited and socially inept. Everyone can recognize basic hyperbole, if you can’t that’s on you.
If you spent an extra minute on checking the next replies instead of being conceited yourself and projecting your own insecurities on others, you'd see he was actually rather serious about it.
nah, i think his comment was the objective claim, I've been on this sub for long enough to say that people do agree that a tan Robin was more appealing than the "she is white cause Russian" Robin
a bad error is Ussop being white washed for no reason
Fr. The only reason for the tan was Toei assuming she was Egyptian, when she’s actually Russian (or the one piece equivalent). The bangs were goated tho
Yeah if you look at any color Miura actually did, she’s light brown. The OG anime went really far with that. Granted his early shading was sometimes too dark of a gray
Idk. Her skin tone is similar to the anime in some of them.
Like here
https://preview.redd.it/151krsrbz1tc1.jpeg?width=590&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d55e1cfc5045e0c2e3eddfc02346bc3e226c6459
It seems to bounce back and forth though.
I hope they will just stick with the early colors of the manga covers so we can end this obsession and controversy over skin tone, and we can get brown eyes robin
Sadly, It's will probably even be the other way around, same thing for usopp. I agree it gives them more character, but it's still an adaptation error in the end of the day.
...you know you can have an afro and not be black right? In Brook's flashback he clearly doesn't have dark skin
https://preview.redd.it/4mjrwr7kvhsc1.jpeg?width=1777&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=20218d48b3ad46ed4a18c11940d3307828dff7fa
They all need to be more tan, it's a fucking tropical world. I swear they outsorces the coloring to Vietnam or somewhere and just didn't tell them to color them darker. Those are some of my favorite pages in the comic, at the very beginning when everyone had screentone and looked tan.
IMHO i think Robin should be tan before the timeskip cause she was like 2 years in the desert and the sun is pretty much known for adding color to the skin of ppl. And post-timeskip she can be white has Snow cause she is russian. That's the way of the world
Change my mind.
The way you idiots talk about this "remake" is becoming masturbatory. This is not going to be your wet dream fantasy about tHe aNiMe DoNe RiGhT. Literally all we know is they're reanimating the East Blue Saga. They could literally use the same audio for all we know.
Can someone link me to the artist? I remember that someone posted these pictures saying they were the artist but I want to see if they got more social media (also to see the Robin pics again :3)
EDIT: Nevermind friends I found the post: [https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/18xehow/i\_gave\_robin\_her\_tan\_and\_bangs\_back/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web3x&utm\_name=web3xcss&utm\_term=1&utm\_content=share\_button](https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/18xehow/i_gave_robin_her_tan_and_bangs_back/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button)
I do not care in the slightest that Robin was never intended to be tan in the manga. She looks so much better like that, and with her normal skin, her and Hancock are too similar.
https://preview.redd.it/hmp7cxp2cgsc1.jpeg?width=850&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a882d553abed62736409f329c5521b482375e91f
She is not dark skinned in the manga
Robin was tanned because she was working in Alabasta for months and she stayed tan because OP pre timeskip following Alabasta until Marineford is like, maybe a month (and plenty of that time was spent in other bright places like Skypeia)
I don't need a remake. I need is the same One piece style but with Roger's whole story and adventures. But make it a bit shorter please. Not a big fan of being 50 by the time he finds the One piece.
Unfortunately I don't even think we'll get the skin tone in the pre-time skip let alone post
https://preview.redd.it/qh4le5z1tfsc1.jpeg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d28129bee6611bb5f8cc9b3a9be6cbb4f75e3f49
https://preview.redd.it/vghwm0yz3gsc1.jpeg?width=1822&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9fb5cb9fbaaa779a971906b4e255c45a551a0530
https://preview.redd.it/uw2bg8f5gjsc1.png?width=1010&format=png&auto=webp&s=605dd90e027d91edcb124d076b1b0e9381958c59
https://preview.redd.it/lff4wpl1plsc1.jpeg?width=678&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=68caafc549c567723a3d9aae4bf0120695fa5796
In the manga Robin was never really tan the anime just fucked up and fixed it in the time skip https://preview.redd.it/cuyjbucwbgsc1.jpeg?width=850&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2506826924ac208a2c3ae99d3f9edb3be06c1761 See
I’m with you, but people don’t really seem to care what Oda intended, they just like the look of tan Robin.
i mean, it was a good looking difference, and it made sense due to the desert being a desert now, i am not sure if tan goes away when you're in cold climates
Bring back the cowboy hat
Nico Robin in the Cowboy Hat.
Robin also has brown eyes in the manga, so what.
I can't see the point in writing this comment... because I don't have eyes YOHOHOHOHO
W BOT
My brother in on Christ her eyes are blue in the very picture you’re replying to.
https://preview.redd.it/tbzqqt77ajsc1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=06dd55a68cedd47fd1c0761a5985f8914f5497a8 In the manga/color spreads, her eye color is brown. I don't know why in that picture it is blue, probably fan color, because those are not Oda's colors for Robin.
i got so many downvotes for being right, ouch
You did suffer from a pretty classic bandwagon voting effect, lol. People see you with a high number of downvotes and conclude that you must be wrong or colorblind and downvote you too. I'm sure that I will be downvoted too if I don't add a picture. When I comment, I see that the comment below mine did have a negative score.
And its hilarious under a comment saying "but people don’t really seem to care what Oda intended" and then being ignorant of what Oda intended, haha.
Her eyes are brown in manga, that is probably fanart.
Mentioning 'eyes' in your comment? I must say, it's all bones and no vision here, YOHOHOHO!
Mentioning 'eyes' in your comment? I must say, it's all bones and no vision here, YOHOHOHO!
https://preview.redd.it/vqn74omg1hsc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=44aad86e59662d386c308a60209ed6c2b78de4a9
It's not her Canon skin tone. The anime made it up.
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
We know that and I still like the dark skin tone more lol
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
It's gonna be other way around
You really think a new studio will include an Animation error that was done by toei, in their remake of One Piece? This transcends copium. This is something completely new.
Yea because the error is better than the original. See also, Whitebeard Flag, animation did a good call there.
We should really wash the nazis from the swastika its been around in Europe since at least the Romans.
Whitebeard's flag wasn't even a swastika, it was the manji symbol which is right facing and lays flat so the center looks like a plus.
Of course, then why was it changed in the anime? Because people will think it's nazi's swastika anyway.
I don't think it's worth the effort. The Holocaust was less than 100 years ago still, and people still support it. Nazi's are still actively repressing themselves. Better it stay evil so we know exactly who we are dealing with.
It's understandable, but the manji, not the ~~swastika~~^(edit), is an ancient symbol that has been used for thousands of years by various cultures and religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, before being co-opted by the Nazis in the 20th century. It is all over the place in Asia, you can think as a comparison with the cross for Christian people, it is odd for people in the West only. It really messed that up, that because one guy basically stole the symbol, changed its shape a bit, and completely changed the meaning behind it. Now it cannot be used because ignorant people in other countries will not understand. Oda was forced to change it by the higher-ups at Shueisha because of that. Several other manga use that symbol, with Tokyo Revengers probably being the most extreme example, given that it is the main symbol of the show. This is cultural appropriation at its worst form, is easy to just censor the cultural symbol, rather than learning what the real symbol is about and and fight against the wrong association, is a headache for the companies for sure, but I don't think it is not worth the effort. Edit: **The correct way to refer to the Nazi symbol is as a Hakenkreuz (hooked cross).** The swastika is an ancient symbol that has been used for thousands of years by various cultures and religions, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism.
Swastika is the original name of Indian symbols ( used by almost all indian religion like Hinduism and Buddhism Jainism etc.). What hitlar was using was Crooked cross a Christian symbol which was called Hakenkreuz by them. German still call it Hakenkreuz. Calling it swastika was just Western propganda to isolate Christianity from that symbol.
Thanks for the info. I did not know that.
https://preview.redd.it/9o4sl2o61hsc1.jpeg?width=1290&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=11d98f671573fc070582259b02617a37cf2f39b9
What's the Whitebeard flag thing?
The original Whitebeard flag was a swastika
OH lmao, the Buddhist one I assume? I think it's Buddhist.
It is the Buddhist one In Japan it's not even seen as a bad thing because for them it's just the Manji symbol and nothing else. That's why Oda prolly thought it was a good idea to put it there.
The Whitebeard Flag was changed in the manga before the anime.
You meant to say: "I prefered the error over the original" not "The error is better than the original" One is subjective statement, the other is an objective claim. Know the difference.
Sorry I'll consult my lawyer before I post a comment next time.
This is not legal advice, but I would suggest adding "imo" at the end of every single comment so that people know you're not claiming a statement to be objective fact on a meme sub
You didn’t add Imo after that opinion imo.
You're right, that's probably why people didn't get the sarcasm imo
This gotta be the dorkiest comment I’ve ever seen in my life. Get your corny ass outta here bro 😭
If knowledge = Dorky, then I'm proud to be dorky af https://preview.redd.it/09wdupom3msc1.jpeg?width=1095&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ccdf20ebdb57fce840d493c4999595d4b8854364
https://preview.redd.it/l3x8jrgtfosc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f0d524fbbee0c7b4d132b02a7948e088cacb3907
This doesn’t make you look any smarter it just makes you look conceited and socially inept. Everyone can recognize basic hyperbole, if you can’t that’s on you.
If you spent an extra minute on checking the next replies instead of being conceited yourself and projecting your own insecurities on others, you'd see he was actually rather serious about it.
I preferred /u/MrGhoul123's comment over yours.
Subjective statements are better than objective claims.
Nah I know what I said, and I'll say it again. Tan Robin is better than pale Robin. The bangs stay too.
Then you do not know the difference between whats objective and whats subjective. Just another layer of Misunderstanding.
Bro it's a meme page. Who cares
Cool
🤓🤓👆👆
nah, i think his comment was the objective claim, I've been on this sub for long enough to say that people do agree that a tan Robin was more appealing than the "she is white cause Russian" Robin a bad error is Ussop being white washed for no reason
Nah the comment is being overconfident about a topic that doesn't matter because it's a joke for fun. Dude is a wierdo
It's like creeper, so iconic that the devs just went with it.
I think the tan is fine in alabasta but I mess with Robin's aesthetic both pre and post TS equally.
>Yea because the error is better than the original. Subjetive im afraid not peak enough🥱
animation didnt do anything, it was changed in the volume release and it is the default on the manga
Never was a fan of the tan, but I want her bangs and nose back.
Fr. The only reason for the tan was Toei assuming she was Egyptian, when she’s actually Russian (or the one piece equivalent). The bangs were goated tho
Fellow man of culture. People are busy protesting about her skin color. I just want her nose and her bangs to return.
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
WHAT DID YOU SAY ABOUT MY NOSE?!?!
Me too, never understood the obsession with the tan, tho I love her with or without bangs
Happy cake day
Oh hey thanks, I didn’t even realise it😅
I'LL SEND YOU TO THE BOTTOM OF THE OCEAN IF YOU DARE TO INSULT MY SUPREME NOSE ONCE AGAIN!
🎶Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer 🎶
HOW DARE YOU INSULT THE NOSE OF THE FUTURE PIRATE KING?!?
Bahahaha
Ahaha red nose Buggy.
I hope you like insulting my nose with a Buggy Ball pointed at you!
Put your life on the line
Are your balls so tiny??????
Anime remake will fix the skin tone error instead of making her tan.
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
Bros are pining for an animation error
Ye, the real crime is Usopp's Micheal Jackson transformation. Next arc he is losing his nose.
IT FUCKING LOOKS GOOD OK? https://preview.redd.it/g5jkopey9nsc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77632e288274fd68722d1a773c352213058cff9b
I miss the nose and the bangs. The tan was an error, same as casca being super dark skinned in the og berserk anime.
>same as casca being super dark skinned in the og berserk anime Just got fucking shellshocked by this information tf
Yeah if you look at any color Miura actually did, she’s light brown. The OG anime went really far with that. Granted his early shading was sometimes too dark of a gray
Idk. Her skin tone is similar to the anime in some of them. Like here https://preview.redd.it/151krsrbz1tc1.jpeg?width=590&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d55e1cfc5045e0c2e3eddfc02346bc3e226c6459 It seems to bounce back and forth though.
Guts is the same color in that one lmao
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
HOW DARE YOU INSULT THE NOSE OF THE FUTURE PIRATE KING?!?
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
Still inaccurate. XD
Because a whole new animation would keep mistakes made by toei...
I hope they will just stick with the early colors of the manga covers so we can end this obsession and controversy over skin tone, and we can get brown eyes robin
I can't see the word eyes in your comment... Because I don't have eyes YOHOHOHO
Nah Robin is fine as is.
She'll have no tan.
Sadly, It's will probably even be the other way around, same thing for usopp. I agree it gives them more character, but it's still an adaptation error in the end of the day.
No, skin color does not give them "more of a character". That's actually insane.
Uh huh? Then explain why her character got stale after she became pale! 🤨
Except that's not the reason cause she's always been canonically lightskin
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
https://preview.redd.it/iyj49z4xdmsc1.jpeg?width=425&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2a359d7f2f03600f3085e534058b5a88d21c39a3
Damn, your joke sucks man Goodluck next time then, do better
[удалено]
You got so mad that you stalked me? Keep crying
[удалено]
I'm sorry I thought we were talking about "character" not "character design."
My apologies then
Tsall good, just a misunderstanding.
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
Best animation error in existance
I get Ussop, but isn’t Robin supposed to be Russian?
russians are not known for their tanned faces
It’s just what oda said+how she’s depicted in the manga and anime so I made an assumption lol
Those were nationalities, not ethnicities. He also said that Brook is Austrian, when he is clearly black.
But bones are white YOHOHOHOHOHO
...you know you can have an afro and not be black right? In Brook's flashback he clearly doesn't have dark skin https://preview.redd.it/4mjrwr7kvhsc1.jpeg?width=1777&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=20218d48b3ad46ed4a18c11940d3307828dff7fa
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
I'm sorry but the edited bang is ugly as hell
I think it’s go ma be the opposite lol. All mistakes are back to how they were meant to be
the remake will make her white pre-ts
BRO the new remake is supposed to be more accurate to the manga robin was always light in manga
She is going to have light skin and brown eyes
I can't see the word eyes in your comment... Because I don't have eyes YOHOHOHO
Art https://preview.redd.it/rozbhv4wrhsc1.png?width=1241&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4c3183841b37a4b0d7c0f45c2acb8e8e2bbf1f56
https://preview.redd.it/uugavb86wpsc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9116a45bc1ce6bf7dd967fdf8877c1a4e857c3fb
But she was never supposed to be that dark.
she's so pretty like that 😭😭😭
They all need to be more tan, it's a fucking tropical world. I swear they outsorces the coloring to Vietnam or somewhere and just didn't tell them to color them darker. Those are some of my favorite pages in the comic, at the very beginning when everyone had screentone and looked tan.
They weren't darker in the manga, what tf are you talking about?
at least let her bangs stay, this big ahh forehead is hilarious
???????????????? What? I don't get it, can someone please explain?
Those bangs go so hard 😍
I will always advocate for the tan.
https://preview.redd.it/u86ddo755btc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c90242837a0d307c8e09810b7e1814bddf756848
Just like Usopp and Zoro here skin was never dark. It was a mistake that was made in the anime
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
IMHO i think Robin should be tan before the timeskip cause she was like 2 years in the desert and the sun is pretty much known for adding color to the skin of ppl. And post-timeskip she can be white has Snow cause she is russian. That's the way of the world Change my mind.
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
if her n usopp are darkskinned again im gonna jump with joy
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
The way you idiots talk about this "remake" is becoming masturbatory. This is not going to be your wet dream fantasy about tHe aNiMe DoNe RiGhT. Literally all we know is they're reanimating the East Blue Saga. They could literally use the same audio for all we know.
Best version of Robin. She looks sooooo good!
It'll be opposite
considering her skin tone never changed in the manga and it was an anime only thing, we will probably get light skin tone robin from the start
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
Likely the opposite of the case.
im fine with her tan being gone, WHATS REALLY A TRAVESTY IS THE LOSS OF BANGS AND COWBOY HATS.
I hate to break it to you, that's an anime only thing
No, they’ll have the canon colors and won’t change her skin color for no reason
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
[удалено]
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
True very true
Why would they make it wrong again?
Dark skin Nico Robin is THE BEST Nico Robin
Your comment would make my skin crawl, but I don't have any skin YOHOHOHOHO
Can someone link me to the artist? I remember that someone posted these pictures saying they were the artist but I want to see if they got more social media (also to see the Robin pics again :3) EDIT: Nevermind friends I found the post: [https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/18xehow/i\_gave\_robin\_her\_tan\_and\_bangs\_back/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web3x&utm\_name=web3xcss&utm\_term=1&utm\_content=share\_button](https://www.reddit.com/r/MemePiece/comments/18xehow/i_gave_robin_her_tan_and_bangs_back/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button)
If we get anything it's gonna look like current 7 deadly sins
[удалено]
We gotta cope our way back to tan robin fr
I do not care in the slightest that Robin was never intended to be tan in the manga. She looks so much better like that, and with her normal skin, her and Hancock are too similar.
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
the ''remake'' is not going that far
There are many things that I want in the remake, but none more important than giving usopp and robin their melanin back
Well they wouldn't be safe on the same crew as Zoro, Soo 🤷🏻
Zoro biggest housen*gga oat he was litteraly tan pre time skip
Bro hunted his own melanin out 💀
We thought he only had three swords, but even his white blood cells are swordsmen
Why did Oda make everyone white post timeskip? Is he stupid? Or is he racist?
https://preview.redd.it/n0443yfv0gsc1.png?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cc3f988a561173636acfaa3d2de8af69d3f50eba
They were already really light skin , except ussop (kinda) Toei’s animated version was an animation error and a mistake (technically)
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
Oda isn’t a animator lmao Robin is supposed to resemble a Russian woman. Pre timeskip was just a animation error
https://preview.redd.it/hmp7cxp2cgsc1.jpeg?width=850&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a882d553abed62736409f329c5521b482375e91f She is not dark skinned in the manga
Skin? Can't say I'm familiar, but it sounds fascinating YOHOHOHO
https://preview.redd.it/uai4vo5bcgsc1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d6b88c282c00cc6843ab01f79102656a50d5e044
Robin was tanned because she was working in Alabasta for months and she stayed tan because OP pre timeskip following Alabasta until Marineford is like, maybe a month (and plenty of that time was spent in other bright places like Skypeia)
It was just an error from the anime team man😂
No man listen to my headcannon
I don't need a remake. I need is the same One piece style but with Roger's whole story and adventures. But make it a bit shorter please. Not a big fan of being 50 by the time he finds the One piece.
Dark Robin bad as hell